True Detective: 10 Dream Castings For Season 4
Ali and Dorff were an unlikely pairing that struck gold in Season Three... so who’s next?
Season 3 of True Detective got Nic Pizzolatto’s anthology crime series firmly back on track after star performances from Mahershala Ali and Stephen Dorff. Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey’s dynamic was crucial to the show’s initial success, and the show has been built upon the sparks flying between the leads.
Right from the start, the show has always had huge A-List stars in its lead roles, and while Dorff is probably the smallest name of the lot, he’s arguably turned in one of the best performances yet as the haggard Detective West. Season 4 will likely have some big names too, and hopefully will strike upon another dream team.
This explores not only twenty actors who fit the True Detective aesthetic and ideals perfectly, but also assembles them into ten duos able to carry a season. Examining the typical roles of these actors, what kind of characters True Detective usually has and how their dynamics could work all come into play here.
Sometimes actors pull out the performance of a lifetime (see, Stephen Dorff), so even if none of these twenty are cast, True Detective Season 4 has tons of momentum from Season 3. Still though, it’s fun to speculate.
10. Sam Rockwell And Christopher Walken
If you like True Detective, you should really consider watching Seven Psychopaths. It’s just as dark, has the same noirish vibes, but has more comedy thrown in there too. It’s Martin McDonagh’s least famous film, but it can kick it with Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri and In Bruges nonetheless.
The cast of Seven Psychopaths includes True Detective alumni Colin Farrell and Woody Harrelson, as well as Rockwell and Walken, so the True Detective suitability is baked into the pairing.
Walken has a dark, mysterious edge to every one of his roles, something in his voice and mannerisms that makes him both compelling and disconcerting. Rockwell, meanwhile, is a relative chameleon, able to embody a multitude of roles but still somehow make us root for him.
Given Walken’s age, if Pizzolatto was to do a time jump again we might only see him in the earliest era, giving us a new plot strand as Rockwell is left to figure out the case alone. With Walken’s mysterious vibes and Rockwell often playing loners, these two together could create a powerful dynamic in the first era that fades into a more ethereal connection post time jump as Rockwell deals with the hole left by his mentor.
9. Regina King And Sam Elliott
Regina King scooped Best Supporting Actress at this year’s Oscars for her powerhouse turn in the moving If Beale Street Could Talk, and while no True Detective fan would begrudge Mahershala Ali’s win the Supporting Actor category, Sam Elliott can feel a little hard done by that his role as the emotionally wounded brother in A Star Is Born left him empty-handed.
In Season 3, following an argument over the case, Stephen Dorff’s Roland just catches himself before he calls Ali’s Hays ‘n***er’. Hays challenges him to say it, but Roland says it’s enough for Hays to know he was thinking it.
King is no stranger to racially charged roles, having featured in The Boondocks as well as Beale Street. Nobility with anger in the face of injustice is something she does incredibly well.
Elliott, meanwhile, is somewhat of a throwback, with the looks, mannerisms... even an aura of years gone by. King and Elliott might clash more than the other partnerships, but that would be an excellent way to shake things up. Both are experts at playing the ‘wounded animal’ archetype in one way or another; it would be fascinating to see them oppose each other in a character-driven story.
8. Evan Peters And Rami Malek
If they play Season 4 safe, these two likely won’t get a look in. However, if they decide to take a risk with two younger stars, in Malek and Peters they’d have two actors whose stock is set to rise for years to come.
Along with Sarah Paulson, many would credit Evan Peters with carrying the American Horror Story franchise with his (often subtly) dark characters. Paulson has broken out into Crime Story, Carol and Glass, while Peters has instead gone to X-Men to establish himself as a blockbuster name.
Speaking of subtlety, while Malek’s performance as Freddie Mercury was over the top by design, his roles in Mr. Robot and BoJack Horseman are both more reserved and nuanced. Two young guns on their first case could be a cracking story.
