10 Most Devastatingly Wasted WWE Storylines

Jake Roberts as the Higher Power anyone?

As wrestling fans, it€™s virtually impossible not to fantasy book matches and storylines as they play out; particularly when it comes to main event feuds and big events like WrestleMania, Royal Rumble and SummerSlam. As such, when a dedicated grapple fan sees that a promoter is playing with the perfect hand, failure to cash in with an amazing storyline can leave a long-lasting scar that€™s hard to forget. So what makes great storyline turn sour? While there can be many factors involved, the death of most would-be classics usually boils down to one or more of the holy trinity of bad booking: disappointing pay-offs, poor planning or backstage politics. In the last ten years alone, we€™ve seen the €œMillion Dollar Mania€ fiasco, the whole €œIllegitimate Son€ debacle and the cluster that was the €œAnonymous Raw GM€ gimmick; all of which are perfect examples of non-existent pay-offs (and the less said about the poorly-timed €œWho Killed Vince?€ angle the better). Similarly, promising stables like the The Legacy and The Nexus have all fallen foul to poor planning; while talents like Colt Cabana, Zack Ryder and even Muhammad Hassan have all seen their careers held back by circumstance, egos and backstage politics. And this is all in the last decade! In an industry that spans over 100 years, the list of wasted storylines could go on for a lifetime. To save on time and column inches, here€™s a list of ten great examples of promoters dropping the ball on what should have been spectacular viewing.

10. Matt Hardy vs Edge (2005)

Great wrestling rivalries are built on simple reasoning. I hate you; you hate me €“ let€™s fight. The Matt Hardy/Edge/Lita love triangle situation was perfect; maybe not for Mr Hardy€™s future life plans, but for a wrestling angle, Vince had struck pure adulterated adultery gold. The Matt Hardy/Edge rivalry in 2005 immediately caught fire when Hardy was fired from WWE; prompting the subsequent revelation that Edge and Lita had been having an affair off-screen while Matt had been off recuperating an injury. The legit scandal was shocking news and earned Hardy mass fan support in the process, while simultaneously earning widespread hatred for both Edge and Lita (complete with the €œYou Screwed Matt€ chants which followed the couple wherever they went). Eventually, the heat from fans built to the point that WWE had no other choice but to rehire Hardy and face the issue head on. What followed was a superb example of worked shoot booking that was truly a sight to behold. Both men hated each other and it was evident for everyone to see. The reason was simple; one man had stolen another man€™s girl and there wasn€™t a viewer watching that couldn€™t sympathise with that scenario. Add to this some shoot subtleties here and there €“ like Hardy€™s renegade Ring of Honor references over the house mic and the insane ByteThis phone call between Hardy and his estranged ex €“ and the angle went from white hot to nuclear. And it was all set to explode at SummerSlam...or so we thought. Sadly, the SummerSlam match was bizarrely short and instead of Hardy getting the revenge he needed and the fans so badly knew he deserved, he instead took a complete pounding at the hands of Edge €“ and it was brutal. McDonald€™s French Fry machine didn€™t take as many potatoes as Matt Hardy did that day and, before the match had really even begun, the referee had called for the bell in a match that lasted less than five minutes. Edge was declared the victor while a semi-conscious Hardy was left to lick his own wounds when he was capable of doing so.
The sight of Hardy bloodied, on the wrong end of a Rated R beatdown was far from what the fans had expected, wanted or needed. Not only did it derail his momentum as the valiant babyface returning for justice, it emasculated his character as a man who was out for revenge against the homewrecker who tore his life apart. The two would feud for another month or so trading beatings and victories before Hardy lost a €œLoser Leaves Raw€ match at the WWE Homecoming special and got shipped off to Smackdown, ending their feud after just a couple of months. With genuine palpable heat between the two men and a real reason to back up their programme, there was no storyline hotter than the Hardy/Edge/Lita scenario in 2005 and the Hardy vs. Edge feud had legs that could rival Stacy Keibler€™s. Instead, Hardy was unceremoniously jobbed out to Edge in under five minutes, which not only hurt the storyline going forward but damaged the reputation of protagonist. After that, the subsequent matches struggled to live up to excitement of the SummerSlam encounter, leading to the whole resolution of the feud arriving far too soon.

