10 Expectations Vs. Reality For WWE WrestleMania 38
The WWE WrestleMania 38 card looks terrible, but will it actually BE terrible...?
WrestleMania creates such a vast expectation of quality that matches automatically become better than they really are because they happened at WrestleMania.
To WWE fans, it's the biggest night of the calendar year. To lapsed fans who once loved WWE but despise it now, it's the one night per year that they actually watch. Everybody that retains a passing interest in professional wrestling watches WrestleMania because it is WrestleMania.
The build to last year's event was truly abysmal. Edge dilly-dallying over which title to pursue, can-they-co-exist bullsh*t repeated about four times, AJ Styles doing lamer segments than Bobby's Sisters and Old Day: it was horrendous, and yet, the magic of WrestleMania still glowed despite Bayley's cruel burial and box-like structures.
But how true is that in 2022?
WrestleMania 38 is a weird hybrid of a freak show and TV-quality undercard fare so mundane and repetitive that WWE has had to resort two at least two mystery opponent storylines, all but admitting that they can't tell stories. Isn't...isn't that what the "bad" promotion relies on? Constant "surprises"?
Half the friggin' card is a surprise at this point.
So what can be expected of it, really, and will it match the reality...?
10. The Undercard
Expectation:
It's WrestleMania, and the first "proper" WrestleMania since 2019. The crowd is going to be massively up for the occasion - so much so that the more inessential-seeming "attractions" will be elevated by the return of sports entertainment's most gorgeous, big-time backdrop. Yes, much of WrestleMania might look like a bit drab on paper, but you'll all get lost in the spell.
Reality:
This article will take a remarkably positive turn momentarily, but not here. That undercard is an atrocity that the novelty of WrestleMania won't do a f*cking thing to solve. Sasha Banks might be the most mishandled talent in the modern history of the company. She's in a meaningless multi-woman tag. The undercard will be as depressing as it is drab.
What a sh*tty line-up of matches that in the context to which they truly belong - filler episodes of television - would end after a maximum of nine minutes in a disqualification. Rick Boogs might draw a pop by squawking, and Randy Orton and Riddle doing a stereo RKO spot will raise the roof after 15 minutes of something that's been done to death on RAW of late, but what are Drew McIntyre and Happy Corbin going to do?
12 punishingly dull minutes of f*ck all, that's what.
9. Edge Vs. AJ Styles
Expectation:
An absolute classic for the ages, a match every bit as seminal as Kurt Angle Vs. Shawn Michaels, Shawn Michaels Vs. The Undertaker, Randy Savage Vs. Ricky Steamboat, Daniel Bryan Vs. Kofi Kington, Bret Vs. Owen...
Both men are outstanding at the craft and will be granted plenty of time to reach the "epic" stratosphere on a gimmick-packed celeb night with not too many matches listed thus far. They each excel at the counter, which should create some superb, heart-in-mouth drama even before their deep repertoires are kicked out of as the acute near-falls pop the crowd down the stretch. Anything less than very good would be considered a major disappointment, but luckily, that is effectively impossible. Both men are simply too great at this, which is why the match was made in the first instance.
Edge countering the Phenomenal forearm with a mid-air Spear, AJ Styles landing on his feet after Edge ducks a Pele kick, only to be met by the Edge-o-Matic...
Rejoice!
This can't not be fantastic!
Reality:
It will be fantastic, but be prepared for some ac-ting from your man Edge, who seems desperate for a Hollywood exec to notice him. He might even pull up a stool and say long words for the sake of appearing intelligent when talking trash.
****1/2 wrestling, 0 chance of an Emmy despite some cringe-worthy attempts.
8. Can Ronda Rousey Level Up?
Expectation:
Ronda Rousey was incredible in 2018. A not particularly pleasant human being, yes, but one who stormed through a rookie year that was possibly more impressive than even Kurt Angle's. A "hot take" perhaps, but Angle had the benefit of working Chris Jericho, Chris Benoit, and The Rock. Ronda Rousey had a rock to work with, but she had to push the f*cker up a mountain in the form of Nia Jax, and she somehow managed to do it.
Twice!
But that Ronda Rousey has not returned. This Ronda Rousey, quite understandably, lacks the same killer dynamism.
Reality:
Ronda is a star and will prove why she's a star on the biggest stage possible. That's what stars do. The first match with Charlotte Flair, at Survivor Series 2018, was exceptional. The pacing was furious, the near-misses on Ronda's back-fists were so perfectly-timed that it felt like a proper scrap, and the tone was nice and nasty. The only thing it lacked was a satisfying finish, and that should be corrected here.
