The Walking Dead: Ranking Every Season From Worst To Best
Separating the survivors from the walker-fodder...
In 2010, AMC’'s zombie drama of survival horror swept the globe almost as quickly as its central walkers overran the planet, a smash hit from its debut episode. With the audience swelling year after year, it’s fair to say we’ve been infected, and nothing short of a few more whacks from Lucille will cause the numbers to dwindle.
Over the course of the decade, the show has progressively morphed from a story about the dawn of the zombie apocalypse into a study of the disintegration of what it means to be human, with morals and values becoming obsolete impediments to pure survival.
Increasingly bloodthirsty and unforgiving to its characters, all of whom are in constant danger from all fronts, they're forced to do whatever’s necessary to stay alive for another day against multiple manifestations of threats, walkers and humans alike.
While the show has seen better days, it’s been affirmed that no end is in sight just yet. With multiple future seasons planned and outlined, its creators fully confident that our hunger for zombie action won’t be subsiding anytime soon.
With the latest season wrapped and entered into the pantheon of television history, it’s time to take a look back and see how each of the show’s seven seasons so far stack up against each other. Open, dead inside.
7. Season 7 (2016-17)
A joyless slog from start to finish, season 7 was hurt badly by an underwhelming antagonist and the sidelining of the show’s best characters. Negan’s introduction at the end of season 6 immediately started the character off on the wrong foot with audiences, killing an unidentified character in one of the cheapest cliff hangers in recent memory.
He failed from then on to endear himself as a villain, quite literally a cartoon character devoid of added dimensions or depth, and one who endlessly repeated the same tired speeches of superiority while stroking his barbed Lucille episode after episode. With Carol mostly inactive, Daryl imprisoned for the first half, and Morgan mired in a tedious arc of shattered pacifism, the show felt too fractured, with too few moments of heart to make all the misery bearable.
The whole season was built around first setting up and then delivering on Rick’s call to arms, and an eventual rebellion by several clans against Negan and his Saviors, but was paced so sluggishly, in such a dull manner, that the climax failed to achieve any real sense of catharsis or even anticipation for next year. When an entire season so ponderously sets the pieces on the board, it’s hard to feel much excitement for the game that’s coming.
The hope is that the past year was a necessary evil that moved everything into place for an intense arc of war next season, but that in itself does nothing to make season 7 one that fans are eager to revisit.
Best Episode: New Best Friends - Thrusting Rick into a gladiator duel with a spike-armoured walker in a pit of trash provided a touch of much needed pulp and popcorn entertainment for a season sorely lacking in creative moments.
Worst Episode: The Day Will Come When You Won’t Be - When the season premiere revealed Negan to have gruesomely murdered first Abraham and then Glenn, it set an unwelcomely nihilistic tone of sadism and brutality for a season that largely persisted in its bleakness throughout the year. The promise of hope followed by its cruel withdrawal had been repeated time and time again even before this season, and this was a low point.
6. Season 2 (2011-12)
The epitome of hate-watching for many, season 2 had a massive audience, but a large portion of highly vocal detractors. Criticism was in many ways well justified as the second season established the show’s typical pattern of “the group finds a safe location, stays there all season, then leaves after it’s violently compromised”.
In this case, Hershel’s Farm was the chosen site for characters who hadn’t yet been given a whole lot of depth to mostly sit around meditating on civilisation and morality, and engaging in soap opera storylines. The search for Carol’s lost daughter Sophia was largely responsible for both the characters and story stalling with the entire first half dedicated to one fruitless hunt after another.
The season was also marred by stunning ineptitude and incompetence from its characters in a year that featured Andrea accidentally shooting at Daryl with a sniper rifle, Carl taunting and then running away from a walker which went on to kill Dale, and Lori managing to overturn her car whilst driving in a straight line. If not for a few strong sequences and moments, mostly in the second half of the season and usually involving Shane (RIP) and his boiling conflict with Rick, season 2 would be nigh on unsalvageable.
Best Episode: Pretty Much Dead Already - For all its faults, the Sophia arc paid off in devastating fashion as we discover to the shock of all that she had been killed and turned long before, stored in Hershel’s barn with a host of other walkers that Hershel’s family had foolishly hoped to heal. Even the most cynical of viewers would be hard pressed not to find that shot of Sophia’s shambling emergence from the barn chillingly effective.
Worst Episode: Chupacabra - In which Glenn pouts for the entire hour, and Daryl hallucinates (that beloved TV trope!) the return of his thought-dead brother Merle. He’s later mistaken for a walker despite being surrounded by people that are visibly not walkers, and shot by a witless Andrea in one of the most maddening moments of the show.
5. Season 3 (2012-13)
The third season showed a lot of promise from the start, bringing some much needed consistency to the show with a higher class of action and sustained tension. The dark setting of the fortified high-security prison also allowed for some memorable set-pieces that genuinely appealed to the show’s horror roots.
