10 Absolute Worst Matches In WWE SummerSlam History
It's my Biggest Party Of The Summer, and I'll cry if I want to.
WWE's "second biggest" pay-per-view is not really its second biggest pay-per-view.
With Royal Rumble lighting the long Road To WrestleMania since 1993, the January Classic captures the prestige of the season along with a stipulation match that has inspired generations of performers and fans alike in their fawning fandom of 'The Grandest Stage'.
Vince McMahon hates the Survivor Series, but fans have clung to the elimination format almost every year since its 1987 inception. Even King Of The Ring, briefly considered the fifth of "The Big Five" in WWE's calendar had a tournament that the company championed as a starmaker in spite of Billy Gunn and Mabel's horrendous failed runs.
SummerSlam is none of these things and never really was, and yet remains the secondary jewel in the company crown. All because of absolute bangers like the ones in this list, not because of the disasters below.
The August supercard asks for major, WrestleMania-level matches even if the organisation hasn't always got its sh*t together enough to deliver as promised. Often lacking the platform WrestleMania provides, a lack of bells and whistles can prove fatal for a contest that needs a helping hand from the pencil, rather than a sharp stab in the eye...
10. Sheamus Vs Alberto Del Rio (SummerSlam 2012)
A dreadfully dull battle that perhaps might have resonated with fans that had just discovered pro wrestling in 2012 (but a decade of decline suggests there probably weren't too many of those...), Sheamus' successful World Championship defence against Alberto Del Rio fell victim to neither of the pair being over enough to satisfy their brief for the night.
'The Great White' hadn't ever managed to escape the curse of his original title win at that year's WrestleMania - the 18 second victory over Daniel Bryan triggered a "YES Movement" but a profound "No" from the audience to ever accepting the Royal Rumble winner as their chosen champion.
Foreshadowing years of that sh*t, Sheamus was the first and thus least-damaged by the role, but Alberto Del Rio had been in a semi-permanent state of flux since debuting too. Permitted to get moderately over in his first year, he was damaged goods nearly two years into a tepid heel run that had already peaked a year earlier.
Under the circumstances, competent work became a worst case scenario for two men laughably expected to produce a corker. The silence (years before boredom would produce boos) was deafening.
9. Jake Roberts Vs Hercules (SummerSlam 1988)
WWE pay-per-views didn't always exist strictly to pay off or directly service television angles. SummerSlam 1988's bloated card worked just as hard as the weekly weekend shows to furnish programmes touring the country on the lucrative house show circuit as it did entertain the customers that had paid top dollar to see Hulk Hogan et al beamed directly into their homes.
The Madison Square Garden crowd pick their moments for the show as a result, only really greeting the star or story-laden matches with respectful ovations. A clash-of-styles clunker between Jake Roberts and Hercules is not one of these.
Roberts is rightfully lauded as a psychological thriller between the ropes - few ever grasped the intangibles as well. His addictive personality fed his thirst to constantly manipulate the audience. Chasing that dragon at work to justify the ones he pursued outside of it, Jake satisfied all of us while getting his hit. Against the muscled and moribund Hercules, he was a torturous headlock merchant for the overlong duration whilst fans salivated over his real feud with Rick Rude.
It wasn't the worst exhibition of one of these sorts of encounters from the early years though. One in particular was absolutely criminal...
8. Nailz Vs Virgil (SummerSlam 1992)
Let's talk about Nailz.
Nailz was not everything you've been told.
Nailz was not some absurd rendering of Vince McMahon's pro wrestling at its worst. Nailz was not some writers room pitch gone horribly wrong through the WWE gimmick machine.
What Nailz was, was a logical extension of the Big Boss Man arc. His story saw him arrive as heel former prison guard that enjoyed his brutal work, before gradually becoming a reformed babyface thanks to his adventures as a pro wrestler. What Nailz was, was a man that had suffered under his once-violent rule, ignorant to the world and how it might have changed, looking for vengeance. Boss Man found reformation outside of the confines of a prison. Nailz had found none within them.
