10 Best Matches In NXT TakeOver History

Spoiled for choice, but which matches made the cut?

Sasha Bayley
WWE.com

NXT’s live specials have had a habit of outshining main roster pay-per-views in recent years. It started with NXT Arrival, a blockbuster night of action highlighted by an epic Sami Zayn vs. Cesaro showdown back in February 2014. NXT’s young stars made WWE’s Elimination Chamber (which took place 4 days prior) look tame by comparison, and the developmental brand has grown exponentially since the live specials adopted the TakeOver monicker that May.

From Sami Zayn and Finn Balor to Sasha Banks and Kevin Owens, NXT has spawned countless future main roster stars, and their TakeOver performances are part of their success. Unhindered by the main roster’s rules and restrictions, NXT’s biggest and brightest rarely fail to deliver, and any credible “Match of the Year” list is peppered with TakeOver clashes.

Last week’s TakeOver: Brooklyn II produced another stunning night of action, and with the likes of Shinsuke Nakamura, Asuka and Bobby Roode leading the Full Sail charge, there’s little sign of slowing down. TakeOver will continue churning-out high-level matches with frightening consistency, even with NXT’s relatively high roster turnover.

In the wake of Brooklyn II, let’s take a look at some of NXT TakeOver’s greatest moments. Here are the 10 best matches in TakeOver history.

10. Finn Balor Vs. Kevin Owens (TakeOver: Brooklyn, 2015)

finn balor kevin owens
WWE.com

NXT has produced some borderline classic events over the past few years, and Brooklyn ranks among the best. An outstanding card from top-to-bottom, it featured one of the best WWE women’s matches in recent memory (we’ll get to that later), and was headlined by this Finn Balor vs. Kevin Owens ladder match.

They initially had a tough time capturing the crowd’s imagination after the women’s match, and while this NXT Title match wasn’t quite on-par with Owens and Balor’s WWE Beast in the East clash, it remains a thrilling match.

Owens had dropped the NXT Championship to Balor one month prior, and Brooklyn was presented as his last shot at regaining it from The Irishman. Ladder matches can be tough psychologically, particularly in one-on-one situations without any other wrestlers to help set the ladder spots up, and Balor and Owens did well to prevent things from descending into a spotfest. The big moments flowed together seamlessly, and Owens was particularly excellent in his domineering bully role, especially when interacting with the crowd.

They won the hot crowd over by the end, and when Finn Balor climbed the ladder to retrieve the belt, it was the last time fans would ever see Owens in NXT. Bigger things awaited KO on the main roster, while Balor was now fully established as NXT’s icon.


9. Sasha Banks Vs. Becky Lynch (TakeOver: Unstoppable, 2015)

Sasha Banks Becky Lynch NXT TakeOver
WWE.com

Sasha Banks and Bayley might have the more storied NXT rivalry, but it’s impossible to overlook the quality of The Boss’ May 2015 clash with Becky Lynch. NXT’s Four Horsewomen (rounded-off by Charlotte) have produced some of NXT’s finest matches, and this ranks near the top.

This was Becky Lynch’s coming-out party. She’d spent months playing the role of Sasha’s sidekick, but finally grew tired of standing outside The Boss’ spotlight in the lead-up to the event. At Unstoppable, Lynch was out to prove a point to her former ally, and she fought with a passion and vigour fans hadn't yet seen from her. Becky emerged from this match as a knock-down in ring performer, a flawless technician, and a surprising powerhouse.

It was Sasha who walked away with the victory, though. After a long period of arm work from both competitors, Sasha caught her opponent in the Banks Statement for the tap-out, and a successful title defence. It was the match of the night, a MOTY candidate, and a spectacular display of both wrestlers’ abilities.

Becky lost, but she looked every bit like a superstar in the making. She continued selling the agony of defeat long after Banks had disappeared to the backstage area, and walked-out of Full Sail University with a won-over crowd singing along to her entrance music. A true star-making performance.


8. Neville Vs. Finn Balor (Takeover: Rival, 2015)

Neville Finn Balor NXT TakeOver
WWE.com

Finn Balor’s ascent through the main roster ranks has been swift, but his early rise through NXT was just as impressive. Debuting alongside Hideo Itami in late 2014, Balor found himself involved in a number one contender’s tournament in January 2015. Defeating Curtis Axel in the first round and Itami in the second, Balor met (Adrian) Neville in TakeOver: Rival’s tournament final, and what a match it was.

Balor couldn’t have faced tougher opposition. Neville was a former NXT Champion, and his spell at Full Sail University had marked him as one of the world’s finest professional wrestlers. They hit the ring to produce a smooth back-and-forth affair that wasn’t particularly long, but left the fans delighted.

One of the match’s key highlights was Neville harking back to the low-key heel role he’d played during his feud with Sami Zayn. Neville spent large chunks of the match almost running away from Balor’s offensive, but won the crowd back with his typically stunning high-flying offense and stiff striking. It’s a shame Neville hasn’t been afforded such opportunities on the main roster, because he remains one of WWE’s most exhilarating performers.

