10 Fatal Mistakes That Destroyed The TNA Brand

Total Nonstop Awful.

Jenna Morasca
ImpactWrestling

TNA is dead.

It is a phrase many had expected to hear for years, and a reality the company's remaining fans had long learned to accept. When parent company Anthem Sports & Entertainment confirmed they were to rebrand the company under the recently purchased Global Force Wrestling banner, it brought to an end 15 years that came to symbolise the good, bad and ugly of professional wrestling.

There were times, brief and distant at they may now seem, when Total Nonstop Action was the most entertaining wrestling product in the word. However, these flashes of inspiration and moments of glory were inevitably undone in record time, such was the cataclysmic failure of the company to sustain any upward momentum.

Unfortunately, despite glimpses of greatness, TNA became a brand defined more by disaster than triumph. Even during the organisation's embryonic days when the business at large desperately required competition for a freewheeling WWE, the Orlando outfit had a habit not just of dropping the ball, but tripping over it as it tumbled along the floor.

It was perhaps destined for toxicity. Named solely as a not-that-sly reference to the Attitude Era's propensity for scantily clad women, it handcuffed itself from the very beginning, and never truly burst free from the self-imposed shackles as wrestling's easy punchline. And it'll require a 'force' even greater than Jeff Jarrett's latest promotion to wash away the stains left behind.

10. The Reverse Battle Royal

Reverse Battle Royal Bound for Glory 2007
TNA

Back in the dim and distant past, TNA had a creditable habit of subverting traditional wrestling tropes in an effort to differentiate themselves from WWE to casual fans that may stumble across their product.

That resulted in a host of brand new philosophies, divisions, titles and matches, will all had the potential to fall flat despite noble intentions. Such was the case with the utterly horrendous 'Fight For The Right' tournament.

Though nobody formally ever took credit for it, the idea smacked of Vince Russo's WCW booking policy of changing things just for the sake of it, especially if it meant violating the suspension of disbelief required for watching wrestling full stop.

The format was TNA at its convoluted worst. A group of wrestlers (usually 16 or 18) would start on the outside of the ring, and fight to get in. That was it. The problem, had it not been blindingly obvious, was how painfully easy that task was.

The resultant mess saw wrestlers punching, and kicking, and punching and kicking, and punching and kicking, trying to make stepping between the ropes look an arduous endeavour. The first half that got in, had another battle royal fought under traditional rules, until there were two left to compete in a regular one fall singles match.

Astonishingly, the Battle Royal only formed part of a bigger tournament, which made the result of this complete shambles largely redundant.


9. Rowdy Roddy

Vince Russo Roddy Piper
ImpactWrestling.com

More Vince Russo insanity, as Rowdy Roddy Piper enters the earliest version of TNA to cut a worked shoot promo that flies way, way off the rails.

The company's original weekly pay-per-view format bizarrely suited the style Russo had purported to have mastered as WWE's Attitude Era creative head.

Though both he and the company denied a working relationship beyond his on screen role, most believed he was in the ear of Jeff Jarrett and company heads, especially considering the machine gun booking that saw hundreds of ideas blasted onto screens each with the hope at least one thing connected with viewers.

Alongside women, weapons and (occasionally) wrestling, TNA was littered with old legends lending star power along with a live microphone to council themselves through post-WCW stress disorders.

Piper's segment was the worst of the bunch.

Fresh off an atrocious WWE run, Piper used the appearance first to plug his website, then his book, before going off on Vince Russo's on-screen character. It rapidly turned real when he called TNA 'the last place Russo hasn't killed', before committing a vicious character assassination on the vilified scribe.

After suggesting that 'there are young men that have a future, and this guy will deliberately kill those guys dreams', he got darker, saying 'did you write in my cousin Owen's death?' The crowd fell uncomfortably silent as the segment careered into infamy.

Predictably, it all went nowhere. The peek behind the curtain didn't produce a lengthy feud or even one match. TNA just looked like an awkward wasteland for a week before going off to search for another ranting icon.


8. Beer Money Buried

Beer Money
TNA

There were numerous growing pains for TNA during the period between their historic Spike TV deal in 2005 and Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff's arrival in 2010, but it occasionally fostered acts that emotionally connected in such a way that the entire organisation looked bigger for their presence.

Arguably the company's most successful tag team project ever, Beer Money Inc (later shorted to Beer Money) were a hugely over babyface combo organically established from the graveyards of America's Most Wanted and Team Canada.

Both Bobby Roode and James Storm were in the midst of passable singles run, but were cancelling each other out as heels somewhat when they began teaming together alongside Storm's manager Jacqueline in 2008.