9. Austin€™s Hit & Run (1999)

When Steve Austin was left laying courtesy of some extremely suspect driving at the 1999 edition of Survivor Series, the world was left wondering who had taken out the Rattlesnake in the WWF€™s very own €œWho Shot JR?€ moment. Not that JR, the other famous JR...never mind. In reality, the stunt was merely a clever way of writing Austin out of the storylines while he underwent neck surgery; however, the anonymous hit and run assailant provided a great opportunity for Austin to hit the ground running upon his return, as the Bionic Redneck would inevitably look to exact revenge on his mysterious attacker. So who was the man behind the wheel that night? Was it a main event conspirator who€™d advanced up the card in his absence? Some headline hero from Austin€™s past with a score to settle perhaps? Both good guesses, but neither comes close. It was in fact Rikishi. Yeah... http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2dxhxt_rikishi-i-did-it-for-the-rock-promo-wwf-raw-10-09-2000_sport Needless to say, the big reveal had about as much impact as a Ric Flair chair shot and, despite the questionable culprit, the returning Rattlesnake more than obliged his Too Cool target with a serious receipt at No Mercy; laying a textbook Stone Cold beatdown on the former Sultan. With a reasoning that was as dodgy as the Phatman€™s ring gear, Rikishi€™s explanation that he did it all for his cousin, The Rock, so €œThe Brahma Bull€ could ascend up the ladder was poor writing by the WWF creative team; especially considering The Rock was already a three-time champ by that point anyway. To make matters worse, Big Kish had only re-debuted in the Fed as Rikishi the night before the incident took place, making the whole timeline suspect at best. Surely even the former Headshrinker must have known that mowing down the company€™s top draw would be strongly frowned upon on your second day in? It was later revealed as an afterthought that in had, in fact, been Triple H behind the whole thing all along...which was in no way to be construed as the WWF covering their tracks after realising the Rikishi unveiling had been less than astounding.

8. nWo In WWE (2002)

Okay, so this one might be a controversial addition to the list, but hear me out. When the original New World Order dusted off their trademark black and whites in 2002, wrestling fans across the globe could barely believe their eyes. The inconceivable had happened and the prodigal sons €“ Hogan, Hall and Nash €“ had returned to the land that made them famous. Not only that but they had done so under the very spray-painted banner that had threatened to put Vince McMahon out of business five years earlier. They immediately made an impact on their debut at the No Way Out PPV, costing Steve Austin the WWF title and ruffling the feathers of The Rock, immediately setting up the iconic encounter between Hogan and The Great One at WrestleMania X8 and ultimately creating a truly immortal moment in sports entertainment between arguably its two biggest stars in history. Not a bad way to start out, right?
While it€™s hard to argue with the direction the initial nWo angle took with Hogan/Rock, it didn€™t take long for Vince€™s version of the nWo to quickly lose its steam once the dust had settled on the Show of Shows and the WrestleMania hangover kicked in. Hogan quickly left the group to return to his red and yellow roots and World Title glory, leaving The Outsiders €“ Hall and Nash €“ to recruit former members of the €™96 incarnation, X-Pac and Big Show. Soon after, the injury-prone Nash would suffer a serious biceps tear, taking him out of action for several months and essentially leaving the group without a leader. Meanwhile, typical wrestling luck would have it that Scott Hall had fallen off the wagon and was quickly handed his marching orders; leaving the nWo without its three founding members. Even the addition of Hall of Famers Ric Flair, Booker T and Shawn Michaels couldn€™t salvage the group at this point and another injury to the returning Nash €“ this time a quadriceps tear €“ would call last orders on the nWo until 2014, where the core members of Hogan, Hall and Nash (with the occasional addition of X-Pac) have made sporadic one-night returns here and there since. Looking back, there€™s no denying that the pairing of Hogan and Rock in Toronto was a thing of beauty for any long-time wrestling fan. However, the possibilities of dream matches that never materialised due to bad timing, injury or otherwise has got to leave the WWF€™s version of the nWo under the €œmissed opportunity€ banner. No nWo vs. DX; no Hogan vs. Austin; no Outsiders vs. The Dudley Boyz €“ the list could go on.
All in all, despite a spectacular arrival, a memorable build towards Mania and their huge contribution to one of the greatest WrestleMania moments of all time, the New World Order€™s run under Vince McMahon was a mixed bag of genius booking and poor decision-making in equal measures, with a little bad luck thrown in. Which, when looking at the bigger picture, was exactly the same formula applied to the group back in their WCW heyday.

