10 Awful Wrestling Matches That Stunk Up Arenas

"MINUS FIVE STARS!"

Warrior Goldust II
WWE.com

A bad wrestling match might contain within it a series of botches.

It might fall apart under the weight of a constrictive stipulation. It might be subjected to a wrestler being in "no condition to perform" in it.

The matches on this list are much, much worse than that. They are the lowest of the low. One stunk up the arena to such an extent that it resulted in the immediate dismissal of two of the poor souls who made up half of it. Astonishingly, some of these matches feature wrestlers who - at least when paired with the correct opponent - were more than capable of assembling a gripping contest. Their inclusion here is as baffling as it is disappointing as it is perversely hilarious.

As a rule of thumb, non-wrestlers aren't included in this list. Your writer, sitting in a cushy office, wouldn't want to be subjected to Dave Meltzer's divisive star rating system. Untrained, unfit, and with a monotonous voice, he couldn't talk you into the building, nor work once inside of it.

There is one exception to this rule: one such catastrophe is so incomprehensibly terrible that it demands inclusion.

10. Hollywood Hogan Vs. The Warrior - WCW Halloween Havoc 1998

Hogan Warrior
WWE

A mat classic was never on the agenda, but Hogan and the Warrior's match at WrestleMania VI eight years earlier was cause enough for some optimism - even if both men's performance level had subsequently degenerated through selfishness and ring rust, respectively.

"They are two of the greatest wrestlers of all-time", said Tony Schiavone euphemistically, as the two circled one another in the early going, which consisted of little more than basic locks. "Come on, Hogan - feel the power!" Warrior cried, challenging his opponent to an '80s-style test of strength.

Meanwhile, in the WWF, Stone Cold Steve Austin was popularising the crazed arena-wide brawl commonplace in the company's Attitude Era.

Warrior, as if seeking vengeance for Hogan's limelight-hogging shenanigans at 'Mania VI, mistimed his selling to an almost comical extent. Hogan laughed in arch villain fashion during one of the match's many, many tests of strength, to which fans rain down apathetic jeers.

It is as lazy and arrogant a match you're ever likely to see, and the finish included a spectacular - and literal - misfire: Hogan was meant to throw a fireball in Warrior's direction, but it instead blew up in his hand and scorched his own face.

That just about sums the whole thing up.


9. Jenna Morasca Vs. Sharmell - TNA Victory Road 2009

Sharmell Jen Morasca Victory Road 2009
impactwrestling.com

Morasca wasn't a pro wrestler by trade. That much was evident within the first minute of this trainwreck.

Morasca's first contribution was to botch a lock-up, following which she took a knee to the gut (which she no-sold). She did stay down for longer than a micro-second in the subsequent exchanges, but beyond that, the match devolved into a violation of the industry. Morasca didn't so much run the ropes as tap the top one lightly, as if undergoing a beep test.

Morasca did an abysmal job even of getting beaten down. Things descended from farce to insult when she eventually mounted some offence; she subjected Sharmell to a barrage of slaps so weak that her arms looked to have been made out of latex rubber.

The application and receipt of wrestling holds must be a very difficult skill to master - but aiming realistic slaps in the general vicinity of somebody's face is something even a primary school pupil can do.

The match ended with Morasca's ringside charge Awesome Kong striking Sharmell softly in the throat. Morasca then pinned her following a nonsensical strip routine, gyrating on her as Earl Hebner counts to three.

The ubiquitous "Fire Russo!" chants were never more appropriate.


8. The Brothers Of Destruction Vs. Kronik - WWF Unforgiven 2001

Kronik Brothers of Destruction Unforgiven 2001
WWE.com

This match was the nadir of an Invasion angle that misused oceans of talent and killed stone dead a worldwide wrestling brand which, while devalued, still had potential for resuscitation.

Brian Adams and Bryan Clark were never in danger of approaching the heights of the Brain Busters, but prior to this disgrace, they could at least exchange very basic moves.

Jim Ross suffered the commentator's curse shortly after the bell. "Adams and Clark - they're two big, powerful men. They wanna make an impact". They did make an impact - this match stands below even Gerald Brisco Vs. Pat Patterson at King Of The Ring 2000 as the worst of the Attitude Era.

They seemed to be in a different time zone to their opponents. Clark fell on his a*se when taking a neckbreaker in the precise moment the match fell apart entirely. Proceedings degenerated so irrevocably into farce from there that at one point, commentator Paul Heyman implored Bryan Clark, at the top of his voice, to turn around and get himself into the correct position for Undertaker's chokeslam.

