10 Depressing Wrestling Retirement Matches
Not every star gets the send-off they deserve as they ride into retirement, permanent or not.
Trish Stratus vs. Lita at Unforgiven 2006. Austin vs. The Rock at WrestleMania XIX. Shawn Michaels vs. The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXVI. Ric Flair vs. Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XXIV.
These are among the best retirement matches ever put on by WWE. They were full of suspense, emotion, and excitement and served as fitting tributes to the wrestlers they were sending off.
This list is not made up of that kind of match.
No, this is a list of ten retirement matches that served as sad, joyless affairs that may have spiked a rating or drawn some heat but were less than fitting career enders for the competitors who were retiring after the match. In some cases, 'retirement' needs to be qualified because some of these were less than permanent.
Realistically, anyone who puts their bodies and wellness on the line for us fans as wrestlers deserves an amazing end to their career, as they do things most of us simply couldn't, and all for the sake of entertainment.
Unfortunately, this is often not the case, and these ten matches highlight retirement matches that were just depressing to watch.
10. Kurt Angle Vs. Baron Corbin (WrestleMania 35)
At the height of Kurt Angle's popularity, the idea that he would ever go out against Baron Corbin was unthinkable. One of the other SmackDown Six? Sure. Shawn Michaels? Absolutely. Brock Lesnar? Awesome.
Sigh.
For the business, it made sense. Corbin has had the benefit of Vince McMahon loving him since he arrived. He had a long feud with Angle leading up to 'Mania 35. Angle is a pro and would do the right thing by putting over a younger talent on his way out.
Still...
The match was underwhelming, certainly not a showcase of what Angle could do or had been. Corbin has consistently been a heel, and pitting him against one of the most beloved WWE stars ever was a heat generator, but was certainly not befitting one of the greats.
Angle has said recently that he wanted to finish his career against John Cena. When he requested this of Vince McMahon, he was told no because of the work that had gone into the build-up. Angle was also told if he waited another year he could have his match with Cena at 'Mania 36.
Angle declined and was resigned to a retirement match with someone who was certainly not his calibre.
9. Hulk Hogan Vs. Kidman, Ric Flair Vs. David Flair (Great American Bash 2000)
Nothing like a two-fer of sad and unnecessary 'retirement' matches. GAB 2000 featured two bouts with the retirement stipulation (way to think outside the box, WCW,) featuring wrestlers who were simply NOT going to be taken out by their scheduled opponents.
In a storyline too convoluted to recount, Ric and his son, supported by Russo, were at odds. After weeks of back and forth build, Ric led his considerably less experienced son through the match while also making it look plausible that David could beat him. After a mercifully short affair, Flair pinned David. Then, 24 hours later, Russo reversed the whole thing on Nitro.
Kidman against Hogan was a multi-stipulation match: the winner earned a title shot, and if Hogan lost he would be forced to retire. With Russo and Hogan constantly butting heads (resulting in the unforgettable dueling swerves and promos a month later at Bash at the Beach), it was slightly possible that the Russo-backed Kidman might prevail.
No it wasn't. At all.
After a middling match, Hogan, despite being the face, used brass knuckles to coldcock Kidman for a win. Behind the scenes, he had used his creative control clause to ensure the match would go in his favour.
Again.
8. Kevin Nash Vs. Hulk Hogan (Road Wild 1999)
This match was not only for Hogan's championship, it was also a retirement match. It marked the first time that the two had 'wrestled' since the infamous Fingerpoke of Doom; Hogan was back in his yellow and red as a babyface. Surprisingly, this was downplayed by commentators and video hype.
And videos were necessary, because the title had changed hands so many times in the previous few months it was impossible to keep track of who won it when and if they were heel or face.
As the main event, you would expect a pretty good crowd reaction... but you'd be wrong. Hogan and Nash had fought so many times and in so many ways that their rivalry no longer had any meaning, and no one really cared about the stakes.
