10 Current Stars Who Should Have Been WWE Champion By Now

The guys who got close to the title... only for WWE to lose faith.

Professional Wrestling history is overflowing with talented wrestlers who should have been world champion, but for whatever reason were never given the opportunity. €œRowdy€ Roddy Piper, Jake €œThe Snake€ Roberts and Scott Hall are three legends that seem like they should have been champion, but never held the big one. The WWE Championship picture always seems somewhat impenetrable for certain wrestlers, even if they€™re more than qualified to be there. When a fan favourite like CM Punk or Daniel Bryan breaks out in a major way, it€™s cause for celebration among fans so cynical that they expect it to be traded between John Cena and Randy Orton forever. Over the past five years there have been thirty-one separate WWE Championship reigns, but only thirteen individuals were actually champion. In that time, WWE could, and should, have been more focused on making new stars instead of relying on the same small percentage of wrestlers to carry the title. With the WWE World Heavyweight Champion, Brock Lesnar appearing on less pay-per-views and even less Raws, it seems even harder for talent to break through and go for the gold. Here are ten current WWE wrestlers that really should have been World Heavyweight Champion by now.

10. Seth Rollins

When Brock Lesnar and John Cena met in a rematch for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, fans had no idea how it was going to end. It was apparant it wouldn't be the fifteen minute squash that SummerSlam was, but it didn€™t seem likely that Cena was going to defeat Lesnar either. When Seth Rollins interfered and attacked Brock Lesnar, it seemed stupid. Why attack the most powerful, dominant wrestler the WWE has ever seen? Why anger him when he barely acknowledges your existence? Opinion quickly changed when Rollins hit Lesnar with the Curb Stomp, and suddenly fans were instead thinking €œWhat if?€ It seemed possible that Mr. Money in the Bank would dethrone the Beast and become the WWE World Heavyweight Champion. In hindsight, it seems like WWE should have taken the bold risk of allowing Rollins to succeed in taking out Lesnar. WWE€™s experiment with Lesnar hasn€™t proved to be worth the money they spent, and it would have solidified Rollins as a permanent main eventer for the rest of his career.

9. Kofi Kingston

There was a time when Kofi Kingston was supposed to be the future. Around 2009, there was a class of wrestlers like John Morrison, Drew McIntyre and Ted DiBiase that seemed to be the next wave of main eventers, and Kofi was among that class. After several inconsequential singles and tag title runs, Kofi was thrust into a main event calibre feud with none other than Randy Orton. He even had a career defining moment when he hit his signature €œBoom Drop€ off a guard rail in the crowd onto Orton, putting The Viper through a table in the process. This feud seemed to be the start of something major for Kofi Kingston, but it proved to be his undoing. During a match with Orton, Kofi was apparently supposed to take the punt as the finish of the match, but kept getting to his feet. Orton hit him with an RKO and yelled €œSTUPID! STUPID!€ at Kingston before pinning him. The word is that this is the reason Kofi€™s career has never risen any higher than his feud with Randy Orton, and if it€™s true, it€™s a real shame. WWE have been under heavy criticism this year for never having a black WWE Champion, and in Kofi Kingston they have someone with the look, athleticism and charisma to represent the company.

8. Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt has had an odd year to say the least. All of 2014, he€™s been involved in feuds with main eventers like Daniel Bryan, John Cena and Chris Jericho, but there€™s something about him that WWE just can€™t seem to get right. It should be fairly easy, he€™s a twisted cult leader with possible supernatural connections, and in the ring he€™s incredibly tough and incredibly athletic. He should be filling the role of the twenty-first century Undertaker and be a force of nature as much he is a wrestler. This hasn€™t been the case with Bray Wyatt, and time and time again he€™s presented as cowardly and ineffectual. He immediately tried to escape a steel cage when facing Chris Jericho, and the entire Wyatt Family stable were sacrificed in order to prove that John Cena is tough and strong after he lost to Brock Lesnar. Exactly a year after The Undertaker debuted, he won the WWF Championship from Hulk Hogan and in many ways it signified that Hulkamania was over in the WWF. They had an opportunity to do that again this year and make Bray Wyatt the WWE World Heavweight Champion, but instead, he€™s stuck in an underwhelming feud with Dean Ambrose over nothing.

7. Cody Rhodes

There was a brief time where it seemed like fan support might carry Cody Rhodes to the main event. It began last year at the Money in the Bank pay-per-view where he had a show-stealing performance in the eponymous match, only to be double-crossed by his tag partner Damien Sandow. Then, in September he was placed into a match with Randy Orton that he had to win otherwise he€™d be fired. After losing the match and being shown the door, he cut an impassioned promo about how the McMahon family has been stepping on the Rhodes family for generations and displayed a fire few knew he had. The Rhodes€™ got their revenge on The Authority when Cody along with Goldust defeated The Shield for the Tag Team Championship with their father in their corner. However, the story never truly felt over, and in many ways the tag title victory felt like a consolation prize. Cody Rhodes proved to the world that he has the potential and popularity to be a main event superstar, but the narrative didn€™t have any room for him. The story was Daniel Bryan v The Authority, and while adding Cody at the time may not have worked, he€™s more than earned it by now.

