10 AEW Wrestlers Tony Khan Totally FUMBLED
The biggest fumbles from the first five years of All Elite Wrestling
Very much a case of "cause of/solution to" situation at the time, All Elite Wrestling's 2019 roster facilitated more opportunities than might have initially been obvious.
Outside of cameos for pre-pay-per-view Battle Royals at the like, it was relatively easy to name just about everybody on the show from the top slate of initial stars to those on the come-up to those getting their first mainstream opportunity in the most unlikely of circumstances. With a solid hierarchy of talents and a solid enough rankings framework with which to arrange them, the alternative to the market leader quickly became the more attractive place to work for a sizeable number of wrestlers on the other side and beyond.
What looked like a dream scenario eventually morphed into a big problem for Tony Khan.
No one promotion can be full to the brim with main eventers, but the same applies to every rung on the ladder and the more available wrestlers knocking on the door, the more everybody's spot lost a certain value. Fewer main eventers were made, fewer newbies broke through, and the midcard pretty much ceased to exist as a functioning route to the top.
"Fumble" might seem harsh when speaking of a fan-turned-booker with his hands full, but actions have consequences even when you're using your billions to ostensibly make wrestling better...
10. Anthony Ogogo
It's hard to know the exact extent of the value being wasted by not featuring Anthony Ogogo as a regular on AEW television and in meaningful storylines, because he's spent so little time in the spots.
He's wrestled 53 matches total since signing his AEW deal, which isn't a huge number and gets even smaller when 24 (and counting) haven't taken place in All Elite Wrestling rings. Getting reps is crucial for anybody's development, but so little of said development has helped him make meaningful strides forward as a wrestler.
It'd be nice to say it wasn't as simple as him being cursed by the mistakes made in his first major angle, but it still feels that way several years on from a weird build with and damaging loss to Cody Rhodes in what was only his third AEW bout at Double Or Nothing 2021. He had been revealed as a killer with a kill-shot when QT Marshall's Factory broke away from The Nightmare Family, but a strange patriotism-themed build and oddly-agented his match left Ogogo's blade fairly blunt.
Since then, it's been more cameos and another run in another stable, but it feels as though the Olympic Bronze Medallist's time in Shane Taylor Productions will end the same way as in The Factory - with almost no fanfare.
9. The Four Pillars (As A Concept)
The build to the Four Pillars match at *Double or Nothing* 2023 was a frustratingly missed opportunity, failing to deliver the compelling story such a unique (and ultimately excellent) match deserved.
With Darby Allin, Sammy Guevara, Jungle Boy, and MJF all representing AEW's homegrown future - and labelled as such from the beginning of the company - this should have been a showcase of the organisation's young talent in a narrative-driven, high-stakes contest for their richest prize. Instead, AEW muddled the build with convoluted promos, unnecessary comedy, and repetitive segments that undermined the seriousness of the feud.
As the clear biggest star of the group and defending champion, MJF carried the bulk of the promos while the others struggled to find consistent character depth or motivation. The storyline lacked tension and personal stakes, feeling more like a thrown-together showcase than a defining moment for AEW's future stars. By the time the match arrived, the excitement around the "Four Pillars" concept had largely fizzled, leaving a once-in-a-generation story feeling half-baked and underwhelming.
8. Wardlow
Wardlow's booking in AEW has been one misfire after another for the man formerly known as 'Mr Mayhem', potentially squandering for good the immense promise he showed during AEW's critical and commercial peak.
When he first appeared, Wardlow was positioned as a dominant force - a monster with shades of Bill Goldberg and others like him, poised to be a cornerstone of the company as he loomed dauntingly in the background. However, one too many missteps in the five years since have left him floundering. After his highly anticipated turn at the climax of MJF's programme with CM Punk in 2022, he seemed destined for babyface superstardom, but after squashing 'The Salt Of The Earth' at Double Or Nothing that year, he drifted inconsequentially for a little too long.
When he was strapped up as TNT Champion, the reigns did more harm than good due to poor storytelling and - in Tony Khan's defence - extremely inconsistent match quality. The lack of a compelling narrative direction post-MJF was palpable though, so much so that when he joined the Undisputed Kingdom in an attempt to once again destroy his former boss, it felt like the first time he had direction since he'd last left his side.
It was another false dawn, with Wardlow's 2024 mostly lost to Adam Cole's injury and the stable's wider failure to connect.
7. Big Bill
Your mileage may vary on exactly how much Big Bill has suffered creatively in AEW considering how much of a surprise success story his post-WWE and Impact Wrestling reinvention has been, but it's continually frustrating that a man known for his height continues to smash his head against a glass ceiling rather than just burst through it.
Earning plaudits for being a total popper in 2023, he joined forces with Ricky Starks to upset FTR for the AEW Tag Team Championships for a reign that delighted audiences desperate for something fresh, and the duo served their purpose to completion by dropping the gold to Sting and Darby Allin ahead of the former's retirement. But with Starks' status uncertain (more on that later), Bill was slotted into Chris Jericho's Learning Tree stable as the former World Champion's newest Jake Hager.
Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it, and the hilarious seven-footer might yet find his momentum cut short once again.
6. The Singles Careers Of The Lucha Brothers
Former tag team champions and one half of what many consider to be the best match in AEW history, The Lucha Brothers have had a run to be proud of under Tony Khan. But Rey Fénix and Penta El Zero Miedo? Not so much.
While their doubles work has been exceptional when paired against The Young Bucks in particular, Penta and Fénix' singles trajectories have been less than stellar at best and infuriating at worst. Lacking direction and purpose, the pushes - and that's generous - haven't positioned either man in meaningful, long-term storylines. Penta, in particular, had glimpses of a breakout run when he faced Cody Rhodes during the 'American Nightmare's star-making peak, but it quickly fizzled out, leaving him directionless and with an arm-breaking finisher that had lost all of its magic.
