10 Best NXT Matches Of 2019 (So Far)

Young King Cole.

NXT TakeOver NY 095
WWE

A foreword on this list - 2019's half-way point provides opportune time for reflection on action thus far, but it's eminently possible that many of the matches here could appear in the December end-of-year edition.

NXT, for all the potential pitfalls, remains a glorious gift to the fanbase at large.

The weekly television product, subjectively, hasn't ever really recovered from the bleak reality of the future all the hopefuls theoretically aspire towards. A 2014-2016 golden era was underpinned by a collective drive for all the "developmental" prospects to make it to the main roster, back when the supposed grander stage had greater prestige than Full Sail or a blacklit TakeOver special. Back before an inconvenient truth was the devastating norm.

With Superstars suffering their sophomore slump at the hands of main roster writers rather than those in Orlando, Florida, NXT has instead become the place to enjoy the characters you love, and pray to a deity of your choosing that they never f*cking leave. It's an odd setup, admittedly, but one that helped usher in the balls-to-the-wall match quality that's elevated the specials (if not the show overall) into rarified air.

A card once extremely hard just to get on to became just about impossible unless you could promise to blow the roof off. It's why the TakeOver brand is so sacred, and why almost every match on this list comes from one of the year's editions.

Almost...

10. Adam Cole Vs Aleister Black Vs Matt Riddle Vs Ricochet Vs Velveteen Dream (NXT TV Mar. 20, 2019)

Adam Cole Ricochet Matt Riddle
WWE

A spit-take showcase that brought out the very best of the five best of the rest on the NXT roster, this five-way battle repeatedly faced the risk of falling off a spotfest cliff until it became apparent how just willing the combatants were to dive from the height for the most magnificent outcome.

So often reduced to turn-taking, WWE and NXT multi-mans don't always deliver on the promise of the thrilling match graphics that come before them. Insular, singular story replace the creativity required to craft spots involving more than two wrestlers, whilst those selling on the floor look like caterpillars bored of waiting to become butterflies.

This, with a huge, huge spot on the line, was none of those things.

Ricochet was given one of his last opportunities to flex his alien athleticism on the developmental brand before his permanent main roster move. Aleister Black, too, was a man unburdened by the sort of scripting that has left him defeated by a door on SmackDown Live. Matt Riddle, as good a loser as he is a winner, appeared at times impervious to the multitude of blockbuster assaults, all while the 23-year-old Velveteen Dream was simply too young for this sh*t.

Like much of this list, the biggest moment of the match belonged to Adam Cole, and it came with his crucial killshot. Working just as hard but twice as smart, Cole replaced guts with brains to jump the queue, leaping from from the TakeOver outhouse to the NXT penthouse with one winning Last Shot.


9. Shayna Baszler Vs Bianca Belair (TakeOver: Phoenix)

shayna baszler bianca belair
WWE.com

Shayna Baszler's TakeOver matches are entirely at odds with virtually everything else on the celebrated cards for how one-sided she promises they'll be. Surrounded by battles rich in spirit and competitive fire, Baszler's modus operandi is always to stub out the flame of her opponents before they even have the chance to engulf her. At January's Phoenix supercard, she was forced to engage in some stature-enhancing sh*thousery to extinguish Bianca Belair's unbeaten streak.

'The EST Of NXT' refused to comply to Baszler's destructive dominance early on, reframing her arrogance as bravery and her inexperience as an iron will. Rattled, 'The Queen Of Spades' resorted to the sort of shortcuts her character refused to acknowledge because of the weakness they reflected - panic, concern, consternation, fear.

Brilliantly, the chaos caused by Four Horsewomen sh*t-disturbers Marina Shafir and Jessamyn Duke didn't phase Belair, but the loss of match structure late on did. The Challenger had gleefully leapt over top of the banana skins, only to slip on the biggest one she'd tried to hide - her own unpreparedness.

It was only in that moment of weakness that Baszler - given split seconds to refocus - could lock on her Kirifuda Clutch and claim the contest as another trophy. The relief in her eyes was apparent despite yet another crucial element that kept her atop the her opponent - the ability to mask the fright.


8. Velveteen Dream Vs Matt Riddle (TakeOver: New York)

Velveteen Dream Matt Riddle NXT TakeOver New York
WWE

A thrilling clash of styles underpinned by underrated character work from two men that are advanced beyond any reasoned expectations, the North American Championship match between Matt Riddle and Velveteen Dream very fittingly cast two of the best relative newcomers as the chief candidates to battle for NXT's secondary strap.

Equal parts fun and functionally hard as all f*ck, Riddle's initial confidence was suddenly cast asunder by Dream's charismatic cockiness. More go than "Bro", he dug deep into his MMA arsenal to overawe the young Champion, forcing him to either find the escape or fight for it. Dream, legitimising his histrionics, managed both.

