10 Disturbing Backstories Behind WWE Gimmicks
Yowie wowie!
Vince McMahon and the WWE have been creating content and characters for nearly 40 years now, so every gimmick you can imagine will have been contemplated by Vince and a bevvy of writers at one point or another. WWE’s conceived some complex, complicated and creepy backstories for certain talent since the ‘80s professional wrestling boom.
There have been those gimmicks that have been inspired and influenced by real-life events/personality traits of the wrestlers who portray them (amateur wrestlers, second/third generation talent, luchadors etc.) and then there have been those spawned from the depths of creative not-of-this-world fantasies from WWE writers (zombies, prisoners, minotaurs, monks, evil Santas etc.). Vince McMahon seemingly doesn’t have a preference for which style of gimmick makes it to TV, only caring if they resonate with an audience or not. He famously said regarding WWE’s outlook on the Beyond The Mat documentary: “We make movies.”
Supernatural horrors or real-life fears in society have ran rampant in the most disturbing gimmicks to ever emerge in WWE. Here, we’ll look at the 10 gimmicks with the most unpleasant and distressing backstories. Some of these roles are so twisted you’d think Vince conceived them with the same sinister bloody smile he exhibited at WrestleMania XIX.
10. Doink
Doink the Clown’s backstory strangely mirrors Heath Ledger’s portrayal of The Joker in The Dark Knight, in the sense that his origin purposely remains a mystery – with the mystery in and of itself being the most disturbing thing. The lack of backstory makes Doink that much creepier.
Matt Borne portrayed Doink when he debuted for the WWF in ’92, and would expertly utilize people's irrational fear of clowns in the gimmick. Doink would initially play silly pranks on wrestlers, like upending Big Boss Man with a tripwire or dumping water on Marty Jannetty. However, over time he would present himself as overly scary and hateful in his attitude. He would enter the ring silly and cartoonish as a ruse, and as his matches progressed he showcased himself as a technically sound wrestler with his demeanour abruptly changing to sinister as he beat down his opponents. And as soon as the bell rang as the match ended, Doink resumed his silly/cartoon humour.
Doink methodically switched between cartoony and creepy, notably in his interviews. He’d comment in promos with lines like, “I am no more than an instrument of nature... A product of my environment." Matt Borne was really ahead of his time.
WWE’s Senior Vice President Bruce Prichard’s said on his Something to Wrestle podcast about Doink’s mind-set:
"People love clowns or they hate clowns. And you can always think of someone that hides behind the makeup of a clown. You know for the most part they’re painting on a happy face because underneath the paint is a miserable person."
9. Bray Wyatt/The Fiend
What Matt Osborne could not do with the Doink character, Bray Wyatt did with his - evolving with it and reaching headliner status.
After nearly a year away from the ring Wyatt, who portrayed the cult leader of the Wyatt Family, came back with one of the most compelling and engrossing characters WWE had seen in years with The Fiend. He sucked viewers into his Mr. Rogers-like children’s show, only to then reveal the horrifyingly Fiend character connected to it. Fan theories ran rampant regarding The Fiend, whether the smiling sweater Fun House character only existed in Wyatt’s mind whilst The Fiend existed in the real world. You never see The Fiend or Bray Wyatt together and The Fiend hauntingly walks to the ring with a lantern inside a replica of Wyatt’s head after all.
On his Fun House segments Wyatt educated viewers on his backstory, filled with pain and suffering, explaining how The Fiend exists to wreak havoc on anyone that once caused Wyatt pain, demonstrated with The Fiend the following year taking out Kane, Daniel Bryan and John Cena. His Firefly Fun House puppets gave clues to his distressing history too, like Huskus the Pig being Wyatt’s bitterness for the Husky Harris character he had to portray in his early days of WWE.
8. The Undertaker
The Undertaker is the most successful supernatural persona WWE’s ever produced. Since his debut at Survivor Series 1990 he’s been portrayed as a supernatural soulless zombie-like figure, being able to survive death over and over again because he is dead (he’s been set on fire and buried alive throughout his career).
Initially his backstory was vague and unclear. He appeared simply as an eerie dominant force accompanied by his manager Paul Bearer to the ring, who would go on to dethrone Hulk Hogan for the WWF Championship and bury The Ultimate Warrior. Undertaker has previously said in interviews on his portrayal of The Deadman: “There needs to be some sense of mystery, some mystique, some kind of something that’s not given."
Cut to 1997 and details regarding ‘Taker’s origin story emerged. After turning his back on The Undertaker at SummerSlam, Paul Bearer aligned himself with Mankind and Vader to take him out. When that didn’t work, Bearer threatened to reveal a deep dark sickening secret about The Undertaker, where he repeatedly used the line "The fires of hell!" Bearer revealed The Undertaker’s mother, father and brother died when he was young in a house fire and accused The Undertaker of being the one who started it. This leads us right into our next entry with...
