10 Most Brutual Matches In WWE History

When WWE felt more like ECW.

In the modern PG-era of the WWE it can often feel as though wrestling has lost its edge. We still see great matches between fantastically skilled opponents €“ the company€™s talent pool is arguably at its strongest point ever €“ but that old sense of danger has been greatly diminished. As a fan first brought up on wrestling in the early 2000s, the sudden lack of blood, vulgarity, and downright carnage seems a little disconcerting. In truth, this is probably a good thing. Nobody wants to see anyone hurt or killed on TV, much less their favourite WWE superstars. These new regulations have allowed wrestlers to prolong their careers and attract a whole new fanbase of youngsters. However, there€™s no denying the excitement of a truly violent or shocking moment in a WWE ring. Since it never hurts to look back, here are ten of the most utterly brutal matches of a bygone era.

10. Steve Austin & Triple H vs Chris Jericho & Chris Benoit €“ Raw, May 2001

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WBKW8gyAxFc We begin with one of only two matches on this list shown on free TV. As the WWE understandably saved its most brutal moments for big Pay Per View events, moments of true mayhem were slightly harder to come by on Raw or Smackdown. Not in the case of this match however. Triple H and Stone Cold were on an absolute tear in the spring of 2000 after the latter€™s shocking heel turn at WrestleMania. They formed a tag team known as the Two Man Power Trip and soon held the company€™s top four titles (the Intercontinental, Tag Team, and WWF championships). Their short reign of terror ended in grisly fashion the night after Judgement Day as they faced off against another pair of rivals-turned-teammates, Chris Jericho and Chris Benoit. The match seemed a standard encounter €“ if a little hard-hitting €“ until Triple H tore his quad tripping over the canvas. He allegedly tore the muscle entirely off the bone, suffering an injury that would keep him out for over eight months. In an unbelievable show of toughness, the Game would see the match out to its conclusion, even allowing Y2J to put him in the Walls of Jericho atop the announce table for an excruciating amount of time. When asked later about why he continued the match, he answered €˜The show goes on. I just picked up the pieces of what was left of my leg and worried about it when it was over.€™ Admirable. And utterly crazy.

9. John Cena vs Rob Van Dam - ECW One Night Stand, June 2006

This match is on the list not for the brutality of its content, but of its atmosphere. Rarely has the WWE seen such an outpouring of hatred from a crowd than for John Cena in New York€™s Hammerstein Ballroom. Admittedly it was predictable. Cena stood for everything the ECW faithful hated: popular, handsome, successful, clean-cut. He also stood in the way of a true ECW alumnus, the beloved Rob Van Dam, so the poisonous air was a surprise to nobody that night. On an evening in which Randy Orton had already been punched by a young child on the way to the ring, Cena found himself greeted by a wall of noise €“ not exactly the cheers he was used to on Raw. As the now-infamous €œIf Cena Wins We Riot€ sign waved in the background, the WWE champion removed his t-shirt and threw it into the crowd. It came almost immediately back to him. He tried again, and again it was returned with interest. The message was clear: we don€™t want you here, you€™re not our kind. Thankfully he didn€™t win; there was no riot. Instead he masterfully took everything the crowd threw at him and used it to goad them further, each successful manoeuvre greeted by a groan or boo, until RVD€™s eventual victory threatened to blow the roof off. Although the antithesis of everything ECW stood for, Cena must be held majorly responsible for bringing the promotion€™s sense of danger and violence back to mainstream wrestling. Even if he did so by being absolutely despised.

8. Kurt Angle vs Brock Lesnar - WrestleMania 19, March 2003

It would have been the best ending to a WrestleMania ever. Brock Lesnar, the next big thing in wrestling, defeating established champion Kurt Angle for the title...with a shooting star press!? A man of Lesnar€™s stature should never be able to execute that move, a full backflip from the top rope onto an opponent below. It€™s a feat only pulled off by the industry€™s most nimble cruiserweights, yet Lesnar had proven he was capable, performing it in his younger days at the WWE€™s developmental facility. Except he couldn€™t. Not two years later in front of 53,000 people at the biggest event in wrestling. The crowd gasped €“ first in awe, then in horror €“ as Brock took off from the top rope, rotated slightly, and landed sickeningly on his neck. Nobody would have been surprised if the match had been called off there and then; it was a miracle he was still breathing. The quick-thinking Angle improvised a pinfall attempt, which Lesnar somehow kicked out of. Summoning the strength from somewhere as his face turned an unhealthy shade of red, Brock hoisted Kurt onto his shoulders, hit the F-5, and ended the match. It was still one of the most awe-inspiring main events €˜Mania had ever seen, but not quite for the reasons intended.