About the only thing that drew a reaction was that Hogan acted like it was 1989, not '99, and did his classic Hogan shtick - Hulking up, big boot, leg drop, match over. Aside from this small nostalgia factor, this was still 1999 WCW, and it was obvious that both Nash and Hogan were just there for the paycheque.
Also, Nash would be back in six weeks as part of a new nWo.
7. Kevin Nash Vs. Scott Steiner (Superbrawl Revenge 2001)
This is another retirement that happened because of timing. Specifically, the timing of WCW finally imploding and being bought by WWE.
In a last minute addition to the Superbrawl Revenge card, it was decided the main event of the show would be Nash vs. Steiner, for Steiner's title, with the loser retiring from WCW.
What was pretty predictable turned into a huge cluster.
Nash started things off by hitting Steiner with the title belt, pinning him in 17 seconds. Ric Flair, for some reason, was empowered to make changes and made it a two out of three falls match with no-DQ rules.
After DDP, Buff Bagwell, Flair and Midajah all got involved, Steiner hit Nash with a steel pipe but couldn't get him back into the ring, prompting Flair to make it a falls count anywhere match. First pin (on the floor) to Steiner.
More chicanery ensued, with continued interference and several chair shots, resulting in Steiner getting the second pinfall and the win.
Nash was gone from WCW. The thing was, in a few weeks, so was everyone else, so, really, this was another meaningless car wreck that only dragged down everyone involved.
In other words, a perfect microcosm of late-era WCW.
6. Lita Vs. Mickie James (Survivor Series 2006)
Lita was one of the bright lights of the Women's/Divas' division in terms of wrestling ability. When usually the women on the roster were spending time pillow fighting or rolling around in pudding, Lita, Trish Stratus, Molly Holly and a few others had actual matches. For Lita, this included the honour of beating Trish Stratus for her title in the first ever women's main event on Raw.
So, what better way to celebrate her last match than to humiliate her and reduce her to a sex object?
Lita lost to James at Survivor Series 2006, putting over an up-and-comer as is ring tradition. Instead of letting Lita enjoy a few minutes in the spotlight, what should have been an emotional moment became a bit by having Cryme Tyme come to ringside and auction off Lita's 'property' (mostly bras and such) in what they called a 'ho sale.'
Hi-larious! No dignity for you!
Lita has shared how she talked to everyone possible up to and including Vince himself to change the angle, only to be met with 'no' all along. So, sucking it up for the company, Lita went out and did the job, only to be laughed out of the building.
5. Goldberg & DeWayne Bruce Vs. Buff Bagwell & Lex Luger (Sin 2001)
The final years of WCW read like a manual of corporate mismanagement. Throw money around, throw ideas around, throw stipulations around, change titles, hire Vince Russo...
In summer 2000, Goldberg worked a weird program with Vince Russo, starting as a heel, then turning kinda face during a worked shoot, before becoming a total face with Russo as his nemesis.
In his role of the month that summer, Russo gave Goldberg an ultimatum - replicate your winning streak from 1997/98 or you're out. This actually worked for a while, as Goldberg began to win matches consistently and build up some momentum.
Then along came a meaningless (even by WCW standards) pay per view and Goldberg lost and was out. During the match, a planted fan in the front row 'maced' Goldberg, allowing him to take steel chair shots from Luger before Bagwell hit him off Luger's shoulders with a Blockbuster for the pin.
In reality, Goldberg needed time off for shoulder surgery, but by the time he recovered, WCW had folded and been absorbed by WWE. He would later have a run in WWE, as well as more recent one-offs, but this car crash of a match represents his WCW retirement.
4. Paige & Absolution Vs. Sasha Banks, Bayley, & Mickie James (House Show, December 2017)
Paige has had a tumultuous few years with WWE. After an incredible debut with a title win over AJ Lee the night after 'Mania XXX, she moved into singles competition, joined the cast of Total Divas, and feuded with pretty much the entire Women's Division.
In August 2016, Paige was suspended for 30 days for a Wellness violation, followed by another suspension in October, and took time off to have neck surgery to treat old injuries.
