10 Scapegoats For RUBBISH WWE Ideas
Got a totally rotten WWE idea? Don't worry, because SOMEBODY can be blamed!
Well, somebody needs to take the blame!
The sheer volume of creative ideas WWE burns through every year is staggering, so it's logical to assume that many will fall short in execution. Once they do, fingers start getting pointed internally and from fans. Who's responsible for this nonsense?! Probably Vince Russo. No, that's a (poor) joke.
The truth is often a grey area. Naturally, wrestlers actually working any matches/angles/characters do need to take some criticism, but it must be agony for those folks when burnt out writers leave them hanging with wonky concepts or creative direction that's outright baffling.
That's when the word "scapegoat" starts getting hurled around willy nilly.
WWE tends to deflect when things go sour. They shift blame onto a specific person in hopes it'll trick the audience into agreeing. That rarely works. Pro wrestling fans aren't thick - most have a good handle on how this stuff works by now, and they know when Vince McMahon, Triple H or some other higher-up made an arse of things.
Get ready to relive some of WWE's worst ideas, and feel sorry for the people accused of failing!
10. Bart Gunn Ruins ‘Brawl For All’
The WWF would've had a ready-made main event rival for 'Stone Cold' had stupid Bart Gunn not used his stupid hands to knock others out in a stupid shoot fight tournament on stupid TV. Stupid! Oh yes, some believed sticking 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams in a legit toughman contest was his ticket to the top in 1998.
Gunn had other plans. He was genuinely handy with ye olde fisticuffs, so he mauled the competition for real and eventually earned the right to get knocked out by Butterbean at WrestleMania XV. That wasn't the original plan; it was nowhere close.
In the minds of fed chiefs, Bart ruined their 'Brawl For All' idea by being a good fighter. It's so childish that the WWF got angry about Gunn doing his job properly. Imagine things not going your way when you book something realistic. Isn't that why wrestling is a work in the first place?! So promoters can plan?
Poor Gunn was a scapegoat.
9. Keith Lee Has “Attitude Problems”
Heads were turned when WWE announced they'd released former NXT star Keith Lee from his contract in November 2021. Previously, Lee had seemed like a can't miss prospect, and it looked like the company knew it when booking him in spots opposite top names like Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns.
PWTorch's Wade Keller later reported that "attitude problems" were partly to blame for Keith's exit, but the man himself has refuted those. Lee, who joined AEW shortly after leaving WWE, cited serious health problems and a disconnect with the crummy "Bearcat" gimmick he was tasked with playing.
That flopped in a hurry on Raw, so WWE scrambled to point the finger of blame. It couldn't be that creative farted out something awful, eh? No, Lee was surely the one who had to shoulder responsibility for "Bearcat" completely failing to capture the imaginations of main roster fans.
Why didn't they just let the guy do what he'd been doing on NXT? He had a puncher's chance with that presentation.
8. Seth Rollins Suffers Post-HIAC Booing
One Seth Rollins has been very candid about his thoughts on the Hell In A Cell 2019 clanger he worked vs. Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' alter ego. The current World Heavyweight Champ has always maintained that he was hung out to dry by the bout's dreadful non-finish, and called himself "dead in the water" creatively as soon as it happened.
That's fair.
WWE's decision to script a stoppage inside the Cell was terrible. It was rightly booed by fans, and felt like a total cop out at the time. Almost overnight, Rollins went from being a credible workhorse babyface people loved to someone they viewed akin to Roman Reigns circa 2016.
Seth's plight showed that creative didn't have a clue how to book faces at the time. The writing team seemed intent on making babyfaces as unlikeable as possible, which was a real problem. Of course, blame was pinned on Rollins, and he wasn't too chuffed about that.
7. Cody Rhodes Isn't Helping Stardust
If Keith Lee felt disconnected from WWE's creative processes in 2021, then he needed only spare a thought for Cody Rhodes several years before. Cody was having a thoroughly miserable time as Stardust, and he wanted nothing more than to shed the goofy guise to become himself again.
The writers didn't see it that way, and neither did Vince McMahon.
Clearly, some behind the scenes believed Rhodes was just being difficult by trying to push his way out from behind the face paints, but that's unfair. Cody did everything he could to make Stardust work, but the gimmick had a short shelf life and he blatantly needed change.
This idea that Rhodes just needed to hang on and embrace Stardust is laughable. He did, but how much more could anyone be expected to stomach? WWE likely thought Cody would regret requesting his release in 2016. Not a chance. He backed himself, it worked, and then he returned to the promotion as a mega-star (not a mega-Stardust).
6. Baron Corbin Blamed For Raw Being Crap
This segment was one of WWE's most preposterous.
Live on the 17 December 2018 episode of Raw, Vince McMahon, his son Shane, his daughter Stephanie and his son-in-law Triple H apologised for a woeful flagship product that year. That seemed out of character, but it wasn't long before the skit's true intentions were revealed to the world.
Then-acting GM Baron Corbin was brought out and directly blamed for sagging ratings during his tenure. It was a quite-ridiculous lack of self-awareness from the company's power base. They'd acknowledged that Raw had been crap, but then shifted blame onto an on-screen character who only did as he was told and held no real sway anyway (something fans knew).