The match saw Neville’s offensive domination build down the stretch, only for Balor to kick-out of everything that was thrown at him. In the end, Balor got his knees-up on Neville's Red Arrow, before working towards his own top rope finisher, the Coup de Grace, and securing contendership.


7. The Revival Vs. American Alpha (TakeOver: The End, 2016)

american alpha the revival
WWE Network

How do you pick The Revival’s best match? It’s a tough task. Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder have been a revelation in NXT’s tag division, and after years of struggling to separate themselves from the pack, they’ve built a reputation as two of WWE’s most reliable performers. Eschewing flips and flashiness for old-fashioned brawling and tag psychology, they’re a joy to watch, and their series with American Alpha nothing short of fantastic.

Chad Gable and Jason Jordan are a great unit brimming with chemistry themselves, and whenever they stepped into the ring with The Revival, magic happened. Their first clash at TakeOver: Dallas was outstanding, but The End took things up a notch.

For four relatively unknown wrestlers operating in a developmental brand, this match was stunningly good. From counters and hot tags to strikes and submissions, this match had it all. The nearfalls were particularly out of control, and the quartet built towards a stunningly dramatic conclusion that saw The Revival walk away with the win, and the NXT Tag Team Titles around their waists.

It lacked some of Dallas’ livewire crowd reactions, but it’s hard to take away from this match. American Alpha have outstanding chemistry with The Revival, so here’s hoping the two teams clash again whenever Dash and Dawson make it to the main roster.


6. Neville Vs. Sami Zayn Vs. Tyler Breeze Vs. Tyson Kidd (TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way, 2014)

NXT TakeOver Fatal 4-Way
WWE.com

NXT’s main event scene has been littered with outrageously good wrestlers for a while now, and while it’s hard to take away from Shinsuke Nakamura and Samoa Joe, 2014 might’ve been a peak year in this regard. TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way, funnily enough, saw NXT’s top four stars collide in a breathless contest for the NXT Title, and it was one of the year’s very best matches.

Tyson Kidd was the main roster cast-off who’d finally been given an opportunity to utilise his fantastic range of abilities and surprising charisma in NXT. Tyler Breeze was probably the most basic worker of the four, but an outstanding heel, and one of the brand’s most marketable acts. Sami Zayn and Neville, meanwhile, had already become two of WWE’s most respected performers, with Neville playing the dominant champion, and Sami the loveable underdog.

Some still refer to this as NXT’s best ever match, but it has stern competition for that mantel. That’s not to take away from the clash, however: it was perfectly chaotic, and the four participants did a masterful job in not letting it descend to a sloppy mess. Laced with four distinct narratives (Kidd’s in-ring dominance, Breeze’s opportunism, Zayn’s “so close, but so far” tale, and Neville repeatedly getting knocked out of the ring), it told a great story, and goes down as one of WWE’s best ever four-way matches.


5. Bayley Vs. Sasha Banks (TakeOver: Respect, 2015)

Triple H Bayley NXT TakeOver Respect
WWE.com

NXT’s Four Horsewomen left behind a legacy of excellence that will be tough for current champion Asuka to follow. That’s not taking anything away from The Empress of Tomorrow, who continues to prove her value with her own outstanding performances, but NXT’s Horsewomen helped kick-off WWE’s “Divas Revolution” before the term had even been coined. This was Bayley and Sasha’s second big-time TakeOver showdown, and it delivered on every conceivable level.

Bayley had wrested the Women’s Championship from Sasha’s clutches a few months prior in Brooklyn, and at TakeOver: Respect, NXT’s top two women headlined as the night’s main eventers. The 30-minute Iron Woman match saw the duo wrestle to a 2-2 stalemate just 17 minutes in, and with 13 left on the clock, there was still everything to play for.

The final act came just three seconds prior to the 30-minute mark. In one final act of desperation, Bayley synched Sasha into a modified Rings of Saturn submission, and as she pulled harder and harder, The Boss had no choice but to tap. Triple H, William Regal, and the NXT roster appeared on the ramp to applaud their efforts, and while the match didn’t quite live-up to the standards set in Brooklyn, it was a performance worthy of closing any big wrestling show.

A huge moment for women’s wrestling in WWE and one of the most emotional matches in TakeOver history, Bayley vs. Banks II is worth 30 minutes of anyone’s time.


4. The Revival Vs. Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa (TakeOver: Brooklyn II, 2016)

Tomasso Ciampa The Revival
WWE.com

Now firmly established as one of the best tag teams in the world, two-time tag champions The Revival took-on their latest challengers Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa at TakeOver: Brooklyn II. While the show didn’t quite deliver on its early “Show of the Year” potential, that was through no fault of the tag teams, who spared no effort to produce a stunning clash that’ll feature prominently on countless end-of-year ballots.

The Revival hit a new level in this one. Their cut-offs, strategies, and increasingly creative shortcuts continue to make them one of the sport’s most exciting acts, despite their straightforward, bruising style. There’s a strong Arn Anderson/Tully Blanchard vibe about them that just can’t be ignored, and this was them at their virtuoso best.

