10 Best AEW Matches Ever (According To The Internet)

Yes, Hangman Page IS the main character in All Elite Wrestling.

MJF goat
AEW

Is Dave Meltzer too generous with his star ratings in recent times, and does he actually reflect the voice of the wrestling fandom? Do his ratings mean as much as they once did, at a time when a ***** effort actually left a lasting cultural footprint?

These are questions that have polluted social media in recent years. His ratings were always controversial, and this sort of conversation took place on forums years and years before AEW broke everybody's brains - but the discourse is more toxic than ever. Longtime readers of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter will always cherish Dave, earnestly and ironically, because his writing opened a gateway into two worlds: the endlessly fascinating backstage corridors, and the art that exists on the international and independent stages outside of the mainstream product you watched as a child.

On the following evidence, Meltzer is not, in fact, an AEW shill who only goes high with his ratings because he is being paid to do so. That is a deranged, outright brainwashed take and it's genuinely alarming how many people actually believe it.

The curators of Cagematch.net echo his ratings, but within the top 10 matches, there is a distinct lack of potentially impulsive TV match ratings.

So which matches make up the very tippy-top...?

10. Hangman Page Vs. Jon Moxley - Revolution 2023 (9.28/10 Per Cagematch)

Hangman Page Jon Moxley Revolution
AEW

There's nothing better in wrestling than an excellent match studded with great ideas that isn't convoluted or masturbatory, and the Jon Moxley Vs. Hangman Page Texas Death match struck that sweet spot.

It never lost the tone of an ultra-violent war because every plunder spot was arranged in such a subtle, practically hidden way that it felt like they were arrived at organically. The level of thought existed to make it feel like no thought had been put into the match at all, that it was a spontaneous war. In a great spot, Mox grabbed a fork and repeatedly jabbed it into Page's forehead when he had him trapped in a triangle choke. 'Death Jitsu' isn't just a cool-sounding slogan with which to sell t-shirts; in this match, it was an omni-badass genre fusion. The garbage element wasn't artless; Mox located a way to use weapons to compound the damage he was already delivering.

Fate conspired to enhance this feeling when Page took a header into a suspended barbed wire chair, which took a chunk out of his hair.

Deeper in the match, Page was blasted through a barbed wire board suspended across two chairs, and was only able to survive by propping himself up on one of them. Every spot logically informed the next.

Bloodline fans look away: the finish, a lesson on the glorification of violence, was actually a nod to Western cinema!


9. Stadium Stampede - Double Or Nothing 2020 (9.29)

Chris Jericho AEW Double Or Nothing 2020 Stadium Stampede
AEW/Lee South

AEW is still capable of greatness in 2023, but it is difficult to shake the troubling notion that Tony Khan hit his creative peak when nobody was allowed to attend his shows in person.

Khan looked at the bleak, empty space of Daily's Place and used it as blank canvas. He didn't see what wasn't there, but what could be there. The pandemic era was uneven, and even at its very best bittersweet. Only the worst engagement accounts would put over something like the Tooth & Nail match.

But when Tony Khan nailed it, he almost made his product better for the limitations. Consider something like the Parking Lot Fight between the Best Friends and Santana and Ortiz, which somehow isn't included in the Cagematch top 10. Almost every other match in the no fans era was an emulation of what wrestling used to be, even if the emulation was great on its own, bizarre terms. The Parking Lot Fight couldn't have happened at any other time.

AEW's cinematic output was vastly superior to WWE's because the thread of pro wrestling action was never dropped. This was the case throughout the incredibly creative, much-needed levity that was the first Stadium Stampede match.

Consider the awesome sequence between Hangman Page and Jake Hager. An amusing western bar brawl scene, it folded in slapstick elements but was a dynamic mini-match in parallel. Page executing a perfect backflip off the bar - with a very low ceiling - was a massively impressive physical feat, and there was no bullsh*t camera trickery. Even in quasi-canon, with a heavy emphasis on escapist fun, this was still an AEW main event. Page bumped on a shoot pool table to maintain the balls-to-the-wall standard.

