10 Biggest Swerves WWE Made Before WrestleMania

Title changes, classic angles and retirement returns...

Sycho Sid Bret Hart
WWE.com

Since Yokozuna ousted 'Macho Man' Randy Savage from the ring and was declared winner of the 1993 match, the Royal Rumble has acted as a precursor to WrestleMania.

Theoretically, he who emerges as the Rumble winner goes on to main event WWE's biggest show of the year, but what would any 'Road to WrestleMania' be without a few bumps along the way?

The period between January-March/April each year is the most exciting time to be a wrestling fan as sweeping changes, epic twists, and even shock title switches often await fans before the 'Show of Shows'. WWE themselves routinely tweak the final 'Mania card in the weeks and months before, meaning not every proposed or expected WrestleMania main event actually ends up happening.

Sometimes these changes/tweaks are deliberate, but on other occasions they occur organically; unable to account for injuries or fan demands, WWE have been forced to drastically alter their 'Mania plans more than once.

Each year, these swerves are a constant source of deliberation, causing endless chatter amongst fans about what 'might have been' during WWE's busiest time of the year...

10. The Big Show Debuts Amidst Cage Match Chaos (1999)

Steve Austin, Vince McMahon, Big Show
WWE.com

The fact a villainous Mr. McMahon character won the 1999 Royal Rumble match is something of a swerve to begin with. Steve Austin was chasing a third consecutive Rumble win in '99, only to be foiled by his arch nemesis. The box office appeal of Austin vs. McMahon continued the next month at the St. Valentine's Day Massacre pay-per-view.

Locked inside a steel cage with one another, the warring duo were set to determine whether or not Austin would go on to WrestleMania XV and receive a shot at the WWF Title. As if that wasn't dramatic enough, the cage bout witnessed the company debut of The Big Show.

Show would aid Austin unintentionally by hurling him against the cage wall. Breaking the structure, Stone Cold tumbled to the floor and was declared the winner as McMahon stood aghast inside the ring.

Many had been expecting Austin to defeat McMahon, although there were few accounting for the idea of Big Show accidentally helping his cause. The swerve here is that McMahon's Rumble victory meant little in the end, as the WWF eventually promoted Austin vs. The Rock come 'Mania anyway.


9. John Cena & The Rock Go Twice In A Lifetime (2013)

John Cena WrestleMania XXV
WWE

It's still cringeworthy to look back on WWE's 'Once In A Lifetime' promotion for The Rock vs. John Cena at WrestleMania XXVIII and then realise that the same match happened again one year later. In hindsight, it would have been better for the creative team to steer clear of such restrictive branding, because they were always going to try and squeeze another rematch in somewhere.

As the reigning WWE Champion in January, a high-flying CM Punk was shut down by the returning Rock at Royal Rumble. On the exact same pay-per-view, Cena won the Rumble match itself and secured himself a slot in the main event of 'Mania XXIX.

Suddenly, Rock vs. Cena was set for WrestleMania yet again. What's more, the WWE Title would be on the line, surely enraging Punk when he realised that he had been dislodged from the top table just in time for WWE's most lucrative time of the year.

Those wondering if Punk's lengthy title run would continue into WrestleMania were left disappointed, as the outspoken champ was left dethroned and out of the main event picture while WWE focused on adding the title to Rock vs. Cena II.


8. Batista Grants Mr. McMahon's Wishes (2010)

Batista WWE Champion 2010
WWE.com

Successfully defending his newly-won gold at the Royal Rumble against Randy Orton didn't change the popular opinion that Sheamus wouldn't make it to WrestleMania with the WWE Title. There was a bigger match that creative had planned, another rematch which loomed on the horizon and threatened the Irishman's 'Mania dreams.

Plans would become clear at the Elimination Chamber show in February. John Cena outlasted the likes of Sheamus and Triple H to win the WWE Title, but the babyface would see his celebrations cut short by an emerging Vince McMahon. Callously pulling the rug out from underneath Cena, McMahon ordered the new champ to defend against a fresh Batista.

One Spear and Batista Bomb combination later and 'The Animal' was the new titleholder heading into WrestleMania XXVI. Batista had been refreshed by turning heel at the end of 2009, and he was the ideal choice to further McMahon's storyline attempts to replace Cena in the 'poster boy' role.

Even though Cena would still bag the title come 'Mania, it felt like a huge swerve to have Batista come out at McMahon's behest, destroy him at Elimination Chamber and take the belt before then.