What Nailz also was, was a f*cking abysmal pro wrestler, relevant to precisely one programme. And it wasn't with f*cking Virgil. In front of one of the company's biggest ever crowds.
7. Jerry Lawler Vs Jake Roberts (SummerSlam 1996)
An ugly storyline made even worse by the fact it was playing out in real life, Jerry Lawler's abuse of Jake Roberts' alcoholism wouldn't have made fertile content for their SummerSlam 1996 match even if it wasn't true.
'The King's delivery was typically sublime, but gallows humour at the expense of supposedly recovering addict Roberts required 'The Snake' to be on board with the angle and not trapped in the near-fatal grip of his disease. A 1996 return to the company came with a series of promos explaining his renewed relationship with God as a way to help him cope with his past sins. By SummerSlam he had slipped. Heel Lawler pointing that out (as well as forcing actual alcohol down his throat) as part of this clumsy, clunky clusterf*ck was - at it's low bar best - pitiful WWE comedy in the middle of the company's second biggest event of the year.
A nothing match went the way of the bully heel - such is life in the company - to facilitate Mark Henry's introduction into storylines as the one to finally shut Lawler up. Roberts was literally covered in alcohol by the time the 'World's Strongest Man' stepped in.
6. The Kat Vs Terri (SummerSlam 2000)
It was the best of times. That wasn't made overtly clear here.
Competing against one another in a sequel to a poorly-received WrestleMania match, Kat and Terri were made to work a "Thong Stinkface" clash at SummerSlam, with victory confirmed by who could perform Rikishi's trademark gross-out manoeuvre whilst sporting the non-existent bikini bottoms.
Empty titillation followed, as Jim Ross sardonically critiqued their 'deep crotch slams', whilst Jerry Lawler squealed himself to neargasm as per f*cking usual.
Of all the unsavoury moments from the Attitude Era that don't age well, this sort of mistreatment of women at large is easily the hardest to revisit. No 21st Century match should really have been this exploitative, no matter the expectation or game willingness of those involved. And, objectively speaking, the presentation was total trash. Neither could wrestle, rendering nearly all their physicality as horribly exposed to the elements as they were.
Fans popped for the finish, of course. WWE were in touch with that portion of their audience, even if that version of entertainment was rapidly becoming out of touch with society at large.
5. Batista Vs Booker T (SummerSlam 2006)
Proving (when, truthfully, proof wasn't even required) that real fights don't actually make for good wrestling feuds, Booker T and Batista's absolute stinker at SummerSlam foreshadowed the rest of a rotten feud they'd have over the World Heavyweight Title that year.
Booker and Batista had an actual altercation at the filming of the pay-per-view's commercial after the former WCW Champion took exception with how the less experienced headliner was handling himself on set. A matter of respect for real manifested as a matter of rank boredom as the two clearly failed to click at the event itself several months later.
Well and truly adjusted to the multiple-pay-per-view formula by 2006, WWE weren't in any mood to conclude the feud at the first time of asking, forcing viewers to endure more of their tense tussles throughout the year. Batista's disqualification win did less than f*ck all for either of them. Showing footage of the real fight might have actually told a more entertaining story.
4. Jinder Mahal Vs Shinsuke Nakamura (SummerSlam 2017)
A boring battle over a stone dead WWE Championship between the worst titleholder of a generation a Challenger already dulled by his rotten main roster run, Shinsuke Nakamura's battle with Jinder Mahal was perhaps the most depressing fight for the title in its once-rich history.
Mahal had been scripted to go low in the build-up, making racist remarks against still images of 'The King Of Strong Style' in the cheapest (and yet, unsuccessful) grasp for heat of Mahal's p*ss poor reign. Nakamura lost in 11:25, and in his rematch in an even longer outing a month later. It was frankly astonishing that the company managed to rebuild him in time for the Royal Rumble he won en route to his last stab at WWE main event supremacy.