Both actors have an air of cockiness about them when they turn it on, and as such a pairing with a more grizzled, older actor may be better. However, seeing two idealistic, slightly naive detectives changed in different ways by the twisted darkness of the crime they uncover would be a bold new direction for the show to take.
7. Nikolaj Coster-Waldau And Kristen Stewart
Put down the pitchforks for a second. Yes, Stewart is absolutely cardboard in Twilight, but if you’ve seen the rest of her career you’ll know how much of a splotch on her record that is.
She pretty much steals the show in Still Alice (along with the Oscar-winning turn from Julianne Moore), and has an ethereal grit in The Clouds Of Sils Maria and Personal Shopper.
As for Nikolaj Coster-Waldau, he’ll be in need of a new role once Game Of Thrones reaches its electrifying conclusion this May. He has an easy charm in his performance as Jaime, one that hides the struggles and insecurities underneath. Later series explore this complexity well, as True Detective would allow him to flex his subtle talent once more.
As for their pairing, Stewart does best when bouncing off someone; she’d be the Marty to Coster-Waldau’s Rust. Also, in Game Of Thrones, Lena Heady’s reserved approach to Cersei, only letting her emotions burst out when she’s at her most venomous, is very similar to Stewart’s style; this pair could have an unpredictably brilliant chemistry.
Stewart brings a disaffected coldness while Coster-Waldau has charisma to spare; they could be a modern-day Mulder and Scully.
6. Jon Hamm And Christoph Waltz
Jon Hamm has already led one of the most acclaimed shows of all time in Mad Men, while Christoph Waltz is the only actor to win an Oscar under Quentin Tarantino’s eclectic directing style; a feat Waltz has pulled off twice. If these two were cast, there would be no doubts to the quality of talent on screen.
Hamm’s portrayal as Don Draper is one of the most complex performances in television history, something often missed by those who idolise his smooth talking ways. The man is empty, broken, vulnerable; yet he’s cool, charming and full of charisma at the same time.
As for Waltz, he’s perhaps more recognisable as a villain, but his role in Django Unchained shows - if there was any doubt - that he’s capable of much more. Both are actors who are excellent at showing deep, internal conflict.
Waltz’s charm is a lot more relaxed than Hamm’s (which by design often comes off as self-serving), and their mutual abilities to play easy going characters with turbulent souls could be fascinating, especially with a time jump in the equation.
Similar to Malek/Peters, these two could be an initially easygoing pair, forever changed by what they witness.
5. Ryan Gosling And Kirsten Dunst
Ryan Gosling seems made for True Detective, having apparently rejected the expected trajectory of his career and turning away from the Hollywood pretty boy leads The Notebook and Crazy, Stupid Love set him up for.
Instead, Gosling has starred in increasingly darker tales like Lars And The Real Girl, Drive, A Place Beyond The Pines and Only God Forgives. Dunst’s career has gone in a similar way, with her making her name in more cheery, popcorn movies like Drop Dead Gorgeous and Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy.
Since then, she’s shown serious acting chops in Melancholia and The Two Faces Of January, while her ability to carry a TV series was clear as the best thing in Fargo’s second season. Both she and Gosling are actors of serious steel that’s sometimes missed in the midst of their Hollywood looks.
In All Good Things, the pair had electrifying chemistry, with Gosling hiding his inner darkness throughout while the storyline twisted Dunst’s character into knots until it all spilled out. The film itself was only okay, but with a tighter storyline and the romance angle put aside for the violent thrills crime dramas often bring, these two could light up the small screen.
4. Michael Shannon And Jeremy Renner
Michael Shannon has already played a role similar to one that could feature in True Detective, as the cancer stricken investigator in Nocturnal Animals. That role saw him bag an Oscar nomination, so there’s every chance he’d want to take up the role again.
Besides, with Pizzolatto’s character building and Shannon’s wide range, he could inhabit a completely different personality this time around.