Stronger character moments, heightened stakes and a much greater sense of urgency contributed to the general improvement of the show. The Governor’s introduction as a villain - fascination with severed walker heads and all - was still handled with more subtly sinister undertones than the threat posed by Negan and his blunt, bludgeoning instrument.
As a whole, however, it lost steam continuing into the second half, as the story continuously shifted between the prison and the inhabitants of Woodbury. The Governor’s romantic pairing with the much derided Andrea did nothing to improve her standing in the eyes of fans and his full blown assault that the season purported to be driving towards fizzled out with a whimper; his army fleeing the prison at the first meagre sign of resistance.
Still, fans will fondly remember Merle’s return, and some real gems from the year such as Clear and Killer Within which, along with the strong first half, established the third season as a return to form of sorts.
Best Episode: Clear - The series would come to experiment with short story vignette formats more and more often, and this is one of the earlier examples. A stunning triumph, Clear brings the highly anticipated return of a now deranged Morgan, whose story is laced with palpable tragedy. The tight focus on a small group of characters is reminiscent of season 1, while the small plot point of the hitchhiker that bookends the episode also demonstrates just how much these people have been forced to change, their humanity slowly stripped, in order to survive.
Worst Episode: I Ain’t a Judas - Andrea’s attempts to mend fences between Rick’s group and The Governor’s clan continues the trend of the show utterly failing to make her a sympathetic character: her insistence that The Governor - quite obviously a very bad man - can be reasoned with coupled with her propensity for self-righteous lectures contribute to a highly irritating hour of place-setting. By the time she chooses not to kill The Governor in his sleep, any hope for the audience warming up to her has long gone.
4. Season 6 (2015-16)
Year six also began with a strong run of high-octane pulp action, finding bolder, bloodier ways to balance the mounting zombie hazard with the arguably even greater dangers posed by the living.
By this point, the show knew the strengths of its better characters in Carol, Daryl, and the freshly returned Morgan, and kept them central to a story that set our battle-hardened heroes against two enemy groups that truly showed the depravity of humanity’s baser instincts when unchecked and ungoverned by law and morality: one feral, one meticulously organised, both savagely relentless.
In dealing with these threats, however, the series frequently made poor use of its now unwieldy cast, with an abundance of superfluous characters in the Alexandria community mostly used as redshirts, and the introduction of the Hilltop group as a counter to Negan’s villainous Saviors stretched the ungainly cast far too thin.
In addition, the show began to overindulge in cheap gimmicks and manipulative stunts as the plot armour given to the main players became more and more obvious, with both Glenn and Daryl the subject of cliffhangers that teased their fates even before the now infamous POV shot in the finale which cynically and lazily left the identity of Lucille’s victim a mystery.
Best Episode: Here’s Not Here - The sanctity of life and the question of the lengths one should go to in order to survive was prominently examined over the course of the year by two of the show’s best characters in Morgan and Carol, and this sequel to season 3’s “Clear” provides a poignant and deftly conceived origin story for Morgan’s newfound mantra of pacifism. Operating as a two-man morality play with an excellent guest star, it’s a fantastic example of how good the show can be when it experiments with form.
Worst Episode: Last Day on Earth - I’ve wailed on Negan and his Saviors a lot already, but we need to do a little more as the season 6 finale is bound to go down as an all-time low. A massively bloated running time is wasted by tedium and storytelling repetitions as we wait, and wait, and wait for Negan to show up before he finally graces us with a horrendously written monologue and an insultingly gratuitous cliffhanger. At least The Governor never mentioned “pee pee pants.”
3. Season 1 (2010)
The fleeting six episodes that made up the show’s debut season placed a great deal of importance on an atmosphere of horror; at this early point, zombie imagery still had the power to shock, with viewers not yet as desensitised to the ghastly, gory sights of personal apocalypse as the characters would later come to grow.
It’s fascinating to see how our heroes began at the dawn of the walker outbreak, still to learn the harrowing lessons which would later trigger their shedding of basic human traits in order to survive. In particular, the immense satisfaction of Carol’s arc over the course of the series is even sweeter when we revisit how she began as a powerless, abused wife.
The season’s main flaw is one that it’s blameless for: its brief length means it’s only able to begin to set up character relationships, and is unable to provide much more than a taste of what the show would grow into, for better or worse. With a short six episode order, a few weaker instalments negatively affect the balance and consistency of the season.
While certainly satisfying criteria for zombie action and fearful, atmospheric set pieces, the season also foreshadowed key issues that the show would come to struggle with, the writing growing steadily sillier as the finale approached and with certain supporting characters laughably shafted in terms of screen time and depth (take a bow, T-Dog and Jacqui!).
Still, the importance and atmosphere of the show’s debut season coupled with its lack of major weaknesses keep it ranked highly in fan regard.
