10 Buried Treasures That Could Leave WWE Before 2018

Forgotten but not gone.

Wolfgang Tyler Bate
WWE.com

For every fantastical childhood tale of a pirate or explorer at long last discovering a bounty they'd only heard or dreamt about from mythical stories of their own, the accompanying illustration is almost always of a dusty old chest with a beaming bullion inside. The stark contrast between the two is by design. Highlighting the worth of the treasure and the glory of the find, the shimmering jewels and glistening gold promise wealth and prosperity to the recipient as reward for their quest.

Vince McMahon's hidden fortune sadly only exists because of his overt actual one.

A monolithic enterprise perhaps beyond anything anybody in the wrestling industry ever thought possible, WWE is the sprawling market leader of an industry it helped redefine, but has become too big to service all the muscular rank-and-file that helped maintain its lofty presence.

With three main roster broadcasts, one touring developmental brand and a host of offshoot projects to service a growing Network, the company continues to attempt to be all things to all fans as wrestling itself goes through something of a contemporary boom period.

Ultimately though, the organisation's pressing concern should be the vast array of talent still locked out of the writers room, but locked in WWE's treasure chest. Laying dormant or in need of fresh discovery, these gems threaten to remain hidden unless the biggest swashbuckler of all remembers how he amassed such enormous riches in the first place.

10. Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

The horrific current incarnation of Dolph Ziggler's freewheeling midcarder act is destined to end in defeat at the hands of Bobby Roode, but could this unending parade of entrances finally mark his exit?

'The Show Off' need only look to Drew McIntyre, Cody Rhodes and countless others that have sought and found fortune elsewhere in wrestling as the industry constantly expands and evolves. In truth, he probably doesn't have a lot longer before he loses his caché with the the very audience that would have furnished a prosperous run mirroring the impressive efforts of his peers.

Dolph was once the maligned figure of the WWE midcard. An energetic, hard-working babyface with an impactful style and a host of memorable matches, he was the big-bumping bestie of WWE's hipster corner. The growth of NXT sadly marked the start of Dolph's downward spiral, both in the eyes of company decision makers and the fans that once fought his corner.

With a new cause to get behind or maligned star to magnify, those fans only had time for selected idols, and Ziggler fell further out of favour. A loser that just keeps losing and perceived as such by nearly all the millions that watch him weekly, it may be now or never for Dolph.


9. The Colóns

WWE Money In The Bank 2017 Hype Bros Colons
WWE.com

The Colons made a surprise switch to SmackDown Live! in April 2017's 'Superstar shake-up', but the biggest shock about it was that WWE management even remembered that they existed.

Token jobbers on Monday Night Raw, they immediately fulfilled the same role on the blue brand, despite early success against an American Alpha duo also destined for disaster. A July knee injury shelved Primo, leaving Epico perhaps more relieved than rueing his bad luck when the company elected to keep the act off television altogether whilst his brother convalesced.

Though Primo is now fit to return, The Colon act is profoundly not. A dead horse already beaten beyond recognition, their wafer-thin timeshare salesmen gimmick was doomed from the first vignette, and their trajectory looked equally stilted in a brief repackaging as miscast Tuesday night bad-asses.

In 2014, Primo, Epico and ex-roster member Carlito inducted father and Puerto Rican wrestling icon Carlos into the WWE Hall Of Fame. The former apple-spitting Intercontinental Champion stole the stage and the show. With charisma so effortless that it was just too laid back for WWE management to fully understand when he was on the main roster, Carlito may have missed his window. Only considered utility men despite their fabulous talents, his brother and cousin never really had it opened a crack for them in the first place.


8. Mickie James

Emma Mickie James
WWE.com

When the former WWE Womens and Divas Champion surprisingly reemerged to lose to Asuka at November 2016's NXT TakeOver: Toronto, a main roster return seemed assured following her high quality display.

Though somewhat silly in execution, her placement as Becky Lynch's masked assailant 'La Luchadora' at least placed her at the top of SmackDown Live's burgeoning division alongside Alexa Bliss, but a sharp loss of interest from the creative team in continuing either the rivalry or relationship resulted in her making up the numbers at WrestleMania then moving across to Monday Night Raw to share the absolute lowest spot on the totem pole with Dana Brooke.

With a healthy following carried over from her original run and an in-ring ability matching the expected quality benchmark now on display weekly, her perplexing demotion seems to imply that WWE perhaps consider her too long in the tooth for a front-facing role in their wobbly 'revolution'.