Ronda looked poor at the Rumble, and Charlotte has declined since 2018 - but this should overdeliver. Flair has a habit of this.
7. Bianca Belair Vs. Becky Lynch
Expectation:
It's the story WWE elegantly planted at SummerSlam, and will finally be brought to a euphoric, cathartic close: after being wrong-footed and humiliated by Becky Lynch, Bianca Belair will at last exact her revenge at the culmination of a long-term story arc. The crowd will go wild as Belair powers out of the Disarm Her, slams Lynch to the mat, and recaptures the RAW Women's Title. The scene will act as evidence that, despite being written off by many, Vince McMahon doesn't just book TV at random. He knows what he's doing, even if the cynics can't see it.
Don't doubt his genius. This man took wrestling away from smoky bingo halls!
Reality:
Despite Lynch claiming on RAW this week that the fans turned their backs on her, they've never once had the heart to jeer her. She either gets cheered in defiance or loses audiences entirely with her acting reel. Also, WWE hasn't exactly preserved this story; Lynch and Belair have worked together extensively, people mostly got over it, and what is effectively a B-tier rivalry will sadly receive a B-tier reception until the fans are worked into caring about it in the last five minutes.
6. How Good Will Logan Paul Be?
Expectation:
He isn't a pro wrestler, so he probably won't be particularly good at pro wrestling. Besides which, he's in there with Dominick Mysterio, who's hardly a plane-hopping NWA World Champion carry-job specialist from the territory era. He's closer to the broomstick, if anything. Rey Mysterio remains incredible at his craft, not that WWE recognises this by booking him in nothing nine-minute RAW matches, so the omens aren't great for that interaction either. The Miz Vs. Dominick Mysterio meanwhile has as much chance of creating a 'WrestleMania Moment' in 2022 as Disco Inferno does. This is going to be actively horrendous.
Reality:
The reality is that celebrities almost invariably perform well on the Grandest Stage because WWE actually gives a sh*t about protecting and impressing them. It would embarrass WWE under the watchful eye of the mainstream media if they didn't. Measures are taken to ensure the success of this sort of thing, and moreover, despite being a d*ckhead of a human being, Logan Paul is no slouch as an athlete. WWE being WWE are too thick to just let the f*cking guy cut a heel promo on TV, which he'd be incredible at, but they will get it right on the night.
5. The Cody Question
Expectation:
They'll botch Cody Rhodes. Surely. They botch everybody else. Why would Cody be any different?
He won't be allowed to blade or set himself on fire anymore. He won't be allowed to cut promos that range from incredible to bemusing because few in WWE are actually allowed to be interesting. And already, the storyline hinting towards his arrival is bad. Seth Rollins can't get a match at WrestleMania. They are literally telling a story about a man they have built as a star for a decade not being enough of a star to appear on a card alongside Austin Theory and Natalya, so how is Cody expected to become a star under this nonsensical approach? The fans only just got that Cody is actually on his way, and that was Chicago. The rest of the "WWE Universe" can't take the hint. How loud can it be?
Reality:
WWE are brilliant at precisely one thing - being incredibly cynical - and putting Cody over as a star attraction is a brilliantly cynical move. Such a move encourages his AEW peers to consider jumping in the future. He'll work an excellent match with Rollins, and delaying his debut is a tremendous ploy: it will make the occasion feel that more surreal and special when it actually happens.
Cody almost has to turn heel quickly - he's the traitor, the man who talked more sh*t about WWE than anybody - so expect some sh*t-eating grin "too sweet" taunts mid-match to gradually draw the ire of the crowd.
If WWE are competent...
4. Sami Zayn Vs. Johnny Knoxville
Expectation:
A disgrace to the great sport of professional wrestling, which WWE somehow still is in the minds of some people because Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels had cracking runs with the Intercontinental Title in the early 1990s. That title is somehow still revered by WWE fans, even though the promotion has spent longer saying it might be prestigious again than actually building its prestige.
Johnny Knoxville was buried in some circles for having the temerity not to be Ricky Steamboat in 1987. Respectfully: what promotion have you been watching for the last 23 years, since the Godfather won the belt in 1999?
And yet, expectations for Zayn Vs. Knoxville are very low because some fans think that WWE is or should be Jim Crockett Promotions.