A daft odyssey of brutality and entertainment, this was what AEW talked about when they talked about creative freedom.


8. Kenny Omega Vs. Hangman Page - Full Gear 2021 (9.29)

Kenny Omega Hangman Page
AEW

This was the perfect conclusion to the first chapter of Kenny Omega and Hangman Page's AEW story.

It was as good for what it wasn't as much for what it was. It wasn't an hour-long epic that trawled through the entire story told on television. It was the fist-pumping climax of the action movie. It wasn't patronising. Everybody knew what they were getting, and what they wanted, and without undermining the drama, they got it: Omega Vs. Page was lung-bursting fan service in which Page was undeniable. It wouldn't be a surprise, were it to be revealed that the structure of the match was inspired by Randy Savage Vs. Ultimate Warrior from WrestleMania VII. Like Savage, Omega had ran out of road.

Omega was on unreal form, given that he entered the match, his last before a long injury-enforced hiatus, a physical wreck. His springboard power bomb, something he has rarely used, was a crucial beat that underscored that he wasn't entirely out of ideas.

The main thrust of the story told was articulated in a great, great spot that underlined the moment at which both characters had arrived. This was Page's night; Omega had taken so many desperate shortcuts that he'd forgotten who he once was. Omega, drained, tried to treat Page with disdain. He tried, using Toshiaki Kawada's insulting kicks, to make Page feel like he wasn't Elite.

Page roared "Is that all you got, motherf*cker?" in defiance, and proved that he was.


7. Cody Rhodes Vs. Dustin Rhodes - Double Or Nothing 2019 (9.42)

Cody Dustin Rhodes
AEW

The idea that AEW overuses blood is and isn't without merit.

Years after AEW had apparently diluted its effect, a claret-drenched Wheeler YUTA put himself on the map. Dr. Britt Baker created an iconic wrestling image when she pissed blood in her Lights Out match with Thunder Rosa. Ages after he had become a meme, Jon Moxley's blade job in his second match against Konosuke Takeshita, on the December 7, 2022 Rampage, did so much to advance Take's slow-burn breakthrough.

Still, it just doesn't feel the same way as it did when Dustin Rhodes wrestled as if he needed a transfusion during the first-ever Double Or Nothing.

In his match against brother Cody Rhodes, Dustin lost a lot of blood. A lot: the canvas looked like the floor of an abattoir. But, as a master understated craftsman, he worked it like he'd lost far more. In one great spot, one that barely qualifies as a "spot" in the modern sense, Dustin, on the verge of passing out, just lifted his shoulders off the mat, narrowly avoiding getting pinned when trapped in the figure-four. One barely perceptible movement generated a monster of a reaction in the MGM Grand. That was pro wrestling.

Cody played cult leader babyface in his entrance, a condescending heel pr*ck in the body of the match, and left the ring the saviour of wrestling having created an iconic blueprint of what his new company could achieve.

A level of danger, drama and emotion missing from wrestling in decades was conjured across its 22 spellbinding minutes.


6. Hangman Page Vs. Bryan Danielson - AEW Dynamite, January 5, 2022 (9.44)

Bryan Danielson Hangman Page
AEW/Scott Lesh

Spoiler: there is somehow no space on this list - voted for by fans, not your author - for CM Punk. Does this mean that hardcore AEW fans don't appreciate an intricate, understated form of wrestling in which everything matters?

Not necessarily.

Ironically, given that Hangman Page is to Punk's mind an "empty-headed dumb f*cking f*ck", his second match with Bryan Danielson was an absorbing, brilliantly cerebral affair that did not waste a single second. This was refined, masterful wrestling as sport.

Sometimes, in a real sport, effective strategy can undo itself. As an example, consider the gegenpress philosophy in football. Relentless pressure can unsettle the opposition into making errors, but it can also tire out the team applying the tactic. The team can orchestrate their own downfall.

