10 Biggest Winners & Losers From WWE Backlash 2018

These Superstars defined WWE Backlash 2018...for better or worse.

WWE Backlash 2018 Seth Rollins The Miz
WWE.com

Any WWE pay-per-view is certain to have its fair share of winners and losers, Superstars who experienced creative highs and lows over the course of the ungodly long special presentations the company produces on its official streaming network, and the 2018 edition of Backlash was no different Sunday night.

The winners were those Superstars who seized the spotlight, delivering performances that stole the show and positioned them favorably to enjoy a red-hot summer in Vince McMahon's company.

They will enter the coming week of television prepared to shine even brighter, capitalizing on the roll they suddenly find themselves on.

The losers, on the other hand, suffered from questionable booking and lackluster performances that hurt their momentum and left their immediate futures in question.

They will face this week's television with one goal in mind: a quick recovery that puts them in the position to thrive as Money in the Bank approaches.

Where does intercontinental champion Seth Rollins find himself? How about his Shield teammate Roman Reigns? Was AJ Styles or Shinsuke Nakamura able to overcome relatively disappointing booking on the road to Backlash and emerge as "winners"?

The answers regarding those Superstars and more lie within.

10. Loser: Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan's return to the squared circle should mean so much more than it does.

Instead, he has been shuffled into the midcard and the pop that greeted him Sunday in Newark reflected as much. The crowd was not nearly as into the bearded wonder as they should have been, and with good reason. What should have been a momentous comeback has, instead, become an afterthought of sorts.

Bryan was tasked with putting over Big Cass Sunday night, bumping around the squared circle and really hammering home the ferocity of the big man. Though he won the match, the entire ordeal fell flat with the audience.

Making matters worse was that Bryan, a Superstar that has caught his fair share of ass kickings in the past, was stupid enough to turn his back on Cass and catch another.

Despite the victory, Bryan was portrayed as a typical nerd babyface Sunday rather than the courageous underdog that has fought through obstacles his entire career and continues to do so as he chases championship gold.

It is a version of the character fans will not be so quick to throw their belief and support behind.


9. Loser: Nia Jax

Alexa Bliss Nia Jax
WWE.com

The manner in which WWE Creative has consistently booked Nia Jax since her babyface turn prior to WrestleMania has completely lost sight of what made her such an appealing character in the first place.

It was not because she was an inspirational Superstar who fought off insults about her weight and other bullying tactics to become champion. No, they loved her because she met confrontation head-on and obliterated it with an unmatched fury.

While there was a hint of that Jax Sunday night at Backlash, the post-match promo she cut moments after successfully retaining the Raw Women's Championship against Alexa Bliss unraveled all of it.

Cutting a promo straight out of WWE's Be A Star program, she was greeted with boos by a WWE Universe that simply does not buy it.

They want Goldberg and Vader, not whatever it is WWE is trying to accomplish with Jax. They want a badass, not


8. Winner: Carmella

WWE Backlash 2018 Carmella Charlotte
WWE.com

The amount of trust management has in Carmella to be a long-term women's champion was on display Sunday during her SmackDown Women's Championship defense against Charlotte.

Not only was she allowed to get some considerable offense in on The Queen, she would eventually take advantage of a momentary opening and pin the former titleholder clean in the center of the ring.

The win not only lent credibility to Carmella's reign as champion, it earned her legitimacy as a wrestler. Early in the match, it appeared as though WWE would take the Honky Tonk Man approach with The Princess of Staten Island.

She avoided contact, rolled to the outside of the ring and teased leaving with her title, content to retain via countout.

Instead, she seized control, survived a comeback and retained her title.

On a show featuring heels like Big Cass, Samoa Joe, Shinsuke Nakamura, Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn, it was Carmella who was booked the best and strongest.

Whether WWE Creative can continue building on the momentum Carmella has after the show, or if she will descend into the formulaic booking that adversely affects most heels in WWE, remains to be seen.


