10 Awesome WWE Ideas That Didn't Last

Kofi Kingston as a main eventer? It's not the first time...

The Shield Faces
WWE.com

Great ideas don’t grow on trees, but with an entire team of writers working for them you’d expect WWE to have more than most. Even so being a WWE fan can often be an arduous prospect, putting up with an avalanche of uninspired content in the hope that something thrilling is waiting around the corner. The wait is patient, but the wait is almost always rewarding.

Whether we’re talking about a heel turn, a storyline development or throwing two individuals together as a tag team WWE has had some great ideas over the years, ideas that have reinvigorated careers, thrilled viewers and sold entire shows in the process. They’ve also had some absolute stinkers, but what point is there in thinking about those?

Sometimes the life of an idea is cut short. There can be a number of reasons for this, some negative and some positive. More often than not (as you’ll see) the reason is injury, but sometimes politics or a complete lack of patience are also to blame. Things that could have been great get left to rot; potentially career-defining moments left out in the cold.

Here are 10 great ideas that WWE had that simply didn’t last.


10. The Wrestling Classic

Wrestling Classic
WWE.com

Before there was a Big Four on the WWE calendar there was just WrestleMania, the first of which was held in 1985. Later that year the then-WWF attempted to capitalise on its success by holding a show called The Wrestling Classic, the second PPV in the company's history.

It would prove to be a one and done job; The Wrestling Classic would never return. The show featured a 16-man single elimination tournament, with nothing but pride on the line. Junkyard Dog would stand tall at the climax, defeating ‘Macho Man’ Randy Savage in the final. The show wasn’t great, but it still stands as unique today.

With the WWE Network, WWE has shown that tournament-centric shows can work, and with the abundance of talent on the roster there is no reason why an annual tournament such as this can't work.

They could even make this an annual network-only show, call it something like, oh I don’t know, King of the Ring maybe? Wait…


9. Cryme Tyme Cenation

Cryme Tyme John Cena
WWE.com

Sure, it gave us the awful JBL is Poopy nonsense, but for a brief while in 2008 an alliance was formed between John Cena and Cryme Tyme, collectively known as Cryme Tyme Cenation (CTC). The alliance came not long after Shad Gaspard and JTG had returned to the WWE, and being positioned on-screen with the number one name in the company at the time gave the tag team a legitimacy they had previously lacked.

The alliance also began repairing some of the damage done to Cena’s reputation with the hardcore fans, as the now PG-friendly face of the company began to show some of the chops that had initially made him the Doctor of Thuganomics. It seemed like a win-win situation; Cryme Tyme look credible, Cena looks cool.

Unfortunately for Cena, a herniated disc in his neck put him out for several months, thus ending the alliance. Cryme Tyme’s WWE career would come to nought, and Cena would return as good ol’ JC at Survivor Series that year.


8. Kofi Kingston - Main Event Star

Kofi Kingston 2009
WWE.com

Though Kofi Kingston's current tilt at the WWE title is predicated on the fact that he's been a solid, hard-working midcard hand for the better part of the past decade, there was actually another time when he was being positioned to be the major babyface of the company.

The year was 2009, and Kofi had been on the main roster for two years. He’d won the odd championship, but outside of exciting performances it didn’t seem as though he’d be pushed to the moon any time soon. Slowly but surely WWE began to strip away the lighter side of his character, removing the Jamaican influences and allowing Kofi to show his serious side.

All of which led to what should have been a career-making feud with Randy Orton. As Kofi hit Orton with a Boom Drop in the crowd at Madison Square Garden it did indeed seem as though a star was born. Orton would ultimately win the feud (clearly the wrong decision), but it was an incident a few months after that would end Kofi’s push.

Kofi seemed to make a slight mistake towards the end of a triple threat match, leading to Orton calling him ‘stupid’ in the ring and angrily hitting an RKO. Kofi’s push was dead, and midcard purgatory beckoned until his 2019 escape. Hopefully he has better luck this time around.


