10 Amazing Wrestlers WWE Fans Will NEVER Love

These incredible workers will never get the credit they deserve from EVERY WWE fan.

Logan Paul Shocked
WWE/BT Sport

Pretty much every member of WWE's fanbase gets all doe-eyed and protective when legends like Steve Austin, The Undertaker and Trish Stratus get brought up. That's even true of more modern names like Sami Zayn, Becky Lynch and he-who-came-back-from-the-brink Roman Reigns.

Meanwhile, nobody is going to bat for Baron Corbin.

It's a strange thing, but there are just some wrestlers past and present that WWE fans will never love. They might receive a compliment here or there, sure (that match was good, that angle worked a treat etc etc), but generally? Yeah, most folks seem to ignore these men and women when talking about the best, or screw up their faces when they're merely brought up mid-conversation.

This is a shame, because they were all amazing in their own ways. Obviously, this list is very subjective - the guy writing it has simply noticed that there's an almost-automatic rejection of anything positive these folks have contributed to WWE's on-screen product.

Naturally, the company's own presentation and/or rewriting of history doesn't help sometimes. These fab talents may never get the credit they deserve for in-ring skill or blistering character work...

10. Marty Jannetty

Marty Jannetty
WWE

This is a logical starting point.

Marty Jannetty is the prototypical "other guy". Christ, wrestling pushed him to the side in favour of golden boy Shawn Michaels so hard that tag partners who don't go on to become World Champs are referred to as "the Marty Jannetty of the team". That's cold.

Here's the deal: Marty was one hell of a worker in his own right. There's a reason why the then-WWF brought him back time and time again. They knew he could deliver solid matches in his sleep, and quietly hoped that Jannetty would blow up like HBK did by becoming a top singles star.

It'd never happen for a variety of reasons. Personal demons are often cited as the main one, which is fair, but Marty had already been typecast over the years as good in tags but not on his own. He'll probably never get the credit his own in-ring work richly deserves - and the looming Dark Side of the Ring special likely won't alter that...


9. Taka Michinoku

Taka Michinoku kaientai
WWE.com

What's the first thing wrestling fans think of when they hear the name Taka Michinoku? Why it's that "Indeeeeeed" overdub he worked alongside fellow Kaientai stablemate Funaki, of course. No-one talks about his speedy in-ring style, or matches that stood apart from anything else on WWF TV in the late-1990s.

In fairness, Taka was the early kingpin of an unloved division. He won the WWF Light-Heavyweight Title in late-1997, but Vince McMahon would never embrace his own WCW Cruiserweight Title rival. In fact, as Bruce Prichard has revealed on his podcast, Vince viewed the Light-Heavyweight belt as "less than".

Why even push it in the first place then?!

As a result, Michinoku's best work is hidden behind "comedic" promos and jobber-iffic tag-team bouts. Hell, even his top performance opposite then-wrestling machine Triple H on Raw in 2000 is overlooked in favour of the Kaientai comedy, and that's just a damn shame considering how much potential he had as the WWF's very own Rey Mysterio Jr.


8. Gail Kim

gail kim wrestlemania
WWE.com

Ask many contemporary female wrestlers to name a handful of heroes and Gail Kim will surely be in there somewhere. After all, Kim helped revolutionise women's wrestling in North America by leading the charge for Knockouts in TNA, and her matches vs. Awesome Kong were exactly that - they were awesome.

Her two WWE runs? Less so.

Gail is a two-time WWE Women's Champion, but she'll never get house room in company circles these days. That could change if the E ever hires Kim as a trainer at the Performance Center, or something like that, but she was soured big time on the fed a long time ago so it's unlikely.

Despite being heralded by many as a true pioneer in the women's game, Gail won't be paraded in front of WWE fans as some returning great who changed the rules by refusing to settle for Diva bullsh*t. In short, today's wrestling fanbase will never get the chance to love her the way some others do.

Boo to that.


7. Colt Cabana (Scotty Goldman)

Scotty Goldman
WWE

Scotty. F'n. Goldman.

Revisit any of that character's appearances on SmackDown between 2008-2009 and you'll see nothing that made Colt Cabana a walking treasure in ROH and elsewhere on the independent wrestling scene. His quirky promos and squash match losses screamed 1980s enhancement talent, and that was never going to get over.

Being brutally honest, Colt was set up to fail in WWE. His zany personality was watered down, and he wasn't allowed to show what a true talent he can be between the ropes either. Basically, he was the living, breathing antithesis of everything Vince McMahon wanted in a "WWE Superstar", and it's baffling that he was even shunted onto telly this way in the first place.

Cabana was able to spread his wings outside the restrictive WWE environment though, at least. That doesn't change the fact that he won't get another chance to show the promotion's wider audience what he's capable of.


6. Ultimo Dragon

Ultimo Dragon belts
WWE.com

'Oh, it's that dude who fell down during his entrance at WrestleMania XX'.

That's what some would say when shown footage of the dazzling Ultimo Dragon. They'd skim past his J-Crown Title success, or the unreal body of work he put together throughout the 1990s. People would even gloss over Dragon's time in WCW between 1996-1998.

