Top 25 Sitcom Christmas Specials
As December begins, so does Christmas. And with it comes merriment, goodwill to all men, and Mistletoe And Wine being played so often that you want to garrotte Cliff Richard with Christmas tree lights. But one of the biggest Christmas staples is the sitcom Christmas special. And to celebrate the start of the festive season, weve compiled the twenty five best ones. But before we begin, two things: 1. This list is subjective. As much of a socially stunted sitcom addict as I am, there are sitcoms that I either havent seen or just dont care for. And 2.To be eligible or a place on this list, two criteria must be met. It has to be a sitcom. Panel shows, sketch shows, and comedy dramas arent eligible. The plot has to involve Christmas. Being broadcast at Christmas isnt enough to get it on this list. So, with that in mind, let's dive in... 25. The Simpsons Grift Of The Magi (FOX, 1999)
A corporation takes over Springfield elementary school and uses the children to come up with ideas for a new toy named Funzo. Originally, this slot was filled by the series very first episode Simpsons Roasting On An Open Fire but on a rewatch, I found to be a bit shaky (which is understandable since its the first episode) and just not as funny as I remembered. So delving into the episodes of The Simpsons I knew from before I stopped watching it (Around Series 17), I rediscovered Grift Of The Magi. Although, its a Christmas episode, it sidesteps the traditional sitcom Christmas jokes, focussing more on satirising the commercial side of it. As a nineteen year old resident of the UK, the Gary Coleman cameo really doesnt do anything for me and it takes a while for the plot to get going but, as mentioned, theres some good satire in there and a nicely executed parody of various well known Christmas stories at the end. Best Moment: Homer, Bart, and Lisa stealing all the Funzos after discovering that they are programmed to destroy other toys.
24. Benidorm (ITV1, 2010)
Its Christmastime in Benidorm as the Garvey family return to visit their uniquely foul-tempered elderly relative Madge whos struggling to locate her nightclubs guest act Su Pollard. This episodes a bit scattershot with so many tenuously connected plotlines but they seem to work reasonably well on their own if not together. The episodes main aim is to kill Madges husband Mel due to the death of actor Geoffrey Hutchings before production began on the episode but it still weaves some good comedy moments around that required scene. Geordie actor Tim Healey is excellent in his supporting role as transvestite handyman Les/Leslie, and its got brilliant cameos from Cilla Black, Su Pollard, and Roy Wood as well as an incredibly disappointing one from Louie Spence (Which is disappointing solely because it exists) and theres some pretty serious mood whiplash towards the end as we go straight from Roy Wood performing I Wish It Could Be Christmas Every Day to the characters learning of Mels death but the drama of the scene works well enough. Its far from perfect but its good fun and pays a decent tribute to both Mel and Geoffrey Hutchings. Best Moment: Madges argument with Su Pollard and its aftermath.
23. The Big Bang Theory The Bath Item Gift Hypothesis (CBS, 2008)
Leonard befriends a colleague but is annoyed when he starts dating Penny. Meanwhile, Sheldon agonises over finding a Christmas present for Penny thats worth the same as whatever she is giving him. Ill be honest, the main attraction of this episode is the side-plot that sees Sheldons neuroses go into overdrive when choosing Pennys Christmas present. The Leonard and Penny plot is quite dull and just doesnt have the spark and creativity of Sheldon dealing with Christmas. Its that story that has the best dialogue, and situational and sight gags. Its almost entirely Sheldon-driven but Raj and Howard get some decent moments as well. Theres not much else to say than its traditional Big Bang Theory with a Christmas subplot in the mix. A solid effort, milking the situation for all its worth with great results. Best Moment: Sheldons reaction to being given a napkin used by Leonard Nimoy.
22. How I Met Your Mother How Lily Stole Christmas (CBS, 2006)
Lily discovers an answering machine message in which Ted calls her a Grinch (Future Teds euphemism for a very bad word). As revenge, she steals all of his Christmas decorations. Parodies of The Grinch are pretty common but this one is actually quite inventive and uses the bare bones of The Grinchs plot to build a more character driven story. A really clever plot device is that since Ted is telling the story to his children in the future (the framing device of the entire show), he replaces very instance of the offending word (Its four letters long and begins with C) with 'Grinch'. Not only does it allow the shows writers to get the story across without falling foul of the censors, it also allows for scenes like Teds cousins (all of whom are younger than ten and have incredibly strict Christian parents) saying the word Grinch over and over again. It may seem juvenile that this is why I think this episode is so funny but its really the context that elevates it above just being crude. As well as that, overall theres some good character moments and its a decent personal story between Lily and Ted. Its not as Christmassy as it could have been but its still very funny. Best Moment: The reactions from incidental characters whenever Ted says Grinch.
21. Miranda The Perfect Christmas (BBC One, 2010)
Tired of Christmas with her overbearing and embarrassing parents, joke shop owner Miranda plans the perfect Christmas with no family. Miranda is a sitcom that tends to polarise sitcom viewers. On the one hand, there are people who see it as an enjoyable bit of fluff that doesnt bother itself with serious meaning, and on the other there are people who consider it to be lowbrow and outdated. This episodes not the best of the series but it boasts some fairly entertaining moments and a wonderfully deadpan performance by Tom Conti (The Dark Knight Rises) as Mirandas father. Its a little bit over the top at times but thats one of the reasons I personally enjoy it so much. Its stupid and farcical but its funny and lighthearted. Its also quite refreshing for a sitcom to show the hassle of Christmas shopping from the shopkeepers point of view as Miranda finds herself overwhelmed by the Christmas Eve rush in her joke shop. Best Moment: Mirandas parents Christmas party, complete with a rewritten version of Good King Wenceslas that mocks Miranda.