She returned in November 2017, forming Absolution with Mandy Rose and Sonya Deville and getting back in the ring. Her career would shortly come to an inglorious end at a house show a few weeks later.
During a spot, Sasha kicked Paige in the back before Paige was in position. Paige immediately dropped to her knees, unable to get to her feet and having to roll onto her back. The referee immediately stopped the match and called for medics. Paige then had a barrage of medical testing that confirmed the worst - she was done.
Sadly, at age 25, Paige was told she would no longer be medically cleared, and despite continuing to be involved with WWE, she will likely never get a proper send-off match.
3. Ric Flair Vs. Vince Russo & David Flair, (Nitro, 12/06/00)
Oy.
At Great American Bash 2000 (which we covered earlier in this list), Flair was booked into a retirement match against his son David. Since David was not a wrestler, as should have happened, Ric won.
Not good enough for Vince Russo.
On the next night's Nitro, Flair launched into a tirade against Russo for kidnapping David (don't ask, it's 2000 WCW.) This escalated into a handicap, hair vs. hair, retirement match involving both Flairs and Russo.
Over the next four minutes, David and Russo proceeded to beat the s**t out of Ric. The scene was made even more awkward because Ric's family was ringside (including a young Ashley Flair, who the world would grow to know as Charlotte,) watching this go down.
At one point, Russo secured a model of the Statue of Liberty and pummeled Ric with it until his family threw in the towel. While 'security' held off Flair's family, Russo and David shaved Ric bald as he lay unconscious. When this was done, Russo turned on David and shaved him as well.
Ric Flair's retirement matches were a constant throughout his career, but this one was deeply disturbing, ultimately meaningless, and did nothing but make the Nature Boy and his family look stupid.
2. Undertaker Vs. Roman Reigns (WrestleMania 33)
The Undertaker and WrestleMania go together like beer and pretzels. His legendary undefeated streak was a key part of the 'Mania mystique for over two decades.
It was becoming obvious, though, that the Deadman was slowing down. His appearances became more sporadic, usually only involving major events.
When 'Mania 33 rolled around, it appeared clear this was to be Undertaker's last ride. His match held the main event slot and Jim Ross was brought in for commentary. It felt like a huge event, and given Reigns' mega-push, it appeared clear WWE wanted 'Taker to do the job and put Reigns over (finally.)
It didn't work.
Reigns was booed the entire match. 'Taker was nowhere near keeping up with the younger Reigns, the glory days of his epic 'Mania matches clearly gone. Before leaving defeated, Mark Calaway left his coat, gloves, and hat in the ring with a single spotlight on them, a sad yet iconic image to mark his last real solo in-ring match.
Reigns capped his win on next night's Raw, arrogantly uttering five simple words that destroyed the crowd.
Super Showdowns aside, 'Taker did have two more great appearances post-'retirement', teaming with Reigns in an awesome Extreme Rules 2019 bout and in the brilliant 2020 Boneyard Match against AJ Styles.
1. Bret Hart Vs. Bill Goldberg / Kevin Nash (Starrcade 1999 / Nitro January 2000)
Bret Hart will undoubtedly go down as one of the best to ever lace a pair of boots. His technical expertise, his in-ring psychology, and his ring general status all combine to make him one of the greatest ever.
After a mostly-wasted run, Hart faced Goldberg at Starrcade 1999, where Goldberg threw a poorly timed kick that legitimately rung Bret's bell, causing a concussion that would only worsen.
This would be Hitman's last match as the Bret Hart we knew and loved.
Two weeks after Starrcade, Hart faced Terry Funk in a hardcore match, adding to his injuries. A week after that, Hart squared off against Nash on Nitro in what would be his last full in-ring match. His timing and balance were visibly off. The match turned into the usual WCW non-finish and Hart would vacate his title a week later after the concussion diagnosis.
Goldberg has gone on record as saying it was the biggest mistake he ever made, as he effectively ended Hart's career. Hart seems to have forgiven him, but has also stated several times that Goldberg was unprofessional and that he constantly hurt his opponents through his lack of skill.
For true wrestling fans, this one still really hurts.