10 Amazing Wrestling Callbacks You Totally Missed
Wrestlers don't just work the house in 2023: starring MJF, Kenny Omega and Shawn Michaels...
Dave Meltzer has a theory, and it's very true to a point, with which he addresses criticism of his controversial star rating system.
When people accuse him of inflating the system, he counters by saying that wrestling tends to date poorly, and, if anything, he'd sooner lower historical ratings in retrospect than rein in his enthusiasm about the modern scene. He points out, rightfully, that the wrestlers of yore worked for a different crowd in a different time and place with no knowledge - or care - about how future generations would receive their work.
This annoys people, who believe that - rather than being fooled by nostalgia - a sensibility is missing from today's wrestling. It's difficult to watch, as an example, the greatest work of Terry Funk and not feel as though a certain grit, animosity and agony would not go amiss.
If Meltzer's theory was true then, it isn't true now.
In this age of accessibility through technology and the episodic TV model, the best modern wrestlers actively want their fans to watch their entire body of work intently. They aren't working for the house anymore: they want fans to recall story beats planted years ago to deepen their enjoyment of what is to follow.
That, or, knowing the past exists and has been documented all over social media, they mine it to add more credibility to their work through continuity...
10. Samoa Joe Barges Past MJF
Back when he was in NXT Champion, when making his entrance at TakeOver: Brooklyn II, Samoa Joe cruelly pushed a member of his security detail against a wall, all while wearing a smug expression on his face.
That person was MJF, who at the time was an aspiring unknown doing extra work to get his face out there.
Now, because he's a genius, MJF pays attention to everything. The man exists in character at all times in order to maintain the illusion that he is a "real" person in whom you can actually invest. Even before the events of AEW All Out 2023, MJF curated this tiny morsel of WWE storytelling. Upon Samoa Joe's first release from WWE, on April 15, 2021, the usual thing happened: fans petitioned for AEW to sign him. MJF, never letting even a small, theoretical narrative opportunity slip through his fingers, tweeted "Stop posting the gif".
It has at last been revisited in AEW canon when, at All Out, Joe opted to make his ring entrance immediately following Better Than You Bay-Bay's successful defence of the ROH World Tag Team titles. Joe, with a callback, brushed MJF aside before later applying a standing guillotine choke.
Building interest in their match, MJF has created the impression that he never got over the slight - reflecting his Rejection Sensitivity Disorder character arc in the process.
Just sublime depths of character work.
9. CM Punk With A Golden Nod To The Past
CM Punk is a thug.
Not, not because he's a temperamental fellow who would fight Haku if he thought he'd waved politely in Dave Meltzer's direction, but because T is for terrible, H is for hell, U is for ugly and G is for jail 'cause a thug can't spell.
CM Punk loved and idolised Tracy Smothers, who created that quite incredible catchphrase - one that's all the better, somehow, for not making that much sense. Smothers was a straight shooter who, after working some of the best (and earliest) ladder matches in the '90s, spent his twilight years on the indies. There, he cultivated a great reputation for imparting advice and being a good soul with the interests of the next generation in mind.
He dressed as the Golden Vampire to outwit the deeply missed Sweet N' Sour Larry Sweeney at an IWA Mid-South show in 2005, from which Punk took inspiration to fool Samoa Joe on the August 19, 2023 AEW Collision. With Joe expecting a tune-up match against a jobber, Punk struck him - that is euphemistic - with the GTS. Their now infamous date at Wembley was set.
Look, the GTS was more Tom Magee than Tracy, but it was still a nice deep cut.
8. Hangman Page Attempts To Atone
The booking in AEW used to be better and more thought-out and critics of the promotion point this out in hopes that a bit of a kicking might drive Tony Khan into recapturing his form.
The booking of the Elite ahead of and at All Out 2020 was majestic.
In a great bit of daring plotting, that made exquisite use of the rankings system, FTR and the Young Bucks almost collided in a four-way Gauntlet match between the teams ranked #1, #2, #3 and #4. Tony Khan, and talk about build, used the (unrealised) threat of a free first-time meeting between the Bucks and FTR as a means of convincing fans that they'd much rather pay for it. This was a bait-and-switch, but the best possible version. The people wanted the scam!
