10 Best Second Runs In WWE History

If at first you don't succeed, try, try again... although work the indies first.

Shawn Michaels is sad
WWE

They say you only get one chance at a first impression, but that doesn't mean that second chances aren't important too.

Whilst wrestling history is full of performers who nailed it first time, there are are plenty of examples of wrestlers who took multiple tries to reach the top.

Whether they were released unceremoniously, fired for wrongdoing, or just needed some time to sort their lives out, the following ten wrestlers all left WWE at one point, only to be brought back and excel.

We've ranked this list based not only on the success of these wrestler's second runs but also how they stack up against their first. If a wrestler won championships and had stellar matches in their second run, but also did the same in their first, then they'll be lower down the list that somebody who flopped first time around and soared on the second.

So, with many former stars returning under the Triple H era, let's find out whose example they should follow to ensure a successful second go around in the WWE.

10. Brock Lesnar (2012 - Present)

Brock Lesnar John Cena
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar's first WWE run was one of the most unique and controversial in all of wrestling history.

Debuting the night after WrestleMania X-8, Lesnar was pushed to the top of the card at light speed, securing a Royal Rumble win, a WrestleMania main event, and the WWE Title all within his first year.

Then, just one year later, he was gone. Lesnar had grown tired of the WWE lifestyle and he left after WrestleMania XX, leaving a huge Beast-shaped hole in the company.

After a career that took him to NJPW, the NFL, and the UFC, the Beast Incarnate eventually returned to WWE a full decade after his debut. What followed was yet another controversial run, which saw him hold the company's top prize hostage multiple times and become one of the most divisive figures the industry has ever known.

Still, there's no denying the success that Brock has had since his return. He's won far more titles, had far more big matches, and made a boatload more money than he did in his first run and, for that reason, he deserves a spot on this list. No matter how much you may hate Suplex City.


9. Ric Flair (2001 - 2008)

Ric Flair Vince Mcmahon
WWE.com

Much like Brock, Ric Flair's first WWE run was also a massive success. The Nature Boy won the WWF title twice between 1991 and 1993 and his win in the 1992 Royal Rumble is now the stuff of legend.

However, Flair was only in the company for just over a year before he returned to WCW for the better part of a decade. After that company folded, the winners of the Monday Night War were keen to bring the Nature Boy back in.

Ric made his return in grand fashion, revealing himself as the WWF's new co-owner in ear-pulling fashion. Flair would follow this up with a string of good matches, his time in Evolution, and would eventually retire in dramatic fashion against Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania.

And he never wrestled again...

Though he never reclaimed the World Title, Flair arguably had a greater quantity of memorable moments during his second period working for Vince. Despite being beyond his physical prime, Naitch proved in this run that he was still as entertaining as ever and that he could still go in the ring if he had to, despite his advanced age.


8. William Regal (2000 - 2013)

William Regal NXT
WWE

This one might be cheating a little considering that Regal lasted less than a year in his first WWE stint. To give him credit, he was suffering from serious addiction issues that saw him enter rehab.

Upon his return to The Federation in 2000, the former WCW man soon found his niche as a nasty, but wickedly funny heel. Whether as European Champion, Commissioner, or King of the Ring, Regal excelled in every role he was given and became a firm, if underrated WWE favourite.

But it was Regal's work in NXT that really puts this run on a pedestal. The Blackpool native was instrumental in the success of the Black and Gold brand, both as an on-screen General Manager and as a behind-the-scenes scout and trainer. He helped put on some of the best wrestling in the world in the mid-to-late 2010s, before being unceremoniously released by WWE in 2022.

Whilst anything would have been better than his first run, considering the state Regal was in when he was first let go, let's just be grateful we got a second run at all, let alone one that would change wrestling forever.


7. Goldberg (2016 - Present)

Goldberg WWE SmackDown
WWE.com

Another performer who lasted just one year in his first WWE run, Goldberg entered McMahon-land as one of the hottest unsigned former WCW stars.

Despite a strong start, Goldberg soon went from one flop after another, culminating in a disastrous final match with Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania XX. After that, Bill would be gone from the company for over 12 years.

Things changed at Survivor Series 2016 when Goldberg squared off against Lesnar once again. 86 seconds later and Big Bill had scored the win in an upset that was as shocking as it was thrilling.

What has followed for Da Man has been a string of big matches, big victories, and World Championship reigns. Whilst his second WWE run hasn't been perfect - his Saudi Arabia appearances alone have been enough to turn some fans against him forever - it's impossible to argue that Goldberg hasn't made far more of an impression on the world of wrestling in this run than he did in his previous one.

And hey, this run is still ongoing, so there's still plenty of time for Bill to move up a few more places on this list... or, alternatively, plummet a few places down...


6. Bobby Lashley (2018 - Present)

Bobby Lashley WWE Champion
WWE

When Bobby Lashley first debuted on SmackDown in 2005, you can basically hear Vince McMahon drooling backstage. He was young, athletic, strong, and came with a string of amateur wrestling achievements as big as his biceps.

Whilst Lashley had some memorable moments over the next three years - an ECW Championship reign, a feud with Vince McMahon, The Battle of the Billionaires, etc. - he never quite reached the levels that many hoped he would and was released from the company in 2008.

Over the next decade, Lashley finally began living up to his potential. He made waves in the worlds of MMA, and in the world of pro wrestling he dominated TNA/Impact Wrestling as a four-time World Champion.

Vince's drool was once again audible on the Raw after WrestleMania 34 when Lashley made his WWE return. Over the next four years, Lashley formed the incredibly popular Hurt Business and, on an episode of Raw in March 2021, he finally reached the mountain top by submitting The Miz for the WWE Championship.