Arguably the best high flyer on the planet at one point, Fénix was reduced to thrilling matches with no follow-up too. The overcrowded roster ultimately left Lucha Brothers adrift in both divisions, and a rumoured exit to WWE has been welcomed on both sides as a mutually beneficial escape hatch.
5. Powerhouse Hobbs
Thanks to his relative youth (33, so only just approaching 2024 wrestler prime) and even younger TV age, there's still plenty of time to get Powerhouse Hobbs right. But it's so far so not-that-good for the promising monster.
Hobbs has been just another victim - pun very much intended - of the company’s confusing erratic booking from the moment Team Taz disbanded. A brutal enforcer following his heel turn on Cody Rhodes to join the group, showcasing raw power and charisma. However, AEW’s failure to follow through on his initial push has left Hobbs floundering in midcard purgatory.
Despite moments where it seemed like he was on the verge of breaking out, he’s been repeatedly undercut by a lack of consistent direction and a bizarre need to have him in stables rather than as his own man. His association with QTV was a horribly misguided nod to a strain of continuity audiences weren't interested in, and joining the Don Callis Family was infuriating optics-wise based on how marginalised he'd been by his last placement in a stable.
A 2024 injury break was a blow and a blessing in equal measure, and to paraphrase one of Hobbs' biggest locker room supporters, here's hoping the get-back will be better than the setback.
4. Ricky Starks
Ricky Starks' exit from AEW has felt inevitable for longer than any of his sustained pushes, which feels important to note in a list with a title salaciously crafted around blame that lies mostly with Tony Khan. From the outside looking in - and even if this is completely not the case - the road has looked rocky for some time, and more's the pity for All Elite Wrestling.
From the moment he debuted, Starks oozed charisma, skill, and that elusive and increasingly hard-to-harness pro wrestling "it" that made him stand out. His work with Team Taz showcased his immense potential, but once that faction dissolved, AEW failed to capitalise on his momentum. Despite occasional flashes of brilliance as a babyface in a TV feud with MJF, Starks has been hindered by stop-start pushes and the all-too-familiar lack of sustained direction.
Often thrust into programs that either lacked substance or failed to highlight his real strengths, he was left adrift twice in 2023 and early 2024 - once when his burgeoning feud with CM Punk was axed thanks to the latter's sudden firing, and the other when his title winning team with Big Bill reached its natural conclusion. It's been limbo ever since, unless that's changed by the time you read this. Which, to circle right back, is again kind of the central problem.
3. Cody Rhodes
Cody Rhodes' booking in AEW was a perplexing mix of era-defining brilliance and baffling nonsense, ultimately leading to his departure for WWE. It's unknown exactly how much control Tony Khan had/shared when it came to 'The American Nightmare's trajectory but the project coming to an end just three years into the company's existence spoke to how much he was perfectly happy to relinquish.
As a founding figure and one of AEW’s most recognisable faces, Cody was positioned as a top star from Night One. Yet, a series of self-imposed limitations such as his vow never to challenge for the AEW World Title (and then subsequently hang around a little too long in the TNT ranks) gradually boxed him into a corner.
Instead of evolving into a megastar, Cody became embroiled in midcard feuds that did little to enhance his character or the brand. His storylines often felt disconnected from the rest of AEW’s narrative too, and his insistence on playing a traditional babyface began to clash with the more nuanced characters around him. This combination of creative stagnation and fan backlash eroded his standing to a remarkable extent by early-2022, making WWE’s offer of a fresh start and a clear direction impossible to resist.
2. CM Punk
CM Punk was responsible for the actions of CM Punk, and by 2023, those actions were sackable offences that left Tony Khan with few options beyond the ones he eventually took. The fumble was not in letting CM Punk go (and indeed go back to WWE), but in allowing a situation with his biggest star to reach the point where everything became so untenable.
Khan's fumble was not being a more diligent man manager from the off. Who knows exactly when relations changed between Punk and The Elite from the heady days of 2021 when he was taking studio shots with The Young Bucks and having Twitter craic with Hangman Page? Not many folk, but Tony Khan should have been one of them. Who knows how different the Autumn of 2022 could have been had incidents never made it to television, or certain fires extinguished before they could burn relations to the ground.
To understand the value of Punk to your business is not to accept the rough with the smooth but to manage a monster so that everybody gets to win. It's not an easy tightrope to walk, but Tony Khan slipped off too late to clamber back on.
1. The Troubling Majority Of Those That Have Competed In The Women's Division
The women's division's growth has been one of the most prominent success stories in All Elite Wrestling in 2024, but the promotion has been kicking around since 2019 and even the most backward-facing archaic version of WWE was able to get its act together parity-wise midway through the 2010s.
Even now, AEW's the best it's ever been for women and still not really good enough.
Tony Khan, from the outside, appears to have struggled to give the women’s roster the same attention and care as their male counterparts. The division’s biggest stars over the years such as Britt Baker, Hikaru Shida, Ace figure Toni Storm and major acquisition Mercedes Moné have managed to find space to shine, but often in isolation, with little continuity or depth in the broader storytelling. Matches are frequently relegated to the same time slot or treated as afterthoughts, and there’s been a frustrating lack of meaningful feuds beyond the title pictures.
The inconsistent TV time and underdeveloped characters have stunted the division's growth and left a trail of half-baked and incomplete characters exchanging wins and losses in listless never-ending jockeying for position, making it feel secondary instead of integral to AEW's identity. Even when opportunities arise, such as the introduction of the TBS Championship via indestructible force Jade Cargill, they've often fallen flat due to erratic booking.
The times are definitely changing, but overdue is an understatement.