The Walking Dead: 10 Characters Who Died At The Wrong Time

Characters who died far too early... or far too late.

The Walking Dead Beth
AMC

Throughout its run, The Walking Dead was host to all manner of different characters, all brought together by a changed world that forced them to adapt and clash in often heartbreaking ways.

And whilst many of these characters were compelling - the gritty Rick Grimes, the villainous Negan and sword-swinging Michonne - not all of them left the series when they should have, with several prominent figures dying long before or long after their development had run its course.

Of course, The Walking Dead was not averse to killing its characters en masse, often in gruelling and left-field ways, but that doesn't mean the writers were always on the ball about who to kill and - more importantly - why.

From characters just hitting their stride cut down before their prime, to those who stuck around long after viewers wanted and others who were written off half-heartedly due to behind-the-scenes feuds, here are 10 characters both good and bad who died at the wrong time.

This article will contain major spoilers about all eleven seasons of The Walking Dead, but not the recent slew of spin-offs.

10. Jessie Anderson

The Walking Dead Jessie
AMC

Introduced as a member of the so-called "safe haven" Alexandria in the show's fifth season, Jessie was a strong woman trapped in an abusive marriage, struggling to connect with her two sons whilst the world changed dramatically around them. 

Eventually, Jessie also became a potential love interest for Rick, living as a sort of hopeful symbol for the life he wanted. She was saved from her awful husband and even started to get through to her kids. All seemed well, and Jessie was growing into quite the compelling figure - but this The Walking Dead, where good things don't last.

In season six, Jessie is devoured by a walker horde along with her youngest son, breaking Rick's heart. It was a cruel, avoidable death - why did that damn kid not shut up? - that helped send Rick into a rage that rallied the rest of Alexandria together, but it was also a shame.

Jessie's story still had plenty of juice left, as did her relationship with Rick (soon to end up with Michonne). That she's never really mentioned again just adds insult to injury.


9. Pope

Walking Dead Pope
AMC

This one was just infuriating. The first villain of the show's final season, Pope was a bloodthirsty, god-fearing military man who had formed something of a cult with his fellow soldiers, and had menacingly taken Daryl as one of his own.

Now, Daryl was too smart to align himself with Pope, but he was great undercover, tricking the madman into thinking they were together only to work behind the scenes to save his friends.

It's teased, overtly and repeatedly, that Pope is onto Daryl's double agent schtick, and the two battle-hardened fighters seemed destined to come to blows. Only, it never happens. Before it can, Pope's killed by his right-hand, Leah, and that's that.

Looking back, it's also hilarious how often Pope mentions wanting to face off with his so-called "nemesis", Maggie, only for the two characters to never meet. In fact, it's never even made clear Maggie knew who the guy was. What a mess.


8. Rosita Espinosa

The Walking Dead Outpost 22 Rosita
AMC

Rosita Espinosa was one of The Walking Dead's most prolific characters - surpassed, if you'll believe it, only by Rick, Daryl, Carol and Maggie - which is baffling considering how thin and inconsequential she was throughout the show. 

Though Christian Serratos does a commendable job of selling Rosita as the tough, unwavering fighter she was, that was about all the actress was given. Even when she was given something to work with - a relationship with Gabriel, a child whose father she was forced to kill - it fell flat. 

Despite this, Rosita managed to make it to the very last episode of The Walking Dead, and was in fact its final major death, an odd distinction given how rushed it was, and how truly forgettable she was as a character. 

Again, this isn't to knock Serratos, but we live in a world where Carl Grimes was killed by a lone walker off-screen, but Rosita fought to the end without any major personality traits. Madness. 


7. Tyreese Williams

Tyreeses Death
AMC

Oh, Tyreese, you gentle giant. There were a lot of characters naturally unprepared for the end of the world, but none more so than Tyreese, who spent his entire three-season run on The Walking Dead driven mad by the cruelty that surrounded him. 

Whilst this was often compelling, especially in the first act of season five when he was forced to act as baby Judith's guardian angel, it was also quite repetitive, his rage and disillusionment one-note and almost boring. 

That being said, when he did finally bite the dust, drifting off after a couple of walkers left him hallucinating his peaceful trip to the great beyond, he'd only just started to find himself and come to terms with his grief. 

This seemed to promise a brighter future for the big-hearted hero, one in which he was made stronger by his trials and tribulations, but it never came to pass. He died before his new chapter could begin, his future forever lost. 


6. Paul "Jesus" Rovia

The Walking Dead Jesus Season 9
Jackson Lee Davis/AMC

To his credit, Tom Payne was fantastic as Jesus, the pacifistic, hopeful Hilltop leader whose brevity and calm moral resolve made for a welcome breath of fresh air from the more brutally-minded of his friends. 

It's just that - and really we can't blame him here - Payne was never given anything of note to work with, Jesus's role cut dramatically from what it was in the source material and his potentially lovely relationships with Aaron, Maggie, Tara and Daryl never taking off as they should. 

