10 Best Booking Decisions In Wrestling History
Elite-level booking decisions - starring Steve Austin, Hulk Hogan and more...
Roman Reigns, Tribal Chief, is the biggest star in pro wrestling.
The decision to book him in this heel role wasn't a huge money-drawing decision in the old world sense - WWE is staggeringly financially successful through TV rights fees, which were last negotiated when Reigns was floundering as a babyface - but WWE is nonetheless red-hot with him on top for the first time in years and years. And years.
How much credit do Vince McMahon, Triple H and Paul Heyman truly deserve?
The latter earns more praise than the former, who screwed Roman up so often and for so long that he effectively created his own competition. Everybody else on the planet knew that Roman should have been positioned as a heel by, at the latest, 2015. A great decision-maker is meant to be ahead of their audience. They are meant to a visionary.
Vince saw the vision six full years after everybody else did, including Roman himself, who noped out of WWE and basically said that he was not going back if he was getting covered in dog food. It was a good decision, but "concession" is probably the more accurate word.
What were the best actual booking decisions, ideas, ever...?
10. The Grand AEW Comeback
'December 18' is literally a date that will live in infamy. It is shorthand for "Well, the first competition for nearly two decades was nice while it lasted (eight months)".
It was the Dynamite on which The Dark Order Angle happened, Kenny Omega and Cody Rhodes bumped for "creepers", and Evil Uno drew blood from a rubber johnny in Matt Jackson's mouth in a Bray Wyattpilled angle. Even the good matches on the show, the culmination of a bizarre, weeks-long flirtation with spooky nonsense, were botch-plagued. It was as if the entire promotion was haunted, which was ironic, since the supernatural vibe in the fiction was not remotely effective.
Tony Khan knew of and was hurt by the response, and took a drastic step to resolve the mounting problems: he disbanded the booking committee he had formed with himself and the EVPs, took final cut privileges for himself, and set about restoring the aura of his star babyface unit.
He did so on the incredible January 1, 2020 Dynamite, one of the best editions of the show ever. Easing the anxiety felt by an audience scared that the dream was over, he asked the same question many cynics had posed in an opening video package voiceover:
Are the Elite still Elite?
The answer, revealed throughout the show, was both "yes" and "no".
Cody defeated Darby Allin in a great continuation of their legacy rivalry while Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks defeated the future Death Triangle in a lush illustration of what AEW's heart looks like: pulsating, state-of-the-art Trios action set against the unique, gorgeous backdrop of Daily's Place.
The Elite also wasn't Elite since, in a great cliffhanger, piss-funny boozehound Hangman Page was relegated to commentary. He didn't feel Elite, but his comedic tour de force, in which he finally showed his All In chops on TV, was Elite in the minds of the fans.
AEW in the aftermath of the grand return to form quickly negotiated a rights fee, and never again faced such a position of peril.
9. Hulk Hogan Is The Third Man
For all the chatter of WCW being the most incompetent wrestling promotion of all-time, they at least arrived at one of the most obvious booking decisions ever in a third of the time WWE did.
It took WWE six years to finally accept that the fans weren't fond of Roman's babyface character. They loathed him, in fact.
Six years!
Six!
In that time frame, between 2014 and 2020, two World Cups took place and two European Championships were scheduled to take place, and all the while, Roman won LOL.
In 1994, Hulk Hogan became the cause of and solution to all of WCW's problems. He grew business, setting a PPV record, but the diehards hated him. WCW fans liked pro wrestling. It's strange that they didn't protest and migrate to the WWF, which was more of a territory in 1994 than it ever was, but they wanted a great version of WCW. Hogan prevented that, and they resented him.
That's the narrative, anyway, one that doesn't fully explain why the WCW fans liked the nWo too much - but the decision to turn Hogan in '96 was ingenious. As the leader of the nWo, he made WCW bigger, much bigger, bigger than the WWF for 83 weeks, and unlike Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, he wasn't remotely cool.
He became the literal necessary evil, catalysing the second mainstream boom, and he, again, was at the forefront of it.
8. Shane Douglas Throws Down The Belt
Paul Heyman could not have pinpointed a more ideal time to commit the transgression with which NWA Eastern Championship Wrestling became Extreme Championship Wrestling.
In 1994, infamously, Heyman and founder Tod Gordon convinced Shane Douglas to throw the NWA World Heavyweight title to the ground. Douglas cut a promo claiming that he did not want the rub from an organisation "that died, RIP, seven years ago".