Gargano and Ciampa were on-fire, too. The duo have outstanding chemistry, and while both are already certified indy darlings, it’s their differing roles that set them apart. Gargano is the undersized and affable underdog who excels at getting the crowd on his side and taking heat, while Ciampa is a ruthless, fired-up berserker who wrestles with the conviction of a dozen men. Both fought to their peak of their abilities, and the near-falls that peppered the match’s final act were nothing short of heart-stopping.

The match ended with Gargano tapping following a brutal leg-work sequence, and the post-match left NXT fans with their hearts in their mouths. The portrayal of Ciampa’s frustration coupled with Gargano’s disappointment was as masterful an acting performance as you’ll ever see from two wrestlers, and if WWE do pull the trigger on their teased split, the ensuing feud is going to be electric.


3. Sami Zayn Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura (TakeOver: Dallas, 2016)

nakamura zayn
WWE.com

Shinsuke Nakamura’s WWE signing left the wrestling world in shock. He’d been one of NJPW’s standout performers for years, and had built a reputation as one of the sport’s absolute best all-round stars. Though he has the skills and charisma to succeed anywhere on the planet, it was a jolt to see him depart his long-time home for pastures new, but his TakeOver: Dallas debut was an absolute barnstormer.

Sami Zayn was on his way out of NXT at this point. He’d been unsuccessful in his post-injury attempts at recapturing the NXT Championship, and General Manager William Regal saw fit to reward him one last big match. Nakamura was the opponent, and the two put-on a wrestling clinic the night before WrestleMania 32.

Nakamura was an immediate star. His awe-inspiring ring entrance, trademark gesticulations, and hard-hitting style saw him win the crowd over immediately, and he couldn’t put a foot wrong against the face of NXT. He and Zayn engaged in a brutal, fast-flowing Japanese-style match that saw Zayn harness some of Nakamura’s own strong style influences, and as the “fight forever” chants broke-out, Dallas was enthralled.

Nakamura took the victory, but Zayn had ended his NXT stint on a high note and he walked-out from developmental as one of the most important wrestlers in the brand’s history. For Nakamura, it was the first stop on the road to NXT Championship glory, and proof that he was born to become a major WWE star.


2. Sasha Banks Vs. Bayley (TakeOver: Brooklyn, 2015)

sasha banks bayley
WWE.com

Bayley and Sasha Banks’ reputations as two of the finest female wrestlers on the planet was already established by this point, but TakeOver: Brooklyn really pushed them over the edge. This was the night they became bona fide superstars and standard-bearers for women’s wrestling across the globe.

It’s hard to think of a better women’s match in WWE history. Bayley and Sasha gave a near-flawless performance in Brooklyn, and while they didn’t headline the card, they produced a match that the night’s main eventers (Kevin Owens and Finn Balor) just couldn’t better.

This was the peak of Banks’ heel act. While Bayley had emerged with boundless joy and enthusiasm, Banks took her sweet time in getting to the ring, basking in her own sense of royalty and self-importance. The psychology was fantastic from the start, with Sasha not worried about Bayley, but Bayley very much worried about Sasha. The challenger stepped-up and tried to prove her newfound confidence to The Boss, but Sasha slapped her down at every juncture until the match’s end.

Banks started working on Bayley’s already-injured hand, and the match hit fever pitch. In the end, Bayley drilled Sasha with a stunning top rope Rana before finishing her off with the Bayley-to-Belly, and that was that. Her underdog story was complete, she was the NXT Women’s Champion, and she and Sasha had produced one of the greatest WWE matches of the past decade.


1. Neville Vs. Sami Zayn (TakeOver: R Evolution, 2014)

Sami Zayn TakeOver R Evolution
WWE Network

There’s only one match that can conceivably better Sasha and Bayley’s stunning performance in Brooklyn, and it’s right here. Sami Zayn and Neville’s NXT Title clash in December 2014 remains the peak of WWE developmental, and a perfect storm of story, psychology, and pure athletic ability.

Sami’s underdog story had been a constant throughout 2014. Always the bridesmaid and never the bride, Zayn had come agonisingly close to becoming NXT Champion on a number of occasions, but could never quite get the job done. At TakeOver: R Evolution, he finally shook the monkey from his back.

With Zayn as the more natural babyface, Neville switched to a tweener role prior to and throughout the match. The story was clear: Neville was the dominant champion, and his friend Sami was the also-ran. Neville wasn’t shy in criticising his challenger’s inability to win the big one, and continually derided him for not willing to do whatever it took to win, even if it meant getting his hands dirty.

The story was perfect, and the match was off the charts. Zayn showed unbelievable babyface fire throughout, and while they continually teased that Sami’s compassion would once again cost him, he sealed the win with two Helluva Kicks. The NXT roster swarmed the ring to celebrate Sami’s big moment with him, but as one door closed, another opened. Kevin Owens viciously destroyed Zayn in the aftermath to start the latest chapter of their long-running personal rivalry: a flawless aftermath for a flawless match.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.