10 Alternative Wrestling Awards For 2023

Wrestler Of The Year? Match Of The Year? These achievements extend yet farther...

Seth Rollins Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE

WhatCulture Wrestling has throughout the last however many weeks already awarded the more traditional prizes - and to those who have read them already, thank you for that, and indeed your support throughout 2023.

(For a run-down of the Best Wresters Of 2023, click here. For the Best Wrestlers of the Year, click here.)

Some achievements however don't fall within the scope of traditional year-end content. Sometimes, an action or pattern of behaviour is so ill-advised that the person must be recognised in their field, even if that field is very, very dumb. Sometimes, the biggest achievement is in not doing anything. Think about it: between WWE and AEW alone, not counting LVL UP, ROH or Main Event, the former puts out seven hours of weekly television, the latter five. How is it possible to get away with barely appearing on television at all?

You are all glued to your smartphones at all times. You are either reading this on a smartphone or are taking a break from social media to read this on your work computer. You need to log off.

Which wrestler simply can't being themselves to do that?

10. The 'Well, That Sounds Like A F*cking You Problem' Award

Adam Copeland
AEW

Look, episodic pro wrestling television is flawed, and the sooner you learn this, the better off everybody will be. Don't go losing your dignity when somebody says it's bad. It's bad and or a bit dumb even when it's good.

Logic gaps appear everywhere. For example, there is no set policy on when a babyface needs to be saved. They need to have friends, but then, the heels also need to get heat. A promoter will intervene when they don't want to allow fans too long a glimpse of an upcoming main event, but some midcard babyface is about to get his head staved in?

Go wild. It's only Matt Sydal, who cares?

Poor Nick Wayne's mom, on the November 22 Dynamite, was almost blasted in the temple with a Con-chair-to courtesy of her son's new father, Christian Cage. A civilian was in the middle of the ring, mere moments away from, potentially, a life-threatening head injury, and it took Adam Copeland ages to make the save. AEW's security team didn't care. The referee corps didn't care. Copeland only cared until his music struck.

"How many times do I have to tell you? I can only go to that place when I hear Metalingus!'"

Tony Khan was sat in gorilla for all this, and he presumably didn't care either.

"Nick Wayne's mom's brain matter splattering over the canvas will be great for us".


9. The Most Passive Aggressive Award

Andrade el Idolo
AEW

It mustn't be very fulfilling or particularly good for the confidence, if you're a pro wrestler who is barely used on your promoter's television programme - but there's a way of dealing with the frustration.

You can plough ahead, giving it your all in the ring, under the hope that your efforts will one day be rewarded.

Alternatively, you can simply be chuffed that you have a job, and point to your purple Kangol hat with a "How wacky is this?!" look on your face whenever you pass the booker in the corridor.

Or, you can indirectly express your displeasure using the Five Moves of Passive Aggressive Doom, which are as follows:

1) Post a cryptic GIF on Twitter, which could be interpreted as dissatisfaction - but you aren't outright saying that, wink.

2) Put over the disgraced former colleague who may or may not have punched your boss in the face when they jump to the competition.

3) Mention on your podcast that you are unhappy with your creative direction.

4) 'Like' tweets that bury your booker for not giving you the World title.

5) Unfavourably compare your promotion's recent creative to an infamously terrible angle.

Given AEW's creative woes and the extent to which TV time was at a premium in 2023, the nominees are mostly confined to that promotion. Dr. Britt Baker had her moments. John Silver opted for move #5 by comparing the Devil's Masked Men to the Dark Order Creepers. Matt Hardy scored a brace with moves #3 and #4, but Danhausen and Andrade el Idolo gave John Cena a run for his money this year.

Who wins?

That can't be determined. It's like comparing Messi and Ronaldo, Pele and Maradona. You don't quarrel over such outstanding contributions to the field of passive aggressive behaviour: you simply luxuriate in the fact that you experienced it in real-time.


8. The "What On EARTH Are You On About" Award

Gunther Miz
WWE.com

Commentators don't half talk a lot of sh*te at the best of times.

It's a tough gig. You have to be on non-stop, you can't get up and piss, and sometimes, the stories are so bad that you have to play dumb and make yourself look like a complete moron.

It would be harsh, then, to bury someone outright when they are suddenly tasked with having to explain away something like a wrestler selling for a move that obviously did not connect. No, this award is presented to a man who said something utterly baffling on purpose under the impression that it was a good idea.

In what turned out to be a good idea in general, Triple H paired together GUNTHER and The Miz, and in the second match anyway, that crazed juxtaposition informed an improbably dramatic styles clash with one shockingly effective near-fall. The build to the first was flat-out weird. GUNTHER told Miz that he didn't belong in the ring, but rather behind the guardrail "with all those other weirdos that are just like you".

It was a strange choice of word. This Miz is many things. A star. A "talk show host". The least convincing striker since Ali Dia.

Generally, he's a bit of a jock figure, the cock of the walk. For 19 years of his onscreen presence in WWE, he was never a "weirdo". Quite the opposite; if anything, he was the guy who made fun of the "weirdos" like Daniel Bryan.