7. Sting€™s WrestleMania Moment (2015)

When Sting finally made his long-awaited WWE debut at Survivor Series 2015, it was a huge deal for everyone involved. The last hold-out of the Monday Night Wars was finally going to make the jump and get his shot inside a WWE ring and, most importantly of all, finally get his very own, well-deserved €œWrestleMania Moment€. It sounded too good to be true and, sadly for The Icon, it was. From the very outset of the match, it became clear that it was going to be the Triple H show; immediately evident by their respective entrances. Sting was granted a bizarre Japanese drum instrumental that made little sense (with Sting billed from California and residing in Texas), while Triple H was given the most elaborate entrance known to mankind €“ the world that is, not Mick Foley. The Game€™s ring walk was undoubtedly the most memorable of the entire show and the awe-inspiring Terminator-themed entrance was so cool, it almost turned him babyface pre-lock up. When the bell eventually did ring, a decent match followed with some enjoyable spots and fun, if-not slightly nonsensical nostalgia (seriously, the nWo helping Sting?). Nevertheless, the crowd was into it, neither man had missed a beat and all was running smoothly €that was until the finish. Triple H blasts Sting with a sledgehammer to steal the victory and ruin The Stinger€™s WWE/WrestleMania debut€only to offer him his hand in €œrespect€ post-match€which Sting then accepts! Wrestling psychology meltdown! While some believe that a Sting victory would have been too €œobvious€, sometimes the obvious decision is actually the best course of action (see Daniel Bryan€™s WM30 title win). As Sting€™s first match inside a WWE ring, the moment was 25 years overdue and The Icon needed to win; if not to cement his standing amongst the younger fans who weren€™t so familiar with his past, then for the sake of any future Sting matches to come. Conversely, a Triple H loss wouldn€™t have hurt The Game€™s standing in the company one bit. Even the segment later in the night with Ronda Rousey and The Rock could have worked well with a dismissive and defiant Trips laying down an excuse-laden promo prior to their scuffle. A loss for The Stinger immediately devalued The Vigilante and left any future plans for the Venice Beach native up in the air.
Even for Triple H fans, it€™s hard not to chalk it up to ego on this one because it€™s happened so many times before. Triple H even boasts the only WrestleMania victory over Brock Lesnar since his dominant return in 2012 €“ which seems incredible considering the run The Beast has had since then €“ and is a feat not even The Undertaker can match. For Triple H to book himself into Sting€™s very first WWE match is one thing; but to book himself to go over with a victory was just plain short-sighted. It wasn€™t the fact that they missed the boat on a classic WrestleMania moment, it was the fact that they were stood on that boat, bound for WrestleMania and made the conscious decision to jump off right before they had reached the shore. With the match being Sting€™s debut match in WWE, his first appearance at a WrestleMania and a big moment in history (not to mention Steve Borden€™s career), the snub was a huge waste of moment that can now sadly never be undone.

6. €œHorseman€ Paul Roma (1993)

When word got out that the legendary Four Horsemen would be reforming at the inaugural Slamboree event in 1993, the buzz amongst the WCW fans at the time centred around who would be replacing original Horseman, Tully Blanchard, to be the third man alongside The Nature Boy and The Enforcer. With Ole Anderson overlooking proceedings on the set of €œFlair for the Gold€, it€™s safe to say few would have predicted that €œPretty€ Paul Roma would be unveiled as the newest Horseman to enter the fray. Despite picking several wins and even a tag title run with Arn, the former €œYoung Stallion€ and €œPower & Glory€ tag specialist was facing an uphill battle to be considered on par with the established Naitch and Double A €“ and rightfully so. Truthfully, he stood out like The Great Khali at an elf€™s picnic. What makes matters worse is the fact that WCW wasn€™t short of suitable replacements. Steve Austin would have fit the mould perfectly as an up and coming star in the making with something to prove and would have slid into the group effortlessly. Meanwhile, an established veteran, great worker and all-round badass like Ravishing Rick Rude would have had all the credentials to make the role his own. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JHX2koAOHRE Roma as a bonafide €œHorseman€ never really sat well with the fans. Luckily for the WCW audience, this incarnation of the legendary stable wouldn€™t last too long as the group would disband in October. Not so luckily was the reason for this disbanding, with the separation coming as a direct result of the infamous €œscissor incident€ between Arn and Sid Vicious; ironically severing ties between the group until late €˜95.

