10 Failed Heel Turns Of Popular Wrestlers
In the wrestling business, it can be good to be bad... but not all the time.
When the timing is right, nothing is better than an unexpected heel turn. Whether it's Hogan forming the New World Order or Shawn Michaels throwing Marty Jannetty through the Barber Shop window, an effective heel turn can be a thing of beauty.
However, not all performers are cut out for the life on the dark side. Rickie Steamboat, Rey Mysterio, and RVD are three great examples of athletes who are so skilled in the ring, there is just nothing to dislike. As such, these wrestlers were shackled to the role of babyface for virtually their entire careers.
Conversely, sometimes the turn is out of a performer's hands. Look no further than Roman Reigns or John Cena for proof of that. Switching a money-making babyface to heel can be a big decision and one that can often cause hesitation. Holding back can result in a half-cocked switch and compromise the entire run before it even begins. Similarly, when a wrestler decides to break bad for no reason, it can feel forced and make the entire turn appear contrived and nonsensical - neither is a solid foundation for a convincing heel persona.
Whether it's undying fan support, hesitation in the office, or poor reasoning behind it, some heel turns are simply destined to fail.
10. AJ Styles - WWE (2016)
When AJ Styles finally made his WWE debut at Royal Rumble 2016, the hugely positive reaction he received in response was enough to instantly tell him - and Vince McMahon - that his jump to WWE was the right choice.
His TNA/NJPW fans were pleased to see him, while the WWE Universe unfamiliar with his talents were quickly converted. Styles quickly proved he was exactly what he said he was - 'phenomenal' - which made it all the more illogical when WWE decided to turn him heel.
With the spectacular Styles consistently churning out great matches regardless of opposition, he's a difficult character to dislike under normal circumstances. To make matters even more difficult, they turned him heel during a programme with the already polarising John Cena.
As such, WWE once again ended up with a scenario where the heel was cheered more than the babyface. The crowd erupted when Styles defeated Cena - particularly at SummerSlam. This trend would continue for much of Styles' heel run and few were disappointed when Styles defeated Dean Ambrose for the WWE Title at Backlash.
WWE eventually learned their lesson and went with the fans, turning Styles babyface post-WrestleMania 33.
9. Steve Austin - WWF (2001)
At WrestleMania X-Seven, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin did the unthinkable when he "sold his soul to Satan" and aligned himself with Mr. McMahon in front of 67,000 people.
Timing is everything in wrestling and, while the concept seemed good on paper, it was clear that the fans still loved Austin at the time and the turn felt forced. The fact that the initial turn took place in Austin's home state also didn't help matters; if there's one place that isn't going to boo 'The Texas Rattlesnake', it's probably going to be Texas. Meanwhile, the logic behind the alliance with McMahon also seemed false and contrasted the years of feuding that preceded it.
But the WWF weren't simply going to drop the idea at the first hurdle. Vince McMahon and his team tried their best to generate heat for 'Stone Cold' and, on occasion it worked well. Having the Texan viciously bully Spike Dudley in front of his girlfriend and rough up Michael Cole at ringside were great heat-seeking performances; meanwhile, his assault of long-time friend, Jim Ross in his home state of Oklahoma was also a strong decision.
At times, the heel turn definitely did work and this is perhaps never more evident than his WWF Championship defence against Chris Benoit in Benoit's hometown of Edmonton. However, the WWF often had to rely on exceptional circumstances - such as location - to get fans to really turn on the beloved 'Rattlesnake'.
8. Bret Hart - WCW (1998)
The Montreal Screwjob was arguably the most controversial moment in pro wrestling history. Blurring the lines of fiction and reality, Vince McMahon's double-cross of loyal champion, Bret 'The Hitman' Hart, was as real as it gets.
As the most talked about wrestler in the industry, WCW had a winning hand with Hart - if they knew how to use him. Sadly for all concerned, they did not. 'The Hitman' would make his inauspicious debut on 15 December 1997, where he was announced as the special referee for the Bischoff/Zbyszko bout at Starrcade. Hardly an earth-shaking debut for wrestling's hottest commodity.
Hart would also find himself involved in the confusing conclusion to the Hogan/Sting main event at Starrcade. The finish was a mess and did no favours to the debuting Hart. After initially reprising his role as valiant hero with an opposing stance against the nWo, Hart inexplicably helped Hogan regain the WCW Title in April 1998.
