The Walking Dead: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best

Exploring the highs and lows of AMC's hit post-apocalyptic drama.

The Walking Dead
AMC

And just like that, it's the end of an era: After twelve years and eleven seasons, AMC's hit drama The Walking Dead has officially aired its last episode. Though the franchise will live on in the form of several promising spin-offs, the show that started it all is done for good.

Initially the simple tale of embattled family man Rick Grimes, The Walking Dead was constantly evolving to incorporate new characters, communities, and hurdles for them to face. It was as much about the undead as it was about the greed and evil of man, and though it had its flaws, it never lacked empathy or excitement.

With its ridiculously high body count, affecting performances, and worldbuilding, the series painted a striking, bleak portrait of life after the end of the world.

At its best, it was one of the strongest shows on TV; at its worst, when its eyes got too big for its stomach, it proved a controversial affair few were willing to stick around for. Now that it's over, we can finally take a big step back and view the series as a whole, exploring what made it work...and what didn't.

With that in mind, from the mind-numbing lows of its All Out War melodrama to its recent gems, here are all 11 seasons of The Walking Dead ranked worst to best.

11. Season Eight

The Walking Dead Wrath
Gene Page/AMC

The Walking Dead's weakest chapter is ultimately the victim of its own lofty goals. In an attempt to tell the sweeping, action-packed story of the communities' war against Negan and the Saviors, season eight simply gives itself far too much to do.

With everyone scattered into different camps, often alone and struggling to give anything to the overarching conflict, the season's biggest fault is its overbearing cast of characters, whom the writers fail to juggle in a compelling way.

From the maddeningly underused (Daryl, Michonne, Jesus) to the outright annoying (Negan, Gabriel, Morgan) and betrayed (Carl!), season eight fumbles through scenes of excessive violence, unfinished subplots and unearned twists, including of course the awfully executed demise of Carl Grimes.

Considering every episode ends with an anti-climax, it's little wonder fans were unable to get comfortable with it. Credit where it's due, though: When it slows down to focus on the moral pitfalls of war, it can pack a punch. What a shame.


10. Season Seven

The Walking Dead Negan Lucille Glenn
AMC

Season seven is The Walking Dead at its most depressing and relentlessly bleak, opening with the cruel deaths of Glenn and Abraham and piling on the remorseless tragedy of the Survivors' predicament with every episode that follows.

Largely concerned with the pitiless, bat-wielding megalomaniac Negan, the season throws its characters to the wolves, hitting them with endless trauma until they finally snap and conspire to fight back. It makes for hard viewing, slipping often into outright torture porn, but it has some virtues.

With Andrew Lincoln and Jeffrey Dean Morgan on incredibly fine form and its slow-burning intensity, season seven at least gives itself time to focus on the growth of its characters. Rick, Carl, Michonne and Maggie in particular shine as they battle their grief and anger, and Negan (in small doses) makes for an entertaining threat.

Unfortunately, the flaws are too many. The poor special effects, Carol and Morgan's dull feud, the surreal introduction of Ezekiel and his tiger, Daryl's imprisonment, the icy cold brutality -- it's all too much to bear, existing to shock and little more.


9. Season One

Andrew Lincoln In The Walking Dead Episode 1 01 Days Gone Bye 620x399
AMC

This will be too low for many fans, but in the grand scheme of The Walking Dead, its first season is too slight to compete with what would follow. It's obviously not bad, but it's also table-setting, creating a foundation for bigger things.

Starting with the show's stunning pilot Days Gone Bye, the season thrusts moralistic sheriff's deputy Rick Grimes into a desperate race to find his family in a world bafflingly overrun by the undead. Sombre and patient, it paints a frank portrait of our innate need to survive and find connection.

From the rising intensity of Shane Walsh to its horrific opening moments -- where a conflicted Rick is forced to kill a child walker -- The Walking Dead's six-episode debut is a bracing set-up to a troubling world, promising plenty of heartbreak.

