10 Creepiest Gimmicks In Wrestling Right Now

Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the ring.

Cameron Grimes Dexter Lumis
WWE

Wrestling and horror movies are both enduring cult media. In some ways they are not too dissimilar. Both fans revel in glimpses of blood, follow outlandish character’s seeking revenge in the strangest of actions, and we call it unbelievable but watch it until the closing credits.

The Undertaker’s retirement encouraged fans to reflect on the storied career of ‘The Deadman’. Though ‘Taker evolved from the undead mortician character of his debut, many of his most iconic moments are motivated by the supernatural side.

In such a successful career, many future stars may look to wrestling’s bizarre, supernatural, and creepy depths for inspiration. However, this would be to overlook a key fact. The Undertaker worked because of the talent, commitment, and business acumen of Mark Calaway.

As the late ‘90s Ministry of Darkness storyline proved, slapping on a supernatural gimmick isn’t a guarantee to success. Thankfully, there are numerous wrestlers keeping the creepy and macabre side of wrestling relevant, through their innovative creativity both in and out of the ring.

Get ready to meet your new nightmare … In … Night of the Elite Dead, Impact’s Alive, I Know What You Did Last SummerSlam, or even a heavily misinterpreted remake of The Ring.

10. Alexa Bliss (WWE Raw)

Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

Alexa Bliss is at a tentative position on this list as her character is relatively new. However, it has plenty of unexplored potential. There is significant fan discussion and hype around whether Bliss’ children’s TV presenter persona has its own Fiend side - mask and all.

It is unnerving to see the popular Bliss under the influence of Bray Wyatt’s control, a relationship often compared to The Joker and Harley Quinn (who Bliss used as the basis for her former look).

Much of her creepiness derives from the ability to snap between sweetness and light and slaughter and laughter. Her high-pitched giggles send chills through the spine. Alexa is yet to fully show the pain part of her character in the ring, though the moment she was guided by Bray to bash Friendship Frog to death showed just what she is capable of.

Bliss’ new supernatural side combined with her well-honed heel playbook will make her a formidable force. She is currently one of the most over female wrestlers on the roster, without the need of a title feud. WWE would do well to continue adding more character led wrestlers to their women’s division.


9. Sami Callihan (Impact)

Sami Callihan
Impact Wrestling

Sami Callihan is the definition of the word creep. He has all the necessary red flags of a serial killer. Maybe his time as NXT’s resident hacker Solomon Crowe caused more trauma to him than it did the audience.

Callihan is the former leader of the cultish Ohio Verses Everything. His intensity and gruff as gravel voice make him a natural cult leader-cum-master manipulator.

Callihan’s intense face often merely alternates between scowling and sneering. This is occasionally broken by manic excitement and bulging eyes when he beats his foes bloody, with any weapon to hand. However, Callihan’s violent parlour trick is to throw fireballs into the face of his unlucky prey.

He is prone to violently assaulting women, infamously smashing a glass bottle into the face of Melissa Santos, and has one of the stiffest piledrivers in the business. Adding to his FBI profile, Callihan has a fascination with bodily fluids, particularly his own saliva, which he often plays with and throws/spits it onto his opponent’s bodies.

Callihan currently has ‘the World’s Most Dangerous Man’ Ken Shamrock under his spell, making him more dangerous than ever.


8. Vincent (ROH)

Vincent ROH
ROHWrestling.com

Vincent’s look is heavily inspired by horror director and rock star Rob Zombie. The only man who can convincingly hold their own against Marilyn Manson is a good source for creepy character inspiration.

Vincent is also likely to draw comparisons to the other Manson. He has the serial killer’s absent eyes and cool smile on the brink of a sneer. His vocal delivery is that of a ‘60s California hippy, though his words promote cruelty.

Also, like Charles Manson, Vincent is a deranged cult leader, leading The Righteous, a noble sounding group that Vincent helms with the intent of transforming Ring Of Honor into Ring Of Horror. He does so with an encyclopaedic knowledge of horror and penchant for extreme violence.

