10 Best Wrestlers Of 2023 (So Far)

Wrestling scales more new heights, but which WWE & AEW stars are reaching the tallest ever summits?

Sami Zayn
WWE

First, the qualifiers/things that will make you cross/less cross about the people that are/aren't in this list;

- In line with WhatCulture.com's primary coverage this will be centred around those wrestling for WWE and AEW. That's not to undermine those in NJPW, Stardom, TJPW, Impact Wrestling, ROH, GCW or anybody else outside the mainstream North American bubble, but consider this specific caveat before contacting the local authorities over a glaring omission.

- In conjunction with the above, the entire role of the television wrestler will be taken into account accordingly. Quality of matches comes first, but quality of promos and ability to build said matches comes above the quantity of contests if they’ve all been mostly meaningless. There’s a surplus of great wrestling just like there’s a surplus of great prestige television shows, but which performers - like the great characters in said shows - grabbed you by the throat and forced you to sit up and pay attention to what they were doing?

- And finally, like many articles on this website, it's a subjective collection of wrestlers, yours may be different, almost definitely is different, and that's fine.

For those that crave blanket positivity in their coverage, here are loads of it…

10. Bianca Belair

WWE WrestleMania 39 Bianca Belair
WWE.com

It takes a performer of immense talent to fire out big stage bangers such her Backlash battle with Iyo Sky and WrestleMania 39 and Night Of Champions blinders with Asuka. Still, those encounters warrant even more praise when measured against their respective builds and suspect week-to-week booking in general.

From back when she first landed in NXT, WWE haven’t shied away from presenting Bianca Belair as the total package, but the pressure of that rests on her shoulders every time she steps out under the company’s brightest spotlights. Her hit rate in this and any years are subsequently astonishing.

She’s worked 40 matches in 2023 as of this writing, and most of them outside of her title fights with Asuka have been singles or tag offerings against members of Damage CTRL. Weaker than the sum of its parts by orders of magnitude, the group are indicative of Triple H’s clear malaise with women’s wrestling at present, yet Belair’s worked hard with Sky, Dakota Kai and Bayley to keep the action hot even when the angles have been ice cold.

You have to play certain tricks to shine above the house style in WWE, and Belair keeps playing them. As does…


9. Sami Zayn

Kevin Owens Sami Zayn
WWE.com

During their various topline guest spots or high-profile singles matches against one another, it used to be said that Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens had gamed the WWE system. At long last, it might be time to admit that they've actually changed it.

Zayn informed arguably the most successful of Triple H's localised B-Show strategy, setting Montreal ablaze over two incredible nights in February for an Elimination Chamber title shot. His run against Roman Reigns convinced enough people that he should have been cast as 'The Tribal Chief's final boss over WrestleMania weekend, but WWE used his incredible momentum to book him and Owens to dethrone The Usos in the first Tag Team Championship main event in WrestleMania history.

As Champions, they've been the only act credited with leaving a permanent scar on The Bloodline, and Zayn working babyface again (old music included) feels like a reward for the incredibly hard yards he ran as a heel for the better part of five years. That sort of promotional malpractice shouldn't happen again.


8. Jon Moxley

AEW Double Or Nothing 2023 Jon Moxley
AEW

Jon Moxley remains the god of all of this despite having a far smoother run of things in 2023 than the wild west year he found himself trudging through in the wake of All Out 2022.

The former three-time AEW World Heavyweight Champion hasn't been near the company's top strap since losing it to MJF, but has taken his character on quite the ride as part of the Blackpool Combat Club's violent heel turn.

Approaching every match like a fight he wants to finish as quickly as he can, he has reimagined what it is to be one of the best in the world, including cutting down and run-times as much as he cuts his forehead. Losing clean to Hangman Page at Revolution brought out the worst in him, turning the company's safest pair of hands into the most violent. Leading the charge against The Elite alongside Brian Danielson has allowed him to flex his villainous chops for the first time since AEW's launch, and he himself has stressed how he's only now realising the type of pro wrestler he wants to be.

Based on his 2019-2022 form, only Mox knows how high he can fly.


7. Cody Rhodes

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes is currently in the middle of a programme that's nothing to do with him winning the WWE Championship, but it's not the incomplete storyline with Brock Lesnar or his Money In The Bank aspirations getting in the way of him being allowed to "Finish The Story".