Having asked to leave the show, Payne was written out the series during the season nine mid-season finale, killed suddenly by a lone Whisperer (despite being the show's best fighter) and very quickly forgotten. 

Given Payne's performance and Jesus's potential as a community leader and love interest - in a show with painfully little romance - his demise just felt cruel. If only they'd given Payne the character he deserved, he'd have been around to the end, no question. 


5. Andrea Harrison

The Walking Dead Andrea Season 2
AMC

As far The Walking Dead characters, few are as universally reviled as Andrea, a strong but broken member of Rick Grimes' original Atlanta group who eventually became the show's female lead. 

In the first two seasons of the show, Andrea wasn't particularly endearing or well-written, her grief over her sister's death, her animosity toward her surrogate father Dale, and her repetitive desire to have a gun in her hands a cause of much-discussed audience derision. 

But to note these flaws is also to note how strong a character she was becoming just before she died (in one of the show's most infuriatingly dumb death scenes), her love for the villainous Governor and hope to reconnect with her old friends allowing her to become quite the entertaining figure. 

Despite this otherwise welcome character development, though - and ignoring the fact that Andrea makes it almost to the comics' end as Rick's wife - she was killed off-screen and rarely spoken of again, her growing potential forever squandered. 


4. Merle Dixon

Merles Death
AMC

The older brother of Daryl, Merle was a mean piece of work who was also one of The Walking Dead's most entertaining and complex characters during its first three seasons. 

Made a main player in the third season and reunited with his estranged sibling, Merle was a character caught in something of a crossroads, at once a bitter, broken man set in his ways, and a good-hearted soul who had kept his virtues buried for far too long. 

Just as it seemed he was on the path to a redemption he'd survive, though, proving his loyalty to Rick after all their clashes and making peace with Daryl, the writers decided to give Merle a suicide mission in which he tried to kill The Governor. 

Killed brutally and left as a walker for his brother to find, Merle was only just starting to become something extra special. In another world, he'd have fought with the main group for another season or two, but Michael Rooker, god bless him, wasn't meant to stick around. 


3. Leah Shaw

The Walking Dead Leah
AMC

Leah Shaw, introduced in the backend of The Walking Dead's tenth season, never really came together as a character, and to be totally honest she probably died right when she needed to. 

The problem here, then, is that whilst the timing was acceptable, the way and why of it was seriously anticlimactic and emotionless, given the fact she was killed by her former lover Daryl without ever realising he was the one to do the deed. 

At once a briefly stirring love interest and a ferocious villain who wanted to blindly protect her family of sadistic ex-soldiers, Leah's character was all over the place, bordering on the irritating in her inconsistencies, but surely we could have seen her and Daryl square off one last time before the end. 

Thrown in half-baked to add some depth to Daryl's long-empty love life, and then reimagined as an antagonist with unexplored motivations, Leah was a massive waste of potential whose death should have at least been more heartbreaking and built-up for her old beau.


2. Beth Greene

The Walking Dead Beth Greene
AMC

Of all the characters in The Walking Dead, Beth Greene was always the most unfairly maligned, a depressed, struggling teenager who seemed destined to die only to become stronger and braver with every twist of fate she endured. 

Sure, she was a touch underwhelming in season two, but given time to bond with Daryl Dixon after the loss of her father and home, the younger Greene sibling was showing clear, exciting signs of becoming something really special - like Carol or sister Maggie, a predictable victim turned fearless survivor. 

But, no. Instead of acting on this development, The Walking Dead deployed its most nonsensical death scene, killing Beth with an accidental bullet to the head just as she was about to be reunited with her family and friends. 

That we spent so much time watching her finally become a compelling force, only for her to die so cruelly at the very last second, makes Beth Greene's death all the more ill-timed. She had so much left to offer. 


1. Carl Grimes

The Walking Dead Carl Grimes
AMC

With the death of Carl Grimes, so died The Walking Dead as audiences knew it. Of every character in the show, Carl (and later Judith) seemed the only one sure to survive it all, the son of a protective Rick Grimes, destined to lead the new world and defeat the old.

That's what happens in the comics, anyway, and the show seemed to be leaning that way, too. For all its melodrama, The Walking Dead's one emotional constant was Rick's desire to protect his family and give them a real future. 

Worse still is the fact that Carl himself was actually a compelling character in his own right, a scrappy born leader who by his season eight death was growing into quite the man, an endearing reflection of his father's best intentions. 

In the end, though, Carl Grimes wasn't meant to have the future the show seemed to be ending for. After everything he'd been through, he was bitten by a walker and then killed himself before he could turn. Yeah, it wasn't even a good death (and it wasn't even on-screen). 

But, hey, at least Judith lived happily ever after. He'd have wanted that, even if he should have been there, too. 


Watch Next


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/