They were deprived of the real thing when Hangman Page, manipulated by FTR, prevented Nick Jackson from executing his role in the Meltzer Driver by clutching the leg. The distraction saw the Bucks eliminated.
FTR advanced to face Kenny Omega and Hangman Page instead, and in the match, in an attempt to atone, Page prevented Dax Harwood from drilling Omega with a suplex using the exact same body language. Even his anguished head was twisted at the exact same angle.
Contrition as a counter: melodramatic in-ring storytelling rarely is as clever as that.
7. Shawn Michaels Knows His Gear
Shawn Michaels was an expert with gear.
Pause.
For all the criticism pelted at WWE in the 2000s - and rightly so, what with them killing the WCW dream and replacing it with an endless cookie cutter developmental nightmare - they, more often than not, got the big stories with the big stars right.
The Shawn Michaels Vs. Undertaker programme was exceptional. Michaels didn't just come close to defeating 'Taker in that unforgettable classic at WrestleMania 25: he humanised 'Taker in a way nobody else had. This was inspired, pivotal. The story of the match convinced Michaels that he was the one to finally break the Streak, and, in a great continuing story, he grew obsessed with the thought over the next 12 months.
Across Royal Rumble and Elimination Chamber, Shawn eliminated his friends, sold madness when he himself was eliminated, and screwed the Undertaker out of the World Heavyweight championship - just so that he could get the chance. Of course, he put his career on the line in one last bid to make it happen.
At the 2010 Rumble, and he never did it elsewhere, he wore the exact same tights he had at 'Mania 25. This callback conveyed the idea that he was so obsessed with 'Taker that he had become irrational to the point of superstition.
6. Shawn Michaels Was As Good As They Said He Was
Known for a very long time as an undisputed North American great, Shawn Michaels has taken something of a critical battering in recent years.
He's not entirely blameless here. Coming out of retirement to take blood money obviously did him no favours. But the resentment is almost indirect. His "Sorry, I love you" and Shocked Kick-Out Faces are, when done to excess, a plague on the modern scene. His influence has allowed, with no hyperbole, hundreds of inferior wrestlers to take his shortcuts and eat themselves with melodrama.
He produced more than half of those matches, yes, but he was a genius of a pro wrestler. He was, before becoming enamoured with broad melodrama, as understated as anybody.
He was the special guest referee for the Rock Vs. Triple H Iron Man at Judgment Day 2000. In the build, the Rock brought up a long-forgotten angle in which Shawn Michaels hit him with the Sweet Chin Music on the SmackDown premiere. Michaels owing to his various problems was a fitful presence in a very fitful time - but Rock remembered and told Shawn not to screw him.
As did the most hawk-eyed WWF fans, whom Michaels rewarded. With under two minutes left, the match tied 5-5, the Rock motioned to hit the People's Elbow. Watch Michaels carefully: for a split-second, his footwork suggests that he is about to cut him off with the Sweet Chin Music. He doesn't, but he puts your heart in your mouth before you can even register it.
For a man who spent ages staring at his hands, this was blink-and-you'll-miss-it brilliance from HBK.
5. CM Punk: Extremely Online
CM Punk, forever an enigma, positions himself as above the childish games of online wrestling circles - and yet haunts social media more than every engagement farm account put together.
The man who used to keep his own LiveJournal was also fond of a shoot interview, and in a famous example conducted alongside Samoa Joe, he told the story of a rib he once played on then-ROH booker Gabe Sapolsky. Mimicking Homicide, Punk called Gabe and pretended that "he" couldn't make Final Battle 2003 because he'd just been offered monster money to stay in Puerto Rico. Even though it was his dream to wrestle Satoshi Kojima, he just couldn't turn it down.
It was a shame. He really wanted to take the lariat!
Punk did this - with an escalating stream of "Lariat! Kojima!" nonsense - because Gabe's hysterical, end-of-the-world conniption fits were the stuff of legend and a source of great amusement within the locker room.
Fast-forward two full decades, and it was Punk who worked Kojima at AEW x NJPW Forbidden Door 2023.
During that match - even in a role well beneath Punk, he was so fantastic at playing the stooging midcard heel - he cornered Satoshi and threw his bicep at him.
All the while, he yelled "Kojima! Lariat! Kojima!"