7. Kane
The Undertaker, whilst acknowledging his tragic backstory of being orphaned growing up, denied he was the one that started the fire that burned down his family home. Bearer claimed he had proof though, revealing his brother Kane, although he was severely scarred and disfigured, survived the fire.
Bearer heckled The Undertaker in his wailing voice with “Kane's alive!” Bearer told of how he helped raise Kane, having him institutionalized in an asylum after the fire, with Kane plotting his revenge on The Undertaker ever since. ‘Taker countered with how Kane solely started the fire as he was a pyromaniac growing up and how there’s no way he could have survived. Bearer would later unintentionally admit he had an affair with The Undertaker’s mother too, making Kane his son and The Undertaker’s half-brother.
Kane epically debuted at the Badd Blood pay-per-view, acting like Frankenstein’s Monster to Paul Bearer as he ripped the Hell in a Cell open and tombstoned The Undertaker, costing him the match and WWF Championship. This was the start of a never-ending feud/alliance between The Undertaker and Kane. Kane has said of it:
"I think that was the best piece of epic storytelling WWE has ever done. Just the whole thing as far as from the introduction of Kane, from Paul Bearer talking about Kane before you ever saw him, to the storyline itself, the matches and everything. I just thought that it was just a great piece of storytelling. Everything seemed to work, we had all these different pieces. One reason I called it epic storytelling was because the feud was like mythology, right? You had these two large and alive characters with this huge backstory and all these different things."
Some more of Kane’s grievous backstory was later revealed in 2002 (in an angle that was quickly dropped), noting how Kane held years of mental anguish over accidentally killing his girlfriend Katie Vick when they were drink-driving and he lost control of the car. And in 2003 we saw how Kane’s scars all this time that had him hide under a mask for years were not physical but mental.
6. Festus
Luke Gallows' first run in WWE was as the Southern, intellectually challenged slack-jawed ‘Festus’. The character was a Vince McMahon creation based on a kid Vince went to school with who was somewhat slow but would suddenly snap. Gallows has said on first being informed about Festus:
"So we go to Vince's office and I'm 23 and this is Vince McMahon and I'm like, 'I can't be a mark, but this is some sh*t right here.' I'm looking at Vince and he goes, he starts telling me a story, 'I knew this kid in school and he looked like this' and he did this face. 'This is the way he looked and when something would happen, he'd lose his mind like crazy!' And I'm looking at him, going, 'I can do that - that's not a problem.' So he goes, 'do this face!' and I do the Festus open mouth, tongue out face and he looked at me and he goes, 'can you do that?' And I start doing it and then we start doing it back and forth. And Vince is like, 'not like that! Like this! Make your jaw more slack!' And I'm like, 'Oh my God! I must make Vince happy!'"
The backstory of the Festus character would take a dark twist when Luke Gallows joined CM Punk in one of the most underappreciated and underrated stables ever, The Straight Edge Society. In that run, Punk would reveal Festus and the way he acted was in actuality a side effect of Festus’ family and friends drugging him with large amounts of prescription pain medication. Gallows would thank Punk for being the one to get him clean and “showing him the way.”
The majority of the time when WWE repackages a talent they cover up any previous incarnation they had but this a rare case of Luke Gallows and Festus being the same character.
5. Mankind
After being Cactus Jack for years in WCW, ECW, Smoky Mountain Wrestling and Japan, Mick Foley debuted in the WWF in 1996 with a new persona: ‘Mankind’.
It was a disturbing character in Mick Foley's early run with WWF, as he presented himself to the audience as mentally tortured whilst squealing/screaming continuously in his promos. He talked of his woes to a rat named George, wailed for his "Mommy!", wore a Hannibal Lecter-esque mask, festered in boiler rooms and regularly abused himself.
Mankind was shown as a deranged individual that touched on mental health/pain in the WWF for the first time. Mick’s later said in interviews he was emotionally drained playing Mankind.
Mankind participated in a sit-down interview with Jim Ross in 1997 that gave some clues into his backstory (before he put the Mandible Claw on JR), claiming he enjoyed pain, saying about society: “They ruled me out because I had a strange appetite for strange things!" and "I never had the chance to show the world that I can love and be loved." He spoke of how he was bullied at school and was called a freak.
Mankind was a tragic character in his early heel days, with Mick playing him as if Mankind truly believed he was the hero in the WWF.
4. Deacon Batista
Batista, former World Heavyweight Champion (four times), WWE Champion (twice) and WrestleMania headliner (twice), first debuted on the main roster in the truly lame gimmick of being D-Von Dudley’s lackey.