Bryan Danielson did here, which led to an awesome sequence informed by his deep thinking approach. He brutalised Page throughout, using a blunt force strategy after his limb work failed him in their first match. The problem is that Page was soaked with so much of his own blood that Danielson could not apply the LeBell lock. Page slipped out of it, and eventually won, but this was such a thoughtful way of getting over in defeat.

As great as it was, it still wasn't the best match they worked together...


5. The Young Bucks Vs. The Lucha Bros. - AEW All Out 2021 (9.50)

Lucha Bros All Out
AEW

The idea that aerial excitement and storytelling and emotion are mutually exclusive is a pitiful and shallow take, and this stunning Match of the Year proved it. Cagematch has it at 9.50, and rightly so: it was phenomenal.

It stands up as evidence that the Young Bucks are foundational to the success of All Elite Wrestling. On a night when the promotion promised to enter a dream period that was in fact too good to be true, the Young Bucks stole it.

Their match against the Lucha Bros. at All Out 2021 was the in-ring peak of the show. Before the emotional apex was reached, the two teams had a wild time playing with the cool bit of a cage match that is weirdly under-served these days: executing immensely satisfying flailing bumps into the mesh. The failed dives and last minute counters into the walls felt like gratuitous video game violence in the best possible way.

And that emotional apex, Christ.

Both teams cultivated in an incredible, über-rare atmosphere. After Matt Jackson went on a thumbtack sneaker rampage, they made it feel like the Lucha Bros. needed the support of the crowd. The flippy guys told the oldest and best story and updated it to incorporate a demented take on the modern athletic standard. They orchestrated such a level of emotion that the match finish felt like an audible. The image of a blood-soaked Penta, his mask torn, face punctured by tacks, looking vulnerable for possibly the first time in his career, was that powerful.

No audible had been called: the heat segment was simply so excellent that anything but the babyface win would have felt like an injustice.


4. Hangman Page Vs. Bryan Danielson - AEW Dynamite: Winter Is Coming 2021 (9.54)

Bryan Danielson Hangman Page
AEW

Hangman Page's AEW World title reign was a disappointment, sadly.

The idea that the money is all in the chase is bullsh*t - in AEW alone, Jon Moxley and Orange Cassidy's lengthy babyface reigns are among the highlights of a company that has peaked at the all-timer stratosphere - but Page's journey was so compelling that there was a finality to it all when he realised his goal.

It also didn't help that CM Punk was doing the best work of a polarising yet glittering career in his seminal feud with MJF.

The reign wasn't great, but it got off to an incredible start with an ironic shortcut: AEW's decision to immediately cast Page as a World champion in the mould of the territory Iron Man was strong. Page's Winter Is Coming hour-long draw with Bryan Danielson was a classic; Danielson throughout handed Page a lesson in how to be a big match sh*thouse, but spent too long flexing his amazing cardio and working over one too many limbs in order to negate the Buckshot lariat. This accomplished several things:

It strengthened Danielson's sudden heel turn (he had deputised for Jon Moxley). The story of the match - Page barely surviving a lethal if unfocused Danielson - created scope for a rematch. And the first went an hour!

The story, elegantly broken up to peak at various points in order to work within the constraints of commercial breaks, cast Page as an unsolvable puzzle who could not be denied. Danielson working over every part of Hangman's frame also informed every comeback. They effectively created a sense that Page couldn't do anything, so when he did, he generated an eruption of a pop.

Everybody knew Page wasn't losing his first defence. Nobody felt that as the match, brimming with tension, unfolded.


3. Kenny Omega Vs. Bryan Danielson - AEW Dynamite: Grand Slam I (9.57)

Omega Danielson
AEW

Was Tony Khan too cautious to optimise the unbelievable feeling he had generated at All Out 2021?

Probably.

The follow-up Dynamite was notable only for a Jon Moxley Vs. Minoru Suzuki main event, and even if the terrible look of amateur hour timekeeping didn't undermine it, Mox had just wrestled an ostensible exhibition match against another New Japan Da at the pay-per-view. The world did not change as promised.