5. 10-10-10 (2010)

When it comes to empty promises, utter letdowns and generally failing to deliver on grandiose declarations, no company has ever been more of a repeat offender than TNA. Whether it€™s a €œgroundbreaking announcement€ or a €œshocking return€, TNA usually misses the mark with their definition of either one and it rarely matches up with the same expectation held of the fans. Perhaps the biggest example of this was their long running storyline heading into Bound For Glory 2010 and the arrival of €œThey€. With Abyss crowing about the arrival of the mysterious unnamed group for what seemed like months on end, a date was eventually set for the enigmatic €œThey€ and their coming out party. €œThey€ would materialise at Bound For Glory on 10-10-10 in a reveal that was far from a perfect ten on the fans€™ scorecards. When the three-way main event for the World Title between Kurt Angle, Jeff Hardy and Mr Anderson began, it was widely assumed that €œThey€ were on the horizon and the arrival was imminent. Sadly for the wrestling world, this prediction was true and €œThey€ had arrived in the form Eric Bischoff, chair in hand, looking about as intimidating as a new-born kitten on a bed of pink feathers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FRLl-vkDvf0 But never fear grapple fans, soon enough the ever-heroic Hulk Hogan €“ fresh out of back surgery €“ would enter the fray to save the helpless combatants from said chair-wielding kitten. The Hulkster meant business and would immediately storm the scene €“ and by €œstorm€ I mean €œgingerly waddle down the ramp like Walter Jnr from Breaking Bad€. Upon his arrival in-ring several minutes later, Hogan and €œEasy E€ soon made their intentions clear€as Jeff Hardy (that€™s Jeff Harvey to you, Mike Adamle) grabbed Hogan€™s crutches and wailed both Angle and Anderson before covering the latter for the three count, securing the belt and €œswerving€ everyone in the process. Originality 4 life, brother €“nWo Style! A myriad of random personnel would then enter the frame in what was seemingly a random fire drill from the Gorilla Position, as Abyss and Jeff Jarrett both hit the ring to pose with the new title holder. What was more shocking than the finish itself was the fact that this random group of people congregating in the ring were not, in fact, conducting a fire drill, but were actually members of the new group. In classic TNA logic, the stable €“ consisting of Hardy, Hogan, Bischoff, Abyss and the Jarretts €“ were all supposedly on the same page despite being the biggest bunch of misfits since The Oddities danced their way onto the scene in 1998. It was the cocktail no-one ordered and with good reason.
The only interesting thing to come out of this swerve finish was the prospect of a Jeff Hardy heel run €“ something which had never really been attempted before and the one thing that felt genuinely original about the entire storyline. Sadly for TNA, that same Jeff Hardy would eventually let his personal life take its own heel turn, resulting in the biggest debacle in the company€™s short history as a clearly €œimpaired€ Hardy would stagger down the ramp to face off against Sting in a nine second farce that effectively ended the Hardy heel turn experiment. Sadly, the €œThey€ faction €“ quickly redubbed €œImmortal€ (cos Hulkamania will live forever €“ get it, brother?) €“ would last considerably longer than Hardy€™s heel run, spanning from October 2010 until April 2012.