20. Family Guy A Very Special Family Guy Freakin' Christmas (FOX, 2001)
The stress of Christmas finally pushes Lois over the edge, causing her to go on an anti-Yuletide rampage. Back in the days before I personally think Family Guy lost its way (Around Season 6), it got its first Christmas episode towards the end of Season Three. There are some good jokes based around the hell of Christmas shopping, Peters stupidity, and one about a very disturbing use for a video recorder. One of the episodes biggest strengths is how well everythings tied together. The subplot of Stewie attempting to appease Santa and get some plutonium for Christmas is skilfully weaved into the main story and nothing feels like too much of a non-sequitur. As well as that, the cutaways are limited and always relevant. There are no This is worse than that time when (Insert joke here) gags which means that the episode never strays far from its premise. Its focussed, has a relatively fresh story, and is good slightly off-colour fun. Best Moment: Loiss rampage including her pushing George Bailey (the main character of Its A Wonderful Life) off a bridge and melting Frosty the Snowman.
19. Men Behaving Badly Jingle Balls (BBC One, 1997)
Gary battles with the turkey while Tonys clinginess begins to grate on Deborah. Im just going to get my one annoyance with this out of the way right now: the fantasy sequences showing the characters having a perfect Christmas in a large house with servants are used way too much. Its a good joke at first but by the third or fourth time, its just dull. But other than that, its business as usual for Men Behaving Badly. Theres all of the staple Christmas gags like terrible Christmas presents (a deep fat fryer and a stolen birdhouse from Gary) and the nightmare of preparing Christmas dinner, but neatly avoids the cliché of characters spending time with family members they hate by having the main four characters spend Christmas with each other. The only other disappointment is that we dont get any of Gary and Tonys trademark rambling conversations. Though we do get a pretty funny opening scene without Deborah and Dorothy in which Gary tries to buy Christmas presents from passers-by while a drunk Tony snogs a dog and a cars wing mirror. A great episode but dragged down by the overused fantasy sequences. Best Moment: Tony burying Deborahs presents after she calls him an annoying puppy.
18. Not Going Out Absent Father Christmas (BBC One, 2008)
Lees Christmas is complicated by the return of his estranged father, Frank who claims he is dying. As is usual for Not Going Out, much of the comedy of this episode is based on rapid-fire one liners and puns but the inclusion of Frank as a character allows for some new elements such as Lee struggling with an irritating houseguest rather than flatmate Lucys issues with him, and the scenes of Lee and Frank (both of whom are equally devious and mistrustful) attempting to outwit each other as Lee attempts to prove that Frank is lying about being terminally ill. The best thing about the episode is Bobby Balls performance as Frank. Hes working with a very well written script and has near perfect comic timing. The episode also does something new in pushing main characters Lucy, Tim, and Barbara into the background giving much of the meat of the episode to Lee Mack and Bobby Ball. It does something different but keeps true to its tried and tested formula. Its not the most Christmas-centric of Christmas specials but it does just fine in my book. Its low on the list because it borrows far too much from the Only Fools And Horses episode Thicker Than Water that saw Del and Rodneys estranged father return at Christmas. Best Moment: The flashback to Frank taking a young Lee to the fair and teaching him the very Northern life lesson If youve tried your heart and still havent won something, just nick it.
17. Outnumbered The Robbers (BBC One, 2009)
Boxing Day is anything but relaxing for the Brockmans as they deal with the aftermath of being robbed. Semi-improvised comedy Outnumbereds first Christmas special does its best to break away from Christmas sitcom conventions with the episode being set on Boxing Day rather than Christmas Day, and with the story focussing more on the aftermath of the robbery as parents Sue and Pete try to rationalise their planned insurance fraud. Ramona Marquez (Karen) and Daniel Roches (Ben) largely improvised and incredibly natural performances are a real highlight. However, Tyger Drew-Honey (Jake) is beginning to show signs of growing out of the role and doesnt really have the same impact as his younger cast-mates. Its pretty standard stuff but Roche and Marquezs improvisation really takes it to a higher level. Best Moment: Ben talking about the possibility of the burglars returning when Pete is trying to convince a terrified Karen that they're perfectly safe.
16. The Worst Week Of My Life The Worst Christmas Of My Life (BBC One, 2006)
Walking disaster area Howard Steel (Ben Miller) goes to spend Christmas with his in-laws but, as usual, finds himself in their bad books after causing a number of small catastrophes. This ones a bit of a cheat since its a three episode miniseries but I still think it deserves a place on this list. The Worst Week Of My Life is a bit like a modern Some Mothers Do Ave Em only with cruder jokes and a more self-assured protagonist. As well as the physical comedy and the farce elements, its the intricate plotting of the jokes that makes this such a good miniseries. A good example of this is Howard accidentally urinating over his in-laws Christmas goose. Its a relatively small moment in itself but its the starting point for a huge number of other jokes throughout the three episodes that happen as a result of that mistake. Other than the writing and plotting, Ben Millers excellent performance is the cornerstone of it all but the supporting cast do a brilliant job, especially Geoffrey Whitehead as Howards father-in-law Dick, whose sardonic comments are always a great counterpoint to the physical jokes. Best Moment: Howard dragging Dick into the house shouting Look what Ive found after knocking him unconscious in a minor car crash at a time when (thanks to a misunderstanding) everyone thinks he (Dick) is dead. Angelas (Alison Steadman) reaction is priceless.