The X-Files: 10 Questions We Still Need Answered

Scruffy minds want to know.

If you're an X-Files fan, you know the drill by now: nothing is ever simple. There are no firm endings, just open endings and more questions and what ifs. No one ever really dies on The X-Files. And the truth always remains out there - just out of reach. Tantalizingly so. The recent revival, in the form of a shortened tenth season, was no exception. With just six episodes produced, it had a lot of ground to fill - more than was realistically possible, frankly. Fans had high hopes, and while the six new episodes didn't all live up to those lofty expectations, there were some memorable moments, some shocks, some surprise returns - and, of course, precious few answers. Which means we have questions. Plenty of questions. Are you listening, Chris Carter? Thanks to stellar ratings that saw over fifty million viewers worldwide watch the premiere episodes alone, The X-Files will likely be back at some point, with Mulder and Scully in tow. The story isn't over yet, and be it another season or a third big screen movie, there are more truths to be uncovered. And maybe then, we'll get those answers. In the meantime - here are the questions, ten of them at least, that we're left with after The X-Files revival.

10. Who Else Is Aiding The Smoking Man?

When he summoned Monica Reyes to his bedside, the Cigarette Smoking Man, or Cancer Man, if you prefer, had a small army of guards, who informed Reyes about his condition, but assured her that he would recover. There, he offered her a deal - a pact with the devil, really. Aid him, and in turn, he would make her immune to the coming viral apocalypse. Yet who were those guards, and who else is aiding Ol' Smokey? The Syndicate is long dead, as are Agent Fowley and Alex Krycek, who was always playing for his own team anyway. Yet engineering an epidemic is no small feat, and would have required more than just a handful of conspirators in a dark room. Who were they?

9. Is The Public Now Aware Of Alien Life?

The season finale of the revival/season ten, My Struggle Part 2, ended on a cliffhanger. Mulder was ill, fallen victim to the Spartan virus. Agent Miller had rescued him from the clutches of the Smoking Man, but he was teetering on the edge. Scully was racing to save him, having synthesized a cure using her own blood, which contained alien DNA. Yet when she arrived, she realized she could not cure him - the vaccine would not be enough as his condition was too grave. Instead, he would need stem cells - from their long departed son William no less. And then an alien ship appeared over the crowded bridge on which they were standing, in full view of hundreds of people, if not more in you count the surrounding buildings and streets, the latter of which were all packed with cars. Will all those witnesses retain their memories of this incident? Is the existence of extraterrestrial life now publicly known in The X-Files universe?

8. Just Why Were The X-Files Re-Opened?

So one man wants to speak to Fox Mulder. A web newsman; a pseudo-journalist. The X-Files' version of Jesse Ventura's conspiracy show, with some Bill O'Reilly/Glenn Beck thrown in for good measure. And that draws Mulder out of isolation, and back to the FBI? The agents were actually forgiven - despite Mulder supposedly having a death sentence over his head - after the events of 2008's I Want To Believe. All charges (which were ludicrous in the first place) were dropped. So it was safe for them to return - but fans were never given an explanation as to why the unit was reopened in the revival. Did Walter Skinner order it? Why would he have authority to? He never seemed to have that much power in the past, and it's clear that his position hasn't changed. This might have been an oversight caused by the small batch of episodes optioned, but we'd really like to know: who in the FBI signed off on Mulder and Scully working there again?

7. Miller And Einstein - Are They The Future?

Agents Miller (the believer) and Einstein (the red-headed, skeptical scientist) were introduced in Babylon and returned in the finale of the revival, My Struggle Part 2. They are, in short, Mulder and Scully Jr. Watered down, generic, pretty faces conforming with what's "in" in Hollywood these days. Word is, they were introduced to be part of some backdoor pilot idea, part of a next generation X-Files. But are they really the future? They didn't exactly ignite the imagination of fans, and Chris Carter has mentioned that they were not signed to series contracts. Will they come back if the show returns? Or will Fox, who own the series, simply order more of the original show, or go in an entirely different direction?

6. Are Mulder And Scully Back Together?

As the episodes of season ten progressed, Mulder and Scully seemed to gravitate from being an amicably divorced couple (not literally) to close friends to... well, we don't know. After acknowledging that giving up their son has affected them more than they ever anticipated, they seem somewhat at ease with one another, which was not the case out of the gate. It's a holding hands, taking walks sort of comfort, not a casual sex sort of comfort. Yet what does it mean? Are Mulder and Scully back together? Will they once again become romantically attached? With this fan base, there's no way you can please all the parties all the time, but eventually the situation needs finality.