Labelled an "associate member" of the New World Order, Hart was the prime example of a half-baked heel. Instead of being placed in the same bracket as Sting, Goldberg, and DDP as heroic opposition to Hogan's army, he was given a peripheral nWo role that left him in no-man's land.
Through no fault of his own, Hart's heel turn kept him at arm's length from the World Title picture and he was left to tread water as a mid-card bad guy.
7. Sting - TNA (2010)
Sting's time in TNA was rife with memorable moments, from World Title victories to his complete reinvention as 'Joker Sting'. Unfortunately, in the pursuit of unpredictability, TNA went down the road less travelled and took Sting to a territory he was not best suited for - the land of the heel.
Sting had long been established as TNA's franchise player when Hulk Hogan arrived in 2010 and stole his thunder. 'The Stinger' responded by jumping Hogan during his tag match with Abyss against Flair and Styles, turning heel in the process.
The following months saw Sting continue his heelish ways, claiming Hogan was out for himself as he always had been. Sting eventually began teaming with Kevin Nash in his stand against the babyface Hogan and even adopted his old Wolfpac red and black for the first time in over a decade.
While it was undoubtedly different, the whole heel dynamic seemed out of character for TNA's resident conscience. At Bound For Glory, Sting's anti-Hogan crusade was ultimately proved right, when Hogan himself turned heel in the main event. Exonerated as the righteous one all along, Sting left TNA, only to return four months later as a babyface once more.
6. Randy Orton - WWE (2016)
When Randy Orton was paired with Bray Wyatt, the feud initially held promise for the SmackDown superstars. However, that promise would soon turn to confusion, as Orton joined the Wyatt Family himself in October after several weeks of physicality. Contrived, nonsensical and unbelievable, the heel turn was doomed from the start.
Despite winning the Tag Team Championships with the Wyatts, the fans were largely unsure how to react to Orton during this period. Heel Orton was presented largely the same as he had been as a babyface; the only thing that had changed was the company he kept. Growing a hefty beard or simply changing his attire would have made the world of difference.
Worse still, the frequent allusion to Orton's betrayal made the entire angle incredibly predictable. While it can be argued that the entire storyline was constructed that way so fans would tune in for his eventual turn, the Orton/Wyatt relationship lasted five months. WWE had plenty of time to make Orton a card-carrying Wyatt member in that time.
The basis of the alliance was flawed from the start and his predictable switch back to babyface leading into their match at WrestleMania only made Wyatt seem foolish. The supposed 'Eater of Worlds' couldn't predict what the entire world could foresee and, while the feud did result in WWE Championship reigns for both men, their characters suffered in the long term.
5. Michael Cole - WWE (2010)
Okay, while Michael Cole can hardly be labelled a "wrestler" and his status as "popular" may be a bit of a stretch, Cole's heel turn in 2010 was an abomination that demands to be highlighted.
Cole began his subtle turn when he notably started to degrade Daniel Bryan weekly on NXT. This eventually resulted in physicality and cemented Cole's heel status when he cowardly slapped Bryan in the face. His appointment as mouthpiece for the Anonymous GM saw him gain considerable heat from the crowd, specifically when he would begin each statement with the line "and I quote".
However, it wasn't until Cole physically involved himself in the WWE Title match between Miz and Jerry Lawler that his persona became completely unbearable. Cole helped The Miz achieve victory, instigating the feud between Cole and his broadcast partner. The rivalry bled into the show's commentary and became a noticeable distraction from the action, while it also culminated in one of the worst WrestleMania matches in history.
Heel Cole undoubtedly drew heat but it wasn't the "good heat" where people tune in to see the heel get their comeuppance. Instead, his antics drew that which encourages viewers to mute, fast forward or switch off. More than anything else, the sight of Cole in a singlet is one that can never be unseen.
4. Jim Duggan - WCW (2000)
'Hacksaw' Jim Duggan has long been viewed as quite literally the flag-waving American for the bulk of his career. With 'Old Glory' in toe, 'Hacksaw' would habitually incite chants of "USA" throughout his matches and made a name for himself as an American patriot of the wrestling biz. So when 'Hacksaw' switched his allegiance and joined Team Canada, more than a few members of the audience were left confused.
