10 Ex-WWE Superstars With Unfinished Business

WWE needs to revive some bad apples!

carlito the bad apple
WWE.com

If there's one thing Vince McMahon has proved over the years, it's that, short of a Chris Benoit-sized horror story or, as it seems, a spot of awful racism, no one is truly ever Gone For Good when it comes to WWE.

History has shown that pretty much anyone that's rubbed the Boss up the wrong way can make amends and be back on Raw one day, whether it's Steve Austin bringing his ball back in 2003, the Ultimate Warrior building bridges to finally make it into the WWE Hall Of Fame last year shortly before his untimely passing, or Bret Hart putting the most infamous wrestling bust-up in history to rest when he returned to WWE's flagship programme after over 12 years away in 2010.

Be it through simply falling down the pecking order and out of favour or sticking a middle finger up at the company and rolling off into the sunset, there are many WWE alumni who left before their time was truly up, and who we reckon would still have plenty to offer should they decide to return...

10. Alberto Del Rio

Alberto Del Rio To Forget
WWE.com

What Happened: After an amazing early push that saw him win the Royal Rumble, bag a Money In The Bank contract and win his first World Title courtesy of a cash-in on a white-hot CM Punk (yeah, it didn't really benefit anyone in hindsight, did it?), Del Rio fell in and out of the main event scene before falling out with the company after an altercation with a WWE employee. Del Rio was released like a poo after a hot curry, and headed to Lucha Underground by way of AAA.

How To Book A Return: A simple Rumble return would do the job for someone like Del Rio - give him the chance to come out, hit all his badass spots (god damn we love that enziguri) and flirt with some potential future feuds. Oh, and obviously, it has to be with a full Ricardo Rodriguez intro. Splitting those dudes up was criminal.


9. Drew McIntyre

drew mcintyre
WWE.com

What Happened: This one was a real head-scratcher. Introduced in 2007 as Vince McMahon's 'Chosen One', Drew seemed to have it all: a tall, well-built, good-looking guy with natural charisma and a decent workrate, with the open backing of the Boss himself.

A largely meandering few years ended with him being drafted into the brilliantly daft but criminally underused 3MB, before being let go as part of a roster cut that featured some other surprising names including Brodus Clay and Evan Bourne. He's since dabbled with TNA and re-established himself as the face of ICW, and has vowed that he'll be back in WWE one day.

How To Book It: During a Raw UK run (preferably in Glasgow, of course - hey, we're fantasy booking!), have his old buddy and fan favourite Heath Slater receive an ass-whupping courtesy of some heels (we vote that dastardly Stardust and his Ascension goons). Drew makes a surprise and ecstatically received return to make the save, only to then turn around and kick the holy snot out of Heath himself. Boo! How could you! You were bandmates, dammit! Drew then goes on a heel run that'd see him feud with the likes of Cesaro, Ziggler and basically all the cool faces that he can have wicked matches with.


8. Shelton Benjamin

Shelton Benjamin Ic Champion
WWE.com

What Happened: Arguably the best pure athlete that came through WWE's ranks in the early 2000s, graduating from the same class as John Cena, Batista, Brock Lesnar and Randy Orton (yeah, it was a solid year), Shelton became one of the most reliable workers in the company, becoming the star of the early Money In The Bank matches and wrestling awesome bouts with everyone from Shawn Michaels to Rob Van Dam. Oh, and his mum turned up for a while. 

Whether it was a perceived lack of true 'star appeal' or just some bad luck of the draw, Shelton was released from WWE in April 2010 in a roster cut that also included Jimmy Wang Yang and Slam Master J. Brutal.

How To Book A Return: This one's easy: host a tournament to qualify for the next Money In The Bank ladder match (which should be at Wrestlemania rather than its own show. Just saying), and have Shelton turn up as a surprise participant in the final match. He loses. We're joking; Shelton wins and goes on to steal the show once again in the MITB, just falling short of winning the briefcase (er, once again. Sorry Shelton) but re-establishing himself as a total lad and going on to do battle in what, by that point, should be electric US and Intercontinental title scenes.