Best Episode: Days Gone Bye - The show’s superb pilot stood out among a barrage of zombie fiction in entertainment with pristine production value, lavish photography and a palpable sense of dread, which caused viewers to latch on in droves to the existing audience of dedicated fans of the bleak source material. Focusing primarily on Rick, with brief appearances by the riveting Morgan and his doomed son, the first episode does an excellent job of establishing the tone and scale of one of the decade’s biggest TV obsessions.
Worst Episode: Vatos - The revelation that the tough Latino gang Rick and company find themselves squaring off with are in fact a kindly group of sweethearts caring for their elderly is sickly and hokey to the point of embarrassment, feeling like an episodic social lesson of the week. The deaths of Carol’s awful husband and Andrea’s sister lack impact, hindered by a lack of development and emotional attachment. Ed Peletier would not be missed.
2. Season 4 (2013-14)
New showrunner Scott Gimple wasted no time in disposing of the riffraff accumulated by the Woodbury storyline in his predecessor’s season 3, by way of a fatal infection that swept through the prison, both cleaning the show of superfluous characters and also giving existing heroes to show just how far they’ve come in this world.
At the same time, the season brought into the fold compelling new players such as Abraham, Eugene, Bob and Tara, while greatly improving the presence of Tyreese and Sasha, all of whom together would come to solidify the spine of the cast for the next few years.
The midseason finale left devastation in its wake, bringing to an end the storylines of both the prison and The Governor, and scattering the cast across the map, left to fend for themselves in small groups separate paths. The season’s willingness to show individual stories especially paid off in the second half as the scattered cast slowly converged and reunited in the journey towards apparent sanctuary Terminus, but this episodic structure also produced a few duds at times, especially in its failed attempts to humanise The Governor.
Nonetheless, this is a strong and consistent season with several clear highlights of the show, and one that improved the depth of the cast, provided emotional gut punches by the cartload, and tested our heroes to surpass their previous limits.
Best Episode: Too Far Gone - Narrowly pipping A and The Grove for the title, the midseason finale violently shatters the status quo and uses the entire cast well in a bloody do over of season 3’s aborted prison assault. The Governor is finally vanquished but only after his devastating execution of Hershel, which causes all hell to break loose in a blinding cloud of vengeance which ultimately scatters the cast to the wind. Also, Daryl blows up a tank by himself. What more needs to be said?
Worst Episode: Live Bait - The first of the Governor-centric episodes begins to fulfil a necessary evil in setting up round two of his attack on Rick and company but never really manages to convince the audience that he's truly turned a new leaf, as it initially tries to suggest. He’d return to his psychopathic ways in only the next episode, and untrusting viewers simply spend this first instalment waiting for the shoe to drop, following a character we’ve no reason to feel attached to. As such, his supposedly redemptive scenes with a family of survivors fall flat, and outside of introducing Tara to the show, it’s ultimately a waste of time.
1. Season 5 (2014-15)
The show’s fifth year is its best, with the first few episodes arguably The Walking Dead at the very height of its powers, stringing together stunning instalments and revelations week after week. It premiered with the single best episode of the show so far, and continued ratcheting up the villainy of Gareth and his cannibalistic fellow Terminus survivors before they’re brutally slaughtered by heroes we’ve followed for years, no longer willing to grant second chances.
The gothic church setting juxtaposed beautifully with the godless world and savagery surrounding it, while the later expansion to the peaceful community of Alexandria allowed for fascinating thematic studies of forever-changed people failing to settle back into the mundanity of domestic life.
The Walking Dead isn’t perfect, and nor is its best season, which spent portions of its first half focusing on the plight of Beth in a corrupt Atlanta hospital, an isolated setting which cut us off from the main story right when it was at its most compelling, miring characters in a subplot of futile escape and doomed rescue. The Alexandria setting also began to inflate the cast to its breaking point as many of the new characters lacked intrigue and complexity.
Still, these complaints in themselves aren’t enough to taint a season which showed no shortage of gripping, dramatic material for its vast array of characters, offering emotionally hard-hitting deaths along with some of the show’s goriest and most violent moments yet.
Best Episode: No Sanctuary - It didn’t take long for Terminus to reveal itself as a house of horrors, and the season premiere quickly spirals events into pure, unadulterated mayhem. The slaughter sequence is unflinchingly brutal and intense, the cannibal antagonists are given an unsettling touch of sympathy, and the triumphant opener masterfully, touchingly reunites loose strands of the group, with Carol saving our heroes among a multitude of fist-pumping moments. The fifth season begins on terrific form.
Worst Episode: Coda - The midseason finale marked a disappointing end to an otherwise brilliant half-season, as the appropriately named Coda does little more than cause its characters to detour from what’s really interesting, concluding a disconnected subplot with one of the few deaths in the season that comes off as pointless, random violence for the sake of random violence.
How would you rank the seasons of The Walking Dead? Let us know down in the comments.