10 Best Wrestling Rivalries That Kept It All In The Ring
Sometimes, an epic series of matches is all it takes...
Rivalries are at the heart of wrestling storytelling. The sport has evolved immensely over the years, but while the mainstream product is drastically different to what it was a few decades ago, the basic dramatic framework remains the same. At its core, it's about two or more parties butting heads on their road to the top, and that'll never change.
The way these feuds are presented has changed with the sport as a whole. The modern era's rivalries are often characterised by what happens outside the ring as much as anything else, particularly in WWE. Rock vs. Austin and Andre vs. Hogan are classic storylines, but they're primarily remembered for the pageantry surrounding them, and the same goes for many more of wrestling's greatest feuds.
Soap opera elements are inevitable in all forms of wrestling, but some rivalries transcend them. In these cases, the ring work is so irresistible that it takes precedence over everything else, and defines the rivalry as a whole.
Each of these feuds brought wrestling storytelling back to its roots as a simulated form of athletic competition, and while they all came with strong narratives, they're ultimately remembered for the matches.
10. Dean Malenko Vs. Eddie Guerrero
Few pairs of wrestlers have ever built the same kind of in-ring chemistry as Dean Malenko and Eddie Guerrero. They didn’t deliver an abundance of Match Of The Year candidates, but from their early days feuding over the ECW Television Title in 1995 to teaming as The Radicalz in WWE five years later, the duo always produced good to great bouts.
In Fit Finlay’s words, “it was just greed of knowledge, and they were trying to prove to each other the knowledge they had was better than the other." Two technical wrestling geniuses going hold for hold for the sake of pride and competition. Though their finest moments came in ECW, you can play almost any Malenko/Guerrero match and know it’s going to be enjoyable, and their matches usually highlighted every show they appeared on.
Their bout at ECW Hostile City Showdown stands out the strongest. On a card full of the loony hardcore wrestling that Paul Heyman’s promotion was known for, the duo wrestled an extremely compelling mat-based draw. Full of expert limb work, it had just enough high spots to keep things from getting too self-indulgent, and is only held back from a perfect rating by Eddie’s inconsistent selling towards the end.
9. Bryan Danielson Vs. Nigel McGuinness
From his dabblings with The Nexus to The ‘Yes!’ Movement’s surge in popularity, Daniel Bryan has been at the heart of some of the modern era’s most memorable storylines. He remains one of WWE’s more enjoyable on-air personalities even in retirement, but as far as his in-ring work goes, no chapter of his career produced more outstanding matches than his rivalry with Nigel McGuinness.
The duo first wrestled as members of opposing teams in Ring Of Honor’s 2005 Trios Tournament, and their earliest singles match came in April 2006. Both Nigel’s ROH Pure Title and Bryan’s World Championship were on the line, but it finished in a count-out. They met in another technical chess battle three months later, with Danielson emerging victorious, and in August, they produced one of the best matches in ROH history.
A title unification match, it saw Bryan (who had a giant chip on his shoulder after besting Nigel in the previous contest) outdo McGuinness in his native Liverpool. Starting with intense mat work, it gradually escalated throughout, with both men to great lengths to put the other. Bryan put Nigel away, but they’d wrestle a further seven singles matches throughout their careers, with McGuinness triumphing in their last big title fight (2008).
8. Barry Windham Vs. Ric Flair
Ric Flair had so many outstanding feuds throughout his wrestling career that his rivalry with Barry Windham often goes unmentioned. This is a shame, as not only did it come during one of the most consistently entertaining periods of ‘The Nature Boy’s’ tenure, but it also produced some of his best in-ring work.
The feud’s premise was simple, with Flair, the flashiest of heels, going against Windham, the country’s most unsung babyface hero. Its greatest moments came through a series of three five star matches in 1986 and 1987, with the first going to a double countout, but Flair taking victory in the other two. Nonetheless, Ric’s masterful selling had the fans buying into the idea that Windham could end his lengthy NWA Heavyweight Title reign at any time, though this never came to pass.