7. The Bobby Heenan Show

WWE Network

Bobby ‘The Brain’ Heenan was arguably the biggest heel in the then-WWF as the '80s became the '90s. Company stories generally revolved around big babyface stars taking on members of the Heenan Family, with most of the crowd’s anger directed at the Broadcast Journalist they lovingly referred to as a ‘weasel’.

Heenan was a multi-talented media man, and his talents were briefly put to the test in ‘The Bobby Heenan Show’. The programme was essentially a real talk show with real guests, not entirely wrestling-based but with the odd wrestling tinge. It came about after Heenan walked off Primetime Wrestling, getting himself the final 30 minutes of that two-hour broadcast to stick it to Gorilla Monsoon.

Heenan interviewed all sorts in what was seemingly an entirely improvised show, showcasing the incredible talents of The Brain. It was a riot, to say the least. Sadly the show only lasted four episodes, as the ratings didn’t quite match the entertainment value.


6. Babyface Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt Alberto Del Rio
WWE.com

This could have been 2016’s crowning moment, if Bray Wyatt wasn't completely cursed. After missing WrestleMania 32 through injury, Bray returned after the Show of Shows to begin a feud with 'Bad News' Barrett's insipid faction The League of Nations. It seemed as though Wyatt was about to enter the babyface world - a world of electric promos and revolutionary fire.

All of which went out when Bray got injured again and returned to begin feuding with The New Day. It was a wet fart of a move to say the least, as all the hope and enthusiasm for WWE’s potentially game-changing anti-hero evaporated.

Since then, Bray has experienced a skittish babyface run of a sort, aligning with Broken Matt Hardy throughout 2018 until injury to the latter curtailed the tandem. Matt eventually returned as though the team had never existed, leaving the cumbersome cultist rudderless - and awaiting a 'fresh direction' - once more.


5. The League Of Nations

League Of Nations
WWE.com

For years, fans had fantasy-booked a faction of European talent, involving men like Sheamus, Wade Barrett, Drew McIntyre, Cesaro and Rusev. In 2015 this became a reality, as the Celtic Warrior joined forces with the King of Bad News and the Bulgarian Brute to form the League of Nations. For reasons best ignored, Mexican Alberto Del Rio was also added to the faction.

What was a great idea on paper became an absolute shambles on camera, as the League bumbled from mishap to mishap in a desperate attempt to make Roman Reigns the sympathetic babyface WWE so desperately wanted him to be. The League were entirely toothless, four top performers sacrificed at the feet of the Roman Empire.

They were beyond salvation, and if anyone benefited from Bray Wyatt’s injury it was the League of Nations. They split as a result, and everyone was better off for it (well, except Barrett, who left the company shortly after). A great idea that was executed horrifically.


4. The Awesome Truth

R Truth The Miz Awesome Truth
WWE.com

It takes a lot of work to make R-Truth a credible heel in the modern day and age, yet somehow WWE managed to do so by aligning him with The Miz of all people. Miz and Truth came together in the summer of 2011 as they felt they were both the victims of a WWE conspiracy keeping them out of the main event. This led to them interrupting matches and basically holding the show hostage. Despite this being The Miz and R-Truth, the angle worked and the two became hated for the right reasons in the process.

It was a chance, seemingly out of nowhere, to solidify two credible main event heels to go up against John Cena and newly-babyface CM Punk. Instead The Awesome Truth were served up on a plate to The Rock and Cena at Survivor Series and subsequently split after Truth gained himself a Wellness Policy violation.

The Miz continued to meander for a few more years before his 2016 career resurgence, whilst Truth hasn’t even come close to entertaining the idea of this level of legitimacy since. The Awesome Truth was one of those rare ideas that didn’t seem great on paper but truly caught on, only to be extinguished before its full potential could be met.