The cartoonish WWF and its desperate sheep, WCW, were out.
Counter-culture was in. A disdain towards traditional values was in. Disillusionment was in. As a result, very quickly, so was ECW and its laser-focused assault on the mood.
The idea in and of itself was tremendous, bold, never done before, a shockwave of an opening statement that instantly cast ECW as a promotion that gave no effs: if they were willing to do that, what were they prepared to let the wrestlers do in the ring?
The timing was the thing. The NWA was dead, but still perceived with a degree of prestige - enough to make the gesture feel profoundly disrespectful, anyway. There was never going to be any pushback; the organisation had been weakened significantly, and they could do sod all about it. No staunch traditionalist fans really existed to thwart the movement.
ECW was set.
7. Strapping Up Hulk Hogan Immediately
What's ironic about one of 2023's most exhausting buzzwords - "adversity" - is that very few tippy-top WWE stars ever faced it. It's a strange Mandela Effect, all this talk of Cody losing at WrestleMania was good, actually.
Steve Austin, John Cena and Batista all won the big one when they were red-hot and when it was time, and they turned out all right. This isn't a response to trolls who don't deserve the oxygen, either. Steve Austin and Mick Foley have echoed Paul Heyman's rhetoric, and they aren't shy about criticising WWE.
It's a lie told to excuse WWE milking the pretentious teat that is the Bloodline cash cow.
Hulk Hogan didn't face adversity, and he had the most longevity of any of the big WWE draws. Vince McMahon Jr. strapped him up within weeks of his return to the WWF, and while a lengthy babyface run was standard operating procedure, and not some bold, maverick move, it was still one of the best booking decisions ever. That, objectively, is the case. Before episodic prime time TV was the dominant revenue stream in wrestling, people wanted to see a live entertainment show, back a winner and a star, and go home happy. Hogan was exactly that. The best ever at it.
And perhaps it was more bold than it would appear through a retrospective lens: Hogan's act while very effective was super cartoonish, far less gritty than the WWWF norm.
Vince was as much a visionary as Hogan was a mega star. Their eventual WrestleMania XIX match did a bad number, but the idea for the story was great. Each man did have a great case for building WWE as we all know it.
6. The WrestleMania 13 Submission Match Finish
It took a while to bloom, the WrestleMania 13 double turn, but the image of a blood-soaked Steve Austin writhing in agony and refusing to quit was vital in connecting him to an audience that, within a year, literally bought into him more than they did Hulk Hogan.
The Bret Hart Vs. Steve Austin Submissions match remains one of the greatest matches ever. It is probably the best display of crowd psychology. With zero exposition and the most subtle of work before the broad, visually iconic finish, Bret showed the audience, without telling them, that Austin was their new guy. The work was practically imperceptible at first. He leathered Austin in the leg with a bit more malice with which he usually worked his opponents over. Over the course of the match, he became increasingly more resentful and nasty.
The audience got it because wrestling fans are not stupid, and they wanted to get it. It was important that the fans were active in this story, as if they had made it happen. Hart takes himself seriously for a reason: the man was a genius.
If it gets old to read about, it certainly doesn't get boring to re-watch: in the throes of pain, blood pissing out of his face, it is impossible to think that wrestling is a work in that moment.
5. The Montreal Screwjob
Vince McMahon could have strapped up Steve Austin in late 1997. Or Ken Shamrock. Bret Hart was willing to do business with the pair of them, and he had plentiful time after Survivor Series to do it.
Vince didn't have to screw Bret Hart and incur the wrath of the locker room by throwing away his longest-standing relationship with a talent beloved by most of "the boys".
He did, listening (separately) to Jim Cornette and Triple H. McMahon, as he so often did, said "F*ck 'em". He knew that the locker room would get over it. He also knew that it wasn't quite Austin's time, and also the value of a transitional champion. (He also really, really liked Shawn Michaels.)
The word "decision" is applied a bit more loosely here. Vince didn't dream up his feud with Steve Austin before he rang for the bell - like the sack of evil, narcisstic trash that he is, he thought he was the babyface - but in binning off Bret, he binned off both a genius and an antiquated approach to his business. Bret was the last, fraying moral fibre, and once that was torn, Vince stormed ahead with the Attitude Era and made more money than ever.
If he didn't know the exact repercussions of the butterfly effect, he knew the direction of the flight and followed it.
4. Turning The Rock Heel Again
In the autumn of 1998, the Rock got white-hot.