Barry had to wait until 1993 to eventually get the belt, and the rivalry continued to grow and evolve over the years. Windham drifted in and out of the Four Horsemen, and became the ‘Lone Wolf’ shortly after his big title win, feuding with Flair once more. The feud took on a more dramatic focus at this point, but in the early days, Flair vs. Windham was all about the in-ring.
7. Kurt Angle Vs. Brock Lesnar
The roots of Brock Lesnar and Kurt Angle’s WWE feud were planted at Armageddon 2002, when Brock interfered in a WWE Championship match between the ‘Olympic Hero’ and the Big Show. Angle went back on a promise to give Lesnar a title shot after helping him to victory, and they feuded in the run up to WrestleMania XIX. This particular contest is best known for Brock’s botched Shooting Star Press, but was a great bout nonetheless.
'The Next Big Thing' turned his attention to John Cena afterwards, but further collisions with the gold medallist were inevitable. Kurt pinned Brock in a Triple Threat match at Vengeance 2003, and they wrestled another great bout at SummerSlam, with Angle tapping his opponent out with an Ankle Lock.
Their finest hour came on a September episode of SmackDown, when they met in perhaps the best Iron Man match in WWE history. It started with a desperate Lesnar going all out to gain the advantage, having been unable to out-wrestle Kurt in the first few matches, but Kurt answered with trademark intensity. Kurt obliterated Lesnar’s legs throughout, but Brock survived, winning the contest 5-4, and effectively concluding the most compelling in-ring rivalry of his career.
6. Hiroshi Tanahashi Vs. Kazuchika Okada
The tale of Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Kazuchika Okada is a classic ‘passing the torch’ story. The former was the untouchable company ace who’d carried NJPW through one of its roughest periods, while Okada had been hand picked as the company’s new golden boy, and was about to have the proverbial rocket strapped to him.
Fresh off returning from an unproductive excursion in the US, Okada wrestled Tanahashi at New Beginning 2012, scoring a stunning upset win over the man who’d soon become his greatest rival. The ensuing IWGP Heavyweight Title run didn’t last long, as Tanahashi took the belt back four months later, but Okada’s ascension was well underway, and the great bouts continued.
2013 was a standout year, with the duo trading victories in a set of five-star matches They didn’t meet again until Wrestle Kingdom 9 (2015), when Tanahashi triumphed once again, then openly mocked a tearful Okada in the aftermath. One full year later, ‘The Rainmaker’ finally usurped Tanahashi, beating him inside the Tokyo Dome for the very first time, and taking his ‘ace’ status in the process.
It was the culmination of four years of in-ring storytelling, and in a simple tale of two wrestlers striving to be the best in the business, the younger man came through.
5. Kurt Angle Vs. Chris Benoit
Chris Benoit and Kurt Angle each had dozens of great matches in WWE, but wrestling each other always seemed to bring out the best in both men. They had excellent chemistry almost from the beginning, and while their feud often featured plenty of WWE’s more distracting soap opera elements, the wrestling stood out above all else.
Two hard-hitting, intense technicians, Benoit and Angle’s presence in a match practically guaranteed excellence. Their first truly great bout took place at WrestleMania X-Seven, and continued over the coming months, with Kurt eventually drawing a line under the feud’s first chapter by winning a Steel Cage match on a June 2001 episode of Raw.
The rivalry reignited in 2002, but broke off when Benoit and Angle embarked upon a brief (but enjoyable) run as uneasy tag partners. The union eventually imploded, however, and at the 2003 Royal Rumble, they produced what many consider to be the best match of either man’s WWE career. Two weeks later, they wrestled their last singles contest on an episode of SmackDown. It was an anticlimactic end to an impressive body of work, but their pay-per-view bouts were undeniable.
4. Mitsuharu Misawa Vs. Kenta Kobashi
Puroresu practitioners don’t get any more legendary than Mitsuharu Misawa and Kenta Kobashi, whose lengthy feud helped carry a promotional run that many consider to be the best in history. Much of AJPW’s success in the 1990s came from Misawa and Kobashi, who built a laundry list of outstanding singles and tag matches together.