Triggering scowls and scorn from the typically-tepid Challenger, he refused to stay down when others with his arrogance would have bottled the big moments. Relighting the babyface fire he'd summoned for a tantalising near-miss against Tommaso Ciampa months earlier, Dream's age could no longer be betrayed by his overwhelming pizzazz, instead driving his desire to remain atop the mountain. Wide-eyed and wild, his fight was imbued by a Brooklyn crowd split before Riddle's wicked character work shunted them over to his opponent's side.

The finish - a wrapped roll-up cribbed from two genius Bret Hart finishes two decades prior - completed the in-match reframing of the real-life wrestler lurking beneath the Dream.


7. Matt Riddle Vs Roderick Strong (TakeOver: XXV)

Roderick Strong Matt Riddle NXT TakeOver XXV
WWE

An entirely different offering from the 'Original Bro' than his heelish (and ultimately unsuccessful) deconstruction of The Velveteen Dream, Matt Riddle was back to boy-popping form in the early stages of his TakeOver: XXV opener with Roderick Strong before The Undisputed Era forced out his wilder side with his relentless back-based battering.

Riddle is such a unique character at present - able to ostensibly care little for the challenge ahead, he's nonetheless armed with enough of an arsenal to completely crush most of the competition if he wants. For the first time since debuting in NXT in 2018, he was forced into fighting rather than doing it mostly for fun. Assaulted clean out of his bloodied slides by Strong to set up the match, Riddle had revenge on his mind and took it by outmuscling his opponent in a total sh*tkicker of a clash.

Strong's stable had a busy night ahead of them as he opened the celebratory NXT special in a less-than-jovial mood, but couldn't see through his attempts to go it alone when the odds were even. A proving ground in kayfabe for Riddle whilst enhancing Strong's reputation outside of the result, the innocuous opener would have stolen any other show. It was only due to TakeOver's remarkable quality bar that it was topped just one match later...


6. Street Profits Vs Oney Lorcan & Danny Burch Vs The Undisputed Era Vs The Forgotten Sons (TakeOver: XXV)

Street Profits NXT TakeOverXXV
WWE

A jaw-dropping throwback to NXT's time as an over-achieving developmental brand on a night that toasted its rich past, the mindblowing ladder war for the company's vacant doubles straps was far more than the exceptional carry-job it may have first appeared.

A stunt show with a story, the clash rivaled the seminal North American Title match despite the inexperience of some of the competitors. Pushing them without pushing them to the point of over-exposure, it was precision-engineered with Street Profits' glorious win clearly in mind the entire time. This book-from-the-finish-backwards logistics management has driven some to accuse NXT of feeling a little to clinical, but it's for these younger performers when the guidance can be utter gold.

The Undisputed Era's Kyle O'Reilly did the structural heavy-lifting, threading many of the moments together by giving his back to the brawl with some hellacious bumps. Elsewhere, The Forgotten Sons were given focus to remember for a change, whilst eventual winners Angelo Dawkins and Montez Ford became the defacto underdog babyfaces ahead of an utterly gripping conclusion.


5. Ricochet Vs Johnny Gargano (TakeOver: Phoenix)

Ricochet Johnny Gargano
WWE.com

Johnny Gargano felt unconvincing and unexceptional as he walked through how he'd orchestrated an attack on Aleister Black as part of his descent into darkness. The company's most reliable babyface had been teased towards total heeldom by virtue of his out-of-control feud with Tommaso Ciampa, we were told, but he was the only one that appeared unaware of it all despite his nascent new relationship with "the dark".

It appeared as if, in kayfabe and reality, the best thing about NXT had dissolved into dust.

A TakeOver: Phoenix win over Ricochet instead informed an entirely new appraisal. 'Johnny TakeOver', with the name literally splashed across his tights, delivered a performance worthy of the moniker in substance, style and subtlety.

The heat they bottled late on felt as impossible as one of Ricochet's incredible high spots. Gargano, even the snide, conflicted Gargano, had the heart and guile that had brought him close-but-not-close-enough to career redemption. The willingness to embrace a certain, understated cruelty elevated the match and his performance into something far greater.

Resorting to the concrete floor as he had done in his blood feud with Ciampa, Gargano initially batted back his tortured soul, but was nearly punished for his hesitation with a Ricochet roll-up. After regaining control, a brainbuster on the exposed ringside area revealed the contents of his newly-warped perspective.

Gargano took an almighty intake of breath from the Phoenix fanbase in shocked celebration not only of his win, but of the lengths (and depths) he'd gone to to achieve it. It proved only the penultimate chapter of a remarkable personal tale.


4. Tommaso Ciampa, Adam Cole & Johnny Gargano Vs Ricochet, Aleister Black & Velveteen Dream (Halftime Heat)

Halftime Heat
WWE

A cocaine classic that served to entertain both a cast of colleagues at the Performance Center and potentially half of the western world flicking over during the SuperBowl, Halftime Heat's return to television after a 19-year-absence reimagined the concept as a firepowered exhibition rather than an empty ratings grab.