4. Black Scorpion (1990)

Ah, early 90s WCW. A land where El Gigante, PN News and the Ding Dongs reigned supreme over TV time and the likes of Shane Douglas, Rob Van Dam and Steve Austin couldn€™t catch a break if they dove head first into an empty swimming pool. As was par for the course during this fantastical Jim Herd era of WCW, questionable booking was usually the green lit without question. One such angle that unavoidably springs to mind was the fabled introduction of the Black Scorpion character into a headline feud with the company€™s franchise player, Sting. In theory, the addition of a shadowy rival with a mysterious history, hell bent on destroying WCW€™s resident golden boy could have worked out well. Sadly for all concerned, this gimmick happened to land in the same lame year that €œSting€™s buddy€ Robocop had also made an appearance and what could have been a decent angle, quickly degenerated in nonsensical, deep-pan Herdness. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kjPdsYm3HEU Depending on who you talk to, it€™s been revealed over time that the Black Scorpion was either intended to be original Four Horseman, Ole Anderson, or the former €œLatin Heartthrob€ of WCCW, Al Perez. However, fate would have it that neither Ole nor Al would end up being revealed as the man behind the mask. Sadly, Ole would suffer a broken arm just weeks into the angle, causing WCW execs to scramble for a suitable replacement. Al Perez would be that very replacement...right up until he flat out refused to do the job for the Stinger and made his swift exit €“ presumably using his Black Scorpion magic and transforming into a tiger. An Ole Anderson reveal would have made good sense all round. Much like the Shockmaster before him, the Black Scorpion had been voiced by the elder Anderson sibling in promos since day one. Moreover, Ole had legitimate history with The Stinger dating back to when Sting had been briefly been a member of the Horsemen before his unceremoniously exit from the group and the two men had had numerous run-ins with each other over the years. Their history also fit in nicely with the frequent references to the Scorpion as being €œsomeone from Sting€™s past€; alluded to on a weekly basis by commentators and even in the Scorp€™s own bizarre promos. So the question remained; exactly who the f**k was the Black Scorpion? Fans and WCW Execs alike were left scratching their collective heads over just who the man underneath the hood of the Black Scorpion was going to be. As usual, when push came to shove, WCW did what they always did and threw Flair into the equation as a quick fix for the payoff at Starrcade. There€™s a reason that Black Scorpion€™s initials are BS... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OGJG3NPOBdI Despite throwing everything at the match €“ including an ET-like entrance, a cage match stipulation and the inclusion of Dick the Bruiser as special referee/Popeye impersonator €“ nothing could hide the fact that the Flair revelation was clearly a last resort and the whole ordeal is understandably still a sore subject with the 16 time World Champ to this day. Perhaps sadder still is the fact that WCW never did decipher the cryptic messages within those initial Black Scorpion promos and whatever happened between the two on a sunny LA beach in €™86 will forever be mystery. Maybe the Stinger stole Scorp€™s sun lounger or kicked sand in his Pina Colada €“ I guess we€™ll never know.

3. Daniel Bryan€™s Return From Injury (2015)

When Daniel Bryan was shoe-horned into the WrestleMania 30 title picture, the WWE Universe collectively rejoiced as worldwide fan opinion was given a rare moment of recognition by WWE brass. The fans wanted Bryan as champ and €“ after some very vocal criticism of the planned heir-apparent, Dave Batista €“ they had gotten him as champ. Sadly, it was not to be, as cruel fate and injury would collide in the form of a severe neck issue, causing the €œYES Man€ to surrender the gold just a few short months later. The remainder of 2014 would come and go with little news on the Bryan front and a return to the ring at all was deeply in question...until he did just that the following January. Conveniently being declared match fit by doctors just in time for the Royal Rumble 2015, the stage was set for one of the most fitting, deserved and emotional WrestleMania moments in history. It was the dream scenario; the people€™s choice triumphantly returning from career-ending injury to regain the title he€™d never lost by slaying an all-conquering beast. It was as poetic as wrestling could get.
Sadly for DB, it turns out that wrestling and poetry mix like beer and Baileys and his fairytale return was not to be. Instead, fans were treated to a Roman Reigns victory at the Rumble and an atmosphere that was flatter than a Flair face bump. Fans would once again voice their disapproval, leading to Bryan once again being thrust into the main event picture; this time at the following month€™s Fast Lane event. However, lightning was not going to strike twice and Daniel Bryan would fall to the €œSamoan Superman€, leaving him out of World Title contention. Bryan would get a €œMania Moment€ of sorts with his Intercontinental Title victory; however, despite the fact that WWE supposedly had big plans for the belt, the fans and Bryan alike knew they could have had so much more had Bryan been given his triumphant return to the top of the card. While the WrestleMania 31 main event would go on to exceed all expectations and close the show off in spectacular fashion, Bryan€™s return from the brink of retirement to win the title he never lost still remains a €œWhat if?€ moment and could have altered the course of history that followed.
The former €œAmerican Dragon€ would go on to reign as IC champ for just over a month before having to relinquish the title due to injury once again, in a cruel repetition of the previous year; adding insult to injury on top of last year€™s insult to injury.