4. Hey! I'm Easter Egging Here!
WWE is largely a more...fitful promotion than AEW, or at least it was when Vince McMahon was firmly in control. It is difficult to fondly recall a moment in the history of the promotion, and blend it into the next phase of a story, when so much of that modern history basically amounts to a lot of incoherent nonsense that Vince retconned through disgust within the span of about three weeks.
Now that WWE has rediscovered a rather important storytelling device called "plotting", the company is able to have some fun with continuity.
As fundamentally silly a TV programme as NXT is, the show - and this is bare minimum stuff really - does actually storyboard things and pay attention to itself. It matters. It's hysterically stupid at times, but it matters. It's one of the weirder passion projects in WWE history.
As an example, a mafioso character named 'Two Dimes', formerly of Tony D'Angelo's family, was killed off when Troy Donovan was found to have broken "policy" in 2022. He was chucked over a bridge and fed to the fishes.
A year later, when his old partner in crime Stacks attempted to solve the mystery of who ratted Tony out to the "feds", two actual dimes were stuck to his conspiracy board. Did he survive the attempt on his life?!
(Yes, since for some strange reason he rocked up in AEW subsequently).
While hardly "amazing" in and of itself, the idea that WWE actually recalls things these days is an amazing phenomenon.
3. Sledgehammer Subtle
You'd be forgiven for missing this one, since, by the time Triple H and Batista entered the ring at WrestleMania 35, the show had already ran long by several months.
And then, when they started telling their story, it was so brutally long that few paid attention. Because it was a Triple H match at WrestleMania, it was of course the longest thing on the show.
It wasn't very good, at all, but it had potential. Elements of the match were fun. Triple H removing Batista's nose ring with pliers was a funny and shockingly well-shot spot, and that sort of thing should have been emphasised more. Elsewhere, it was far too ponderous and self-important for its own good. 10 punchy minutes of meme fodder were exactly what that show needed, but Triple H got in his own way with yet another attempt at an "epic".
In one spot, echoing the events of Vengeance 2005, Triple H attempted to strike Dave with a sledgehammer before eating a Batista bomb regardless.
Since the gap between Vengeance 2005 and WrestleMania 35 was almost as long as the match, it didn't resonate with the nostalgic warmth intended.
2. Yes, Kenny Omega Really Is That Great
Kenny Omega is so otherworldly as a storyteller that he can use the callback even in a way that can elevate bad tropes.
The three-way/Triple Threat, with few exceptions, is largely a cop-out of a match designed to get another star on the marquee or put a body in there to beat. The match itself almost invariably suffers from the same logic gap: a wrestler sells for an eternity on the outside after taking a move to which they'd barely flinch in the context of a singles.
At Double Or Nothing 2021, Omega perfected this trope.
At All Out 2019, he lost to PAC in a shock result when, trapped in the Brutaliser, he lost consciousness. 18 months later, in a three-way that also involved Orange Cassidy, PAC struck again - but this time, Omega had learned a counter. He accelerated backwards in a panic, the momentum caused PAC to tumble out of the ring, and this allowed Omega and Orange to set up their sequence.
Yes, as is always the case, PAC did spend too long on the outside - but there has never been a more logical way of doing the illogical three-way format.
1. Jon Moxley Tells Kenny Omega Who He Is
The chaotic ending of the first edition of AEW Dynamite was one plot hole away from perfection: a narrative big bang in which a stable was formed and half a pay-per-view card was built in one awesome brawl, if only the Elite Vs. Chris Jericho, Santana and Ortiz main event as advertised as a no holds barred match.
It made no sense that the match wasn't thrown out when Jon Moxley blasted Kenny Omega through a glass table, but still: what an incredible spot amid incredible scenes that instantly elevated Dynamite as the energetic new home of pro wrestling.
Mox did that in 2019 to send a message, and Omega tried, foolishly, to answer it. Death match wrestling was Mox's domain. Omega wasn't built for it. They resumed their rivalry a year later, and, in a cracking angle ahead of Winter Is Coming, Mox again executed the Paradigm Shift - this time, onto the AEW World title.
This symbolised two things: Mox was far more than a Death match wrestler, he was the best wrestler period, the World champion - and Omega couldn’t match him one on one, either.
This callback foreshadowed the Omega turn: he could not solve the Moxley puzzle in neither a lawless realm nor a "gentleman's contest", and had to take a shortcut to wrest that title away from him.