Michael Cole ran with it nonetheless, screaming "Do it for all us weirdos, Miz!" when Miz got the better of the physical confrontation.

What?

Why was Cole acting like he was Shannon Moore or some sh*t?


7. The Award For 'Time To Give It Up, Lads'

Samoa Joe Adam Cole MJF
AEW

Better Than You Bay-Bay was a great time.

It was entertaining, unpredictable - who would turn on whom? - and really quite inspired. If ever there were a wrestler nice and good enough to make MJF realise that he could trust people, it was Adam Cole. It was a rare bit of pure wrestling magic; an act that just clicked with awesome chemistry and a compelling, totally unique dynamic.

It ended when Adam Cole suffered a shattered ankle when running to the ring and urging MJF not to quit at Grand Slam in September.

Or at least, it should have.

It didn't.

Instead, because the t-shirts sell so well and necessary storyline pivots are apparently not "great for us", Tony Khan tried to keep it alive. It was dead. It was as dead as fingerless gloves, cycling shorts, or the crowd during a Triple H match at WrestleMania.

This resulted in some sh*tty stuff. MJF working the Righteous on pay-per-view, which was not unlike Steve Austin going over 8-Ball and Skull at Unforgiven '98, just to keep the act going with the ROH Tag Team titles around their waists. The Roderick Strong skits, in which poor Cole had to smile through the very real pain. The show-long storyline at Full Gear, in which an injured MJF couldn't compete but Cole was somehow cleared despite being more injured.

The terrible idea of Khan no-selling reality did much to destroy AEW's rep in the back half of '23.

Dishonourable mention: Triple H trying to get Karrion Kross over.


6. Most Inexplicable Dave Meltzer Star Rating

AEW All In 2023 CM Punk Samoa Joe
AEW

As somebody who was actually at AEW All In: London, CM Punk Vs. Samoa Joe was an overwhelmingly great experience.

A battle between two master trolls soaked in blood, watching Joe tell Punk to go f*ck himself either literally or via gratuitous violence was a joy. The fans at ringside went absolutely banana. Some Elite fans in the crowd turned their backs on it!

Punk walked into the lion's den, "understood the assignment", and showed ass to draw an incandescent level of heat and deafening catharsis. Together, Punk and Joe manipulated one of the biggest crowds ever with ingenious psychology in a match that was also brutal and dramatic on the physical side of things.

This isn't an anti-Dave Meltzer rant - there are plenty of freaks who don't make a living doing that elsewhere, and his ratings, historically, are a very accurate curation of the medium - but he gave it ***1/2.

What?

Did he miss an asterisk?

He went higher on the Collision match, which was nowhere near as good nor heated.

Dave Meltzer is statistically incapable of going lower than ****1/4 on anything these days, so how did this happen?!


5. The Award For The Wrestler Who Most Needed To Log Off

Dax Harwood
AEW

In a profound note of irony, ahead of his match at ROH Final Battle, Dax Harwood remonstrated with a ringside fan for looking at their phone. If anybody ever needed to take their own advice...

Dax Harwood is a phenomenal professional wrestler who hates star ratings and whose one fatal flaw is that he is desperate for you to think that he is a phenomenal professional wrestler. Dax Harwood wants you to think he wrestles great wrestling matches more than an infant wants milk.

This manifests in his work - more than one FTR match missed its dramatic peak in 2023 - and on Twitter, he is very enthusiastic about putting over his own performances. On the same platform earlier this year, he did a very ill-advised worked shoot angle with the AEW social media team in which he teased a departure to WWE - on the basis that they had "forgotten" to create a graphic putting over his Wrestling Observer Newsletter Award for Best Tag Team of 2022.

Doesn't he hate that rag?!

Dax's priorities are confused, he has created a minor backlash effect after being extravagantly over in 2022, and could do with logging off and realising that he's more than good enough already.


4. Most LOLWCW Moment Of The Year

Shinsuke Nakamura Seth Rollins
WWE.com

It's not exactly fair to invoke WCW as shorthand for terrible - the promotion was fun and good even it was sh*te in the early '90s, and peak Nitro was seminal wrestling telly - but it's just part of the millennial wrestling lexicon.

And it is for good reason; because it was a promotion that once booked Kevin Nash to win a match between Kidman and Ric Flair after hitting Mike Awesome with a powerbomb, it probably is fair to describe something with brain-melting logic as a 'LOLWCW' moment.

In a very strange and dumb segment - one that, weirdly, wasn't slaughtered online - Shinsuke Nakamura beat up Seth Rollins in a live pre-tape. Now, that may read as an oxymoron, but that is precisely what happened.

In October, Shinsuke interrupted a live Rollins segment by appearing on the tron. It was a ruse - Shinsuke then attacked Seth in the ring - but the pre-tape kept rolling. The pre-taped Shinsuke - as in, Shinsuke being recorded ahead of time - started to count to 10 after the actual Nakamura attacked Rollins with a steel chair. This angle was done to explain to you thick tw*ts - that is WWE's opinion of you, to be clear - the rules of a Last Man Standing match.

