10 "Next Big Things" In Wrestling Nobody Cared About
Parker Boudreaux was NOT the next big thing, let alone the next Brock Lesnar...
Nick Khan claimed Logan Paul will be the next big thing in pro wrestling.
Saraya claimed Skye Blue will be the next big thing in pro wrestling.
Typing the keyphrase 'next big thing wrestling' into any search engine brings up such conversations of who will be the next big thing in pro wrestling, but it's these examples which immediately catch your eye. Not only do they come from two wholly contrasting minds of pro wrestling - one has had a hand in monopolising the WWE-led industry, the other was once an indelible leader of the Women's Revolution - but they represent two wholly contrasting pro wrestlers.
Logan Paul, a WWE part-timer only on the basis of his infrequent stints, competed for its top prize three matches in, is yet to wrestle a subpar match, and is a cross-platform megastar whose huge social media reach has brought significant interest to WWE. Skye Blue, meanwhile, is a good-to-great AEW prospect whose growth in the Tony Khan-fronted group has been thus far very telling of what the future holds for the pillars of AEW's women's division. She's not a household name yet, but such prominence will come with experience.
Both are worthy of the 'next big thing' moniker - unlike...
10. Austin Theory
Triple H was instrumental in the scouting, signing, and development of so many would-be top WWE Superstars that you forget Austin Theory stood among them. A brash blue chipper, Theory's reign as EVOLVE Champion got the hype train behind across 336 days of hidden gem matches vs. Kyle O'Reilly, JD Drake, and gobs more that saw him come out the other end a carbon copy of what the prototypical WWE Superstar looks like.
But that's precisely why he's failed to get over with the audience.
Staunch WWE supporters don't want a less-chiselled Triple H clone. They want panache and finesse, and while Austin Theory has charisma, he doesn't have a lot of it, meaning he's looked like a chump in promo battles with John Cena and now, fresh off a switch to SmackDown, he's failing to stand out from Pretty Deadly in a trio designed entirely to get Theory over.
His time with the United States Championship has been detrimental to his success, too. Having been involved with the championship since April 2022, featuring in 70.83% of the championship's televised matches with zero stand-out attractions, it wouldn't be a stretch to describe Austin Theory as having devalued the United States Championship amidst GUNTHER's restoration process for the Intercontinental Championship.
9. Erik Watts
Erik Watts managed to weasel his way into sixteen different wrestling companies throughout his "career" while looking like he'd had twenty minutes of training.
The son of renowned racist and homophobe 'Cowboy' Bill Watts, Erik joined WCW from the Power Plant, an apparent World Champion-in-the-making. Scoring wins over a young Steve Austin and Diamond Dallas Page, challenging for the NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship, and wrestling four WCW pay-per-views, Erik Watts was a future World Champion - statistically.
In reality, he was fecklessly bad to an almost reckless extent.
Ostensibly given favourable treatment at the time of his father's tenure as WCW booker, he failed to make a lasting impression and soon followed Daddy to the then-WWF where, as part of the hapless Tekno Team 2000 duo, Erik Watts failed to grab the attention of the audience once again. This cycle repeated everywhere Watts went; TNA, ECW, AJPW, and assorted North American independents were subjected to a cataclysmic Erik Watts booking.
It wasn't just the nepotist booking from his father that derailed him, though. He was hopeless as a performer. A charisma vacuum, Erik couldn't work the most basic of matches, routinely flopping when attempting virtually any fundamental wrestling strike. One of the worst wrestlers ever, Erik Watts made Eva Marie look like peak-Kenny Omega.
8. The Ascension
Were The Ascension born into the wrong era of WWE?
Absolutely.
Konnor and Viktor displayed obstinate strength across their 364-day stint as NXT Tag Team Champions. The doubles division in NXT wasn't exactly bubbling at the time - The Lucha Dragons, almost as proof of that sentiment, were chosen to topple them - but The Ascension brought an aura of real brute force to the division. Their Fall of Man finish was authentic as a match-ender.
The phrase 'main roster call-up' is what plagued them post-NXT. Thrust into the world of main roster WWE in December 2014, The Ascension were given Road Warriors-ripoff branding, and were pointed and laughed at for weeks by commentary, the once-callous duo of NXT's tag team division now being the laughingstock of WWE's tag division. Konnor and Viktor were used to put over every other WWE pairing, their future Cosmic Wasteland pairing with Stardust being the highlight of their run - and that was p*ss-poor.
