10 Changes That Would Enhance WWE's TV
Five hours of WWE TV within 48 hours? Good luck.
Being a wrestling fan might just be more destructive than it is satisfying.
Due to the nature of predetermined matches, many of us probably have the phrase "yeah I would have done that differently" ingrained into our minds. Due to this, many wrestling fans have expanded upon that and now believe they could probably run WWE better than it's currently being run... but the reality is we aren't a great deal better.
While a lot of credit has to be given to the creative team, the writers, the producers and Vince McMahon himself, plenty of work could still be done to revamp the company. Sometimes a small change can make a huge impact, and WWE still has plenty of tiny flaws that honestly aren't even that difficult to fix.
Even with a roster as stacked as theirs is right now, sitting through five hours of WWE television within a 48 hour period remains a daunting task. While we're probably never going to see Raw shrink down to two hours, WWE can at least try to make those three hours as enjoyable as possible.
10. Commentary Changes
Renee Young's official replacement of Jonathon Coachman is a great start, but the impact of commentary could be so much greater if they weren't so heavily structured.
With Vince in the ears of the commentary team, their delivery and topics constantly feel both rigid and forced. No matter what's happening in the ring, the commentary is always trying to sell you on something. Whether it's a match being built to or a literal product WWE wants to sell, the painfully obvious goal of the commentary team is getting you to buy something.
That's not even necessarily a bad thing, WWE is a business and for that business to thrive, they need network buys, app downloads, and sponsors to get their commission. It's completely fair, but they don't always need to make it so obvious and clearly structured.
No matter what Michael Cole is saying at the time, you know it will eventually lead to the word "Sunday", because that's where the real focus is. Sometimes that can be a serious damper to what's actually taking place in the ring at that moment. Allow for looser commentary that feels both more natural and less like a never-ending sales pitch.
9. Stop 50/50 Booking
Anyone up for another match between Finn Bálor vs. Baron Corbin? Of course you aren't, because you probably don't hate yourself.
50/50 booking is the practice of having a match take place one week with a definite winner and then rehashing the same match in the near future and changing the outcome, hence giving both wrestlers a win over the other. On the surface level, it might seem like this is beneficial for both wrestlers in a way, but truthfully, it isn't. At all.
All 50/50 booking does is put both wrestlers back to where they were when they first started, or in much simpler terms, waste everybody's time. Even worse, about half of the time they do this is for a pay-per-view match. WWE will build up to something that they want you to pay money to watch only to completely reverse the decision the next week on TV... why?!
8. Differentiate The Brands
Besides the colours red and blue, Raw and SmackDown Live! are basically one in the same. Despite being labelled as opposing "brands", it all just looks like plain old WWE to everyone.
Simple changes would go such a long way in terms of differentiating these two shows. Change up the sets so that the shows don't look the exact same, and in turn, change up the production style for one of that show too. You could keep Raw's layout the same and let them have the multiple camera-cuts and crowd shots, then on SmackDown Live! bring in a swooping camera that captures from more angles and only uses that and the hard camera.
Maybe make Raw more of the soap-opera type show with in-depth stories while SmackDown Live! focuses more on simple stories with fantastic wrestling. These are just immediate examples, WWE could delve way deeper into the writing and structure for each show to vary the two up as much as possible.
If you want to sell the concept of "Raw vs. SmackDown", you're going to have to make sure there's actually two sides to the fight.
7. "The Land Of Opportunity"
And speaking of differentiating, just about the only thing that does separate these shows would be SmackDown Live!'s nickname, "The Land Of Opportunity". Only problem is, they've yet to really flesh the concept out.
If SmackDown Live! were to become the more wrestling-based show, this would actually end up working out perfectly. While Raw makes the wrestlers slowly build their momentum up, make every match on Tuesday nights have some sort of meaning, whether it be through championship defenses, contenderships, tournaments, or open challenges to impress the blue brand's authority.
Why not revamp the United States Championship into the borderline open challenge championship and open each SmackDown Live! with any wrestler who wants to step up answering the challenge? Really emphasize that anyone can capitalize on the never-ending opportunities if they put in the work. Show off every single wrestler in some capacity and give everyone the spotlight for at least 10-15 minutes.
Not only will this go a long way in differentiating SmackDown Live! from their red counterpart, but it would show off the incredible depth of their roster.
6. Engaging Backstage Segments
It's almost impressive how similarly fake every single backstage segment looks nowadays. Just compare the backstage vignettes from the early-2000s to the ones in 2018, the difference is almost laughable.
Between those red or blue rooms that have their brand's graphic frozen on a TV behind them to the segments where a wrestler is just awkwardly watching a broadcast of the show (usually standing next to the TV and somehow looking at it?) , the sets themselves usually don't resemble any sort of "backstage" area that actually exists.