The thing is, before he was eventually laid out for the count in a second beat-down, Rollins at first got up at the count of seven. At which point pre-tape Nakamura, who unless there were actually two of them recorded this in advance, stopped counting. Did he just correctly guess when Rollins would get up?

How embarrassing would it have been had Rollins ended up getting the best of Shinsuke in this exchange?

You won't have seen a more illogical or fake-feeling angle all year, just blisteringly stupid television, and yet Triple H will get all the credit in the world for his coherent storytelling.


3. Rub-Master Of The Year

Matt Hardy AEW
AEW

No, not that. This isn't the Jerry Lawler Award.

A lot of pro wrestlers deem it their moral duty to bring up young talents and give them the fabled "rub". The idea is for the vet to work with the upcoming act and elevate them to a higher level. Because that's how it apparently works. Some of the more cynical wrestling fans believe that the star only does this to ensure that they stay relevant.

Sheesh!

Matt Hardy was nominated for this award in 2020. Hardy first offered to align with Private Party on the June 3, 2020 Dynamite. 3 years, 6 months, and 17 days have passed since. Isiah Kassidy was more over after a 13 minute, 39 second match against the Young Bucks on the October 9, 2019 AEW Dynamite. He can't escape Hardy. Hardy is the burning of the sun. Hardy is the unfolding of time. The two things that cannot be stopped in this universe are change, and Matt Hardy's storyline association with Isiah Kassidy. Hardy can't be bargained with. He can't be reasoned with. He doesn't feel pity, or remorse, or fear - and he absolutely will not stop, ever, until you are dead.

There's always 2024, Matt!

Don Callis didn't exactly get Konosuke Takeshita over. Powerhouse Hobbs got little out of being paired with Callis nor QT Marshall. Chris Jericho forgot all about the Jericho Appreciation Society and did little to elevate Ricky Starks or Adam Cole, who fared much better with Bryan Danielson and MJF, respectively.

The Blackpool Combat Club did little to get Wheeler YUTA over, sadly, but Jon Moxley was at least clever enough to give himself a project extension; at WrestleDream, he said that he expects YUTA to be a player two years from now.

Nick Wayne is doing OK enough under Christian Cage. That's a bit of a stretch.

Erm. This is getting difficult. It's almost as if AEW should rethink this unsuccessful shortcut to push younger talent.


2. The Tommy Wiseau Award For Terrible Acting

Matt Hardy Useless
AEW

For the uninitiated, Tommy Wiseau is the worst actor of all-time. Comically bad, his creepy laughter, unhinged line readings and utterly alien approach to emulated human interaction have cast him as shorthand for bad acting.

Wrestling actors tend not to be very good, which is worrying, since WWE fancies itself as "cinema" in 2023.

Not all of them are bad, but even the good ones are incredibly broad. Their ability to project emotion is the base requirement for acting. There is rarely if ever any subtlety to the performance, and that's fine. These people are not trained actors. They are trained to convey pain, yes, but that's about it. WWE in particular insists that their characters act, and beyond Hand Staring 101 in the PC, they aren't equipped to do it.

Case in point: Von Wagner.

Now, Von is an inexplicably effective TV character, whose real-life awkwardness informs his performance as a man trying to tap into his emotions for the very first time - but it's not strictly "good". It's like outsider art, almost. His performance when visiting manager Robert Stone's house for Thanksgiving was hysterical. When he was scolded for encouraging Stone's kid's bad behaviour - "You know the kids have to eat their vegetables" - Von said "Oh yeah, right" in much the same way a haunted, guilty perp would say it when their alibi falls apart.

It wasn't quite Razzies-level. That award goes to...

On the April 29 Rampage, as part of the build to the Firm Deletion match, the Firm kidnapped Isiah Kassidy. Big Bill choke-slammed him onto an offscreen crash pad. Matt Hardy reacted to this in much the same way everybody else reacted when they watched the segment: with utter fury at what a disgrace it was. Hardy's screams of "No! No! No! No!" were just abysmal. He sounded like a toddler who was told screen time is over.

Or a wrestling vet who'd been told his screen time was over.


1. The Lanny Poffo Award

Nikki Cross
WWE.com

In this age of modern wrestling and its apparent evils, the more old school-minded wrestling fans have launched a backlash: apparently, the best wrestlers are those who get the most out of doing the least.

On that basis, the best wrestler of all-time is the much-missed Lanny Poffo, who was signed to WCW as a favour to his brother Randy Savage, and received five years' worth of salary for wrestling, at the most, once. They either forgot he existed or just wished to keep Savage sweet. The man was paid to sit around and do nothing.

Who in wrestling was paid handsomely for doing next to nothing in 2023?

Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows are heavy betting favourites, but for the sake of variety won't be considered; much like Bryan Danielson and the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's Best Technical Wrestler Award, they might as well rename the Poffo Award after them two.

Nikki Cross was paid to hover around in backstage segments and look catatonic on the apron. In addition to the Poffo Award, she is competing with Dexter Lumis for the Gets Works Because WWE Is Weirdly Impressed By Their Inability To Blink prize.

The award would have been given to Half The AEW Roster, had the Authors of Pain not worked a single professional wrestling match since re-signing with WWE in 2022.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!