Following The Dudley Boyz split, D-Von was repackaged as the villainous preacher ‘Reverend D-Von’ and he introduced WWE to his protégé Deacon Batista. Batista’s said about the gimmick, not mincing his words:
"Only in WWE. When I first came up, I did this character called Deacon Batista, so it was the same last name, but I was working with this guy named D-Von Dudley and he was doing this televangelist preacher type deal where he was collecting money and I held this big, goofy box and I was a security guard of his money box. So ridiculous. It was horrible."
On a Talk Is Jericho podcast appearance, Batista revealed some of the early ideas for this character that thankfully were dropped, saying how at one time WWE’s initial plans were to reveal the reason the Batista character was so angry all the time was because he was “a rape child” - a monster who destroyed everything in his path because his mother was once raped and he had no knowledge of who his father was.
3. CM Punk
CM Punk will go down as one of the most wicked heels to ever step into a wrestling ring. On FS1’s Backstage this year Punk talked about when he led The Straight Edge Society and how he was so hated, especially when wrestling in the “Bible Belt” (southern United States), that the elderly in the audience would take swings at him and try and attack him.
But you can very much argue CM Punk was misunderstood when playing a heel. He would get heat from yelling at crowds with his “I’m better than you” attitude and his Charles Manson inspired deranged outlook/look (long-haired, bearded, red-eyed), but the things he would say in his promos were be genuine. CM Punk’s told of how some in his family growing up were plagued by alcoholism, hence a central reason why he leads a straight edge lifestyle and loudly advocates for it. It’s Punk’s real-life backstory that he intertwined with his wrestling persona.
What’s disturbing about Punk’s heel character in his 2009-10 run when he was chastising alcohol and prescription drugs is he was completely telling the truth and getting booed for it, especially in his feud with Jeff Hardy over the World Heavyweight Championship. He’d tell Hardy, “Jeff, you've got two strikes. You know how many I have? Zero. Jeff, you know how many times I've been suspended? Zero! You know how many times I've been to a rehab facility? That's right: ZERO!”
2. Snitsky
Snitsky’s entire gimmick/backstory/what he’s most remembered for/career after wrestling is centred around the infamous angle on Raw that had him responsible for Lita miscarrying her and Kane’s unborn baby in 2004. His entrance music had him yelling "It wasn't my fault" edited in and it would be adopted as his catchphrase for the rest of his career.
Snitsky’s said regarding the angle years later:
"The whole storyline was kind of cool I thought. It was so different, it was pushing the envelope. Let’s be realistic, everything’s been done in wrestling that can be done, and back then it wasn’t as corporate so you could get away with a little more. Nowadays, that storyline would never ever be able to take place. A lot of people don’t realize, it was only supposed to be that one incident, and I was then gonna go back to OVW and keep training until they brought me back up. But it got such a reaction that it took off and had a mind of its own, so they rolled with it. I knew it was gonna be good as soon as I hit him with the chair and he fell on her, the whole crowd started chanting “baby killer”. When that happened, I was like, This is great, this is gonna be good."
Only in wrestling can someone claim crowds of people yelling ‘baby killer’ at them is a good thing.
Amazingly, in 2014 it was revealed a smiling Snitsky in a cooking apron was the spokesperson for a pressure cooker with him claiming at the end of advertisements: “What are you waiting for? Check out the Power Pressure Cooker XL and become popular, rich and happy. And if you don’t… it’s not my fault. But at the very least, you’ll be well-fed.”
1. Dominik Mysterio
Dominik has been heavily involved in Rey and Seth Rollins’ feud as of late, seeking retribution for the injuries Seth inflicted on Rey and taking his eye. And from a character standpoint, you have to seriously contend that Dominik might have the most disturbing backstory of them all before he trained to be a wrestler when older. It all stems from his father Rey Mysterio’s 2005 feud with Eddie Guerrero, where they both fought over custody of then 8-year-old Dominik.
Really, think about it. From Dominik’s perspective he was a happy-go-lucky kid when his uncle Eddie brutally turned on his Dad and tormented him emotionally and physically for months, with Guerrero later revealing, with his parents crying in the ring, that he was Dominik’s biological father. That resulted in social services taking Dominik away from his parents only for Rey and Eddie to clash in a ladder match, not for a title, but for his custody hanging above the ring.
Dominik, in wrestling canon, technically still has Eddie Guerrero as his biological father. Dominik’s detailed how in real-life the angle affected him growing up, saying: “I believe I was in the third grade at the time. Everyone would ask me, 'So who really is your dad? Is it Eddie? Is it Rey?' And I'd be like, 'Well, it's Rey.' That was always the question every time I got back. Still to this day people are like, 'So who really is your dad?'"