7. John Morrison

John Morrison WWE
WWE.com

What Happened: One of the most gifted and unique athletes to emerge during the wake of the Ruthless Aggression era, Morrison established himself as one of the most exciting wrestlers in the company. While accusations that he couldn't cut it on the mic often hindred his progress, he was electric in the ring and produced five star matches with the likes of Rey Mysterio, Dolph Ziggler, Sheamus and CM Punk amongst others. 

He parted amicably with WWE in 2011, and while he initially hinted he may be taking a long sabbatical from the squared circle, he's been on the indie circuit since, including his current and excellent stint with Lucha Underground.

How To Book It: Frustrated with his terrible booking over the past three ye-sorry, with a perceived lack of athletic competition (KAYFABE!!!), a heel Dolph Ziggler goes on a run of ludicrously OTT, show-offy squashes of WWE midcarders, getting on the mic before and after every match to hate on fan favourites and b*tch on how lame the locker room is.

He wants competition, damn it! No one can steal the show like him! You can probably guess what happens next: out comes Johnny Nitro (who, it should be pointed out, is great on the mic these days) and in come three months of wrestling masterclasses. Easy.


6. Jim Ross

Jim Ross Raw
WWE.com

What Happened: In what universe is there no room in WWE for a man who has given so much to that company? Oh, that's right, the WWE Universe! After making a few sporadic appearances over the previous three or four years, Jim's incredible WWE career came to a firm conclusion following a bizarre incident that saw Ross fail to control a seemingly drunk Ric Flair (and a very amused Steve Austin) at a launch event for the WWE 2K14 game in September 2013. 

Ross has since indicated that he is open to any work that may be available, though he is effectively done with being on the road in a 24/7 capacity. Which is fair enough, as the dude's 63.

How To Book A Return: No big storyline needed: as his podcast shows, Jim still has one of the sharpest minds in the business and is an invaluable addition to any wrestling organisation. His experience as Head Of Talent Relations means he could be an extremely useful addition to WWE's backstage staff, be that in Connecticut, NXT or even remotely. Just bring the guy home, already. It's ridiculous.


5. Carlito

Carlito Wwe
WWE.com

What Happened: After an immense initial run that saw him defeat John Cena for the US title on his debut and go on to establish himself as one of WWE's finest midcard talents (and one half of the underrated Colons tag team), Carlito did a very uncool thing by getting himself Future Endeavoured due to a violation of the WWE's Wellness Program. 

Rumours that he had refused to go to rehab to deal with an addiction to painkillers didn't help matters, but, after five years working the independant circuit, rumours have recently arisen that Carlito is talking to WWE about a potential return. Now that would be cool.

How To Book It: Now, how's this for impact: backstage at Raw, John Cena runs into Cesaro, who promises that he's gonna have one more crack at that US title...in the Open Challenge tonight! However, as Cena's waiting in the ring, Cesaro is found unconscious backstage...covered in apple chunks?! 

Cue the shocking return of Carlito, who, in a nod to his 2004 debut, cheats to beat Cena and take the title! Carlito then manages to retain the title in the rematch, before a disgrunted Cesaro shows up to  get some sweet revenge in a feud that would be capable of some world class matches (and, finally, putting the title on Cesaro for a long and prestigious reign).


4. Rey Mysterio

Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

What Happened: It's easy to take Rey Rey for granted in 2015. His last couple of years with WWE were injury-prone and without any feuds or angles that really set the world alight. It also didn't help that he received what was arguably the most lukewarm reception for a big name Rumble competitor ever in 2014 when the crowd realised that there really would be no Daniel Bryan that year. After reports of some rather messy contract issues arose at the start of this year, Mysterio finally left WWE in February after 13 years with the company.

