10 DUMB WWE Title Changes (We Didn't Want To Admit Were GENIUS!)

Some of the most unwanted WWE Championship changes in history were sheer genius.

Paul Heyman WWE Title
WWE

World Champions in real sports function without split focus. If you're champ, then you're the centrepiece of boxing, UFC, football etc. Wrestling is different. Being predetermined allows for creative manoeuvrability and foresight. Promoters don't always look one or two steps beyond the here and now, but they have the chance to without fear of plans being shredded.

Injuries or backstage drama are the only real wobbles facing wrestling writers. Otherwise, they're free to map out plans for the next 12-18 months if they wish, and know there's little standing in the way of turning on paper dreams into on camera reality. That's a blessing, and it's why some seemingly-stupid WWE Title changes turned out to be genius moves.

Fans just didn't see it at the time. How could they? They were in the moment.

Vince McMahon has palmed off a lot criticism over the years for failing to plan things properly, especially towards the end of his run as WWE patriarch. Some of that was fair, but not all of it. The old boss was rarely shy about backing a new horse to see what might happen, or sneakily irking his fanbase knowing what'd be coming later on.

For example...

10. JBL (2004)

WWE Great American Bash 2004 JBL
WWE

Jaws were agape when JBL beat Eddie Guerrero to become WWE Champ at the Great American Bash 2004. How could that happen?! The ex-APA brawler was a tag-team guy and that was it. Surely he wouldn't have the chops to work out as the main man. Anyone thinking that would be shown up throughout '04 and into '05.

People were p*ssed when Layfield beat the popular Guerrero and ended his run, but it was the right move for SmackDown. That show now had a linchpin heel to centre itself around, and WWE knew they could build the easy-to-despise JBL up then tear him down when the time called for that.

That's exactly what the company did with John Cena at WrestleMania 21.

Bradshaw was a necessary evil in the heel champion role, and he had to hold the strap for a long time so fans would beg to see him fall. Giving him a lengthy reign, then using JBL's disconnect with the fanbase as a means to elevate Cena to the top of cards was sensational work from all involved.


9. Sheamus (2009)

TLC 2009 Sheamus
WWE.com

What was that about McMahon backing new horses?

Fans had settled into a pattern of John Cena and Randy Orton trading the WWE Title in recent years, so a newbie like Sheamus winning at TLC 2009 was a bolt from the blue. Nobody saw it coming, and therein lies the true beauty of unexpected change. Sheamus rocketed up the ranks in mere months, then ploughed through Cena’s seemingly-invincible armour like it was nothing to him.

The Irishman has been treated like a top star ever since, which really shows the strength of JC's act. WWE making sure Sheamus went over in a singles match (one with the tacked on tables gimmick) was the genius part. There's no way his first title win would've meant as much had it happened in June 2010's Fatal-4-Way scenario, put it that way.

A lot of folks were dumbfounded when this newbie went from ECW > Raw > WWE Champ in short order, but it did launch a new star and create a bonafide main eventer overnight. It's hard to argue with that sort of thing regardless of what some haters thought in '09.


8. The Miz (2021)

The Miz
WWE.com

Some might've forgotten that The Miz snatched Money In The Bank glory from ladder match winner Otis towards the end of 2020/into early 2021 then cashed in on Drew McIntyre. It seemed almost surreal that Miz was WWE Champion again - he'd been more of a midcard attraction for a decade plus, yet here he was trolling everyone with the top belt.

The circumstances are crucial here.

Drew had just won a gruelling Elimination Chamber match, so think of this as a heel chipping away at McIntyre’s heroic exterior and pushing him closer to an eventual heel turn. WWE didn’t know it at the time, obviously, but they were adding fuel to the fire for Drew's character. This was one of his first big disappointments.

Accidentally or not, booking moments like this shaped McIntyre into a hardened Steve Austin-style 'don't trust anybody' kind of wrestler. Miz didn't hold the title for long before dropping it to Bobby Lashley, but he did successfully irritate a lot of people by even being involved at the top table again.


7. John Cena (2017)

John Cena WWE Champion
WWE

Remember this: A lot of the fans cheering for John Cena's retirement tour in 2025 would've rolled their eyes and dismissed his "Super Cena" guise in 2017. In fact, a fair few would've been angry that WWE put Cena over workhorse champ AJ Styles at the Royal Rumble that year at all. What were they thinking?!

History. That's what they were thinking.

Did John need another title reign? No, not really, but this win tied him with Ric Flair's almost-mythical 16-time World Champion brag. Being a 16-time champ has added some extra juice to John's coming retirement jaunt too. Keep in mind he was clearly winding down as a WWE full-timer at the time, so this win was a neat way to hammer home his legendary status.

Hardcore fans did not like it at the time though. They'd been enjoying a breath of fresh air like Styles, and fancied seeing him hold the gold for a long time to come. Christ knows what they thought of soon-to-be experiment Jinder Mahal then!


6. Brock Lesnar (2019)

Brock Lesnar Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

Well, this isn't going to be popular.

No, a lot of readers aren't going to like this, but WWE were looking at things from a business perspective when they trashed Kofi Kingston's title reign on the 4 October 2019 episode of SmackDown. That was the show's debut on FOX, so Vince McMahon fancied booking something monumental that'd rock the boat and get everyone talking.

Like it or not, he achieved that goal. It's also true that, whilst 'KofiMania' was magical, Brock Lesnar is a much bigger star than the New Day man. So, sure, the circumstances were rotten for anyone who had invested in Kingston, but Lesnar had instant heat on him that'd carry all the way to Drew McIntyre's win at the super-weird WrestleMania 36.