If Renner, providing comic relief while carrying a mature, subtle storyline, gives Shannon a different dynamic to move with, the results would be completely different anyway. Shannon straddles the line between genuinely deep and overreaching into ridiculousness; in Nocturnal Animals, lesser screen time, great writing and Gyllenhaal’s performance kept him the right side of things.
Renner meanwhile has the same smile-inducing nature as Woody Harrelson when he turns on the charm. Just like Harrelson as Hart though, he’s great at pulling overly serious tones back to a relatable level while holding his own in the most demanding sequences.
Together, Shannon allows Pizzolatto the gravitas for his most poetic and mystical lines, while Renner undercuts that perfectly to keep it level. Season Three took some leaves from Season One’s book; Season Four could recreate Marty & Rust.
3. Olivia Colman And Rosamund Pike
Two English actresses might be a bridge too far not just for audiences, but in terms of explaining why the two are working on a case likely to take place in the USA’s Deep South. However, Pike has used an American previously, so let’s just brush past that for now.
As well as the accent, Pike is no stranger to grisly roles, most notably her career-best performance in Gone Girl. She’s often deliberately unlikable, supposed to make audience’s hairs stand up on end.
Colman, on the other hand, is usually the most likeable thing whatever she’s in, be that her earlier comedy or her more recent drama. She may be looking to expand her career after her recent Oscar win, and though she won’t be short of offers, a HBO TV show with critical acclaim certainly won’t be the worst of them.
With Pike’s addictive detestability offset by Colman’s charm, these two have the ability to create a great pairing; one that may even actively ask the audience to take sides. McConaughey’s wounded Cohle in the present is so powerful because we’re rooting for him. Giving us a distaste for Pike would pull the rug out from beneath us.
2. Michael Fassbender And Hugh Jackman
Fassbender has a fascinatingly unpredictable career, with indie movies like Fish Tank and Hunger sitting alongside Oscar showpieces 12 Years A Slave and blockbusters like X-Men and Prometheus. With that level of diversity and the willingness to take risks, a southern noir crime drama would certainly be at home in his catalogue.
Fellow X-Men alum Hugh Jack will always be best known for Wolverine, and recent surprise hit The Greatest Showman saw him shine in another popcorn flick seat filler. Take a closer look at his work though, and Logan, Les Miserables and his numerous stage performances show he’s an incredible actor; much more than muscles and a smile.
Despite their X-Men link, the differing timelines and alternate footing as hero and villain means they’ve only shared a handful of scenes together. However, they (along with James McAvoy) frequently junket together and their chemistry is off the charts.
Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey were great friends before Season One was even cast, which makes sense given how famously laid back the pair are. Their closeness undoubtedly added to their performance, and though we haven’t seen it used in X-Men, it’s clear from interviews that Fassbender and Jackman are best buds too.
1. Charlize Theron And Clive Owen
Charlize Theron, like so many others on this list, has an eccentric back catalogue of movies in her roster. With one Oscar win (Moster) and another nomination (North County), she’s also featured in Mad Max, Young Adult, The Burning Plains, Fast & Furious and Prometheus.
Add in the ludicrous ones like A Million Ways To Die In The West and Gringo, and you’ll find a wonderful actress always pushing her limits and willing to take risks. Atomic Blonde especially showcases how brilliant she’d be in the HBO drama.
Clive Owen’s filmography has narrower range, though most would next to Theron’s. In there though, you’ll find Sin City, Closer and Children Of Men; all movies that sit comfortably with True Detective, while The Knick shows he’s able to carry his talent over to TV too.
Owen is apparently quite nice in real life, but his characters often have a thuggish, sometimes sexist edge to them. Theron on the other hand, takes no prisoners. He brings with him something of the old school, and she’d be fascinating to watch as a brilliant talent struggling to be taken seriously in whatever era Pizzolatto sets Season Four in.
These two would be an absolute powder keg together.
What's your dream pairing for Season 4? Let us know down in the comments.