It was always going to happen. The rule is that fans don't necessarily like heroes; they go for stars. Rock's patter was incredible, his charisma otherworldly, and while he's in the downfall phase of his career at present, back in "the day", he was on fire. He was the coolest man alive, but in the most ideal selection headache of all time, so was Steve Austin.
Vinces McMahon and Russo arrived at their best ever creative decision at the 1998 Survivor Series, one that accomplished two huge financial coups:
1) The Rock was instantly installed as the biggest heel in the company, allowing the WWF to secure the most buys for any WrestleMania event ever (XV).
2) The glimpse of the Rock as a babyface was so thrilling and so over that McMahon knew it would be as easy as piss to turn him whenever it was convenient.
It felt counterintuitive at the time, but back then, Vince McMahon was adept at playing the long game. He had a monster heel and a megastar babyface on deck. Fans resented the Rock for in effect teasing them, but he was so entertaining as the Corporate Champion that it was as easy for Vince to turn him as it was for him to take something out of his pocket.
3. Giant Baba Calls An Audible
Is Giant Baba the best booker ever?
Think of the long game that the All Japan Pro Wrestling matchmaker played with Kenta Kobashi (an honourable mention in this list).
Kobashi lost his first 63 singles matches to establish him as an underdog who fought with more spirit and displayed more in-ring prowess as those losses became more and more narrow. He then evolved into a Pillar of the organisation, an indefatigable in-ring warrior with whom the fans shared an incredible bond. By the time he had dethroned Ace Mitsuharu Misawa for the top prize in the company, it wasn't even the same company, and Baba had sadly passed away. That is how patient Baba was.
So many other bookers, even those who were great at their peak - Vince McMahon, Bill Watts - favoured a certain story or certain attribute in a wrestler.
Baba, adding to his case as the GOAT, took the exact opposite route with Misawa; on the day of his June 8, 1990 match with top star Jumbo Tsuruta, fans chanted his name outside of the building, hours before showtime, and stampeded the merch table.
In a business and era-defining audible, Baba, usually conservative with his booking, changed the original plan and had Misawa win, effectively creating a boom period overnight.
2. Kazuchika Okada's Shock IWGP Heavyweight Title Win
At Dominion 2023, SANADA narrowly defeated Yota Tsuji, who had just returned, reinvented, from an excursion across Germany, Mexico and the United Kingdom.
It was an excellent match - while it didn't quite approach the peak NJPW standard, the explosive Tsuji wrestled with a boatload of presence - but that's not the point. The point is that a lot of New Japan fans thought that Tsuji could have won the big one in his first "proper" New Japan match - and that's because booker Gedo established that idea 11 full years ago when Kazuchika Okada shockingly defeated Hiroshi Tanahashi at The New Beginning 2012.
The precedent for a Tsuji win happened, to reiterate, 11 years ago.
Indirectly - and this is important, since Gedo doesn't deal in short title reigns more often than not and his booking leans more on the predictable side of things - Gedo has for 11 years cultivated the idea that he always has a shock in him. Every big NJPW match is equipped with that promise, which he has not even remotely bastardised.
The decision to strap up Okada was of course brilliant in and of itself; pre-COVID, Okada, an in-ring master so gifted that he himself is able to sell an upset purely through selling for a few minutes, increased business year-on-year every year.
1. The Ishin Gundan "Invasion"
In 1983, New Japan was in the midst of a red-hot period driven by the ultra-novel Ishin Gundan stable that was a tweak on the original invading forces from the ashes of the International Wrestling Enterprise.
The IWE was a legit group that when defunct "invaded" NJPW. Think ECW's role in the 2001 invasion in terms of disparity between the groups (and in a further parallel, much in the way of garbage wrestling).
Ishin Gundan was something else; a fictional break-away promotion of defectors, the group was a huge success, influencing the programme that influenced the nWo, because leader Riki Choshu was an incredible and charismatic figure: the proto-cool heel. His programme with Tatsumi Fujinami (pictured) generated incredible business, selling out 90% of the company's gates, because it was fresh and compelling in several different ways. Grudge rivalries between native talents were rare, and there was a meta edge to a rivalry premised on jealousy and becoming the new face of the company.
Several promotions use this angle to this day.
The match quality was futuristic and super-heated, too. Everything was white-hot. One of the most influential series ever, it only failed because company founder Antonio Inoki was caught in an embezzlement scandal and Choshu left in disgust (or because he reasoned that Inoki was never going to stop being the focal point of the company no matter how hot his angle was or wasn't).