When Vincent asks, “You wanna get sick. You wanna get twisted. You wanna make a horror movie?”, he does so as an expert in all three. His sinister presence goes beyond the ring. He played a psychopathic serial killer in the 2018 horror movie The Find.

Vincent is currently in a feud with a returning Mike Bennett, after his former friend prevented him using a dart to pierce the skin of Matt Taven.


7. EVIL (NJPW)

EVIL NJPW
NJPW

Though Takaaki Watanabe debuted for NJPW in 2011, it took an educational excursion to America to realise his EVIL side.

When he returned to Japan he did so in the guise of the grim reaper. He is the closest NJPW has come to promoting a supernatural character, in the vein of gimmicks such as The Undertaker and Kane. Though this is at times hammy, it only makes the violence he dispenses more shocking. The fact that Tetsuya Naitō, one of his closest friends at the time, renamed him EVIL is more than telling.

EVIL is one of the few guys on the planet that can still make black eye make-up look ominous. He isn’t someone you’d dare compare to a mid-2000s emo. Looking up from his heavy brow, eyeballing the camera, ranting, and branding his enemies “b*stards”, Western fans don’t need to switch on the subtitles to be unnerved by his promos. They are often better off only understanding his “This is EVIL. Everything is EVIL” catchphrase.

‘The King of Darkness’ is currently NJPW’s top heel and has aligned himself with the Bullet Club.


6. Mr. Brodie Lee (AEW)

Brodie Lee Cody
AEW

The Dark Order, a Scientology inspired cult, consists of AEW talent and masked underlings known as Creepers. Little is known about the inner workings of the Dark Order, other than its dictatorial hierarchical structure and its aim to recruit the lonely, unwanted, and disrespected. It had the potential to be sinister, and the mystery around the identity of ‘The Exalted One’ was one of AEW’s most intriguing storylines. However, the revelation of Mr. Brodie Lee as the group’s leader made the Dark Order a credible threat.

‘The Exalted One’ persona is a cross between charismatic yet creepy cult leaders, such as Jim Jones, and Brodie’s former boss Vince McMahon. Brodie carries himself with a self-assurance, steely beady-eyed intensity, and the ability to flip from eloquent charm to ranting egomania.

The references to McMahon are obvious to today’s savvy fans hungry for backstage snippets, from his refusal to allow his co-diners to start eating before he’s finished, to his rage at people yawning in his presence, believing tiredness shows weakness. These allusions could be hammy, and while funny, they are given a creepy edge by Brodie’s skilled delivery.


5. Karrion Kross (WWE NXT)

Karrion Kross injury
WWE.com

Karrion Kross returned to NXT this past week, following an unfortunate shoulder separation just as he'd claimed the brand's top prize. Prior to this misfortune, he and his partner Scarlett were one of the most compelling acts in NXT. Their introduction vignettes were some of the talented production team’s best work. Kross kept the momentum going, taking the NXT Championship at TakeOver: XXX.

Kross has the look of someone seconds away from snapping. It’s all in his eyes. His perfect teeth could be a Hollywood smile, but he bears them like a ravenous animal. He alternates between a soft but gruff voice and screaming into the camera’s lens. Scarlett’s mixture of soft beauty and brooding menace is spellbinding, like an angel who holds the dubious distinction of falling further than any before her.

Kross was even fearsome during his speech to relinquish the NXT Championship. Usually an emotional affair which breaches the fourth wall, Kross was intense as ever, including a vivid description of “ripping the title off Keith Lee’s carcass like flesh from bone”.

Let doomsday resume…


4. Abadon (AEW)

Abadon AEW
AEW

Visually, Abadon is currently the creepiest wrestler employed to a mainstream promotion. A mystery surrounds her, in a similar way to the early days of The Undertaker, that stirs fan’s curiosity.

Abadon’s face is like a gunshot wound, made up of minor tears and trauma, but only able to be perceived by the human eye as one gruesome mess. Even in the sport of professional wrestling, where face paint is more common than at a Halloween fundraiser for Juggalos with acne, Abadon has the most unique and terrifying face design. Her apparently toothless mouth is filled with streaming blood, and her bloody and milky eyes are nauseating.