Even with Triple taking over main roster WWE creative in July 2022, The Ascension wouldn't be salvageable, but there's still part of you that thinks 'what could've been' for The Ascension had they not been victimised by a Vince McMahon crap-chute.
7. Diesel
As Diesel, Kevin Nash was a harrowing portrayal of a WWE Champion, lacking the indispensable traits needed to thrive in the role as he failed to draw a time across his almost year-long oppression over Vince McMahon's fledgeling sports entertainment empire. The New Generation Era wasn't as catchy an era in-ring-wise as its Attitude and Ruthless Aggression successors, instead acting as a transitional period between those and the preceding Golden Era of steroids, bodacious personalities, and Hulk Hogan Hulk Hoganising his way to superstardom.
After the era of Hulk Hogans, Randy Savages, and Ultimate Warriors, someone like Diesel - an ample big man who was pushed beyond what his work merited - wasn't cutting it for audiences. Business was poor and Diesel didn't add to Vince McMahon's fortunes in the way initially intended; truthfully, he detracted from McMahon's bank account, turning fans away as growing-in-popularity promotions like WCW and ECW were revolutionists.
Diesel isn't to blame for standing atop the WWE mountain for as long as he did - Vince McMahon is - but Vince McMahon couldn't help that Diesel was a drab, crap imitation of what a big man wrestler needed to be in 1994.
Slow, plodding, and grunting weren't cutting it anymore.
6. Curtis Axel
The above image should draw only positive connotations. Quite literally, it's the son of 'Mr Perfect' Curt Hennig, one of the best pro wrestlers ever, wearing the WWE Intercontinental Championship, one of the best pro wrestling championships ever, with Paul Heyman, one of the best pro wrestling managers ever.
Curtis Axel should've made it big. He wasn't a terrible hand between the ropes but WWE, as they do with virtually every my-dad-was-a-wrestler-too arc, relied too heavily upon the past, disallowing Axel to become his own character in favour of him playing his father's old role, albeit with less flourish.
The immediate Paul Heyman association was the first sign that WWE viewed Axel as a potential headline act. Wrestling John Cena and Triple H was the second. The third? Winning the Intercontinental Championship, a championship that his father had helped craft into the workrate title - but Curtis Axel wasn't a solid IC champion and it wasn't before long that he dragged the belt down.
Axel was evidently made a Paul Heyman Guy to keep the former ECW running man on-screen during Brock Lesnar's time off, but even he couldn't elevate the second-generation star beyond his career ceiling. Needless to say, when Lesnar returned, it was goodbye to Curtis Axel, who only ever enjoyed brief flirtations with success beyond this.
5. Alberto Del Rio
By 2010, WWE had stopped doing what the audience wanted to see and focused on what they wanted.
Alberto Del Rio was their next crack into his Hispanic market following Rey Mysterio. Possessing the tools necessary of a WWE headliner, Alberto had the gift of the gab, was a skilled striker and submission-based worker, and knew how to draw on the ire of audience. He was quite literally a walking embodiment of what WWE wanted, but it never worked out.
Alberto Del Rio was presented as WWE's next top star several times throughout his two main roster stints, though it became evident across Del Rio's first 12 months in WWE that the audience was never going to accept him as a top draw. Winning the Royal Rumble match, Money in the Bank briefcase, and two WWE Championships in 2011 alone, Alberto Del Rio was cursed by his own booking. He thrived, naturally receiving healthy paychecks due to his status, but at what cost? Nobody liked him, nobody cared about him, and nobody wanted to see him.
His subsequent babyface turn in 2013 was so blatantly forced, too, that it may as well have been the nail in his coffin of a WWE career. Alberto Del Rio was a WWE cast-off masquerading as WWE Champion.
4. Nathan Jones
Don't let this image fool you; Nathan Jones does not hold a WrestleMania victory. He never even wrestled at the show because Vince McMahon realised how green he was and unceremoniously dumped him from the card.
