YOU: 8 Most Intriguing Fan Theories
Did Joe try to kill Candace and Mr. Mooney?
Based on Caroline Kepnes’ novel of the same name, Lifetime’s YOU follows the life of Joe Goldberg, a bookstore manager who stalks and then dates aspiring writer Guinevere Beck.
As the show’s protagonist, Joe does a lot of questionable things – all in the name of love – which has created debate around if we’re supposed to sympathise with his character of not. Either way, Joe remains an unreliable narrator and there are certainly some moments that lack clarity and raise questions.
Whilst we wait for Season 2, fans have been coming up with intriguing theories to make sense of some of the show’s unanswered questions.
Which ones do you believe?
Contains spoilers for all of YOU Season 1.
8. Dr. Nicky Has To Know
Beck starts seeing therapist Dr. Nicky after Peach’s death. When Joe finds out Beck and Dr. Nicky are having an affair, they break up and Joe starts seeing him for sessions under the alias Paul.
One fan theory explains that Dr. Nicky must have been able to figure out that Paul is really Beck’s Joe. This is based on the fact Joe and Beck were telling him the same story from different perspectives, despite the fact that Joe pretended to be gay.
Even if he didn’t figure it out from that, it’s likely that Dr. Nicky’s affair with Beck will have lead him to check her out on social media at least once. Social media is a very big part of Beck’s life and she has photos of her and Joe on her Instagram account.
In the Season 1 finale, Dr. Nicky is arrested for Beck’s murder due to Joe’s planted evidence and Beck’s manuscript detailing his fake obsession with her. If he knows who Joe is, it shouldn’t take him long to figure out that he had something to do with his arrest and Beck’s death.
Not to mention, Dr. Nicky has recordings of them both from therapy.
7. Joe Caused Mr. Mooney’s Stroke
Joe explained to Beck how he visited Mr. Mooney after he and Candace broke up. He found Mooney lying on the floor after suffering from a stroke two days prior, which left him paralysed and unable to speak.
Joe blames himself because he should have been there. He says he’s made an effort to visit Mooney every week since, so it does sound like it could be one of Joe’s genuine, regrettable mistakes. However, this fan theory puts forward the possibility that it was Joe who caused Mooney’s stroke.
There are a few reasons why Joe could want to hurt Mooney. The first is that he knew he killed Elijah, the man Candace had an affair with. The second is that he was getting revenge for the abuse he suffered at Mooney’s hands when he was younger.
Despite this, Mooney is the only family Joe has ever really known, which might explain why Joe paralysed him instead of killed him. On the other hand, maybe he really did try to kill Mooney but something went wrong.
6. Mr. Mooney Is A Serial Killer
Could it be possible that Mr. Mooney was an experienced serial killer who mentored a young Joe? Many fans really like the idea of this theory, and even the ones who think it’s unlikely still know there's something sinister about Mooney’s character.
There’s a scene where Joe shows Paco the book vault and explains how to properly care for the old, limited edition books. This is intercut with flashbacks of Mooney giving Joe the same speech when he was a teenager. This shows that Mooney taught a lot to Joe, and it’s obvious that Joe sees himself in Paco and tries to protect him.
But maybe this wasn’t all Mooney taught Joe. He was the one who Joe confided in when he killed Elijah and his response was “some people deserve to die.” Perhaps Mooney had a code of conduct for such a situation, because he also told Joe exactly what to do when this happened.
There is also the fact that Joe mentions the door in the book vault was built for cash transactions, but we never see it used in this way, even in flashbacks of Mooney. Plus, the vault is soundproof so it could be that Mooney used it in the same way that Joe did.
Whilst Mooney had strict rules for protecting the beloved books, he still trapped Joe in the vault on more than one occasion, so we know that he’s capable of at least that.
5. Joe Tried To Kill Candace
Joe was visibly shocked when Candace returned at the end of the season. He says, “Candace, you’re…” and she finishes his sentence with “Alive.” This alone implies that Joe thought she was dead and she knew that.