Reality:
This should be fabulous for what it is: a violent comedy freak show match pitting a genuine household star against an absurdly skilled and versatile performer who has finally worked out how to get over in the WWE system. Anything goes, so the stip should allow for some daft stunts, which is probably better than WWE pretending to care about wrestling. Knoxville lulling Zayn backstage and into a comedically oversized swinging hand prop? Zayn being struck by a tidal wave of water? Or maybe WWE will just be f*cking useless again and do fake electrocution effects.
Still, better than a ***1/4 match that nobody gives a sh*t about.
3. Mr. McMahon's Involvement
Expectation:
Trust WWE to turn the most inexplicable news report of a bat-sh*t year into something mundane, Jesus Christ. Before something happened - Vince McMahon realising that he's 76 and has more marbles in his mouth these days, presumably - John Pollock of the reputable Post Wrestling had revealed that Mr. McMahon Vs. Pat McAfee was listed internally for WrestleMania 38. Vince McMahon, working a match! Jesus! If he took just one bump, he might turn to dust! Could he still make his t*tties dance, or have they gone full Mae Young at the 2000 Royal Rumble? Has he become so desperate to flog tickets that he was willing to risk an irreversible injury?
We will never know. Plans changed, and WWE is going with Pat McAfee Vs. Austin Theory.
Reality:
Mr. McMahon will make his presence felt. These pseudo-RAW cards need some juice to get something out of those tens of thousands of fans. Hell, they need minutes. Can you see Sami Zayn and Johnny Knoxville going 20 on what is at time of writing a six-match card?
McMahon is going to pretend to make the save for Theory, be daft enough to take an unintentional bump from him, then make him, with the help of McAfee, join the 'Kiss My Ass' club.
That old man ass will be quite the sight to behold.
2. Roman Reigns Vs. Brock Lesnar
Expectation:
F*cking hell, Roman Reigns Vs. Brock Lesnar again?
This is the third time they've ran this, what do they think it is, Austin Vs. The Rock? Christ. It's so boring at this point. The match won't even be any good. The barricade will get broken somehow, Roman will cut a monologue during a dull spot, and then he'll take about 800 Germans before winning in the end. Sigh. Can't WWE think of something else other than this? It's been seven years. Rock and Austin was a better trilogy, and they wrapped it in four.
Reality:
Beyond some terrible editing in worn Attitude Era-adjacent angles, this feud has been top WWE tier. Lesnar is a riot as the jolly hard man psychopath, and Roman's character work is significantly better than his 2020 monologues. Playing the role of a man whose facade of dominance is slipping, his aggressive blow-ups and defensive jokes are fantastic, unique, and entertaining ways of showing ass just as the monster puts him in the corner.
The match will be tremendous. This version of Roman Reigns is fantastic, and a worthy equal to Brock. This was always the core issue with a dynamic WWE insisted upon.
The catharsis of Paul Heyman taking an F5 into the Spear near-fall will thrill even the most jaded fan watching just because it's WrestleMania.
1. Steve Austin's Return
Expectation:
Come on. Kevin Owens did a funny Steve Austin cosplay on RAW last night, and he faked out the audience twice in what was a tremendous bit, but the whole thing started with Owens burying Texas out of nowhere and subsequently wearing a silly, over-sized hat. This is a regionalised house show angle building towards a talk show segment, only at WrestleMania, the likes of which Austin performed 17 years ago at 'Mania 21. It's not going to be very good, is it?
If he thought he could work a great match, there'd be a match graphic.
Reality:
This might end up being a dry run for a dry run - Austin is more likely to work Saudi Arabia than Extreme Rules, if in fact the Owens segment goes well - but it's going to rule.
Nobody does this for free, but Austin is a prideful performer; if he wasn't, he'd have taken the blood money years before now. Dave Meltzer has reported that the man is in phenomenal shape. Even if he can't possibly perform like he did in 1998, in 1998, he adapted to become a white-hot brawler and exploded an industry when he was thrashed. Owens and Austin are world-class talkers. They'll make you want to see the conflict before it's even good or not. Pitched somewhere between a match and an angle, it will be great: Austin was a genius at both.
It won't be amazing, and it's obviously a gigantic indictment of WWE's inability to create new stars, but they have an over-delivery up their sleeve. Think Sting in 2022, not Shawn Michaels in 2018.
Provided he's smart enough to mimic the Okada trunks reveal, this will be far better than a desperate, sad payday.