7. Mick Foley vs Edge €“ WrestleMania 22, April 2006

A quick warning here €“ this is not the only time Mick Foley will feature on this countdown. Unsurprising, I know. Edge€™s stock was rising rapidly at this point in his career, his transition from clean-cut babyface to the self-proclaimed €œRated R Superstar€ a major success. Despite this, he still needed a match to prove he had the toughness to be regarded as a force at the top of the card. Enter Mick Foley. Mick had made a career out of breaking bodies, both his opponents€™ and his own, and this bout met all the expectations that came with it. All the gruesome Foley hallmarks were there. Barbed wire? Check. Thumbtacks? Check. Bleeding? It would be rude not to. The match was warming up nicely, but things really escalated when Edge€™s girlfriend Lita pulled out a bottle of lighter fluid. A table was propped up outside the ring and set ablaze. Somebody was going through that, but the danger of the sequence which followed shocked just about everybody in the Allstate Arena. Edge speared Foley out of the ring and through the table, amazingly taking the brunt of the blow himself face first. He went on to win the match, his tough-guy credentials proven once and for all. Foley had played his part in establishing a new star, just as he had done many times previously...

6. Cactus Jack vs Triple H - Royal Rumble, January 2000

Another example of Foley establishing a hot new wrestler as a legitimate superstar came at the first Pay Per View of the new Millennium, the Royal Rumble. Triple H had sporadically held the WWF Championship throughout 1999, but had yet to truly get himself over with the fans as a dominant threat. Foley helped see to that, this time in the guise of his psychotic alter-ego Cactus Jack. While fire was the crucial ingredient of Foley€™s later match with Edge, the weapon of choice here was a sack of thumbtacks. Towards the end of the match Mick emptied the sack out in the middle of the ring. Both men teased moves near the tacks until, in perhaps the most likely outcome, it was Foley himself who took the horrific bump. The crowd came unstuck as Triple H backdropped his poor opponent right onto the tacks, dozens upon dozens embedding themselves in his flesh. The Game then covered Foley and won the match. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-QTkPmdkZw Just kidding. To everybody€™s horror, Mick kicked out and the match continued. It took an even worse blow to end the bout for good, a nightmarish pedigree face-first into the remaining tacks. As if to prove any watching sceptics wrong, the camera caught a number of them clearly sticking out of Foley€™s forehead as the referee counted to three.

5. Edge & Christian vs The Dudley Boyz vs The Hardy Boyz €“ WrestleMania 16, April 2000

Watching this match provides both feelings of nostalgia and perspective. There are a lot of stars in this one; Jeff Hardy and Edge both went on to hold multiple world championships and become faces of the wrestling world, Christian became an internet darling for his underrated in-ring ability, and the others all went on to enjoy established careers in the WWE and TNA. Yet here they are, all newcomers within their first few years of the World Wrestling Federation, dicing with death on the midcard of WrestleMania 2000. The match is simply too anarchic to summarise in concise fashion. It€™s mainly remembered for Jeff€™s ungodly dive from the top of a ladder onto a prone Bubba Ray below, but there are too many set pieces of a similarly death-defying nature to count. The six men paved the way for the particular hybrid of high-flying and hardcore action we see all the time in the WWE nowadays. TLC matches, the Money in the Bank PPV, an influx of talent based on bravery and athleticism rather than muscle mass €“ all changes which can be traced back to this one bout at the turn of the century. There€™s a certain fondness shared between the six men for this match. Bubba Ray recently tweeted commemorating its 14th anniversary, while Edge gleefully revealed D-Von€™s unlikely fear of highs on Chris Jericho€™s podcast. Although every match on this last can claim to be brutal, not all of them carry the same degree of innovation as this one.