As with the bulk of Japan’s great wrestling rivalries, Kobashi vs. Misawa is all about the matches, their significance, and the stories forged between the ropes. Kobashi was never able to usurp Misawa as AJPW’s ace, with each of his singles victories coming in Champion Carnival tournament bouts. Thus, when 'Orange Crush' finally beat his rival for Pro Wrestling NOAH’s GHC Heavyweight Title in March 2003, the emotional outpouring was huge.
This wasn’t a feud based on an intense personal dislike, but two tremendously skilled warriors trying to beat each other for the top spot. Both were several years outside their time when Kobashi finally sealed his ultimate victory, but the 2003 bout remains a classic, and ranks among the best in a feud that produced three five-star singles matches, and countless others that still take the breath away in 2017, despite the sport’s athletic evolution.
3. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels
The first Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels feud was characterised by typical Attitude Era goofiness, but their second major rivalry was entirely more straightforward. Kicking off in spring 2009, the premise was simple: ‘Taker had never beaten HBK in a singles match, and Shawn wanted to take 'The Phenom's' WrestleMania streak.
The duo met at 'Mania XXV, producing a near perfect WWE style drama-fest that not only revived their outstanding in-ring chemistry 11 years after their last singles bout, but took it to the next level. ‘Taker won, and the two went their separate way for close to a year, before a vengeful HBK attacked ‘The Deadman’ at Elimination Chamber 2002, costing him the WWE Championship.
Undertaker initially declined Shawn’s offer of a rematch, but accepted when Michaels said he’d retire in defeat. One of the most impressive retirement bouts of all time followed, and while Shawn’s loss was inevitable, it’s hard to imagine a more fitting ending than going out on the back of one of his career’s best matches. A perfect conclusion to a legendary career, and a rivalry built around two transcendent wrestling icons desperate to outdo the other's legacy.
2. Ric Flair Vs. Ricky Steamboat
A perfect clash of personalities pitting a flash, hedonistic playboy against a grounded, honourable family man, Ric Flair vs. Ricky Steamboat was an extremely personal rivalry. It kicked off when Steamboat knocked 'The Nature Boy' out with a backhand chop during a promo in Jim Crockett Promotions, but while the feud involved plenty of shenanigans outside the ring, it was defined by its strongest matches.
The rivalry stretched out across multiple decades, though the most celebrated period came in 1989. The first bout took place at the Chi-Town Rumble, where Steamboat defeated Flair to capture his first (and only) World Title, and the last (at WrestleWar) saw him drop the belt back to Flair. Each contest was given the ***** treatment by Dave Meltzer, making it one of the most acclaimed runs of matches in American wrestling history.
The duo would later revive their feud in 1994, and while the matches weren’t of the same standard as their 1989 classics, Flair and Steamboat still produced a series to make their younger peers blush. Their mutual mastery of psychology and technique, coupled with their contrasting personalities, made each match feel special, keeping things exciting across their dozens of singles bouts.
1. Mitsuharu Misawa Vs. Toshiaki Kawada
Few professional wrestling, rivalries regardless of style or location, have ever churned out as many high quality matches as Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Toshiaki Kawada. For many, it represents the sport’s absolute peak as a storytelling medium, with Misawa, AJPW’s ace, fending off constant pressure from Kawada, a ruthless killer with an offensive arsenal custom built to cripple the opposition.
Starting their careers in opposing stables, Kawada and Misawa eventually formed a team, with Mitsuharu’s first AJPW Triple Crown victory coming while he and ‘Dangerous K’ were World Tag Team Champions. Animosity didn’t bloom until Misawa bested his former partner in a brutal, spiteful clash in July 1993, and in June 1994, when Kazuchika Okada and Kenny Omega were just 6 and 10 years old respectively, they produced the sport’s first six star match.
Much like Kenta Kobashi, Kawada often found it hard going against Misawa, and it took him until May 1998 before he’d finally best him for the Triple Crown. It was one of the final singles matches between the two, and while Misawa eventually won the feud by defeating Kawada in 2005, they left an impeccable body of work behind, with their 1994 clash standing as one of the most critically acclaimed bouts of all time.