Why The Walking Dead Can't Survive Without Rick Grimes
Don't dead open inside.
It's finally happening: Andrew Lincoln is (reportedly) leaving The Walking Dead in Season 9.
According to Collider, Lincoln will be appearing in just six episodes of the forthcoming ninth season, and his departure will happen before the finale. The show has lost a lot of key players before - it's partially how it got its reputation, after all - but this is the single biggest change to ever happen to the series.
It comes at a period of uncertainty for the show: showrunner Scott Gimple, who has been overseeing the show since Season 4, is taking on a broader role across the TWD franchise, with Angela Kang stepping up to run the main show. Meanwhile, as well as Lincoln, Lauren Cohan (Maggie Rhee) is also only going to be in just six episodes of Season 9.
On top of all that, ratings have been sliding for the past couple of years, and are now back down to where they were around Season 2, which was before the show took off and become a behemoth. It's fair to say that the show does need a bit of freshening up if it's going to stay on the air (whether it should do that or not is another matter), but losing Lincoln is a blow too big to survive.
4. Rick IS The Show
Ever since its inception back in 2010, Lincoln's Rick Grimes has been the face of the show. He's the series' main protagonist, the sun around which all else orbits, and the basis for pretty much everything that's happened.
The show obviously has a number of other major characters, but none are as developed as Rick nor as important to the narrative. They mostly exist by way of their relationship to Rick: his son, his partner, his friend, his deadly enemy and so on.
This is Rick's storyline above all else, and we've seen a number of instances where episodes that don't involve him can feel like they're missing something. It's not necessarily a good thing that one character is still so intrinsic to the show after so long, but - despite some excellent performances - that is the way it's been written, and at this stage it's a very difficult status quo to move on from while still being The Walking Dead.
3. Carl Was Its Only Future
Rick may be the show, but there was once a possibility of a future without him in the form of his son, Carl. The story was his as much as Rick's, if not more: he was the entire reason Rick fought to survive and create a better world in the first place, and - while Chandler Riggs wasn't the best actor - Carl was the only character well-placed to take the story further in the event of Rick dying.
Of course, The Walking Dead being The Walking Dead, they killed the younger Grimes off in Season 8. Not only was this an invalidation of Rick's entire arc up until that point, but it also robbed the show of its clear future. Without Carl there isn't anyone to really pass the baton on to.
There are plenty of other characters, but none who could have the same sort of arc, and most have reached points in their journeys where there isn't all that much more to do with them, at least not as the main character. That's what Carl represented, and one of his reasons his death was such a huge mistake.
2. Daryl Dixon Isn't Enough To Carry It
'If Daryl dies we riot'.
It was a common refrain during the first few seasons of The Walking Dead, when the character - who was invented for the TV show - became a firm fan-favourite thanks to being a total badass but with a heart of gold.
Nowadays, if Daryl dies we... shrug? The character is still popular, but the past few years have done hardly anything with him. We're long past the point of him being the best character in terms of development or how he's written, with him so often shunted to the sidelines.
That, in turn, makes it difficult to suddenly make him the lead of the show, which Collider's report suggests AMC are aiming to do (including a bumper payday for Norman Reedus). Daryl is the archetypal breakout supporting character: he's cool, he's great in the action sequences, he's slightly mysterious and aloof. He's essentially the Han Solo to Rick Grimes' Luke Skywalker, and there's a reason Han wasn't the main character of Star Wars. Reedus is excellent, but it's impossible to imagine Daryl as the series' narrative, character, and emotional anchor. But then, that's true of all the characters.
1. Time To End?
The two best performers on the show for some time have been Lennie James and Melissa McBride, but neither are well-placed to be the lead - James because Morgan is now on Fear, and McBride because Carol's arc has encompassed pretty much everything already. Michonne, the only other major character with serious development, might be the best fit, but Danai Gurira might be off after Season 9 anyway, and like Daryl they haven't done enough to build the character up into someone ready to lead it into a long-term future.
That leaves us with Jeffrey Dean Morgan, who gives a charismatic performance as Negan, but the character himself is rather empty. He's still the main villain at this point, albeit a defeated one, and given what he's done it'd be impossible for Negan to become a heroic character - or even just one we could buy into as the focal point of the series, despite the prominence of him over the past couple of years. They could always introduce someone new, but not many memorable characters have entered the show in recent years, and it'd get to the point where it might as well be another spin-off.
Even with Rick still alive, the show was growing stale, repetetive, and boring. With Rick on the way out, and Carl already gone, there's no longer a real purpose to this story, and The Walking Dead would be better off ending than trying to limp on. The show has been bitten, and now it needs to be killed off before it reanimates.
What do you think about Andrew Lincoln leaving The Walking Dead? Let us know down in the comments.