Nathan Jones sucked. Badly. Completely inept as to how professional wrestling was supposed to work, he was sluggish in his offence, wholly monotonous when presented with a microphone, and failed to forge a relationship with the audience that is crucial to a babyface's success. Being dragged to a passable-to-good match zero times out of ten, Jones lasted longer than he had any right to, the coup de grace of his WWE run being a Survivor Series 2003 match on Brock Lesnar's quintet against Kurt Angle's.
This was seven months after he was scrapped from the WrestleMania XIX card, though. Vince McMahon had already realised how mediocre his latest pet project was going to be and given how many releases WWE had already made/granted by November 2003 (fourteen), it's a genuine miracle that the Aussie behemoth wasn't on the chopping block.
Remarkably, Vince McMahon still didn't realise how big of a flop this supposed next big thing was going to be because, in 2008, he was reportedly open to giving the former powerlifter another look in! Jones never attended the tryout, for the best.
3. Lord Tensai
In Japan, Matt Bloom - as Giant Bernard - became a world-class performer. He was a throwback bruiser whose work in Bad Intentions - the pairing of him and Karl Anderson - earned him plaudits.
Returning to WWE in April 2012 undid every ounce of this progress.
Recast as Lord Tensai and sporting some Japanese tribal paint spewed across his face because of course, the 330-pounder was presented as the next dominant threat at the height of the CenaWinsLOL campaign, except he didn't confront John Cena. Brock Lesnar, the real next dominant threat, did in his own WWE comeback. Lord Tensai, meanwhile, flattened Alex Riley in a serviceable squash before green misting his own hand to Iron Claw Riley to sleep in front of a dreary audience. They cheered, initially, but that was because it was the post-WrestleMania crowd witnessing a return. They would've popped if Nunzio wandered out.
WWE was evidently keen to promote Lord Tensai to the highest degree possible because, three weeks into his comeback run, Tensai was besting John Cena. It wasn't clean because, again, of course, but this was a real opportunity to create a new main roster beast for when Brock Lesnar wasn't collecting his tri-annual paycheck.
2. Parker Boudreaux
Parker Boudreaux, infamously, has been compared to Brock Lesnar since he first entered the spotlight, and has been plagued by the curse of comparison ever since. Boudreaux looks like Lesnar - sort of - in that his default facial expression is that of a snarl.
But this is where the comparison ends.
Boudreaux is nothing like Lesnar in-ring-wise but everything like your average WWE Performance Center trainee. His work is uninspired, as was the Joe Gacy pairing, who he failed to ever click with, and so, devoid of any audience resonance, Parker squashed a glut of goobers, with his only WWE highlight being that time he threw Brian Kendrick down a flight of stairs. It wasn't even the strangest part of his character, either, as WWE had Parker Boudreaux shave his head cleanly, making him look like a walking thumb in what looked like a walking punishment.
Now in AEW, Parker Boudreaux has flopped again. Still nobody cares about him as his signing was clearly one made without any sense of direction, as he's now been aligned with two seemingly objectless factions: Ari Daivari's Trustbusters and Swerve Strickland's Mogul Affiliates.
Last wrestling on the 3 March Rampage in a loss to Naturally Limitless, it seems Parker Boudreaux's pro wrestling career indeed may have been Naturally Limited.
1. Sin Cara
This may sound hyperbolic in 2023 but before signing with WWE, Sin Cara was to Mexico what Mitsuharu Misawa was to Japan.
As Místico, Sin Cara dazzled audiences, became the nation's biggest box office attraction, and regularly sold out arenas. He was a big deal - and then he was Vince McMahoned.
WWE, idiotically, chose to have Místico move straight into the life of main roster WWE. Stripped of his speedy style, the rebranded Sin Cara flopped, quite literally, on the first night of Vince McMahon attempting to market him as his next big move into international territory. Springboarding into the ring, Cara didn't clear the top rope, resulting in him clumsily crashing onto the ropes.
WWE's inherently disillusioned sports entertainment fanbase was wowed by Sin Cara at first, but they were bored after the initially marvellous entrance. They weren't the audience Sin Cara needed; they still resided in Mexico, where the scene remained red-hot. He instead became renowned for the routine nature in which he botched moves, racking up injuries quicker than Bryan Danielson did with Wrestling Observer Newsletter Best Technical Wrestler awards.
Sin Cara's time as the next big thing in WWE was over the night it began.