5. Why Isn't Mulder Immune To The Spartan Virus?

Scully's alien DNA made her immune to the Spartan virus - the disease attacking human immune systems, making them susceptible to all sorts of otherwise benign ailments. The big question is - why wasn't Mulder also immune? Remember that in seasons six and seven, we saw a storyline unfold where Mulder, who was exposed to the alien black oil and the virus it carries back in fourth season, essentially became something of an alien-human hybrid himself. This resulted in the Smoking Man having an operation performed in which he had some of Mulder's genetic material mixed with his own, to give himself immunity to the alien virus. If, presumably, Mulder and Scully have been through similar experiments over the course of the show, why is one immune and the other not? We're not the only ones asking this question - Chris Carter, the show's creator, also highlighted it as something that needed answering in a recent interview with TVLine.

4. Where Is John Doggett?

John Doggett (Robert Patrick) might have irked David Duchovny fans back when he joined The X-Files in seasons eight and nine (some particularly nasty fans took to calling him Dogbreath), but the fact remains that he was an integral part of the show in those seasons, and did an admirable job with the deck stacked against him. Patrick won a Saturn award for his troubles, and if television had a Medal of Honor he should have been given that too, for facing down some particularly ugly, vocal online criticisms at the time, none of which had much merit. In those years, Doggett took on the role of the skeptic while Scully transitioned to believer, along with Monica Reyes, and really, those two seasons were an improvement on the show's final year with Duchovny. Doggett was something new: a no-nonsense cop who felt solid detective work was the key to solving X-Files. In short, he was the anti-Mulder, and having met Agent Miller (a.k.a. Mulder Part 2), we suddenly appreciate him that much more. While the revival brought Monica Reyes back, her friend and co-worker, Doggett, was nowhere to be found. That's a shame, and we'd love to know what became of him. Maybe Robert Patrick was busy with Scorpion, or just wasn't interested, but if the show can get him back, or give some sort of closure to his character, it would be welcome.

3. Are The Lone Gunmen Alive Or Dead?

Look, you flew one of them in from Australia, but didn't give any of them speaking lines? Seriously, what gives? The Lone Gunmen are alive in The X-Files comic run, which, we have been told, is canon. In the show, we've been told they are dead, and since season nine's Jump the Shark (a mistake in many ways), they've been seen on screen twice: Mulder hallucinated them in the desert in The Truth, the series finale at the time, and again in the fifth episode of the revival, Babylon. Hallucinations don't mean someone is dead - these weren't ghosts it seems, just Mulder having visions in both cases (he also saw Krycek in The Truth, who we know is dead). So they could be alive - but it's an answer we want to know for sure. And really, all that for a silly cameo? We miss these guys, give us more!

2. Was Colonization A Hoax/Smokescreen?

You can almost break down the mythology of The X-Files by era, though it does all tie together, especially in the first five years and the first movie. Some will tell you it got convoluted, but they weren't paying enough attention. It's too long to get into here, but the short version is: Fox Mulder's sister is abducted by aliens, an act he witnesses, as a child. This drives his lifelong pursuit of "the truth" about the paranormal and the existence of aliens. He uncovers a plot, including his own father, to dupe the public about alien life, and an otherworldly scheme to recolonize the Earth. An alien race who once walked the planet is set to return, and intend to utilize mankind - both as their slaves, and as hosts to their own consciousness, carried in the form of a virus, and which can gestate inside its human host. The show would branch off with ideas about super soldiers and the like. Colonization, however, was always the biggest plot point. By the seventh season, it is learned that Mulder may himself be some sort of alien/human hybrid thanks to exposure to the black oil virus. And then in the revival, the whole thread is dropped. Aliens exist, we're told, but it's men in the government using their technology to take over the world that is the real threat. That's the goal of the Smoking Man, not colonization. What? Were nine years of mythology for nothing, or is this just a red herring?

1. What Has Become Of William?

The colonization point could easily have been the biggest question of the season, were it not for Mulder and Scully's son William. Where William is, what he has become, and what he represents, however, are probably the biggest questions of all. Scully gave the child up willingly - that we've known for years. He had been hunted by both men and aliens, so it seemed a safe bet, especially after he displayed supernatural abilities early on. Now, it appears that the life of Fox Mulder depends on finding William. What will that do to a boy entering his teenage years? How will he react to knowing who, and what, he is? Has he already seen signs that he is not normal? Is he still a supernatural being, having been injected with a substance back in the ninth season that supposedly muted his powers? And here's one last question/suggestion when it comes to William Mulder, named for Fox Mulder's murdered father: would a show focusing on him as a young man, uncovering his family history, and trying to live up to the legacy not be a lot more interesting than a couple of Mulder and Scully clones? What do you want answered before the franchise calls it a day? Add your thoughts below!

In this post: 
The X-Files
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.