Being brutally honest, having the McMahons and Trips talk about how rubbish Raw had been was bad enough. Surely any energy put into scripting this segment could've gone on improving the product instead? What a radical concept that is.
Or not.
5. The Appalling Muhammad Hassan Gimmick
Wrestling is supposed to offer escapism from real-world events. It's scripted entertainment, and shouldn't demand anybody think about serious topics like racism, terrorism or war whilst watching. So, WWE deserves a slap for putting fledgling star Marc Copani into the role of Muhammad Hassan in late-2004.
This race baiting gimmick saw Hassan incite hatred of Muslims on live TV. It was the kind of thing the biz was supposed to have moved on from, but apparently not. Worse, when WWE received significant backlash due to grim events like 2005's London bombings, it was Copani who took most of the flak.
His once-promising wrestling career was annihilated in the blink of an eye once management decided to write Hassan off television and pretend the character didn't exist. Copani was never given another shot at company success before being released from his contract in September '05.
He'd been a victim of WWE stupidity and crassness, then got punted for doing as he was told.
4. Goldberg “Doesn’t Know How To Work”
Vince McMahon always believed he could book WCW stars better than WCW. Reportedly, the then-boss told lieutenants he'd show those dafties down in Atlanta how to utilise a giant properly upon signing Big Show in 1999. That same arrogance hampered Bill Goldberg's run when he eventually signed on the dotted line with the fed in 2003.
WWE thought Goldberg running through everyone in squash matches was too limiting. Fair enough, but the way they went about putting him in lengthier bouts and giving Bill "more personality" was frankly naff. Remember that Goldust wig angle? How about putting the squash artist out there for 14 minutes with The Rock at Backlash when everyone just fancied seeing a spear-into-Jackhammer combo?
This thinking was ill-fated, and that's being kind.
WWE lifers like Bruce Prichard would claim that Bill just didn't know how to work. Goldberg was directly criticised upon leaving in 2004 - it was all his fault. WWE weren't willing to accept any responsibility for a tamer-than-expected 12 month run.
3. Buff Bagwell = WCW’s Collateral
At least Goldberg rescued things with an unexpected second stab at WWE. Poor Buff Bagwell didn't get that chance, probs because the knives were out for 'The Stuff' as soon as he leapt over from the sinking WCW ship in 2001. Let's be clear about one thing: The WWF did Bagwell no favours.
Was he insufferable behind the scenes? Hell, probably. Did he have long-term viability on a roster full of top names? Maybe not, but it was foolish to plop him in a WCW-branded main event on Raw that hardcore WWF fans didn't want to see. Buff and Booker T didn't have a prayer of making that work.
No, the match wasn't great, but it certainly wasn't horrible enough to tank someone's entire career. Looking back, Bagwell was collateral damage following the bout. Someone had to take the hit. It wasn't going to be the WWF, and they'd already been charmed by Booker T.
So, Buff was cast aside pronto.
2. Terry Taylor “Didn’t Embrace” Red Rooster
Bruce Prichard has gone on record via his 'Something To Wrestle With' podcast to say that Terry Taylor could've done more to make the cartoonish 'Red Rooster' gimmick fly in the late-1980s. According to Bruce, that character was every bit as viable as something like Curt Hennig's 'Mr. Perfect' persona.
Sulking Terry just didn't embrace it.
Right, maybe Taylor didn't like the idea. That's likely true, but...claiming he could've made more of it had he only been all in is a stretch. The concept sucked from the off, and no amount of grin-and-bear-it positivity from Terry was going to stop fans from laughing at the Rooster.
Taylor was instructed to spike some dyed red hair up, strut around the ring and cock-a-doodle-doo at opponents. Yes, 80s WWF was a cartoon wonderland, but the character was a real struggle immediately. Red Rooster vs. Hulk Hogan was hardly going on the marquee, was it?
Score another one for the scapegoats.
1. JR Blamed For “Razor Ramon” & “Diesel”
This is something Jim Ross discussed when deep-diving on Kane during an episode of his 'Grilling JR' pod. The iconic announcer told co-host Conrad Thompson he was more-than-happy to do his best with a heel turn in 1996, and Jim didn't even mind being a makeweight for the reintroduction of Diesel and Razor Ramon.
There was just one problem: Kevin Nash and Scott Hall had fled to WCW, so they wouldn't be reprising those roles. No, Glenn Jacobs and Rick Bognar would become "Diesel" and "Razor" respectively. To cover their arses, the WWF had Ross claim to make the deal with those guys himself.
It was a bait and switch tactic, one that didn't pan out and left a bad taste in fan mouths. JR chuckled on his podcast when recalling how he became the on-screen scapegoat. Then-authority figure Gorilla Monsoon directly blamed Jim for hoodwinking the fans on TV.
Booking other wrestlers to cosplay two of your biggest gimmicks was a bad idea from the start.
Which other WWE scapegoats can you think of? For more like this, check out 15 Wrestling Pics So Strange They Look AI Generated and 10 New Directions For WWE After Crown Jewel 2023!