7. Loser: Randy Orton

randy orton jeff hardy
WWE.com

When Randy Orton is unmotivated or simply does not care about a match or storyline, it typically shows in his work.

Sunday was no different.

The Viper challenged Jeff Hardy in a match for the United States Championship that was disjointed and never once lived up to the quality of their previous matches. It was slow, disjointed and largely uninteresting. There was a decided lack of urgency on the part of the performers but it was Orton's rather lethargic offense, around which the match was built, that really doomed it to its eventual subpar quality.

It is disappointing given the roll Orton had been in at the start of the year. His work with Jinder Mahal and Bobby Roode has seemingly awakened in Orton a desire to have good-to-great matches on a nightly basis.

Sunday, with Hardy, that desire appeared to have dissipated in favor of a sleepwalking performance that never clicked.

That he lost clean in the center of the ring with a sense of finality that makes a rematch unlikely probably did not help his motivation.

At all.


6. Loser: SmackDown Live

AJ Styles Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

SmackDown Live is consistently presented as the B-show of WWE.

When the company presents a largely inconsequential pay-per-view event like Backlash and still sees fit to put the WWE Championship match third from the top of the card, in order to spotlight Raw's Braun Strowman and Roman Reigns, it only confirms suspicions that the blue brand is inferior to the red one in the eyes of management.

Now factor in Samoa Joe's loss to Reigns in the night's main event and never before has it been more apparent that WWE Creative simply does not invest as much in SmackDown as it does in Raw.

The company had the opportunity to present Styles-Nakamura as the main event match fans deserve from the rivalry and instead, it not only shoved it down the card, it booked an incredibly lame finish that ensures fans of the blue brand will have to watch the two trade low blows for another six weeks before they finally culminate their program in some sort of gimmicky match at Money in the Bank.

As for Joe, it is difficult to take him seriously as a potential number one contender to Styles or Nakamura when he dominated Reigns only to fall to his trademark spear.

On a night where the Raw brand did not have much in the way of anything urgent to present, Backlash should have been a showcase for SmackDown.


5. Winner: The Miz

The Miz Seth Rollins
WWE.com

There are few Superstars in today's WWE who can prove they are worthy of having an entire show built around them. Miz not only did that during his run on Raw, he backed it up at every turn, routinely partaking in the best match on many an episode of WWE's flagship. Ditto for pay-per-view.

Sunday, he challenged Seth Rollins for the Intercontinental Championship in a barnburner of an opening match. Though he ate a curb stomp and lost the match, it is impossible to deny the growth Miz has made as a worker.

Here is a Superstar who, in 2011, was left for dead after a failed run as WWE champion. He was beaten down, survived an ill-fated babyface run and never let his lackluster position in the company hurt his desire to be the best he could.

He exploded back into the spotlight through a series of strong promos and in 2016, cut the most impassioned promo of his career. A passionate performer, he has always been an engaging verbal performer. As a worker, he has progressed to the point that he is one of the most dependable on the roster.

He has perfected an in-ring formula that routinely produces great matches and Sunday, it was on full display as he worked Rollins in a show-stealer that not only boosted his profile as a wrestler but, also, heightened the significance of the intercontinental Championship.


4. Loser: Big Cass

big cass daniel bryan
WWE.com

Big Cass dominated the action Sunday night, pummeling Daniel Bryan throughout their match. He manhandled Bryan and dominated the action. If WWE was absolutely sold on him as one of the faces of SmackDown's bright future, he probably should have bowled right over Bryan and scored an impressive, one-sided even, victory over the former WWE champion.

Instead, his onslaught was rendered meaningless when he was caught with a single kick to the head and trapped in the YES! Lock before tapping out.

For all the damage he did to Bryan, Cass fell to a single strike and submission.

You could argue that makes Bryan look like a fluke and thus, an even bigger loser, but Cass looked weak. He looked like a big man unable to finish the job. Despite considerable heat for his beatdown of Bryan after the match, complete with chants of "you tapped out," it was the manner in which his loss came about that could have longer-term effects on his ability to succeed at the top of the card.