It may have taken a little longer than expected, but the All Mighty has finally cemented himself as a main event player in WWE and he continues to put on great performances to this day.


5. Jeff Hardy (2006 - 2009)

Jeff Hardy World Heavyweight Champion
WWE.com

Jeff Hardy's career has been dogged with controversy for decades, but its important to remember that, at one point, he was one of the most popular babyfaces in the world.

This would never have happened had Jeff not left the WWE in 2003 and eventually wound up in TNA. He had been a singles guy in the last couple of years of his first WWE run, but he was pushed as a top guy for the first time in TNA, challenging for the World Title on numerous occasions and having high profile feuds with likes of Abyss, Rhino, and Sabu.

All this paved the way for Jeff's return to WWE in 2006 and a run that would see him finally ascend to the upper echelons of the company. He won three World Championships during this time and participated in some truly epic matches, not least his legendary feud with CM Punk.

From 1998 to 2003, Jeff was one of the most popular tag team and midcard wrestlers in WWE. However, when he returned to the company after his time in TNA, he was a bona fide main eventer and hasn't been seen as anything less ever since.


4. Daniel Bryan (2010 - 2021)

Daniel Bryan WrestleMania XXX
WWE.com

To call the current Bryan Danielson's time with the Nexus a "run" is a bit cheeky, considering that he got fired after his first televised main roster appearance with them.

This happened because Bryan choked out ring announcer Justin Roberts with his own tie; a cool spot, but one that was deemed too violent for WWE and their sponsors. So, Bryan was let go.

He made his return to the indies, tangling with the likes of PAC, Shingo Takagi, and future BCC mate Jon Moxley before WWE realised the error of their ways and snapped him back up. He re-debuted for the company at SummerSlam 2010, facing off against his former stable as part of Team WWE.

The rest, as they say, is history.

His WWE career was a rollercoaster of highs and lows; from his World Championship win at WrestleMania XXX to his retirement in 2016. After over a decade of fantastic matches and moments, Bryan left WWE in 2021 to start a new legacy in AEW.

Despite his first WWE "run" being a blip in the American Dragon's iconic career, it's important to recognise how important it was and how things could have been very different had he never been fired in 2010.


3. Shawn Michaels (2002 - 2010)

Shawn Michaels WrestleMania 25 entrance.jpg
WWE.com

It sounds a bit ridiculous to call a time that saw HBK win three World Championships, two Royal Rumbles, and have WWE's first ever five-star match his "inferior run". But just look at what happened afterwards.

Despite his in-ring success from 1988 to 1998, Shawn Michaels was less than successful in his personal life due to a rotten attitude and heavy substance abuse.

All this changed when HBK suffered a career-ending back injury at the 1998 Royal Rumble. At least, it was career-ending at the time...

After four years out of the ring and a lot of soul-searching, Michaels made his triumphant return at SummerSlam 2002. His match with Triple H was outstanding, one of the best in the event's history, and it kickstarted a remarkable rebirth for The Showstopper.

Whilst he wouldn't win as many championships as the first time around, Michaels' second stint in the WWE produced some of the greatest matches in the promotion's history with the likes of Kurt Angle, Ric Flair, and (of course) The Undertaker.

Shawn Michaels' journey back to wrestling is truly astounding. He overcame so many obstacles in his life to not only return to the sport he loved, but to claim his rightful place as one of the best ever.


2. Eddie Guerrero (2002 - 2005)

Eddie Guerrero WWE Champion
WWE.com

Easily one of the best loved performers of all time, it wasn't always clear that Eddie Guerrero would end up as a legend.

Alongside the rest of The Radicalz, Eddie defected to WWF from WCW in 2000. He won a handful of championships and took part in some memorable moments (particularly with Chyna), but everything seemed to be over for Eddie when he was arrested for drunk driving and let go in 2001.

After a short stint on the indies, Guerrero returned to WWE. Over the next few years, he formed the popular Los Guerreros tag team with his cousin, Chavo, won more midcard championships, and performed the small feat of pinning Brock Lesnar for the WWE Championship.

Eddie's one and only World Title win in WWE was an emotional affair, the culmination of a long, winding, and often bumpy road. Who knows how much more Eddie could have achieved in his second WWE run had he not been cruelly taken from us in late-2005

Though it ended in tragedy, Eddie Guerrero's second stint in WWE was the one that secured his legacy and ensured that he will always be remembered as one of wrestling's brightest lights extinguished far too soon.


1. Drew McIntyre (2017 - Present)

Drew McIntyre WWE Champion Goldberg Raw
WWE.com

From Chosen One to musical jobber to indie darling to WWE Champion, Drew McIntyre's wrestling career has been anything but ordinary.

First appearing on WWE TV aged just 24-years-old, Drew was positioned as a future main eventer right from the get-go. However, despite some Intercontinental and Tag Team Championship success, things didn't quite work out.

After a turn as part of the beloved undercard stable 3MB, McIntyre was cut from WWE in 2014. Unphased by his release, Drew then worked his backside off for the next three years to turn this tragedy into a triumph.

He returned to WWE in 2017 a changed man, both mentally and physically. He quickly rose the ranks of NXT, was called up to the main roster, and affirmed his position as a top star when he won the 2020 Royal Rumble and subsequently beat Brock Lesnar for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 36.

Drew's tenacity and dedication to his dream are admirable and a great inspiration to anyone who suffers adversity. He continues to make the most of his new position in WWE, proving that anybody can succeed if they're just given a second chance.


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.