John Cena and Nakamura had their first (and, thus far, only) televised encounter on an edition of SmackDown to earn the right to get this match. 'The Champ' was probably happier getting to banter off Baron Corbin in the opener instead.
3. The Undertaker Vs The Undertaker (SummerSlam 1994)
An impossibly boring match considering the story that served it, The Undertaker Vs The Undertaker main event of SummerSlam 1994 managed to kill the 23,000 in attendance as well as the undead zombified caricatures in the ring.
Unhelpfully forced to follow the Bret and Owen Hart cage match, the company were bound to promoting the match as the headliner thanks to a lucrative promotional deal with Dominos Pizza that also roped in Leslie Nielsen and George Kennedy to repurpose their Naked Gun personas to locate the lost 'Deadman' after rumours of his Royal Rumble demise turned out to be greatly exaggerated.
It should have been simpler than it was - the phoney 'Taker was due an absolute sh*tkicking from the real thing, but the contest was booked with a bizarre even-handedness before the purple-gloved returnee wrapped up a match that only went 8:57 but honestly felt like it was approaching the hour mark. Nothing happened, followed by a bit more nothing, before a Tombstone sealed the deal like it always did.
Rumour has it that Ted Dibiase's fraud was supposed to stick around, but the tepid climax to the half-decent angle put paid to that, and the fake 'Phenom' for good.
2. The Brothers Of Destruction Vs Diamond Dallas Page & Chris Kanyon (SummerSlam 2001)
Who knew that a match with one Undertaker could somehow be worse than one with two?
An unforgivably awful mistreatment of two diamonds in the Jersey rough that still could have been pristine had they avoided an 'American Bad *ss' at his insecure worst, this SummerSlam cage match saw 'The Deadman' and brother Kane subject Diamond Dallas Page and Kanyon to an ungodly slaughter in a figurative rendering of what the Invasion angle was rapidly becoming.
Trapped in the middle of a storyline deader than 'Taker's old gimmick, DDP was first revealed as his wife Sara's stalker with the beg to be "made famous" by the 'Demon Of Death Valley". The sheer arrogance of the company to promote Page as requiring such a rub exposed their disinterest in his character, but disinterest was nothing complete to the total destruction he encountered once they actually got in the ring. Kanyon, even as 'Alliance MVP', was insane to join up with him.
With less than even a little respect for their opponents, the pair took their heat, their credibility and their Tag Team Titles to reign as stewards of the WWE and "WCW" doubles divisions after an embarrassing 10 minute squash.
1. Bray Wyatt Vs Kane (SummerSlam 2013)
By 2013, WWE had finally started to figure out how to develop talent thanks to Triple H's exciting reinvention of NXT, but they were tragically about as handy with a debut then as they are today.
Bray Wyatt and his 'Family' had arrived on Raw weeks before the 'Biggest Party Of The Summer' in grand fashion, kicking the sh*t out of Kane despite looking remarkably like pro wrestlers rather than dangerous woodsmen, all to set up a "Ring Of Fire" encounter.
The rebadged Inferno Match was a total disaster.
With result determined by pinfall or submission, the threat of somebody getting set on fire was removed, and good job too. There was no intent of performing the stunt, or any stunt, despite the flames still being gimmicked to shoot towards the sky with every big bump.
The match sucked, but the finish was somehow even worse. Cronies Harper and Rowan tried to pass Wyatt a Kendo Stick through the flames, only for the weapon to (slightly) light up. This triggered actual firefighters rocking up to extinguish it, again removing peril from...a tiny bit more peril. Sure enough, Bray's goon squad finally made their way in to botch their way through a beatdown.
Wyatt pinned him with ease, having previously looked certain to lose. And a certain loser, in his own WWEShop.com t-shirt.
Hot garbage.