It's the in-house "facing adversity" programme that all supposed "superstars" must embark upon now despite every made man in company history doing nothing of the sort en route to the top.

Cody's 2023 resumé was impressive already, but when considering the heavy losses against Lesnar and Roman Reigns, his enduring popularity is frankly astonishing. Nothing can stop 'The American Nightmare', and that thankfully includes WWE's creative and Triple H's post-WrestleMania filibustering about stories not having endings. He will become WWE Champion (not the World Heavyweight one), and he'll do it on loads of merit too.

His Royal Rumble victory featured a blinding mini-match with Gunther, his WrestleMania main event was the best version of the new Roman Reigns epic (despite the result), and his contests with Lesnar have been 'The Beast's most captivating in years. Cody Rhodes is yet again undeniable, in spite of his new employer's desperation to disprove that.


6. Rhea Ripley

WWE Backlash 2023 Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

Rhea Ripley's on such incredible form in 2023 that she'd be number one on this list if anybody else in her orbit were being booked (and working) to a similar standard.

The Judgment Day's toughest member since the moment she joined, Ripley built on a staggeringly impressive second half of 2022 by going coast-to-coast in the Royal Rumble to punch her ticket for WrestleMania 39. A genius seller who understands how her character should approach differing physical obstacles, she made her 23:35 against Charlotte Flair at the 'Show Of Shows' look as tough as the 1:01:08 she spent in the January classic, and stole the show from underneath the epic Bloodline main event drama on the 'Grandest Stage'.

Believably dominant in contrast to the muddled way her character was initially handled on the main roster, there was a measured quality to her thrilling squash wins over Zelina Vega and Natalya at Backlash and Night Of Champions respectively, and her partnership with Dominik Mysterio continues to be one of the most endearingly appalling things in all of wrestling.

A multi-tool player in a division with too few serious contenders, Ripley will surely follow recent trends and hold the SmackDown Women's Championship for a long long time. An impending feud with Becky Lynch could be legacy-defining stuff if it reaches its peak.


5. Kenny Omega

Kenny Omega Bryan Danielson
AEW

Ever the divisive sort, Kenny Omega's 2022 return had fans fizzing for him to shake off the cobwebs in singles action, but the strains of "Battle Cry" only hitting once - and for an AEW Dark taping no less - left many wanting more from 'The Best Bout Machine'.

2023 was just four days old when he came through with the goods, and the hits haven't stopped since.

A Wrestle Kingdom 17 return to New Japan Pro Wrestling and bout with Will Ospreay surpassed sky-high expectations. It instantly sold the potential of a rematch that AEW can promote for Forbidden Door and beyond, and elusive singles offerings against El Hijo del Vikingo and Jon Moxley on Dynamite were two of the company's best matches this year.

Elsewhere, his trios sprints alongside The Young Bucks against AR Fox & Top Flight were a riot, a title loss to The House Of Black at Revolution 2023 and follow-up three-way with The Jericho Appreciation Society represented a peak for the three-man thus far, and Anarchy In The Arena 2 was a reminder that The Elite's never-ending saga can still belong in the company's main event scene.


4. MJF

MJF Promo
AEW

When All Elite Wrestling first launched, there was so much discussion about paradigm shifts in the industry that Jon Moxley was able to rename his finisher in accordance with them. But four years later, current AEW World Heavyweight Champion Maxwell Jacob Friedman has proven the best example of the most significant one.

The paradigm has shifted significantly enough that a company's top heel can preserve his bump card, protect his character's integrity, and wrestle instant classics at an exclusive rate. Well, one company's top heel can, and Roman Reigns isn't on the level of The Devil in 2023.

To underserve the ‘Salt Of The Earth’ based on the few times he’s laced up the boots this year would be to misunderstand his value to AEW and the industry grossly. He recently boasted after Double Or Nothing 2023 that he'd worked the best ever four-way match following on from the best ever iron man match, and even though the joke is as old as the man himself, everybody had no choice but to reply with the Bobby Fish gif in response.

Peerless on the microphone, he sang pennies from heaven while drawing dollars from hell if the Four Pillars build hits anything close to those early 130k+ buyrate predictions and he's living up to his Roddy Piper perceptions by constantly changing the questions when opponents and pundits alike think they've got all the answers.