Just ignore the wonky Cain Velasquez stuff. That was definitely rubbish, but time has been kinder to Brock's win than some would be willing to admit. It reeked of McMahon playing favourites, which then fed right into Drew's Royal Rumble win and eventual title glory.

Having a killer heel like Lesnar to shoot down really helped McIntyre out.


5. Big Show (2002)

WWE Survivor Series 2002 Big Show Paul Heyman
WWE

If you hated Brock beating Kofi in 2019, then you'll get a right good chuckle out of Lesnar suffering some misfortune of his own back in 2002. Initially, it seemed daft to think that Big Show would be the one handpicked to beat Brock and end his first WWE Title reign at Survivor Series that year. Show hadn't exactly been reliable, had he?

WWE looked past his shortcomings and towards the bigger picture.

Show beating Brock in Madison Square Garden achieved two things. One, it got the scheming Paul Heyman (who came across less like he cared about Show and more than he wanted the belt himself) out of there and enabled Brock to push towards a babyface run. Two, it meant Kurt Angle could win the belt from Paul Wight at Armageddon then drop it to newfound baby success story Lesnar at WrestleMania XIX.

In short, Show was a buffer zone between those guys that meant WWE wouldn't need to burn Angle vs. Lesnar on a 'B'-tier pay-per-view. Smartly, they also booked Angle vs. Chris Benoit at the Rumble, then focused on Brock's march back towards the crown.

Those groans in MSG had been all for naught.


4. Kane (1998)

WWF WWE King Of The Ring 1998 Kane Paul Bearer
WWE

Fans there live for the historic King Of The Ring 1998 show likely thought they'd see shenanigans aplenty in the 'First Blood' main event between 'Stone Cold' and Kane. Austin was keeping the belt somehow, everyone watching reasoned. Everyone would be wrong. The WWF put the thing on The Undertaker's brother instead, and Paul Bearer ended the night squealing his shrill catchphrases like a delighted puppy.

No-one saw that coming.

Granted, Kane's title reign only lasted 24 hours before Austin regained the strap on Raw, but it did legitimise the 'Big Red Machine' as a headliner regardless. He'd only been created as a one-off feud for 'Taker, but Kane was so convincing in the role that McMahon rewarded him with an unlikely title win.

This interrupted Austin's post-WrestleMania XIV flow, no doubt, but the PPV result was shocking and the Raw rematch on free TV was resplendent 'Attitude Era' goodness. Whilst short, Kane's fleeting run with the top prize was hardly as dumb as it seemed back in '98.


3. Hulk Hogan (1993)

hulk hogan wrestlemania 9
WWE.com

When Bret comes crashing down, and it hurts inside. You've gotta call Hulk, and he'll turn the tide.

Those are definitely not the lyrics to Hogan's iconic 'Real American' entrance track, but they should've been back at WrestleMania IX. Bret Hart fell short to towering heel Yokozuna in the PPV's main event, then big bald Terry strolled out to defend his honour by...scooping the glory and ending the night as WWF Champion again.

A lot of folks look back on this and hate on Hogan for suddenly winning the title, but the federation's reason for doing it makes perfect sense. They'd tried to send Hulk out to pasture with The Ultimate Warrior in 1990, and again in coming years. By '93, all attempts to replace Hulkamania had failed, so Vince McMahon wanted to see if there was anything left in Hogan.

He knew he could always come back to Bret if things failed, which he did. Mr. Fuji firing out a challenge on the knackered Yoko's behalf was ridiculous, but WWF loyalists popped huge for Hulk becoming a five-time champ. This was worth doing, if only to find out if the Hulk marketing machine would chuck some much-needed cash into fed tills.


2. Hulk Hogan (2002)

WWF WWE Backlash 2002 Hulk Hogan
WWE

'Hulk Hogan: The Reprise'.

There was something poetic about Hulk being the final WWF Champion before the company changed initials to WWE on 6 May 2002. His return as part of the nWo had been shocking but so-so overall, then WrestleMania X8 occurred. There, everyone realised how much they'd missed Hulkamania on WWF programming since 1993.

The timing was fascinating. Triple H had returned amidst much fanfare in January, and he won the top belt at 'Mania from Chris Jericho. One month later, Hunter was staring at the lights for a nostalgia act. Backlash '02 was a love letter to those who'd dearly missed Hulk and others who'd had their fill of Hollywood in WCW's nWo.

It didn't last long (how could it - the man's hips and knees were turning to dust!), but capitalising on that sudden wave of hysteria for Hulkamania 2.0 was genius. It showed a willingness from the soon-to-be WWE to pivot, and proved that Triple H was business minded.


1. Bob Backlund (1994)

Bob Backlund WWE Title
WWE.com

Get your jokes in now about crusty old-timey star Bob Backlund winning the WWF Title during 'New Generation' hype in 1994. In fairness, Bob had struck gold as an out of touch old warhorse who hated all these new fangled wrestlers with their merchandise and flashy gimmicks. The man was literally ideal for the role.

He hadn't been panning out as a babyface anyway. Fans thought Backlund was a boots n' tights bore, and no amount of epic performances in Royal Rumble matches could change that. Flipping the script and going from happy-go-lucky retro baby to delusional but successful and dangerous heel was the right call.

Even so, most grumbled when Bob beat Bret Hart at Survivor Series '94.

It was one of the most implausible title switches ever, but it worked a treat. Owen Hart got to look like a despicable brother screwing over Bret, then new monster Diesel crushed Backlund on a house show to win the belt a few days later. This was win-win for everybody.

What other "dumb" WWE Title changes had hidden genius? For more wrestling, check out 15 Things We Learned From Vince McMahon's Docuseries On Netflix and 10 DUMB WWE Booking Decisions (We Didn't Want To Admit Were GENIUS!)!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.