It's misguided of course, with Natalya astutely playing something of a veteran on SmackDown Live!, and James' television age offset by the wealth of new opponents and combinations that stand before her. But none of those bouts look to be forthcoming. Too talented not to feature prominently somewhere, but in danger of being further overlooked as Mae Young Classic participants filter through, James could and should carefully consider all her options.


7. Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows

sheamus cesaro anderson gallows
WWE.com

A recent edition of Monday Night Raw saw Sheamus, Cesaro, Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins spew out line after line of pitiful and unconvincing dialogue to fill time before the inevitable brawl. The performances weren't remotely believable, but then neither was the verbiage.

Then, subtly saving the day as they so often do, Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson interrupted, bringing the crowd into proceedings with the various beats of their usual spiels and the 'NERDS' anti-catchphrase that has continued to get over in spite of some senseless booking.

Like many midcarders, Gallows and Anderson are required to lose. A lot. But unlike the nervous-looking contemporaries on both broadcasts, they don't lose their dedicated following, nor confidence, in defeat. One of the bottom rung sides since Matt and Jeff Hardy returned to the fold at WrestleMania 33, the former 'Club' members have been left to rot on the main roster with no end in sight as returns for The Revival and a rumoured roster switch for The Usos seemingly rendering them only more surplus to requirements on Monday Nights.

Short of a SmackDown Live! reunion with AJ Styles, it seems as thought the former Bullet Club members would be far more satisfied outside the bubble than within it. They're goodbrothers, they deserve it.


6. The Hype Bros

Mojo Rawley Zack Ryder The Hype Bros
WWE.com

Mojo Rawley attempted to convincingly stare off into the middle distance as he delivered an ominous foretelling of their future. He failed, of course, but his message was as loud and clear as his green ring gear.

Peering into the hardened soul of Zack Ryder, Rawley declared 'If we want things to change, we're going to have to do something drastic', before turning his back to return to his less-than-hyped stance.

The 2017 Andre The Giant Battle Royal winner has had a year that loosely resembles the 12 months that followed for Cesaro, The Big Show and Baron Corbin following their own victories. WWE's new poisoned chalice in the absence of the King Of The Ring crown and cape, the pyrrhic victory has saddled each performer with expectations too lofty over the years, and Mojo was hardly placed to reverse the curse despite empty gestures about getting serious or whatever a superstar says when they acknowledge a stalling tenure.

Meanwhile, Zack Ryder persists. Actual dreams repeatedly crushed and replaced by corporately-agreed goals, his lengthy stint as a WWE Superstar has presumably satiated his lifelong goal to be part of the machine (and reinvest in it by the looks of his toy collections), but a brave new world awaits him beyond Titan Tower's shimmering frontage. He tried and failed to smash a glass ceiling by himself, it's perhaps time to kick down a fire exit instead.


5. Tony Nese

Tony Nese Ab Workout Tree Of Woe Kick Jack Gallagher 205 Live
WWE.com

Popstar Shakira once seductively sang of hips not lying, and it should only be presume she was foretelling the world of Tony Nese' magnificent physique when she spun her yarn on dance and desire.

If the above gif doesn't adequately explain a) why 'The Premier Athlete' has been grossly mishandled by WWE and b) how ignored 205 Live really is, then no further words will do the job in its place.

A fine all-rounder, Nese would have been a revelation in any incarnation of Vince McMahon's empire other than the one he's found himself in. An exquisitely obnoxious heel with a physique becoming increasingly rarer in today's industry and a dynamic in-ring arsenal to match, Nese is a total package in 2017 that sadly entered into the company through a Cruiserweight Classic side door.

The Cruiserweights of WWE in the modern age have become the Divas of the mid-2000s. On Raw, their matches can be timed in seconds more than minutes and rarely have a point beyond establish one queued character at a time for a run at perennial Champion Neville. Things do actually happen on the Network-only Tuesday Night vehicle, but when an atrocious WCW pay-per-view from 1998 out-rates it on the over-the-top service, do they really?

The entire lightweight crew deserve better, but Nese's lack of even one pay-per-view crack at the 'King Of The Cruiserweights' should signpost where his future lies the longer he stays put.


4. Pete Dunne

Pete Dunne Trent Seven WWE Tryout
WWE.com

The current UK Champion may not be the biggest surprise departure to come in 2017 from the once-favoured British Isles crew (more on that later), but a lack of clear direction for his career with or without the title in WWE's muddled experimental project may result in a refocused outlook for the ultra-talented 'Bruiserweight'.