3. Bryan Danielson

Bryan Danielson
AEW

Bryan Danielson took a short sabbatical after Revolution 2023 (and barely took a bump upon his return until Anarchy In The Arena 2), but as usual, Bryan remains a gift to any promotion he works for and any professional wrestler he shares the ring with.

When this year draws to a close, his Iron Man Match with MJF will likely still be the headline, but he's already worked matches that would steal anybody else's best-ofs and - as of writing - hasn't yet locked up with Kazuchika Okada at Forbidden Door.

Getting the best out of a tired trope, the 'American Dragon' was breathing fire during a gauntlet run before his shot at the 'Salt Of The Earth'. His matches with Konosuke Takeshita, Bandido, Brian Cage, Timothy Thatcher and Rush were individually sensational while simultaneously telling one larger singular story, and his subsequent heartbreak after losing to MJF has informed a quietly psychotic heel turn alongside the Blackpool Combat Club.

With Bryan Danielson, when it seems like it can get no better, it does. He may well be working his way into a Wembley rematch with Nigel McGuinness, satisfying the whims of a relatively niche Ring Of Honor diehard crowd in front of one of the biggest paid attendances in wrestling history. Even without that, he'll deliver on that stage as he does every one he steps out on.


2. Gunther

WWE Night Of Champions 2023 GUNTHER
WWE.com

Secondary titles are primary concerns in 2023, and Gunther's Intercontinental Championship run is already the greatest of all time even if it falls short of The Honky Tonk Man's longevity record.

It almost definitely won't, though. WWE are on the home straight with that now, and 'Der Ring General's work has done the heavy lifting passing the days in ways Roman Reigns can only dream of by comparison.

Like the Number One wrestler on this list and certain former Intercontinental Champions, Gunther simply doesn't have bad matches anymore. And if he did, they'd be collector's items in their own right. It's dark arts stuff watching him work too - he forces his opponents into attempting to climb the same mountain but their differing attempts add unique character to every battle. An hour in the Royal Rumble was the test of this, and passing that with flying colours presumably assured him of even greater title runs when this one eventually comes to a close.

Never was this any more pronounced than in his WrestleMania 39 Triple Threat victory over Sheamus and Drew McIntyre. Having swallowed up Match Of The Year plaudits for his singles bout against 'The Celtic Warrior' in 2022, the Champion doubled down on the violence with double the hard-hitting opposition. McIntyre's similar style was the perfect accompaniment, but just when twice the raw power looked enough to demolish the Gunther edifice once and for all, he showed the guts and guile of a future headline babyface lurking beneath the heel exterior.

And speaking of future headline babyfaces...


1. Orange Cassidy

Orange Cassidy
AEW

Orange Cassidy may still appear to some to be a direct contrast to Gunther on the other side of the AEW/WWE divide, but even casual observers must now have seen just how similar the two men are.

Gunther might leather his hands across foes' chests instead of shoving them in his pockets, but the intent is the same - use your most devastating weapon to beat your opponent. As International Champion, 'Freshly Squeezed' has remained a cool customer in increasingly trying times, and the bulk of AEW's midcard has fallen in their efforts to dethrone him as a result.

It's a brilliant bit; the supposedly lazy and work-shy wrestler becomes the undisputed workhorse, but the story has become incredibly valuable to the organisation's bottom line. As the company's hardest-working Champion, Orange has elevated the International Title to number two on the AEW podium and thus could prove responsible for Collision having a high-stakes strap to scrap for when MJF doesn't work Saturdays.

This mustn't go forgotten if and when he loses the belt. Defences against Lee Moriarty, Wheeler Yuta, Jay Lethal (twice), Big Bill, Buddy Matthews, Bandido, Dralistico and especially Jeff Jarrett, made for incredible and nerve-wracking television, and his Double Or Nothing mini-match with Swerve Strickland concluded one of the best battle royals in wrestling history.

A tag team with Darby Allin has formed in the interim, and his mounting injuries are well-served by having a partner just as willing to put his body on the line. He's the cheat code for a perfect Dynamite live experience, but the only formula has been hard work in spite of criticism from those on the grift.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.