After this, The Walking Dead would tackle its themes of survival, hope and humanity with more confidence and depth, but it would rarely tell its story with such economy again.


8. Season Two

The Walking Dead Season Two
AMC

The Walking Dead's sophomore outing gets a lot of hate, and it's easy to see why. With a massively reduced budget, the second season was forced to take on a more minimalist form of storytelling, setting all its action in one place.

Making camp on the farmland of Hershel Greene and his family, the season follows Rick, Shane and the group as they search for one of their own. What follows is a claustrophobic, moody affair, full to bursting with (mostly) brilliant character work but continuously tripped up by its snail-like pace and uneven tone.

Particularly soaring with its depiction of Rick and Shane's escalating feud, season two grapples with the moral implications of the new world, causing a rift between its struggling characters as they confront their sins.

Regrettably, though, these otherwise powerful themes are eventually overcome by the sheer tedium of the season's meandering drama, which features far too much repetition and filler to get itself into a nice rhythm. It features stunning individual moments -- the fate of Sophia, the fall of Shane -- but as a whole it's far too turgid.


7. Season Three

The Walking Dead
AMC

Despite some brief hiccups, season three is where The Walking Dead as we know it was born, filling the screen with its most electric drama, action and intense stakes yet. With Shane gone, the season heralded a new, more confident era for the show.

Opening with the group at their lowest and forced to take refuge in an abandoned prison, the season finds Rick and his found family searching for a new home, desperate to reclaim some kind of life in a world far beyond saving, whilst newcomer The Governor threatens their future.

Bracingly well-paced and effectively balancing its characters' arcs, season three struggles through the death of Lori Grimes, which throws Rick into a melodramatic and overlong spiral of cartoonish grief, but it soars with its ability to finally prove their biggest threat is man rather than the dead.

From the introduction of Michonne and the expanded roles of fan favourites Daryl, Glenn and Maggie, The Walking Dead's third year is an affecting portrayal of family and perseverance that cemented the show as a modern classic.


6. Season Eleven

The Walking Dead
AMC

The Walking Dead's long-awaited final season is a messy, rewarding instalment to the show's legacy. Elongated to twenty-four episodes, the series' swan song pits its heroes against the Commonwealth, and aims to give them some kind of peace.

Tackling themes of oppression and human spirit with more depth than ever before, the season throws its characters into disarray, scattering them like playing pieces onto a battlefield larger than they've ever faced. Forced to confront their pasts, the likes of Daryl, Maggie, Carol and Negan have never seemed so cruelly outnumbered.

This largeness has its benefits, especially when it gives its characters time to deal with the horror of their new war, and the way it brings everyone together into a fight that feels truly final leads to a mass amount of touching character farewells, haunting cliffhangers, and genuine scares.

There are issues -- disjointed pacing, a surprisingly low body count, and low stake gunfights amongst them -- but these flaws quickly pale in comparison to the season's emotional punch. It doesn't tick all the boxes (it was never going to), but season eleven remains a worthy capper to The Walking Dead's staggering journey.

Bring on the spin-offs!


5. Season Six

The Walking Dead The Next World
AMC

The Walking Dead's most underrated chapter, the stunning first half of the sixth season signalled the end of the show's golden age, but fell apart as it numbly crawled toward to the Survivors' poorly teased clash with Negan and the Saviors.

Initially dealing with two crushing outside threats faced by an overhauled Alexandria -- a monster walker horde and the animalistic Wolves -- season six gets off to a powerful start, forcing Rick into a position of power whilst the community struggles to band together to secure its future.

Blending thrilling action with the quiet character development of the central group, the way season six builds to Alexandria's final stand against the walkers is astounding, and the battle itself is arguably the show's finest moment. In its wake, though, the season starts to falter.

Though the Rick/Daryl road-trip episode The Next World brings some effective comedy and worldbuilding into the mix, the rest of the season lurches as it sets up the next chapter. It doesn't take away from the season's early highs, but it's still an oddly disappointing end.