7. Chris Jericho Becomes World Heavyweight Champ (2010)

The Undertaker Shawn Michaels Elimination Chamber
WWE.com

Batista's spontaneously cruel win over a knackered John Cena wasn't the only major swerve to come out of Elimination Chamber 2010. In just the one show, WWE decided to change the entire landscape for WrestleMania, and that included plans for the World Heavyweight Championship.

Held by The Undertaker heading into the pay-per-view, the 'other' World Title in WWE would be around the waist of Chris Jericho come the end. Jericho wasn't permitted to earn a clean win over 'Taker; instead, the opportunistic Canadian picked up the pieces after Shawn Michaels appeared out of nowhere and cracked Undertaker with a Superkick right at the death.

In the span of this one event, WWE set the scene for major 'Mania matches like Shawn Michaels vs. The Undertaker (itself a rematch from 'Mania XXV), John Cena vs. Batista, and Chris Jericho vs. Edge.

The surprise here is that Undertaker seemed a dead cert to hit WrestleMania and defend the World Heavyweight Title, perhaps against Michaels; HBK had been trying to talk 'Taker into a rematch for weeks before Elimination Chamber, explaining away his Superkick interference as a way to get his foe's attention.

Now, the belt was on Chris Jericho, someone nobody expected going into the February pay-per-view.


6. Sycho Sid Wins The Title From Bret Hart (1997)

Sycho Sid Bret Hart
WWE.com

Cheating like the heel he was, Steve Austin eliminated Bret Hart and (the fake) Diesel to win the 1997 Royal Rumble. Austin had already been eliminated by Hart, but as the referees had missed his tumble to the floor entirely, Stone Cold re-entered the ring. His win promised something fresh on top come WrestleMania 13.

When Shawn Michaels beat Sycho Sid in the Rumble's main event, it seemed like Austin vs. Michaels was a possibility for 'Mania. The much more obvious scenario involved running a rematch from 'Mania XII between Michaels and Bret Hart, with the latter seemingly poised to exact revenge and beat HBK.

Neither match would happen. Vacating the title due to a supposed knee injury, Shawn Michaels "lost his smile" and was removed from contention for a main event berth at WrestleMania. Shortly afterwards, a heroic Bret Hart win in a Fatal-4-Way bout (also involving Austin) at In Your House 13 in February appeared to set up Hart vs. Austin for the WWF Title as the most logical choice.

24 hours after winning the title, Hart was beaten by Sid on Raw and the card switched around again. Instead of any matches previously pitched for WrestleMania, a series of twists and turns meant new champ Sid would defend against The Undertaker and Hart would battle his enemy Austin on the undercard.


5. Eddie Guerrero Wins The Title From Brock Lesnar (2004)

Eddie Guerrero WWE Title No Way Out 2004
WWE.com

Former WWE creative mind Bruce Prichard told on his podcast that Vince McMahon couldn't believe how small Eddie Guerrero was upon meeting him. Vince's very words to Bruce were, "he's so tiny", suggesting that the single most powerful man in WWE would never entertain thoughts of making Guerrero a World Champion in his promotion.

Pouring endless colour over a relatively dreary WWE landscape and outshining many via his antics on SmackDown, the feisty Guerrero had become one of the most popular stars on the roster by 2003. Heading into 2004 though, it appeared the charismatic Eddie would have to settle for a lower-card spot at WrestleMania XX.

Nobody could have imagined that he'd be booked to beat Brock Lesnar (a WWE pet project) and win the WWE Title at No Way Out less than a full month before 'Mania, but that's exactly what happened.

It appeared WWE fancied a Lesnar vs. Goldberg title showdown for the card. Instead, plans switched when Brock made it clear he wanted out of the company and Goldberg's contract ticked down; left reeling over the loss of two big stars, McMahon finally turned to Guerrero and gave fans an almighty surprise at No Way Out.


4. Fan Demand Pushes Daniel Bryan Into The Title Picture (2014)

daniel bryan batista randy orton
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan's insertion into the main event picture just in time for WrestleMania XXX could almost be described as more of a complete u-turn than a swerve. Rebelling like crazy against WWE's wishes, many fans point blank refused to cheer a returning Batista after he was written to triumph in the 2014 Royal Rumble.