The pair were, for the want of a better phrase, WWE-ready. They had established catchphrases, t-shirts and moves, and were constantly credible despite TNA typically chaotic booking.

That was until Hogan and Bischoff's aggressive new reshuffle, when inattentive writing completely froze them out of major plans. A forced heel turn made them look like petulant children desperate for Hulk's attention, and the formation of Four Horseman retread Fortune alongside AJ Styles, Desmond Wolfe and Kazarian made all the hardworking stalwarts look painfully second rate.

Their collapse mirrored TNA's steep decline from the company it was trying to be, and the omnishambles it would perpetually become.


7. The Electrified Steel Cage

Lockdown 2007 Electrified Cage Match
TNA

A match so stupid it not only completely embarrassed the four men involved but managed to sabotage an entire pay-per-view, Lockdown 2007's Electrified Cage Match between The Latin American Xchange and Team 3D was a miserable experience for every single person that suffered through it.

With a concept too unrealistic to portray, the four competed under tornado rules attempting to dodge the allegedly charged fencing, despite being unable to do so literally every time they hit the ropes or scaled the posts.

Furthermore, when an unlucky combatant did get shoved into the cables, it would merely trigger a ludicrous sound and light show as a wrestler was forced to unconvincingly sell actual electrocution.

The evocative story between the two teams had been stellar, with LAX tearing through the division before running into the jingoistic Dudleyville pair and their veteran ways. Ironically, the gimmick completely drained the doubles' story of any remaining power.

It being TNA, the company elected to have every other match take place in the 'electrified' structure. Lethal Lockdown, James Storm and Chris Harris' atrocious blindfold match, a choice X-Division opener and the first ever women's cage match in company were all forced to take place inside the farcical creation. It was, fittingly, shocking.


6. Team Pacman

Team Pacman
Impact Wrestling

A desperate grasp for mainstream publicity that leapt headfirst into an embarrassing charade, TNA's decision to use Adam 'Pacman' Jones went about as well as the nightclub incident that earned him notoriety and an NFL suspension in 2007.

Amongst other controversies in a career full of them, Jones was hoofed from the Tennessee Titans after triggering an ugly scene at a Las Vegas strip club that led to shootings and criminal damage.

Making the news whilst sat on the bench, Jones' flirtation with the mainstream was enough to convince TNA to bring him in on a short deal to work as wrestler in a tag team with Ron Killings. It seemed a passable enough use of his name, but the idea unravelled when it became clear the intention was to present him as a babyface despite the universal disdain his actions had garnered.

Furthermore, the Titans and NFL put a block on him getting involved in any physical action whilst serving his suspension, causing the Orlando group a huge headache after they'd carelessly elected to put the Tag Team Titles on the newly-christened 'Team Pacman'.

The solution to the problem did at least create a job for Rasheed 'Consequences' Creed, the future Xavier Woods, who stepped in as Killings' partner in time for them to drop the titles as Pacman quietly departed.


5. Claire Lynch

claire lynch tna
TNA

One TNA's last stabs at dramatic episodic television literally screeched to a halt when a potential romantic liaison between AJ Styles and Dixie Carter was revealed to be nothing more than a bond over a drug-addled mutual friend.

That friend was Claire Lynch, a name with all the downtrodden gravitas of Katie Vick, albeit with a touch less necrophilia.

AJ's rivals Christopher Daniels and Frankie Kazarian had spent weeks torturing the 'Phenomenal One' over the dark secret he shared with Dixie, before Styles and Carter could reveal the truth of their union.

It was a confusing and mildly disappointing payoff considering the illicit romance originally promised, but it got far, far worse when Kaz and Daniels revealed that Styles was the Father of Lynch's unborn child.

As it turned out, the crack-addicted crackpot was in cahoots with the villains, pushing AJ to admit he was her child's father despite Styles' impassioned pleas to the contrary. This set up an utterly absurd contest between the future WWE Champion and Daniels, with the stipulation being that if AJ lost, he would simply accept responsibility of the baby!

Thankfully he won, leading to a lawyer called Grace Stein revealing on behalf of Lynch that Daniels and Kaz had paid her to make the whole thing up.

As it turned out, actress Julia Reilly was hounded with abuse over both the character and the storyline, and felt it may tarnish her future career. It made her the smartest person in the entire sordid tale.


4. Voodoo Kin Mafia

Voodoo kin mafia tna
TNA

TNA were often accused of pandering to WWE in sorry displays that routinely made them look like second-rate imposters to Vince McMahon's product, but their output never quite reeked of as much desperation as when Road Dogg and Billy Gunn (now BG and Kip James) responded to the 2006 D-Generation-X comeback by challenging Shawn Michaels, Hunter Hearst Helmsley and Vince McMahon himself to a real fight.