In the ring, she is a fearsome competitor. She crawls around like a wounded animal who has turned the tide against the game hunter that attempted to end its life. She is both a violent brawler and a skilled wrestler. Predominantly wrestling, rather appropriately, on AEW: Dark, her only loss is to current Women’s Champion Hikaru Shida. The character, and the woman behind it, have a promising career ahead. Abadon has the potential to surpass any of the creepy characters currently on rival promotions.


3. 'The Fiend' Bray Wyatt (WWE Raw)

Bray Wyatt The Fiend
WWE.com

Bray Wyatt’s ‘The Fiend’ persona takes wresting to those outlandish, suspend your disbelief, levels that whips up fan interest. In the duality of Fun House Bray and The Fiend, Wyatt has managed to distil not only the irrational fears of childhood, but also the comfort of being a kid, relaxing and watching ever-happy TV presenters preach over-simplified lessons. He plays upon his ability to manipulate people, seemingly targeting children, without going to that suspect place of Dustin Rhodes' Seven.

Though the plotline of “the monster within” is vastly explored, the Fun House gimmick is unique, and his monster is particularly horrifying. Going from a cheesy smile and an enthusiastic wave to a Glasgow smile and rasping animalistic garbling, Wyatt has continued to advance the character in new and innovative ways, with Fun House Bray’s promos being the non-competitive highlights of Raw.

It helps that The Fiend’s mask, created by Tom Savini Studios, wouldn’t be out of place in a slasher movie or a Slipknot concert. The barely audible demand to 'let him in' is spine-chilling. It is no coincidence that when The Fiend appears you think of your childhood dinosaur night light.


2. Su Yung (Impact)

su yung debut
IMPACT Wrestling

When Impact decided to kill off Su Yung, they did so in a gruesome fashion. Havok slung a noose around her neck and hung her from a staircase rail. Su’s resurrection followed Pet Cemetery rules – “They don't come back the same”.

She re-debuted as Susie, an almost sickly-sweet character with an unnerving entrance theme, which included a lethargic and distorted toy-box tune. While Susie may not retain much of Su Yung’s memories, she keeps her creepiness. The doll-like character is unsettling in its almost emptiness. The fake surface happiness threatens to crack and allow the darkness to seep out. Under the pressure of losing the support of her best friend Kylie Rae, Su Yung emerged, briefly taking the Knockouts Championship from Deonna Purrazzo.

Su Yung, in her severe kabuki-esque make-up and a blood drenched baby doll dress, is one of the most chilling figures in professional wrestling. With her affinity for coffins, spitting bloody mist, and choking the life out of her foes with a gore-soaked glove, Yung is consistently one of Impact’s most unique Knockouts, both in terms of character and in-ring skill.


1. Dexter Lumis (WWE NXT)

Dexter Lumis
NXT

Dexter Lumis is a character committed to creepiness. Every action he performs on-screen is designed to unnerve viewers. Despite him being over as a face, his creepy side has only become more pronounced.

Though Lumis’ attire is street clothes, eyes are drawn to his black gloves. They invoke the nagging suspicion that he is about to do something that he doesn’t want his fingerprints to be associated with. Lumis has the best death stare in the business, drawing you in with his pale blue eyes before his intense pupils drill into you. He slithers around the ring, with the dead face of a psychopath, stalking his opponents, preparing to dispense sadistic violence.

Adding further to the eerie gimmick, Lumis became known as NXT’s “tortured artist”. He often forgoes words to draw bizarre caricatures, the kind you get at a fairground. However, they are stripped of their light-hearted quirkiness depicting such subjects as kidnap and a zombie referee chowing down on an arm.

Little is known about Lumis outside of the ring. However, his sinister actions convey the gimmick in a way many of the roster couldn’t do even with weekly sprawling promos.


In this post: 
Dexter Lumis
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

An English Lit. MA Grad trying to validate my student debt by writing literary fiction and alternative non-fiction.