4. Season Nine

The Walking Dead The Calm Before
AMC

The secret to the success of The Walking Dead's ninth season lies in its simplicity. The war with the Saviors finally over, the communities have entered into some kind of fragile peace, which is of course shattered by the show's biggest loss.

Using its first five episodes to set-up and execute Rick's heartbreaking exit from the show (Lincoln wanted to move closer to his family), the season takes some massive risks, bringing Daryl into the protagonist's chair as he grapples with grief and tries to save his friends from the face-wearing threat of The Whisperers.

Injecting more horror into the show than ever before, season nine mostly plays out on the road, sparingly dealing with the communities' hardships whilst Daryl, Michonne and some new friends battle to keep their homes and humanity intact.

From the horrific introduction of the bone-chilling Whisperers and their leader, Alpha, to Rick's bittersweet swan song and its gutsy time-jumps, The Walking Dead's ninth season is a brutal, heartbreaking return to form, signalling a new, more confident era.


3. Season Four

The Walking Dead Rick Grimes
AMC

In a narrative move later adopted by its aforementioned ninth season, The Walking Dead's fourth chapter spends the first half of its run telling a wholly different story to the one that would follow.

Starting things off with a mysterious and deadly flu epidemic in the prison, which sends its characters in wildly different directions, the season starts fast and strong as we're given early insight into what a peaceful future for the Survivors may look like. Hell, Rick and Carl are farmers!

The second half follows the group as they're scattered, displaced and beaten down by The Governor's vicious return. It's this half, where the group is forced to reconcile their failings, cement their relationships, and strive to overcome their losses that the season becomes one of the show's greats.

It may slump with The Governor's two-episode re-introduction, but watching Rick lose his humanity, Daryl and Beth bond, Carol and Tyreese contend with a damaged child and Glenn and Maggie hopefully seek each other out makes it all worthwhile. This is The Walking Dead at its desperate, brutal, empathetic best.


2. Season Five

The Walking Dead Them
AMC

Season five takes what made its predecessor great -- the bleakness and the hope, the horror and the focussed character work -- and surpassed it, crafting a compelling and almost flawless story of a group of hopeless souls who help one another find a way forward and start again. Again.

On the road and beaten down, Rick and the group are at their lowest low here, mentally and physically exhausted, untrusting of outsiders. It's hard to see them all sink so far and so violently, but this harsh reality serves as the show's driving force; that amongst the carnage, there's always something better on the horizon.

Watching Rick lose his mind trying to protect his family and friends makes for tough viewing -- Lincoln, on series-best form, purposefully makes him unreasonable and cruel -- but seeing the group rally behind him to look to a new future serves as a stark reminder that The Walking Dead isn't all blood and depression.

Season five is The Walking Dead at its finest, most confrontational, sad, and twisting. But it's also a step in the right direction, pushing its characters to face themselves and their hopes with plenty of catharsis and change.


1. Season Ten

The Walking Dead A Certain Doom
AMC

In the end, though, the best season of The Walking Dead has to be its tenth, which follows the communities as they're thrown headlong into a gripping and violent final stand against The Whisperers and their irredeemable leaders.

With stunning effects, towering performances and more horror than even season nine dared to feature, season ten's portrayal of paranoia and insanity makes for a visceral viewing experience that's as disquieting as it is genuinely shocking and dis-arming.

Allowing Daryl, Carol, Negan and more grow in remarkable, often heartbreaking ways, the season balances its claustrophobic dread with a distinct sense of character; despite the rapidly growing cast, everyone is given ample opportunity to change and become undone by their imperfections and enemies.

Epic, challenging and deliciously creepy, season ten is surely The Walking Dead's crowning achievement. The drama has never been stronger, the characters rarely so well explored, and the stakes seldom so high. If you're one of many who stopped watching before the end, you're missing out.


Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/