That's rubbish, because he was seriously, seriously good in-ring. Ultimo's WWE run, which lasted for one miserable year between 2003-2004, started with promise but ended with a real whimper. His 'Mania embarrassment summed the entire experience up in a nutshell - there was to be no Mysterio-like level of success for Dragon under Vinnie Mac's watch.

Ultimo Dragon is deserving of consideration for a spot in WWE's Hall Of Fame, but he might never get there. Whilst he didn't make the splash some thought he might in the company, Dragon did contribute hugely to today's in-ring product.


5. JBL

JBL - WWE Champion
WWE.com

This writer can almost see the bubbling anger when some clap eyes on JBL's name. He routinely pops up when people discuss the "worst WWE Champions ever", and he's become a well-known backstage bully who needed put in his place by Joey Styles (of all people) many moons ago.

None of that changes his inclusion on this list; JBL was fabulous in the arrogant heel champ role throughout 2004-2005, and he had some absolute classics with one Eddie Guerrero. Will he ever get love from most pro wrasslin' fans out there though? Will he b*llocks.

Layfield isn't well-liked or well-respected as a worker by countless folks.

Do yourself a favour at some point. Fire up WWE Network/Peacock and watch some of his promos as WWE Champ. Then, after witnessing those searing heat-fests, watch his bouts vs. Guerrero and John Cena. This is a guy who knew his role, and he played it to the hilt.

That isn't enough to earn him plaudits from many critics.


4. Dean Malenko

Dean Malenko
WWE.com

Technical wrestling genius Dean Malenko was never a great fit for the WWF when he jumped over from WCW as part of The Radicalz group in early-2000. His fondness for combining excellent mat work with faster-paced Cruiserweight stylings clashed with the promotion's product, and he'd quietly retire by mid-2001.

Deano went on to work as a road agent/producer for the next 18 years, and only left WWE in 2019. Since then, he's become a senior producer in AEW, and is well-respected by everyone who crosses his path. So, why doesn't Malenko get more adulation from the WWE masses?

It's a bit of a mystery, because he's another who hatched blueprints for most things hardcore company fans adore these days. Dean worked a realistic in-ring style, and he had a no-frills presentation that was arguably too bland for the raunchy WWF in 2000.

It'd be sweet if he was honoured properly, but that'll probs never happen.


3. Charlotte Flair

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Controversy time. Maybe.

Charlotte Flair is viewed as someone who can have good-to-great matches, and she does click as a heel character on TV. However, she flops when tasked with playing likeable babyface - just check out her latest run as SmackDown Women's Champion for weekly proof of that.

The 'born with a silver spoon in her mouth' story is hard for Charlotte to shake. She's Ric Flair's kid, and that means there will always be some who lazily lean on that as the main reason for her success. This, clearly, is totally unfair when she's carved out a path for herself and had several stunning showcases vs. Sasha Banks, Becky Lynch, Rhea Ripley and more.

There's an overall sense that Charlotte will never be accepted the same way someone like Lynch is though. A narrative has built and built in the minds of many that Flair benefitted solely from nepotism. Add on her shaky babyface runs and you've got someone who's on/off respected.

She certainly isn't loved by all.


2. Ronda Rousey

Ronda Rousey Money
WWE.com

Is Ronda Rousey an "amazing wrestler"? She's definitely a provocative character, and came armed with more excitement than any female rookie in living memory when she properly burst onto the WWE scene at Royal Rumble 2018. That show marked the full-time start of Ronda's wrestling journey (even though she'd shown up here or there for years).

People were right up for seeing Rousey in WWE rings, and her earliest matches had Brock Lesnar-esque danger to them. That caught the eye, but things have faded as the years rolled on. Still, when she's put in the right situations, Ronda is perfectly capable of producing something special.

That doesn't matter to fans who turned their nose up at Rousey from the off.

In fairness, Ronda has bit back at WWE fans via podcasts and other interviews. There's a fractious relationship now, and that'll make another babyface run extremely difficult. Rousey will never be embraced fully by the wider wrestling community, and that's just the way it is.


1. Logan Paul

Logan Paul
WWE.com

So, when do the haters admit that Logan Paul is pretty f*cking good at this stuff?

Those who want to palm off Logan's work will point to opponents like Rey Mysterio, The Miz, Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins as guys who carried Paul kicking and screaming to workable bouts. That's...both unfair and untrue. LP has more than held up his end of the bargain during every supershow performance thus far.

He appears to be a natural, and that really grates on fans who don't like the thought of some YouTuber walking into mega-events like WrestleMania and SummerSlam to sell energy drinks then tear the house down. Truthfully, he still has some kinks to iron out, but the man has only had four matches (five if one includes the 2023 Royal Rumble).

That's insane, and it defo puts Logan Paul up there with some legendary names as someone who's enjoyed one of the best rookie years ever. Regardless, many WWE fans will always reject him as someone "playing wrestler".

Which other wrestlers, past or present, will WWE fans never truly love? For more like this, check out Predicting WWE's WrestleMania XL Cards 1 Year Out and WWE 2K23: 15 Best WCW CAWs You Need To Download!


In this post: 
Logan Paul
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.