That he continues to lack something, a something that is really quite difficult to pinpoint at this point, only renders his situation direr. He needs a signature win badly and a performance that earns the trust of fans even worse.

Until that happens, the likelihood that the Big Cass Experiment crashes and burns is as large as he.


3. Winner: Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns Samoa Joe
WWE.com

One can look at the disappointing quality of his match with Samoa Joe and declare Roman Reigns a big loser from Sunday's Backlash but the fact that The Big Dog headlined a show in a match where no title was up for grabs, and no rivalry would advance past that night, only serves as proof that Vince McMahon and Co. are not at all finished presenting Reigns as the face of the company.

Two straight losses to Brock Lesnar (at WrestleMania and The Greatest Royal Rumble) may have had some questioning whether Reigns is still the man in WWE. His position on the card and his win over a relatively hot heel in Joe quiet the doubters and set Reigns up for one more dance with Lesnar.

The Big Dog is, and always has been, poised for all-time greatness in WWE. A rough patch is not at all enough to diminish his status with the promotion.

Yes, WWE may be eyeing up Braun Strowman for a run with the Universal Championship and it may have Bobby Lashley at its disposal, ready for a significant run when called upon, but it has been a long time since Reigns was involved in a meaningless pay-per-view match like the two of them were Sunday.

There is a reason for that.

He is, and will continue to be, the top star in Vince McMahon's universe for years to come.

Especially if fans keep greeting him with the loudest reaction of the night.


2. Loser: Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Remember that time Braun Strowman won the Greatest Royal Rumble and had a ton of momentum on his side coming out of the completely unnecessary advertisement for the new Saudi Arabia that somehow resembled the old Saudi Arabia?

Pepperidge Farm remembers.

Unfortunately, it does not look like WWE Creative did.

Strowman, arguably the second-hottest babyface in the company behind Seth Rollins, was wasted in a meaningless tag team match that accomplished nothing beyond getting himself, Bobby Lashley, Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens on the card.

Throw in the fact that it was Lashley who scored the pin for his team and you have even more reason to dislike the blatant nature in which WWE Creative wasted one of its hottest stars.

The question is where Strowman goes from here.

Roman Reigns' victory in the main event suggests he may have one more dance with Brock Lesnar over the Universal Championship coming up. That would seemingly leave Strowman out of the title picture for the time being. If that is the case, what does he do?

He has already bowled over Zayn and Owens and brutalized Elias. Could a showdown with Baron Corbin await him?

Whatever the case may be, it is a major step down for a Superstar who, for all intents and purposes, should be waging war at the top of the card.


1. Winner: Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Burn It Down is as apropos a catchphrase for Seth Rollins as there is because The Kingslayer did not just steal the show from the opening match, he burnt the damn thing to the ground, courtesy of another stellar performance in his victory over The Miz.

The intercontinental champion continued his red-hot roll, delivering a performance that essentially cemented any claim he had to being the best wrestler in WWE thus far in 2018. He was crisp, fast and on-target with all of his spots. His selling of Miz's attack on his knee was, for the most part, superb and added drama to many of the contest's near-falls and false finishes.

By the time he escaped a roll-up attempt and planted Miz's face in the mat with his curb stomp finisher, it was safe to say Rollins had accomplished what he hoped by establishing himself as the best champion in WWE.

In the midst of what is arguably the hottest streak of his career, Rollins is turning in performances that will ultimately make it impossible for management to ignore him. In many ways, he has developed into the Bret Hart to Roman Reigns' Lex Luger. He is the fans' choice, the best wrestler on the roster and a Superstar management will not be able to ignore as long as he continues to have the best match on the card every night.


Contributor
Contributor

Erik Beaston is a freelance pro wrestling writer who likes long walks in the park, dandelions and has not quite figured out that this introduction is not for Match.com. He resides in Parts Unknown, where he hosts weekly cookouts with Kane, The Ultimate Warrior, Papa Shango and The Boogeyman. Be jealous.