Alongside Tyler Bate and Trent Seven, Dunne is part the enormously popular 'British Strong Style' triumvirate on one side of the Atlantic whilst portraying an equal-opportunities offender on the other. Elsewhere on home soil independents and beyond, Dunne masterfully portrays a hard-hitting babyface or killer heel as required, at one point in 2017 holding multiple top titles as recognition of his excellence in the field.

As WWE continue drag their feet in launching whatever the UK concept is designed to be, Dunne only looks weaker in his position atop it. The Birmingham-born battler may find himself with more to lose in reputation than financially there is to gain, particularly if Vince McMahon shelves the idea entirely but wishes to keep the elite of his UK selection on retainers for utility spots in NXT.


3. Rusev & Lana

Rusev Lana
WWE.com

Though Rusev gained a modicum of revenge for his embarrassing SummerSlam defeat against Randy Orton with a split-second victory over 'The Apex Predator' on SmackDown Live!, a 'proper' return match with Randy seems likely to doom 'The Bulgarian Brute' to another high profile defeat.

Receiving a reverse push of sorts since moving to SmackDown Live! in April's 'Superstar Shake-up', the former United States Champion was positioned against John Cena in another feud with 'The Champ' he was destined to lose, and a threat to take out a 'legend' has only resulted in a protracted war against the former 'Legend Killer'.

Meanwhile, Lana has found similar stasis after a second stumbling separation from her real-life husband. WWE seem desperate to part the talented pair, but their latest amicable severance hasn't served the 'Ravishing Russian' any better than the disorganised original.

First given a woeful dancing gimmick then routinely mocked on-screen by her peers for a limited array of moves in matches she was forced to have, Lana has reverted to her a role she's excelled in at ringside, but instead accompanies charisma vacuum Tamina instead of her fiendishly entertaining spouse.

They decided for themselves a long time ago that they belonged together for real, but WWE's determination to overlook said chemistry could be enough to force both out to pastures news.


2. Tyler Bate

Tyler Bate
WWE.com

The inaugural United Kingdom Champion this week tasted defeat alongside Moustache Mountain comrade Trent Seven as the pair made up the numbers on NXT, but Tyler Bate's biggest loss this year was perhaps defined by his biggest victory.

An unlikely but rewarding winner of January's UK Title tournament, Bate's emergence at such a young age was presented as a fairytale finish despite his well-rounded experience on the British independent scene and on select shows around the world. As Champion though, his reign peaked the night he held the title aloft in Blackpool's beautiful Empress Ballroom.

Without opponents to defend the title against nor a single clear outline of the division's future, Bate was left to tiptoe through history, taking the title with him to independent shows to the sounds of longterm fan gasps. Until the novelty wore off.

Having barely appeared for the organisation, his first significant appearance ended in definitive defeat to Pete Dunne in an NXT TakeOver: Chicago match many consider to be the best match of the year. Far from finding reward for his efforts, his was again plunged into obscurity as new titleholder Dunne gobbled up the scraps WWE threw to their former pet projects.

Possibly a hindrance rather than a help, Bate's relationship with the company already seems less mutually beneficial than the 20-year-old deserves, and a refresher away from the empire might be what he needs to protect his embryonic topline career.


1. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan Beard
WWE

Daniel Bryan's relentless teases of returning to the squared circle as soon as he's permitted could result in an early departure from the WWE fold if recent new contract squabbles are to be believed.

Appearing to grow gradually more impatient with physical restrictions placed upon him and actively courting contests with the best and brightest from around the world as independent wrestlers continue to achieve mainstream attention without Vince McMahon's marketing machine, Bryan's disinterest is morbidly entertaining despite his best efforts as SmackDown Live!'s comedically powerless Commissioner.

Though presumably satisfied with the money he earns whilst supporting his young family, the 'Yes Man' has made no secret of what truly fuels him. Willing and able to live thriftily thanks to his earth-friendly philosophies, Bryan's last chase is bigger even than his unlikely WrestleMania 30 title challenge.

Looking for competition in an arena where few could out-perform him, he continues to be trapped amongst hundreds that do it half as well, in front of millions that will gradually forget that he even can. It's nailed on that he'll look to remedy that in 2018, but with some companies hosting some of their major events before his current deal expires, it's wholly possible that he'll campaign for a much sharper exit.


In this post: 
Tyler Bate
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.