10 Failed WWE Wrestlers Who Became Cult Classics
R-Truth Will Set You Free.
It's never been hard to be universally loved in pro wrestling than right now.
In the social media-obsessed landscape that makes up the modern age, wrestlers are as likely to log in to Twitter to find notifications loaded with hate as they are love regardless of their babyface/heel alignment. Fantasy roleplaying accounts 'shipping them with other faves, dummy fake account set up to slander them and other brand new scenarios impossible to receive, the shrinking world has created a growing number of ways the performers can view their support, but reduced they way to understand what the f*ck it actually means.
There used to be a divide between megastars and cult favourites, but it's getting harder than ever to spot the difference. The IIconics have an astonishing amount of support for their hilarious antics online, but those cheerleaders are likely to clash heads with fans still furious over WrestleMania match that sent Sasha Banks potentially heading for the exit. Becky Lynch gained hundreds of thousands of followers online whilst being painted by the product as the ousted outcast. The "CM Punk" chants may never stop, even though clamours for his return have gradually begin to subside.
'The Voice Of The Voiceless' was at least a mammoth success during his time atop the industry. None of the below ever achieved such status, but have the honour of amber preservations amongst their by fiercely loyal fans.
10. Hakushi
Another superworker from the period WWE doesn't shine enough spotlight on, WhatCulture.com's Benjamin Richardson rather astutely noted that Hakushi's in-ring work was as ahead of the time as the character was behind it.
Watched with frustration in the present day, WWE's cloy "americanising" of the character after a babyface turn missed the point entirely. He'd earned cheers because his matches were too magnificent to boo - battles with Bret Hart, The 1-2-3 Kid and others on a supremely gifted and hardworking roster were routinely the best of the time, with audiences far more sophisticated than an out-of-touch Vince McMahon gave them credit for.
The Hakushi run represents a western sweet spot for Jinsei Shinsaki too. The man behind the painted tattoos thrilled in Japan for decades but only made occasional appearances for ECW et al during the rest of his time in America.
In WWE less than two years total, his back catalogue became a must-watch for fans playing catch-up with the era years later, not least thanks to clashes such as this firecracker with Hart being put over by 'The Hitman' himself as a personal favourite.
9. Diesel
It took Kevin Nash sitting down for about 400 shoot interviews and your writer putting him over in just about the same number of articles, but the court of public opinion may finally be coming to a fairer verdict on 'Big Daddy Cool's WWE contributions.
The Network has been a gift for filling in many fan blanks, and it's deep within the company archives where the fun and function of his divisive WWE Championship reign can be found. Unfortunately for the seven-footer, most things can be proved with statistics, and for decades the horrendous box office and buy rate figures posted against Nash's 1995 run were enough to fuel an entire generation of fans more than happy to go along with CM Punk's on-screen snark and the prevailing sense of disrespect for his finest works.
Matches with and without the WWE Championship against Bret Hart, Razor Ramon, Shawn Michaels and Jeff Jarrett proved his worth as a performer that could pull his weight given an opponent willing to do a touch more of the heavy lifting. The Diesel gimmick was the coolest f*cking thing on the show until Vince McMahon Vince McMahon'ed it, too.
Nash effectively invented the tweener role when he tore that portrayal to shreds too - Eric Bischoff knew as much when he paid handsomely for his services several months later.
8. Waylon Mercy
Known latterly for providing much of the inspiration for the original Bray Wyatt persona, Waylon Mercy was lionised more for what he wasn't that what he was. In fact, many of Wyatt's own failings could even be attributed to expectations raised unfairly high by the stellar original nearly two decades earlier.
Dan Spivey was too broken down to stick around on WWE's relentless road schedule, Mercy showed no particular in-ring aptitude in his brief opportunities, and - like every other poor soul on the roster - he certainly didn't draw. He was, however, absolutely f*cking terrifying. In WWE's neon New Generation, this was extremely useful.
Decked all in white to subvert his dark arts, Mercy's promos were equally grisly behind a friendly conceit. Aping Cape Fear's serial killer Max Cady in cadence and delivery, Mercy was a tremendous tribute for those fans that knew and a legitimate horrorshow for those that didn't.
His vignettes surviving beyond his matches enhanced the appeal - it's impossible to watch one now and not want to see how this sinister, seething sociopath would do against all your faves.
7. Mark Henry
It seems harsh to call Mark Henry a failure in light of a tenure WWE deem worthy of a Hall Of Fame ring and secured future as a trainer. For the longest period though, he was their greatest shame.
Over-excitedly signing him to a decade-long deal in 1996, Vince McMahon tried to chase him out for years with various humiliating gimmicks and storylines that would have victimised others. Henry, showing remarkable range for somebody from a legitimate sporting background, pulled off all sorts of abysmal moments that gradually wove themselves into the grim fabric of the Attitude Era to the point where he was able to forge a normal wrestling career on the other side.
In terms of the support he's latterly received, "cult" perhaps feels most appropriate here. The fanbase for Mark Henry's best work (two very small windows over a two decade run) has already shrunken from its 2013 salmon-jacket apex. But at its loudest, it helped ensure the 'World's Strongest Man' got a run with one of the organisation's top titles, immortalised as much by his "Hall Of Pain" and faux-retirement as his actual one several years later.
6. Goldust
Long before Dustin Rhodes' head spat blood further than Gangrel at the peak of his powers, Goldust was atoning for some of his darkest hours with a celebrated mid-2010s WWE alongside his brother and rising stars Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose and Roman Reigns.
The wrestler many had always known still existed within 'The Natural' was bursting out, not from his golden gear anymore but from a shell most worried has clamped shut forever during his abysmal Black Reign nadir in TNA.