Khan did bottle the feeling at Grand Slam when promoting the Kenny Omega Vs. Bryan Danielson dream match. "Dream" is the only word that adequately describes the entire presentation: the sight of both men sharing a ring was so surreal, so magic, that Danielson himself burst into a beaming smile.

The match was incredible, elevated by the feeling, but the smile on Bryan's face was replaced over 30 gruelling, best-in-class minutes with something exponentially more unsettling. His selling was expert. Everybody knows of Danielson's concussion history. Danielson knows that you know of it. He manipulated the anxiety in Arthur Ashe to a disturbing extent. If the V-Trigger is the most devastating-looking strike in wrestling, nobody, with the exception of Kazuchika Okada, has sold it as well.

With Danielson being such a master, his selling was subtle, but an impressive stadium-sized crowd registered it. The content and execution was first-rate, obviously. Omega countering the Busaiku knee with a powerbomb looked incredible because it looked, until the last possible moment, that the move was actually going to happen before the counter.

If there's an opposite to the flying nothing, Omega and Danielson devised it.


2. MJF Vs. Bryan Danielson - AEW Revolution 2023 (9.63)

MJF Bryan Danielson
AEW

They said an hour was far too long, that even Bryan Danielson wouldn't be able to pull it off - particularly after the mandatory very long AEW PPV undercard.

Danielson is on everybody's Mount Rushmore, or at least he should be, for a very good reason. Several wrestlers have played the 'Best In The World' gimmick since match quality was emphasised in wrestling's narrative. Danielson's closest in-ring competition, Kenny Omega, nicknamed himself the 'Best Bout Machine'. Chris Jericho and CM Punk have both referred to themselves as the Best In The World, which informed their clash at WrestleMania XXVIII. Shawn Michaels was the Showstopper, Mr. WrestleMania. Austin Aries did this schtick too.

But is there anybody better at actually embodying it in the context of an actual wrestling match - at making it feel like they're so great and dominant that nobody stands a chance against them?

Danielson has done more jobs than any top star ever, but you forget that every time he prowls the ring and paces his matches. His losing feels inconceivable, as it did against MJF. Again: nobody thought prior to the incredible Iron Man match that MJF was losing his first PPV defence.

Everybody, in fact, thought MJF had ran out of road. MJF was on sensational form in the main event, arranging the ringside environment to make it seem as if he were improvising his strategy mid-match, but Danielson's unparalleled ability to portray the very best created an unforgettable brand of drama.


1. Kenny Omega & Hangman Page Vs. The Young Bucks - AEW Revolution 2020 (9.68)

Hangman Page Kenny Omega the Young Bucks
AEW

Dave Meltzer went ****** on this. The users of Cagematch went 9.68.

To many fans, this match is All Elite Wrestling: the very selling point of the promotion, distilled.

It was 30 minutes and five seconds of exhilarating, state of the art action: a relentlessly thrilling vehicle for subtle, layered storytelling that did not require exposition to engage the crowd. Pulsating spectacle and rich emotion were one and the same. It proved correct Cody Rhodes' take that wrestling is capable of accelerating past the basic babyface and heel dynamic. Every wrestler entered the match with a different character motive, all of which were understandable, all of which tore the Elite asunder with incredible action set-pieces.

The match proved that there was a market for a coming of age story about male friendship in the mainstream. It also destroyed the notion that AEW should dumb itself down to cater to a mythical "casual fan". Consider the sequence, inserted into the match as it reached a white-knuckle crescendo, in which Kenny Omega kicked out of the Golden Trigger at one. To fans deep in the weeds of Omega "lore", they grasped the subtext. Omega - and this built his split with Hangman Page in plain sight - showed more emotion towards his former tag partner than his current one. Page using the One-Winged Angel was a heart-wrenching display of support in contrast.

Everybody else just watched an awesome twist, a badass display of defiance. They were not alienated. They got as much out of the match without watching a single episode of Being The Elite.

On this night, AEW embodied itself. It was the best wrestling in the world, and it was for everybody.

For an in-depth, 2000 word match review of this classic, check out my book Becoming All Elite: The Rise of AEW, which is available to purchase on Amazon at this link.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!