The question must be posed: just what were WWE thinking by ignoring Bryan's wild popularity and trying to force feed 'The Animal' to their customers instead? It defied all logic to turn a blind eye: Bryan had a pre-built story with Triple H and hand-picked Authority members like Randy Orton heading into 'Mania, having been robbed of the chance to be champ time and time again by the heel faction.

Faced with the threat of mass booing in their biggest match of the year, WWE officials eventually caved and let Bryan into the main event spotlight. Beating Triple H to earn a slot in the headline Triple Threat, Daniel then went on to win the title.

The fact it took immense fan pressure before WWE were willing to book their most popular babyface in such a match is shocking, but at least it happened. Batista vs. Orton in a singles match would have flopped spectacularly at 'Mania XXX.


3. The WWF Abandons Ric Flair Vs. Hulk Hogan Idea (1992)

hulk hogan sid
WWEcom

Ric Flair's jump over to the WWF during late-1991 made a dream match against Hulk Hogan possible. For years, wrestling fans had wondered who would win between the WWF's 'Hulkamania' creation and the NWA/WCW's more traditional 'Nature Boy'. Finally, such an inter-promotional fantasy could come to life just in time for WrestleMania VIII.

Hogan vs. Flair seemed like a no-brainer, not to mention exactly the kind of marquee match 'Mania was made for. Unfortunately for everyone waiting to see the inevitable, it wouldn't happen; running Hogan vs. Flair on the house show circuit didn't impress Vince McMahon, causing the WWF chief to cancel plans for the match to headline his biggest card of 1992.

Flair did win the WWF Title by coming out on top in the '92 Royal Rumble match, but he'd work with another company stalwart at 'Mania. Randy Savage was thrust into the title match and Hogan was removed, Hulk being moved sideways to feud with Sid Justice.

Justice eliminated Hogan from the Rumble bout, and that was the only storyline reasoning given on TV for squashing fan dreams. Incredibly, Hogan vs. Flair would never happen on WWF/WWE pay-per-view, but it was considered for 'Mania VIII.


2. Mick Foley Returns From Retirement (2000)

Linda McMahon Mick Foley
WWE Network

There will always be regrets over the convoluted storytelling heading into WrestleMania 2000, not to mention the fact that a heel Triple H retained his title to close out the card (the first villain to do so at WrestleMania). In retrospect, Mick Foley's rivalry as both Mankind and Cactus Jack would have been perfect for 'Mania had it not already been finished just beforehand.

As Cactus, a brazen Foley put his entire career on the line against Triple H's WWF Title inside Hell In A Cell. That No Way Out match remains a classic to this day, the kind of encounter with storyline weight that really belonged on a bigger platform such as WrestleMania. Instead, the WWF had other plans.

Built around the 'McMahon In Every Corner' idea, 'Mania 2000's main event became a 4-way elimination affair when Linda McMahon brought Mick back out of retirement on the 20 March episode of Raw. Although fans were undoubtedly delighted to see Foley, the offered excuse of 'this is just a one night thing' from Linda tarnished the impact of that No Way Out loss.

Still, this was a momentous swerve no-one saw coming, that can't be forgotten.


1. Andre The Giant Gifts The Title To Ted DiBiase (1988)

Andre The Giant
WWE.com

Failing to convince Hulk Hogan that he should sell the WWF Title to him, 'Million Dollar Man' Ted DiBiase resorted to using Andre the Giant as a (literally) giant weapon. That story provided a perfect backdrop for the epic WrestleMania III rematch between Andre and Hogan on The Main Event, a televised special that would draw massive ratings in February 1988.

Unthinkably defeating Hulk to win the title, Andre's victory was mired in controversy when it was revealed that DiBiase had paid off referee Earl Hebner, convincing the evil official to 'detain' his elder brother Dave and take his place. It was classic WWF drama, and the situation was made even more outlandish when Andre attempted to give DiBiase the belt in return for wads of cash.

This necessitated the woeful 14-man tournament to crown a new champion at WrestleMania IV, but it can't be forgotten that Andre's win (however controversial) did change the lay of the land heading into the supercard; many had been expecting Hogan vs. DiBiase for 'Mania, a match fans didn't actually get one-on-one on pay-per-view.

The WWF Title was held up until Randy Savage beat DiBiase in a tournament final to become the new champ, thus ending the saga and protecting Hogan whilst a new titleholder could be crowned.

-

What other big twists and turns do you recall WWE making right before WrestleMania? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.