He was acting as Clark's mouthpiece at the time.

This match wasn't fought under Tornado rules, but it would have been an appropriate stipulation; it was a frenzied disaster on an epic scale. 'Taker was furious after the match, as were WWE officials. Adams was sent to developmental territory HWA, while Clark refused - and was promptly given his marching orders.

He didn't know the direction in which to walk out.


7. Al Snow Vs. Big Boss Man - WWF Unforgiven 1999

Kennel From Hell
WWE.com

The Kennel From Hell match, much like the Ambrose Asylum, is unlikely to disgrace a WWE ring ever again.

The build-up to the match was, to its credit, very unique. The duplicitous Boss Man, under the pretence of settling his dispute with Snow, had killed his dog Pepper and fed it to him during a candlelit dinner in a dingy hotel room. This should have raised a red flag or two, but no matter.

You'd think that Snow would be hell-bent on avenging the loss of his murdered dog, but rather than lay into Boss Man from the off, Snow instead scaled the blue barred cage before nonsensically traversing along the upper walls of the surrounding Cell - purely to facilitate a superplex spot. He was made to look like a moron throughout the entire series.

There were, of course, dogs circling the ringside area between the cages. They were meant to threaten the very existence of the two men in the ring, who did little else other than exchange basic punch and kick combinations - but they simply barked at one another (and pissed on the floor) between looking as disinterested as the live crowd.

The match was such a fiasco that even the infamously deluded Vince Russo has accepted the blame for it in later years.


6. Sabu Vs. The Sandman - ECW November To Remember 1997

Sandman Sabu I
WWE Network

"This is going to be a war", promised Joey Styles as Sandman made his inimitable entrance.

Sabu cut this short by nailing him with a plancha, causing his beer to fly over the audience. It was the high point of the match. Sabu was nothing if not inconsistent; his first attempt at his triple jump moonsault saw him smash painfully into the Sandman's knees with his own.

From there, the match, compromised by the bargain bin aesthetic of its cheap-looking, tiny ladders, fell apart even further. Even less money was spent on the tables. Sandman stalled for time in the early going, in setting up Sabu for a table spot, by lightly hitting it with the back of his head. This weak impact was enough to cause the furniture to break.

The next table spot would have been successful - the table didn't break merely by draping Sabu onto it - but Sandman missed him entirely, guillotine legdropping himself through it.

A spot match by definition is almost bereft of psychology - this clunker barely contained any spots, and it dragged for an interminable 20:55. It contained nothing but stalling between spots which were either clumsy or botched entirely.

As disgraceful as Sabu's modern Twitter patter.


5. Sid Vicious Vs. The Nightstalker - WCW Clash Of The Champions XIII

Sid Nightstalker
WWE Network

Sid Vicious, as Shawn Michaels once proclaimed, was "the most expensive piece of luggage in WWF history". Bryan "The Nightstalker" Clark, otherwise known as Adam Bomb, was hardly a technical wizard capable of carrying him.

Accordingly, their match wasn't a scientific mat-based thriller. It would have been unrealistic to expect as much.

It might however have been realistic to expect something beyond tests of strength and bear hugs, which the bout almost exclusively consisted of. Towards the finish, Vicious and the Nightstalker unleashed the full extent of their repertoires, which comprised of punches and claw holds (the latter of which was applied with an almost loving tenderness on Sid's part).

Even a legend as vaunted as Jim Ross couldn't conceal what a disaster the match was, in which only one flat back bump was. As Sid, in a case of turnabout is fair play, used Nightstalker's own weapon against him, the beleaguered Oklahoman could only describe it as "a big, club-like thing".

Naturally, the finish was botched. Big Cat Curtis Hughes attempted to interfere on Nightstalker's behalf, but he completely mistimed his arrival, waiting patiently for Sid to take up his place at the turnbuckle before attempting to attack him.


4. Vampiro Vs. The KISS Demon - WCW Bash At The Beach 2000

Vampiro KISS DEmon
WWE Network

Astonishingly, there was something on the notoriously-awful Bash At The Beach 2000 card just as bad as the main event debacle: Vampiro Vs. Dale "The KISS Demon" Torborg.

With all due respect to KISS, they probably weren't the hippest rock band at the turn of the millennium with which to wage a ratings war against the never-cooler WWF. The KISS Demon was WCW's attempt to cash in on a band that had reached their commercial peak twenty five years prior. Even if he was a marvel between the ropes, Torborg was doomed before he appeared through the curtain.