Linking arms with dad Dusty and Cody against the Authority's 'Hounds Of Justice', Goldust was perhaps the most vital component in the matches but did everything he could to make it about everybody else other than himself. Bringing his experience and a genuine connection with the fans to the clashes, he carried the in-ring and emotional heft in equal measure.
WWE, to their inherent stupidity, then allowed him to rot.
The cult support around 'The Bizarre One' only grew as a result - Goldust had proved his worth beyond anything he'd even achieved at his peak, but found himself demoted as a Goldust/Stardust pairing ground both brothers down. Their seminal AEW Double Or Nothing encounter was as much about reminding the opposition what they'd lost as showing the world what the nascent organisation had to offer.
5. Yokozuna
Yokozuna is an easy wrestler to fall for. Simplistic as it sounds, to get the gimmick and the performer himself...just watch him work.
Springing around the ring for much of his WWE run, the former sumo star brought a legitimate air of menace to the company as its unwelcome champion. The gimmick and specifically his title push was rooted in racism, but the threat he held over the company's best babyface was as real-feeling as the organisation were capable of during a cartoonish time.
Hulk Hogan had shockingly been eliminated from the field, Lex Luger was trying but failing to replace him, whilst Bret Hart's near-miss at WrestleMania IX was gloriously paid off by a heroic victory the following year.
Debuting at a listed 505lbs before bulking up to 568lbs, then 641lbs, Yoko still moved about like a man a quarter of his size when topping out an at announced 800lbs in late-1996. The totals may have been arbitrary to a point, but the visuals did away with the need for the massaging of the figures.
4. Doink
The original re-appraised gimmick from the organisation's commercial nadir, Doink was an Attitude Era punching bag that became a hardcore fan fantasy gimmick when many of those that weren't there for its original run actually went back and saw the best bits.
Intentionally misrepresented as a crystal clear vision of WWE at its most cartoonish, the nuance of a heel clown wasn't focussed upon during video packages of him f*cking around with Dink. As a babyface, he was yet another character tailored to the comedic tastes of one, but as a force for evil, he was utterly anarchic.
A violent assault on Crush at the start of 1993 provided the physical intervention required to explain why the gimmick was no laughing matter. Playing the role with vile snark and sinister intent, Matt Bourne's ability to snap between wide-eyed and wicked-hearted was mesmeric - things were tense and unnerving from the second he bounded into shot.
He had much left to offer in the role if not to WWE. Bourne was let go later in the year due to drug and alcohol issues he couldn't conquer right as the gimmick was rebadged into that of a literal clown. He was a miss between the ropes, but he was too good for that sh*t.
3. Kai En Tai
Taka Michinoku's boy-popping antics as a member of Suzuki-gun in New Japan Pro Wrestling have, in recent years at least, kept alive memories of his fabled and often-farcical Kai En Tai. Worthy of countless revisiting, his mere visibility welcomes generous review of what's perhaps best classified as a entirely different time.
That time was 1998, not 1948, but 50 years feels behind the curve feels about right for the insulated insanity of pro wrestling anyway.
A collection of killers in Japan, the group's Attitude Era incarnation started with good intentions but degenerated into a marginalised malfunction within months. The group debuted by battering Taka before welcoming him in after Val Venis worked a split shift in his other employ with Michinoku's sister.
The "Choppy Choppy Your Pee Pee" segment that followed forever reduced them to comedy, but some of the craic wasn't without its charm even after the four became two.
With retrograde Godzilla dubbing gimmicks, Taka and Sho Funaki got over all over again as crowd pleasers during a time that popular stars were at a premium. Considering the deep-rooted bias within the organisation, it was a credit to their craft and graft that they managed to find a place at all.
2. R-Truth
The launch of the 24/7 Championship was greeted with grim acceptance from a WWE audience beaten into submission by decades of belt mistreatment. As if to establish the strap as a punchline from the off, the company booked a literal chase to crown the first champion after Mick Foley simply left the title in the ring to be collected by the first taker.
What followed was a dangerously close comparison to TNA's catastrophic reverse battle royal. What followed that was R-Truth yet again getting something sh*t, and more importantly himself, over. He's been doing it for years, too.
An creative failure as a babyface following a 2008 re-emergence from the Impact Zone wilderness, Ron 'The Truth' Killings, his character wasn't, until he unlocked a caustic side following a bizarrely brilliant 2011 heel turn that forever transformed how he'd be used.
Propelled to the top of the card for a brief programme with John Cena', Truth's comedic side blossomed thanks to his own creative endeavour. He got a literal figment of his imagination over with 'Little Jimmy', carrying the craic enough to become a better comedy all-rounder than former steward Santino Marella.
Making himself teflon to WWE's atrocious scripting, Truth's actively bantered it off whilst becoming indispensable as a result. He is at this point not so much a credit to the process, but one in spite of it.
1. PCO
In an effort to prove his inhuman endurance over WrestleMania weekend, Pierre Carl Ouellet's violent alter ego PCO took a powerbomb from the ring directly to the arena floor. Only when the Madison Square Garden crowd had fully absorbed the shock did he sit straight up, screaming with pleasure at the pain he'd just experienced.
This is his life now.
PCO's latter-career reinvention as this masochistic psychopath was for this very moment. He couldn't have predicted the specifics, but his intent to take a bow on the grandest possible stage available to him went better than he ever could have imagined - he'd landed back-first but he'd fallen on his feet in the world's most famous arena.
25 years earlier, he was a Quebecer wrestling Men On A Mission in the very same building at one of the most celebrated WrestleManias of all time. He wasn't, however, a talking point or a ticket-seller. Just as he wasn't as a super-worker that just happened to be a pirate a year later. It two over two decades for the industry to catch up with his potential offering.