4. Kurt Angle vs Shane McMahon - King Of The Ring, June 2001

A lot of the matches we€™ve covered so far are hard to watch €“ what€™s more uncomfortable than seeing professional wrestlers bleed and break themselves in the name of entertainment? Well, how about non-wrestlers doing the same? Shane McMahon had already shown himself to be slightly unhinged after taking a couple of incredibly high falls from the side of the WWE TitanTron, but that didn€™t compare to the punishment he received at King of the Ring. Angle didn€™t exactly escape the match unscathed either (actually ending up in hospital once the show was over courtesy of a damaged tailbone). The latter half of the match included a sequence in which Shane was to be hurled through several panes of sugar glass, but Kurt€™s back injury meant that he couldn€™t get the required power behind the throw to do so. That and the fact they€™d bought the wrong type of glass. At the first attempt, Shane bounced sickeningly off the pane and landed on his head and neck. Angle reportedly wanted to skip to the finish of the match, but Shane insisted that they complete the move. It took Kurt five attempts to throw his opponent through two panes of glass, the last one headfirst. It left both men horribly lacerated, Shane€™s forehead in particular coated with blood. In a later interview Angle claimed that he €œhad a blast€, proving that wrestlers€™ minds don€™t quite work the way a normal human€™s does.

€€€3. The Rock vs Mankind - Royal Rumble, January 1999

Surprise! It€™s the return of Mick Foley again, this time in his persona of masked lunatic Mankind. It€™s important to note that all of Foley€™s gimmicks are essentially variations on a very simple theme: deranged psychopath. This match is even more infamous with the benefit of hindsight, now that chairshots to the head are regarded as a cause of serious long-term damage. In perhaps the most brutal chair-based assault in wrestling history, The Rock handcuffed Mick€™s hands behind his back and swung for a home run. Heeding Foley€™s pre-match instructions, Rock was relentless in his attack, battering his opponent with headshot after headshot. While clearly an incredibly brutal bout, this match is also a very poignant one. Immortalised in the highly critical Beyond The Mat wrestling documentary, Rock vs Mankind is notorious for driving Foley€™s infant daughter to tears at ringside. It forces an often unconsidered side-effect of wrestling to the fore €“ the effect such a dangerous profession can have on the performers€™ families.

2. Eddie Guerrero vs JBL - Judgement Day, May 2004

It seems illogical to have a match including dozens of chairshots at number three on the list while this match €“ featuring one of note €“ is at number two. That€™s until you see the chairshot in question. For those unsure about how bleeding works in wrestling, it€™s a trick known as €˜blading€™. The wrestler uses a tiny razor to cut himself, usually near the hairline where blood can flow less dangerously and dramatically. So when JBL smashed Eddie with a chair in the main event of Judgement Day, he collapsed to the floor and prepared to blade. The only problem is that he cut himself too deeply. Way too deeply. I€™m not particularly squeamish about blood, but this match was still incredibly difficult to watch. Guerrero lay back and the crowd gasped in horror as blood literally squirted from his forehead onto his chest. Even his opponent seemed unsure about what to do, but they continued the match anyway.
The excessive blood actually made Eddie€™s climactic comeback much more dramatic, but everybody would agree that his wellbeing was in serious danger that night.

1. Mankind vs The Undertaker €“ King Of The Ring, June 1998

The selection of this match as the most brutal in WWE€™s history will come as no surprise to anybody who has seen it. If you haven€™t, you probably should. It€™s not only the company€™s most brutal match, but one of its most famous. The unforgettable sight of Foley plummeting from the top of the cell structure through the announce table is still used in countless video packages by the WWE to this day (usually begging the viewer not to try this at home). It is truly part of wrestling folklore. Mick has since claimed that the more dangerous of the two terrible falls he suffered that day was the latter, but everybody remembers the first. With an ungraceful, almost ugly motion, Undertaker grabbed Mankind and carted him clean off the top of the cell. Watching it today it looks impossible €“ illogical even. The human body shouldn€™t be in such a situation, let alone survive it. The second fall, a chokeslam on top of the structure, actually did more damage to Foley as a panel of the cell roof surprisingly gave way. Undertaker later stated that he thought he€™d killed Mick as he crashed into the ring below, the impact dislocating his jaw and driving a tooth through his lip. It must have hurt like hell, not that Foley can remember. He had to watch a tape of the match to write about it in his autobiography. Watching such matches are something of a guilty pleasure for a wrestling fan. It€™s probably for the best that such extreme occurrences are no longer commonplace in WWE programming, but nobody familiar with the contests of this list can surely deny their compelling nature.

Content Producer
Content Producer

Highly overrated 23 year old from the North East of England. Hanging off of your gangster car.