2. Leader Of The Ministry (1999)

Back in the wrestling wonderland that was 1999, all was right in the wrestling world. Steve Austin was kicking ass, The Rock was raising eyebrows and fans of the grapple game were treated to the darkest incarnation of the Undertaker the wrestling world had ever seen; including such questionable acts as crucifying Steve Austin, hanging the Big Bossman and generally employing the likes of Mideon and Viscera. So when it was discovered that the Deadman himself had been answering to €œa higher power€ all along, one thing was for sure €“ this guy was going to be one sick, sadistic SOB. So who would it be; who was so evil and satanic that even the €œDemon of Death Valley€ had to drop to a knee? Was it €œThe Taskmaster€ Kevin Sullivan? Abdullah the Butcher, perhaps? Hell, why not even throw Waylon Mercy into the hat as a ringer? Guess again, as the puppet master pulling all the strings was in fact revealed to be none other than Vincent Kennedy McMahon himself. That€™s right folks; the same Vinny Mac that had been at odds with Taker for weeks trying to protect his own daughter from the demonic deeds of The Phenom.
Despite being a classic example of Attitude Era TV (the €œIt was ME, Austin!€ line is still a cool moment despite the nonsense that surrounds it), the revelation that Vince McMahon had been tormenting his own family and repeatedly putting his daughter it harm€™s way purely to stick it to his most hated employee made about as much sense as an Ultimate Warrior promo and the whole storyline had more holes than Swiss cheese. What made matters worse is the fact that the unveiling had largely been rumoured to be none other than Jake €œThe Snake€ Roberts, who would have been beyond perfect in the role. Just imagine, the darkest character ever to set foot in an industry full of dark, seedy characters heading up a faction built on darkness. €œThe Snakeman of Stone Mountain€ was almost too perfect for the role, leaving the end result as a prime example of fantasy booking overshadowing the reality.