How To Book A Return: Recent issues aside, Mysterio is an iron-clad future Hall Of Famer; the most famous cruiserweight in pro wrestling history, an incredible competitor in his heyday and, even now, still a guy that surely has enough to offer to warrant at least one final run with the company. Bring him back in when he's ready, book him in a Mania feud with a hungry and skilled young'un (Adrian Neville?), let him put that person over after one final, great match and let him get that last Mania moment he deserves. You know it makes sense.


3. Beth Phoenix

Beth Phoenix
WWE.com

What Happened: If there's been one unforgivable casualty of the Diva division's failings in recent years, it is surely the Glamazon. One of the most promising female competitors to have ever walked down the ramp, Beth had the potential to be a real one-of-a-kind champion, and in fairness, her three Women's titles, one Diva's title and standing as only the second woman to ever enter the Royal Rumble are something to be proud of. Truth be told, though, the division just didn't give her enough legitimate competition or interesting angles, and by the time she left in September 2012, it felt like a missed opportunity.

How To Book A Return: If, as we recently suggested in our ideas for where the Diva Revolution can go from here, Team B.A.D. were to split, it'd create a mini-feud between a face Sasha Banks and a heel Naomi, with Tamina in her corner. The blow-off could then be a match between Naomi and Sasha, who seemingly has the deck stacked against her, until she reveals that she's managed to find someone to equalise the Tamina threat. That person? You guessed it. Of course, you could just have Beth turn up after a long, hard fought title match between two or three of the many great female wrestlers in the WWE right now and just mash them up. Either/or.


2. Kurt Angle

kurt angle tna promo shoot
ImpactWrestling.com

What Happened: This really is a no-brainer on every single level imagineable. Released from his contract in 2006 (he went on to say that WWE were "running [him] into the ground" and giving him no time off to let him heal up from a host of nagging injuries), Angle has since helped prop TNA up through countless peaks and troughs and, ultimately, done everything there could possibly be left to do over there. He's gone on record many times since last year saying that he feels great, any lingering issues are long behind him and that he's ready for a WWE comeback. For the love of wrestling, make it happen, WWE!

How To Book A Return: Have Angle make a surprise return early on in the 2016 Royal Rumble. Give him a good solid run with a few eliminations and hot moments, before around the 25-man mark, out comes...DANIEL BRYAN! The crowd goes apesh*t as the Bearded One makes his long-awaited return from injury, teasing a face-off with an annoyed Angle, who then gets eliminated by Bryan. 

Angle, furious that D-Bry has ruined his big moment, then interferes in the Rumble to get Bryan eliminated. Heel turn! Bah gawd! This, of course, then leads to an immense feud and one of the greatest Mania matches of all time. 


1. CM Punk

cm punk hoodie
WWE.com

What Happened: You may have heard about this one. Arguably the most controversial WWE exit since the Montreal Screwjob (but perhaps slightly outdone by the whole Hogan being a racist thing), Punk walked out on the company as last year's Wrestlemania season got underway, lifting the lid on the explosive situation in a jaw-dropping podcast with Colt Cabana a few months later that pretty much got the entire internet on his side. 

Still, the fact is that despite having the longest WWE Title reign of the modern era, Punk was never truly treated like The Man during his run, and the fact that he never won a Royal Rumble or properly headlined a Wrestlemania is insane. INSANE, WE SAY!

How To Book A Return: With his UFC commitments and, like, hating the company's guts and stuff, it's fair to say Punk won't be back any time soon, so allow us to pose this at 2017 and beyond. Punk makes a shock return at a Royal Rumble, winning it and then starting Raw the next night, microphone in hand, with the simple line: "My name is CM Punk, and I've got something to say."

Cue a monster pipebomb that clears everything up and set the agenda, Triple H trying (and failing) to screw him out of his Wrestlemania title match and him then going on to win the title at Mania, before feuding with a bitter heel Reigns angry at him 'doing a Batista' and therefore the very thing he raged against. Cool, right?


In this post: 
Carlito
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling fan. I like to talk about it. Argue with me!