Towards the end of Duggan's run in WCW, 'Hacksaw' was given a significant makeover. After six years with the promotion, Duggan had grown stale and had slipped into the background. The decision was made to have Duggan join Lance Storm's Team Canada in an attempt to repackage 'Hacksaw' as a heel.
Abandoning the stars and stripes for the maple leaf of 'The Great White North', Duggan cut his hair and shaved off his trademark beard. The results left Duggan barely recognisable to fans and it was certainly a dramatic departure from the 'Hacksaw' of old.
The heel turn was initially a shot in the arm for Duggan and made him relevant on TV again. However, after such a prolific run as Uncle Sam's poster boy, fans just didn't buy Duggan as a Canadian turncoat. After just three months, Team Canada turned on Duggan at Starrcade and he returned to his American ways.
3. Hulk Hogan - WWF (2002)
Hogan's homecoming to the company he helped build was a momentous occasion for the wrestling industry. After years opposing McMahon in WCW, the sight of Hogan in a WWF ring was proof that anything can happen in wrestling.
'The Hulkster' was reintroduced to the WWF audience at No Way Out 2002. Flanked by Scott Hall and Kevin Nash, Hogan was brought back under his 'Hollywood' persona, adorned in the black and white of the New World Order. The rebellious trio were immediately positioned as invading heels and presented as opposition for perennial babyfaces, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin and The Rock.
While, on paper, the WCW vs. WWF scenario of the nWo taking on the biggest stars of the Attitude Era seemed like the perfect match, in reality, fans were genuinely pleased to see the exiled WWF alumni. It had been several years since Hall, Nash or Hogan had stepped foot in a WWF arena and the nostalgia factor was inescapable.
The subsequent stand-off between Hogan and The Rock on the Raw was beyond electric and a clear indication that fans were torn over who to cheer. Those fears were realised at 'Mania itself when the emphatically pro-Hogan crowd turned on The Rock and forced the WWF to make it official.
One month later, Hogan was wearing red and yellow and once again holding the WWF Championship.
2. Rikishi - WWF (2000)
After undergoing several persona changes, by late 1999, Rikishi had finally found his groove in the WWF. As the dancing funkster, the plus size Samoan was a popular part of the mid-card and his teaming with Too Cool was a fun act that got over in a big way.
But alas, the babyface push wouldn't last and, within a year of his run as a beloved dancer, 'The Phat Man' was turned heel in one of the most notorious swerves of the Attitude Era. Rikishi was revealed as the man who ran over Steve Austin, infamously claiming that he "did it for The Rock".
The reveal was a massive anti-climax and did nothing for Rikishi's career long-term. However, it did see him gain a momentary taste of the main event scene - even if that taste was laced with defeat. Rikishi would go on to face Austin in a severely one-sided whooping at No Mercy, before losing to The Rock at Survivor Series.
Rikishi would also have a memorable spot in the six-man Hell in a Cell match at Armageddon, falling backwards off the cage into a conveniently placed truck of "wood chippings". After a forgettable tandem with Haku, Rikishi returned to his babyface ways in mid-2001 and remained that way until his release in 2004.
1. Jim Ross - WWF (1996)
Few commentators in wrestling history are as beloved as 'Good Ol' JR'. Right up there with the likes of Gordon Solie and Gorilla Monsoon, Ross' place in history as one of the greatest announcers to ever wear a headset is set in stone... making WWF's decision to turn him heel in 1996 all the more baffling.
With WCW's New World Order angle picking up serious steam, Vince McMahon needed a big angle of his own in response. Shawn Michaels could have betrayed Jose Lothario; The Undertaker could have double-crossed Paul Bearer; Bret Hart could have turned his back on the fans... so many great options!
Sadly, this was WWF in '96. What we got instead was Jim Ross cutting a worked shoot promo in the ring and debuting the "returning" Razor Ramon and Diesel (in reality, the fake versions played by Rick Bognar and Glenn Jacobs). The turn went down like hot beer.
Notwithstanding the fact that everything JR said was laced with serious truth, the reception to the fake Razor and Diesel was overwhelmingly negative. Thankfully, the Ross heel turn was quickly dropped altogether shortly after.