3. The Intercontinental Cup

Intercontinental Cup
WWE.com

For years and years WWE has been giving the impression that the Intercontinental Championship is a title that has lost its way, with a stream of champions claiming that they will bring credibility and prestige back to the belt. Every once in a while the company would start making moves to rehabilitate it before quickly losing interest. One such incident came in 2013, when England’s own Wade Barrett was champion.

In order to decide a number one contender for the championship, WWE announced that the Intercontinental Cup would be held on Main Event. It was heavily-promoted on RAW, and WWE even announced the man who would take part in the tournament, performers such as Cesaro, Randy Orton, Damien Sandow and current IC Champion The Miz.

For reasons that weren’t quite clear at the time the IC Cup was nixed. Barrett claimed he had gotten the cup cancelled, but it soon became apparent that the tournament was abandoned in favour of moving forward with a Barrett/Bo Dallas feud. Just start printing money, WWE.

The Intercontinental Cup would have done wonders for the title, the performers, and even for Main Event. As it is, it is just another great idea that wasn’t realised.


2. Renegade Matt Hardy

Matt Hardy 2005
WWE.com

The Edge/Matt Hardy/Lita saga of 2005 was a mess, to say the least. In short, Edge and Lita were fondling whilst Matt was injured, a state of affairs that wouldn’t be so bad if Lita and Matt weren’t an item at the time. WWE subsequently fired Matt, as Edge was a top heel and Lita was Lita. Matt was merely an injured performer.

The WWE audience and internet community were disgusted by this however, and almost overnight Matt Hardy became the most sympathetic babyface in wrestling. It couldn’t be ignored, and rumours of Matt returning to WWE were rife. Before they could truly catch fire Matt started appearing on WWE TV, attacking Edge and either escaping before capture or being arrested.

It was true fourth wall stuff, one of the most convincing times WWE has blurred the line between fiction and reality in forever. Matt would indeed be brought back, and surely the matches between him and Edge would make two genuine new stars for the company.

Their first match came at SummerSlam 2005, and whilst it ended in blood it did so in a ridiculous manner. Edge beat Matt so bad that the match was stopped by the referee. The right ending to that match for sure, but why in god’s name wasn’t it Matt beating Edge into a bloody pulp? From here on the story was dead.


1. The Good Hounds Of Justice

The Shield Entrance
WWE.com

After just over a year of terrorising the WWE roster in the name of all that is heel, Dean Ambrose, Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins began hinting at a babyface turn in the spring of 2014. They did so opposite The Wyatt Family, and the two factions had a couple of matches for the ages. The Shield continued their new good-guy status through WrestleMania season, dismantling Kane and The New Age Outlaws before continually besting Evolution in a series of matches.

The hottest babyface faction in WWE came to a shuddering halt when Seth Rollins turned on Ambrose and Reigns however, the good guy run of The Shield lasting just four months. It was brief but it was beautiful, crowds responding with such vigour that it is clear they want organically cool anti-heroes.

WWE could have got a lot more mileage and a lot more money out of The Shield running a little longer. It would have undoubtedly done a lot of good for Roman Reigns too, giving him the chance to work as a babyface whilst still being protected somewhat by his more experienced partners. Turning The Shield babyface was another great idea that simply wasn’t allowed to last.

A couple of babyface though ultimately abortive Shield reunions have came to pass since, but none have managed a sustained run. 2017's version felt like nothing more than a desperate attempt to get Roman Reigns over, hardly helped by the man himself missing their big TLC homecoming through illness. 2018 saw a partial restoration, before Reigns added his fist following his leukaemia diagnosis - only to have Dean Ambrose turn on him that night. It seems every effort to get the band back together is fighting against fate.

As WrestleMania draws - and Ambrose's time with WWE is seemingly coming to an end - The Shield has embarked on one final albeit disparate nostalgia run, but it's nothing like the 2014 vintage. After April, it's unlikely we'll see the trio seeking justice as a team for a while.


In this post: 
The Shield
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.