1. WCW Invasion (2001)

When it comes to ranking wasted storylines in pro wrestling history, there can be only one true winner of the title €“ the infamous €œInvasion€ angle from 2001. When WWF shocked the world by purchasing WCW, they brought to an end the most heated, personal and monumental rivalry in wrestling history. It was an all out war for supremacy that had left one company dead in the water and the other standing atop the entire industry as the sole survivor and king of the wrestling world. WCW vs WWF had defined an era in professional wrestling and, with the McMahons€™ buyout of their competition, the stage was set for the biggest crossover in sport and door to the fantasy booking room was left wide open for everyone to peer in. The world was finally going to get what it had long been clamouring for but never thought it would see; as two worlds would collide and WCW talent would step into the enemy€™s ring to face off against their WWF counterparts. Paul Heyman said it best: €œWhere there€™s chaos there€™s opportunity€ and the impending chaos had fans licking their lips like King Mabel at the catering table. The question was, who would be first to make the jump into foreign waters? Viewers wouldn€™t have to wait long for their answer, as Lance Storm made his WWF debut on May 28th, firing the first shot in this new civil war. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HIReklrm8CU As skilled a performer as Lance Storm was €“ and he really was a great technician between the ropes €“ he was far from the big name appearance that would have demanded headlines in the sports pages. Sadly, as the weeks progressed and more and more WCW talent began to filter over, it soon became apparent that the likelihood of a main event player showing up was increasingly slim. Truth be told, WWF was not at fault for this predicament as their hands were largely tied by the insane guaranteed money written into the previous WCW contracts; essentially allowing its top performers the luxury of sitting back while the money train kept on rolling. Not only did it hurt the angle but, more than anything else, it cheated the fans out of what could have been the single greatest storyline in wrestling. The only real winners in this scenario were the one€™s cashing the guaranteed cheques. The contract debacle forced WWF creative to think outside the box and before long the WCW invasion had been watered down into a partnership with the reformed ECW crew, which would eventually be christened The Alliance. To make matters worse, the WWF had put their own spin on the equation and instead of it being WCW and ECW, the spotlight had quickly focused on the new €œowners€ of these groups €“ Shane McMahon (WCW) and Stephanie McMahon (ECW) €“ making it less about the organisations and more about the McMahon family feud.
When the Invasion PPV arrived in July, fans were left with a main event that seemed more than a little off-balance on paper. On one side, you had a Hall of Fame team that comprised of a legendary cast: Austin, Taker, Kane, Angle and Jericho. Their opposition, although big names in their own right, were nowhere near the headline attractions to counter this cast of characters that dominated the Monday Night Wars; despite the presence of long-serving Atlanta men, Booker T and Diamond Dallas Page. What should have been WCW Nitro stalwarts like Sting, Goldberg, Hall, Nash and Hogan was instead a mix of notable ECW alumni and WCW names that were still willing to perform outside of their guaranteed contracts. Even without these icons that defined the Monday Night Wars in WCW, heavyweight replacements like Scott Steiner, Lex Luger and Ric Flair were also noticeably absent. It was like watching a band reuniting without the original singer...or lead guitarist...or even the bass player or drummer for that matter. What we were left with was essentially a WCW tribute band of session musicians still using the old band name on a technicality. What was even more baffling was the neglect of the high-profile company staples they did have at their disposal. Key players in ECW history like Raven, Tommy Dreamer and Mike Awesome were all used to little effect despite all being top guys in their old Philly home. Even former ECW Champion, Jerry Lynn, was left out in the cold and ignored completely for the duration of the storyline despite being under contract.
Interestingly enough, there had initially been talks of carrying on the WCW brand as its own show alongside WWF programming; however, the decision to nix this idea €“ reportedly following a poorly received WCW Title match between Booker T and Buff Bagwell on Raw €“ proved to be an equally dangerous move. The resultant angle that followed proved that there was no Plan B after the WWF-owned €œWCW shows€ were canned. While there were some plus points to the Invasion angle €“ the rise of Rob Van Dam being a memorable highlight €“ the whole ordeal served more as an exhibition for WWF stars to showcase their superiority over their former competition. Even the headline spots within The Alliance were eventually given to WWF €œdefectors€ in order to cover for the perceived lack of star power in the inherited WCW/ECW talent pool. The last legitimate WCW Heavyweight Champion, Booker T, was a prime example of this pro-WWF bias, as he quickly lost his Alliance leadership status following Steve Austin€™s switch and would soon lose his coveted WCW Championship crown to The Rock upon his return to action at SummerSlam €˜01.
Soon enough, the storyline had run its course and the WCW/ECW Alliance had lost the war once again. Vince McMahon and his WWF had inevitably regained their dominance with The Rock pinning long-time rival, Steve Austin, to secure sole supremacy for the Fed in the winner-take-all showdown at the Survivor Series; bringing the Invasion angle and The Alliance to an abrupt end. Ironically, the megastars that would have made the WCW Invasion truly awesome would all join the WWF/WWE in the coming months and years, starting the very next night on Raw. Flair would appear the night after Survivor Series as the new €œco-owner€; Hogan, Hall and Nash would surface the following February in nWo colours; while Scott Steiner would debut in late €™02 at the Survivor Series. Even Bill Goldberg would eventually find himself in a WWE ring, making his impact the night after WrestleMania XIX by spearing a hole through The Rock himself.
Had those men been on the team sheet when WCW stepped up to bat in May of 2001, chances are the resulting dream matches and storylines would have been a string of home runs and the wrestling landscape today could be a whole different world to behold.

Contributor
Contributor

Occasional wrestler, full-time gym rat and lifelong lover of the grapple game. Would probably buy you a shot of Jack at the bar in exchange for witty banter...and preferably more Jack. @MartynGrant88 for more wrestling-related musings and weight room wisecracks!