In one of his hallucinations of Candace, she says to him, “Are you gonna leave Beck alone, or will she end up like me?” This could just be a reference to how things ended, but it also sounds like Joe tried to kill her and believed he was successful.
This fan theory also places Joe as the one running Candace’s Instagram account. When Beck can’t find any trace of Candace online, Joe pulls it up and explains that she changed her name. There are loads of posts on there of Candace supposedly in Italy.
We know that Joe has the skills to maintain a fake social media account as we’ve seen him pretend to be Beck and her friends as a way of making it seem like they were alive for longer.
It’s likely that Joe made and maintained the account in order to protect himself. He knows that Candace’s friends think he had something to do with her disappearance, so he was likely making sure he has proof she’s ok in case anyone gets too close to the truth.
But why did Candace never have an actual social media account? She wouldn’t have wanted to alert Joe to the fact she was still alive. Not until she was ready.
4. Mr. Mooney Tried To Kill Candace
If Joe didn’t try and kill Candace, then maybe Mr. Mooney did. After Candace cheated on Joe, he turned to Mooney to help him get through the heartbreak.
After seeing how hurt Joe was over Candace, another theory suggests that it was Mooney that tried to kill her. As mentioned previously, he did tell Joe that “some people deserve to die” and he probably thought she should join Elijah for the pain they caused Joe.
This also serves as another reason for why Joe might’ve caused Mooney’s stroke. As hurt as he was over Candace, he could’ve found out what Mooney did and tried to kill him.
It would also explain why Joe was surprised to see her; not because he killed her, but because he thought Mooney did.
3. Joe Hallucinates More Than We Think
We know that Joe is an unreliable narrator. At times, he has visions of Candace who says things that imply that Joe is guilty of something and is haunted by his past.
But what if Joe’s visions are more frequent than that and less obvious? This fan theory is explained using Peach’s head injury as an example.
When Joe attacked Peach with a rock in the park, her head injury seemed really bad. But when he sees her after the incident, she looks completely fine. Peach left the hospital pretty quickly with just a concussion.
The fact that Peach appears unscathed could be a result of Joe hallucinating and seeing what he wants to see. After all, Joe has stated on multiple occasions that he thinks Peach is attention seeking, which could be altering his perception of reality.
2. Karen Knows Joe’s Secret
In another fan theory, someone suggested that Karen Minty may have discovered what Joe is capable of, which explains how she reacted when he broke up with her. She was too afraid to do it herself, so when he did it she remained calm and saw this as an easy way out.
It also explains Karen’s weird warning to Beck about Joe in reference to Candace. Karen heard Joe saying her name in his sleep, which could’ve prompted her to look into Candace. She could’ve figured out the same theories as Candace’s friends – that she’s dead and Joe had something to do with it. She tells Beck, "Maybe he'll do [to you] whatever the hell he did to Candace."
Either way, Karen didn’t want to get involved in case he hurt her too, so she tried her best to warn Beck. After all, we didn’t see her again after the break up, despite her caring and invested relationship with Claudia and Paco. Karen definitely didn't want to hang around for too long.
1. Beck Is Alive
There are loads of theories about Beck still being alive, but some of them don’t fully check out due to plot holes. However, there are still ways it could work and be the ultimate plot twist.
When Beck finds out Joe killed Benji and Peach, Joe tells her “I would never hurt someone I love.” He could be telling the truth. We never did see Beck’s body for sure, and we don’t yet know if he actually did try to kill Candace.
The body uncovered near Dr. Nicky’s house could have been Ron’s. Joe could’ve made it look like Benji’s by planting the jar of teeth there, along with his creepy box of mementos.
He also could’ve edited Beck’s story a little, especially as Beck claimed to have written “everything”, yet her other friends wondered if Dr. Nicky killed Peach too.
So where is Beck? Still locked away somewhere for Joe’s pleasure of course.
Which YOU fan theories do you believe? Share your favourites down in the comments.