In most backstage segments, the camera work and conversations with interviewers will also come across as very odd. Many wrestlers are also just bad at handling them, not knowing how to act outside of a wrestling ring and coming across incredibly awkward.
Between the sets and the interactions with the interviewers, the older style always seemed to present itself as an actual "backstage" segment, and in turn were a lot more realistic. WWE's current format comes across just as forced as the commentary team.
5. Reintroduce Cruiserweights To Raw
Just as 205 Live was becoming fantastic, Raw took them off of their brand and left the cruiserweights to their WWE Network show.
This one is far too simple - literally just put them back on TV. Just bring Cedric Alexander and Kalisto and Buddy Murphy and the whole gang over and let them be as great as their potential has been demanding of them for years now.
The Cruiserweight Classic tournament truly was fantastic, but in a sense it ended up being pretty bittersweet. While it gave us plenty of instant classics, it also peaked the cruiserweight division immediately, leaving them to slowly fall down the mountain over the next two years.
Instead of giving us the mediocre cruiserweight division Raw was showing us, put 205 Live's cruiserweight quality on Monday nights. The show itself has been one of the best parts of 2018, the main issue comes in the fact that no one knows or cares about it since they're just a show on the WWE Network now.
4. Reestablish Tag Team Wrestling
2017 was the year of tag team wrestling. In 2018, WWE have undone much of the excellent work they'd put into making it so.
Despite having talent stacked high, neither tag team division really feels that full. SmackDown Live! suffered a massive blow losing the Bludgeon Brothers as they and the New Day were pretty much the only championship-level team on the brand, while Raw's tag team champions just two weeks ago were the !*$% B-Team.
WWE has so much wasted talent in their tag team divisions: The Revival, Gallows & Anderson, SAnitY, the Authors of Pain are just finally becoming relevant, and it's been so long since either Breezango or even The Ascension did anything of note that everyone's seemed to have forgotten that they've actually been solid acts in the past.
Whether WWE cuts out the filler and mixes the two tag divisions together or just starts booking properly for their divisions, some sort of change is necessary to keep either division alive.
3. No More Pet Projects
If the Roman Reigns experiment proved anything, it's that Vince McMahon's stubbornness will get the best of him. His insistence to push Reigns to the top genuinely put a multi-year damper on WWE's entire product, which in hindsight is just straight up baffling from a business perspective.
WWE will save themselves a lot of time, money, and headache by just allowing the crowds to naturally choose who they want to cheer for instead of trying to manufacture the perfect poster-boy. For the better part of four years, WWE threw away countless opportunities to boost business in favour of throwing Roman at the screen. Imagine if Daniel Bryan could've been the 2015 Royal Rumble winner, or if Braun Strowman actually captured the Universal Championship back in 2017 when he was setting the entire wrestling world on fire.
This is by no means meant to be a Roman Reigns bash, it's just the perfect example of what will eventually happen when Vince's pet projects get the best of him. It's not even just "we don't want to cheer for him so WWE is bad", it's "you guys are missing out on probably millions of dollars by not investing in the right people".
2. No More Superstar Shake-ups
The Superstar Shakeup is awful; it takes everything that made the original 2016 draft great and takes a metaphorical dump all over it.
Remember when Shane and Stephanie actually drafted up picks and tried their hardest to design their dream roster? Remember how impactful it was when AJ Styles was picked up before John Cena? Remember when Finn Bálor was Raw's third draft pick and suddenly everyone, even including those who hadn't seen a minute of NXT, knew he was a big deal?
All of this is completely reversed and ruined by just randomly throwing wrestlers from one side to the other. Wrestlers don't feel valuable when they can just randomly be moved from one side to the other, what's even the point of brand loyalty at that point? Why would a wrestler like Dean Ambrose fight tooth and nail for SmackDown Live! when he can just be pushed over to Raw half a year later?
Switching wrestlers from brand to brand is absolutely crucial; there's only so many feuds that can take place on a single show. WWE just needs a better way of handling the system, such as incorporating a yearly trade or revived draft of some sort.
1. More Show, Less Tell
George Lucas is often criticized as a writer for his insistence to tell you what you're supposed to be feeling instead of just letting the narrative tell the story naturally. WWE is a lot like George Lucas.
Comparing WWE to NXT almost seems unfair, but perhaps the thing NXT does best is just letting the show present itself. At its core, NXT is just a simple professional wrestling show, and it doesn't try to be much more than that. Their commentators are rarely trying to sell you on the importance of women's wrestling, and instead will just let the women put on great matches of their own.
The audience doesn't need to be constantly reminded about things that the in-ring storytelling can be doing itself. Actions speak louder than words. People can become invested in things without shoving it four feet deep down your throat.
Transitioning this mindset to the main roster and just focusing on the action would help create a product that's more of an enjoyment than a chore to invest yourself in.