6. Damien Sandow

Damien Sandow is one of the worst victims of being in the wrong place at the wrong time. If he€™d won the Money in the Bank briefcase in any previous year, he would more than likely have been World Heavyweight Champion. Unfortunately, towards the end of 2013, WWE decided to unify the WWE and World Heavyweight Championships into one title and Sandow still had his contract for a guaranteed World Heavyweight Championship match. The unification match was never going to be Randy Orton v Damien Sandow, so Sandow had to lose his title match. He didn€™t have to lose it in as embarrassing a fashion as he did though. John Cena€™s arm was already hanging on by a thread from his match with Alberto Del Rio, and Sandow even had time to maul him before cashing in the contract. As wrestling fans have become accustomed to, Cena overcame the odds and defeated Sandow dashing the hopes of fans worldwide. However, it€™s a year later and as Damien Mizdow, he€™s never been more popular, so once again there€™s a chance he may rise to title contention sometime in the future.

5. Ryback

Ryback had the unfortunate luck of being pushed into the WWE Championship scene before his story was ready for him to reach that point. He re-debuted and began squashing enhancement talent and within months he was feuding with CM Punk for the title. At the time, John Cena was feuding with Punk, but he suffered an arm injury a month before their planned Hell in a Cell match. Ryback was surfing a wave of popularity at the time and was slotted into the match in Cena€™s place. The problem was, Ryback never had a chance at winning Punk€™s title as the latter would go on to hold it for 434 days. Ryback€™s main title contention ended up doing him more harm than good, and it took WWE nearly two years to get Ryback back to that initial popularity. The upside is that in those two years Ryback found his personality, thanks to the highly entertaining tag-team, Rybaxel. He€™s once again one of the most over men in the country, and there€™s still plenty of time for The Big Guy to get the WWE Championship.

4. Cesaro

Wrestling is an environment where having talent in abundance doesn€™t necessarily result in success. Some of the worst wrestlers of all time have been WWE Champion, and some of the best never amounted to anything on the big stage. Sometimes there comes along a wrestler so unbelievably gifted that the fans demand the WWE acknowledge it. CM Punk and Daniel Bryan both benefitted from this, and for a while it seemed like Cesaro would as well. Cesaro had a hell of a start to his year, he had an amazing Monday Night Raw match with John Cena, and stole the show at Elimination Chamber. He took it even further when he bodyslammed The Big Show over the top rope at WrestleMania to win the Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal. It seemed like the only way was up for The Swiss Superman but, through no fault of his own, his career has stalled since then. His alignment with Paul Heyman was ill-concieved, and somehow his Real Americans partner Jack Swagger was the one to get the face turn and subsequent push. Fans won€™t let go of Cesaro without a fight though, and he still garners signs and chants everywhere he goes. He€™s still in the prime of his career, so there€™s ample time yet for WWE to realise what they have in him.

3. Wade Barrett

The Nexus€™ demolition of the Monday Night Raw main event is still one of the most shocking and exciting moments in the show€™s 1000+ episode run. It was violent and scary in a way wrestling rarely gets a chance to be, and immediately solidified eight new stars to take notice of. Of those eight stars, Wade Barrett stood head and shoulders above the rest. He arrived main event ready, and as the leader of Nexus, he went toe-to-toe with the likes of Randy Orton, Sheamus and John Cena. During The Nexus€™ time as an active unit, Wade Barrett received numerous WWE Championship opportunities but John Cena cost him every single match bar one. As a result, The Nexus never truly felt threatening and Cena just came across as kind of a bully. The simple way to fix the lack of bite in The Nexus€™ bark would have been to get the WWE Championship onto Barrett. Nothing ever felt at stake because John Cena kneecapped them at every opportunity, but with Barrett as champion Cena would at least have odds to overcome.

2. Goldust

When Dustin Runnels first debuted in WWE as the androgynous Goldust, he was incredibly ahead of his time. The world was not quite ready for a flirtatious, sexually ambiguous occasional cross-dresser in 1995, but in many ways Goldust€™s antics set the standard for the coming Attitude Era. During those early days, Goldust clashed with many current and future main eventers such as The Undertaker, €œRowdy€ Roddy Piper and €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin. He always held his own in these bouts, but for some reason he€™s never come close to being considered for WWE Championship contention. In the post-Attitude Era WWE, Goldust€™s character seemed a lot tamer than it had ten years previously, and he became much more of a comedy character. His weight fluctuated wildly, and he left and returned to WWE on a number of occasions. So when Goldust was brought back to fight for his brother Cody€™s job, he shocked the world by putting on an amazing match with Randy Orton. What was meant to be a one-time deal turned into a full-time contract, and it even netted Goldust and Cody the Tag Team Championships. No-one expected the prime of Goldust€™s career to come at forty-four years old, and many are just now noticing how good he always was. It€™s just a shame that this revelation didn€™t come fifteen years ago, because these days it€™s highly unlikely that Goldust will ever be a World Champion.

1. William Regal

William Regal is someone who could best be described as a €œwrestler€™s wrestler€. For over thirty years, he€™s commanded whatever ring he€™s stepped foot in with untouchable skill and unwavering devotion to his character. His role within the company always depended on what they needed of him, and in 2008 that meant becoming the King of the Ring. This signalled an apparent push for Regal, including a run with the World Heavyweight Championship, but it was all derailed when he was suspended for violating WWE€™s Substance Abuse and Drug Testing Policy. Since then, Regal has addressed this and has always been candid about his own faults and failings. He even brought it up in a promo before his most recent match, last year against Antonio Cesaro.
€œI never achieved what I coveted the most, and that was to become the World Heavyweight Champion, but that€™s my fault because I have wonderful knack for getting myself into a trouble. To the people that really know, I have always been a world class, second-to-none technical wrestler.€
Although for now William Regal hasn€™t officially retired, that match was over a year ago and he hasn€™t wrestled since. It seems the time has indeed passed for Regal, and his name will instead be added to the list of great wrestlers who never won a World Championship alongside Roddy Piper, Jake Roberts and Scott Hall.

In this post: 
Ryback
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I don't read the comments.