Like a eunuch in a d*ck-swinging contest, TNA tried to goad WWE and the two chief degenerates into a response in a variety of outlandish ways, but neither the performers nor the company showed any interest in the angle. BG and Kip visited Titan Towers in a sorry rehash of the famed WCW invasion, and even offered 'Paul Levesque' and 'Michael Hickenbottom' a million dollars to show up in the Impact Zone.

It didn't just fall on deaf ears, it fell on no ears at all. After weeks of the challenges going unanswered, the duo parked the angle completely around the time Triple H was shelved with a second quadricep injury. For all their bluster at the time, both Dogg and Gunn would return to WWE in their original 'New Age Outlaw' incarnation a little over five years later.


3. Jenna Vs Sharmell

Sharmell Jen Morasca Victory Road 2009
impactwrestling.com

Sharmell and Jenna Morasca were not professional wrestlers, and it was thus somewhat unfair to expect a professional wrestling match. However, in electing to promote the match at all, TNA should have took more responsibility to ensure it was a catastrophe on such an epic scale.

The feud between Main Event Mafia valets had been a sidenote to the overarching takeover plot by Kurt Angle's suited-and-booted legends group, but their contest was rooted in sheer titillation.

To her credit, former reality star Morasca went above and beyond in providing the sexually-charged teases, with an incomparable entrance in which she slid legs akimbo through the bottom and middle ropes, almost exposing herself in the process.

Rather than leaning almost entirely on the talents of Awesome Kong and Sojo Bolt acting as corner-women at ringside, the match instead focussed almost entirely on the two untrained stars as they engaged in impossibly bad combat punctuated by possibly the most infamous collection of right and left slaps ever thrown.

It swept the board in year-end 'Worst' awards, and rightfully so, but on balance, it mainly just showed TNA up yet again as a promotion driving too fast and hard in all the wrong directions. WWE were routinely putting untrained models in matches on Raw and SmackDown at the same time, but nothing was remotely as poor as this.


2. Dixie Begs Hulk

Hulk Hogan Dixie Carter
ImpactWrestling.com

Hulk Hogan had been a babyface, heel and babyface again in a tumultuous three years with TNA, and left very little desirable behind.

During his final programme with evil heel stable Aces & Eights, Hogan made amends with Sting after the two had been locked in a power struggle the year prior. He did increasingly less on the show in the summer months though, and had only one major angle to work in the run up to the company's WrestleMania equivalent Bound For Glory in October.

Dixie Carter had turned heel that summer, abusing AJ Styles for his perceived disrespect and gradually morphing into another tired retread of the evil authority figure, and TNA's immediate future appeared to promise a battle for supremacy between the millionaire and 'The Hulkster'.

On television and in real life, Hogan just wasn't all that bothered anymore. Set to depart the company ahead of a glorious return to WWE in early 2014, Hulk's final segment couldn't have made the company look any more pathetic.

After initially issuing Hogan with an ultimatum, she then literally got her knees and begged him to stay after he turned down a working relationship with her. The message, intentional or otherwise, was abundantly clear - TNA needed the stars far far more than they needed TNA.


1. Jeff Hardy Vs Sting

Jeff Hardy Sting Victory Road 2011
Impact Wrestling

It was the most embarrassing night in TNA's potted history. A scene unlike anything ever witnessed before or since on a mainstream wrestling programme, a World Heavyweight Title main event became an uncomfortable exhibition of a man's significant health problems following an utterly inexcusable decision to push forward with a contest as advertised.

Ahead of March 2011's Victory Road pay-per-view, Sting had returned to take Jeff Hardy's TNA Title after the evil 'Immortal' leader had held the company hostage alongside Hulk Hogan, Eric Bischoff and their collected associates since his surprising heel turn the prior October. Hardy requested and received his rematch, but would enter in a performance that dangerously portrayed his troubled personal problems.

To suggest that 'The Charismatic Enigma' was 'in no condition to perform' would be an understatement. He was an absolute mess. Gracelessly bumbling to ringside, he spent an eternity teasing the crowd with a feigned shirt throw, occasionally flashing a look that highlighted his dazed disposition.

Infuriated that TNA would have been stupid enough to send him out in that condition (even if it was just to get locked in a tight pinfall following a visible last minute change from Eric Bischoff), a livid Sting backed up the aisle in abject disgust, loudly agreeing with fans who called 'bullsh*t' as the show went off the air.


In this post: 
TNA
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.