On commentary, Shawn Michaels paid the six the ultimate compliment in expressing his fear at being trapped in the middle of a match worked at such a frenetic and furious pace. Unashamedly spotty, neither fan nor wrestler was given the opportunity to take a breath as the brand's top tier smashed f*ck out of one another with reckless abandon.

For five of the six, it carried echoes of their high-octane indie existence prior to signing on with WWE, but NXT homegrown star Velveteen Dream served as the reminder that the entire presentation was a reimagining of all their collective pasts into one dynamic new presence. Long elevated to this elite level, this was yet another showcase for those that may (inexplicably) still not be watching weekly, or at least for every TakeOver.


3. The War Raiders Vs Ricochet & Aleister Black (NXT TakeOver: New York)

War Raiders Aleister Black Ricochet NXT TakeOver New York 2
WWE Network

A NXT farewell match to all four rather than simply the departing challengers following the surprise call-up (and less-than-surprising rebrand) of The War Raider, a thrilling Tag Title tussle earned added heft within weeks thanks to the systemic main roster ruination of the four.

Hanson and Rowe's tear through the developmental doubles division had served them well because of the heels they deemed worthy of decimation, but the thread of competitive respect between the two sides here was uniquely established by not delivering big hitters early doors rather than lobbing the biggest bombs. A Black Mass stopped just short of taking Rowe's head off in the opening minutes, seconds after Rowe had pulled a powerful punch.

By doing nothing, the wrestlers had created a thirst inside the Barclays Centre for everything. Astonishingly, it was quenched by the gripping conclusion. Meeting Ricochet's skillset, The War Raiders showed superhuman aerial flare. 'The One & Only' responded by deadlifting the heavyweights in his own alien feat of strength. Black, long before he was left to stare at a door, stared down the barrel of a beating fought back like an alternate timeline John Cena - coloured by the ink and armour of his body rather than luminous merchandise and on-the-nose expression.

It approached genuine beauty. It achieved it by becoming broken so soon after.


2. Johnny Gargano Vs Adam Cole (TakeOver: XXV)

Johnny Gargano Adam Cole NXT TakeOver XXV
WWE

Building on an amazing, amazing New York NXT Championship battle (more on that later), Johnny Gargano and Adam Cole went into TakeOver: XXV armed with one more weapon than their first match, but a potent weight of expectation that could well have blown up in their face instead.

Now rivals rather than opponents, Champion Gargano and Challenger Cole had lived a Rocky III in the build-up as the detailed developmental booking carefully crafted them as passing ships. 'Johnny Champion's course was plotted through high schools and family reunions with his new belt and sense of restored pride. The defeated Undisputed Era leader sharped himself to a savage, bloodying point on the Largo loop, biding his time for his second crack at the strap.

After everything they'd given from themselves to the first war, it was a remarkable feat to very nearly top it in such energetic fashion. Drawing from very little about the first match, they instead performed the ultra-versions of their Brooklyn selves. Cole's prevailance, sans Undisputed Era assistance, was crucial to the genetic make-up of the match - he was still a piece of sh*t, but on this night he found a way to be better than the best. His ascension was overdue, but the eventual rise was worth the wait.


1. Johnny Gargano Vs Adam Cole (TakeOver: New York)

Cole Gargano
WWE.com

The NXT Championship was vacant before Adam Cole and Johnny Gargano went to war, but both men crafted a contest so obscenely fulfilling that it was as if they were both trying to keep it, rather than claim it.

From a three year build to a three week one, Gargano's preparation for TakeOver: New York changed dramatically when Tommaso Ciampa's injury dropped a bomb on their planned end-of-the-world main event. Cole's insertion then threatened to make the task even harder - the 'Panama City Playboy' brought with him a cool factor beyond 'Johnny Wrestling's wildest dreams that made him the overwhelming babyface as the contest commenced.

Just 38:25 later, and Brooklyn's Barclays Center capacity crowd had collectively been reduced to a quivering emotional wreck for the good of his cause.

Rich - stinkingly rich - in high quality physicality, the sheer gall of the two to gamble their entire past, present and future repertoire in the knowledge that they'd have to go again was brave in and of itself. Calling back and flashing forward, the pair left nothing out, receiving everything from the impassioned 15,697 fortunate enough to be part of it.

The two-out-of-three falls rule has been a protected entity on the black-and-gold brand, and it was here preserved in amber as a stipulation beyond any hyperbole WWE ordinarily weld on to their biggest and best matches. It outstripped everything else on the busiest wrestling weekend of the year. It toppled the year's best ultra-hot New Japan Pro Wrestling finishing sequences, celebrated for their next-level drama and pacing. It gave the following Sunday's WrestleMania an impossible task of topping it.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.