This match took place, appropriately enough, in a graveyard. It was dead on arrival.

The match - it feels weird even designating it as such - began with the Demon searching for Vampiro with the aid of a fire torch. He looked under the hood of a coffin which, of course, was a diversion. His opponent instead jumped down upon him from a nearby tree. "He's in a tree!" Tony Schiavone confirmed.

"He was in the tree".

Almost mercifully, you could barely determine what's going on. The match was lit only by the referee's torchlight. This, according to Vince Russo, is what fans really wanted to watch, not that boring old 'wrestling' business.

The finishing sequence saw Torborg neck-deep in a nearby lake.

"Is Torborg unconscious in the water? That obviously won't be too good for him", Mark Madden observed.


3. The Ultimate Warrior Vs. Goldust - WWF In Your House: Good Friends, Better Enemies

Warrior Goldust I
WWE.com

Thomas Wolfe once wrote that "You can't go home again". In the case of the Ultimate Warrior, and his 1996 return to the WWF, he was right.

This wasn't so much a match as a bizarre and lazy exhibition of stalling. Warrior, having chased off Goldust (who was apparently too afraid to wrestle), started smoking Marlena's cigar and mugging to the crowd with a strange, wide-eyed expression etched across his face.

Vince McMahon on commentary, famously averse to smoking, seemed as surprised as the ringside audience. He let out a bellow of forced laughter before scrambling desperately to conceal the lack of action. This went on for several agonising minutes. Goldust was forced to improvise for Warrior's galling lack of effort by grabbing a microphone and threatening to kiss every fan in the arena - and he was the guy nursing an injury. Meanwhile, a young fan in attendance held a sign aloft on which 'WARRIOR SMEAR THE QUEER' was emblazoned.

Eventually, Warrior coerced Goldust into retrieving his stolen gown and sitting on Marlena's director's chair - before predictably clotheslining him out of it in the first of three moves in an 07:38 bout.

Warrior then celebrated his countout win atop the turnbuckle with Goldust's wig placed on his head.


2. Viscera Vs. Shelton Benjamin - WWE New Year's Revolution 2006

Shelton Mamma
WWE Network

Viscera as King Mabel was the recipient of possibly the least-deserved push in wrestling history in 1995. Astonishingly, he was still well thought of enough to warrant push after push over a decade later.

Adding to the drudgery, this match took place during Benjamin's brief pairing with his "Momma", a grotesquely racist caricature who absolutely would not shut up at any point. She constantly advised that Viscera "can't move that fast!". She admonished her "son" for not getting up quickly enough. She also reminded Benjamin that she's "right here!" - as if that wasn't excruciatingly obvious.

Content-wise, this was leagues ahead of some of the entries on this list, but Momma Benjamin's encouragement would have ruined Shawn Michaels Vs. Kurt Angle at WrestleMania 21. It was ceaseless.

Not content with grossly approximating a legitimate athletic contest, Viscera also intimated that he'd like to engage in sexual relations with Benjamin's mother in the opening exchanges.

He then carries out the threat at the finish. He violently humps the prone Benjamin, acting as proxy for his Momma, who mercifully interfered to cost Big Vis the match.

On commentary, Jerry Lawler found the whole charade hugely amusing - which said it all.


1. Hunter Hearst Helmsley Vs. Sgt. Slaughter - WWF In Your House: D-Generation X

HHH Slaughter I
WWE Network

The nascent D-Generation X were embroiled in a dispute with then-RAW commissioner Sgt. Slaughter in late 1997, which led to this horrendous "Boot Camp" match.

Slaughter was inactive at this point, for reasons which became painfully apparent almost immediately - as he laid into Helmsley in the corner, the mere act of hitting him with a riding crop was cause enough to slip ingloriously on his a*se.

The rest of his opening shine was conducted at a funereal pace. Slaughter, despite being the man principally in charge of upholding Federation rules, forgot the rules of his own stipulation match in attempting to pin Trips on the outside.

The match's worst crime is that it dragged on for nearly 20 never-ending minutes of plodding inaction. There was barely any sequencing on display; Helmsley and Slaughter instead hit one another with a procession of basic impact moves and outside spots, following which they sold for what seemed like aeons.

Both the sound technician and the timekeeper, evidently as bored as everybody else, didn't even wait for the referee's signal to put an end to the tedium. The DX theme starts up a millisecond before the three count.

Hey, at least Hunter learned when not to go long after all this.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!