10 Forgotten TNA Wrestlers You Totally Don't Remember

SURPRISE! You definitely won't remember a few WWE stars working for TNA.

Judas Mesias TNA
TNA

TNA is right back at the forefront of the wrestling biz thanks to an agreement with WWE. That was a shrewd move from those in charge, especially after a one-sided alliance with AEW that barely benefitted the then-IMPACT Wrestling at all. One rebrand later, and TNA is doing business with Triple H, Shawn Michaels and NXT.

Those three letters aren't the laughing stock they once were.

If that sounds harsh, then you didn't live through the "LOL TNA" days. Total Non-Stop Action became the new WCW in that regard, at least for a while, and it was terribly unfair. Sure, the company produced some horrible stuff, but it was a fun alternative to WWE when it looked like Vince McMahon was about to become the only show in town.

TNA's most famous faces include AJ Styles, Kurt Angle, Sting, Jeff Jarrett, Samoa Joe, Gail Kim, Awesome Kong and many, many more. That's only scratching the surface. Dig deeper to find a vast number of ex-WWE/WCW/ECW workers and some roster members you don't even recognise.

They're the focal point here - those wrestlers nobody remembers from TNA's early days and the IMPACT Zone era.

10. A-1

Team Canada Eric Young Bobby Roode A-1 TNA
TNA

A-1 might hold the record for longest time between TNA appearances.

He worked for the promotion between 2004-2007, then returned for a few matches in 2018. That 11 year gap was once something wrestling fans thought impossible. A few likely figured TNA would be out of business long before reaching 2018! Nah, the promotion plugged away as IMPACT before 2024's re-rebrand.

It's rarely brought up in conversation now, but Team Canada was an important faction during TNA's early years. It helped guys like Bobby Roode and Eric Young bed in on the roster. They weren't the hottest prospects in the group though. Not at first. That spot belonged to A-1, and hardly anyone remembers him.

A-1 was initially cast as an enforcer for Team Canada, but it didn't take long before bookers pushed him into the ring to see if he'd become the breakout star. It wasn't to be. A-1 toiled once TC split, then left TNA in February 2007. Wonder if anyone had a modern-day comeback on their bingo cards?!


9. Chris Melendez

Chris Melendez Mr. Anderson Bully Ray
Impact Wrestling

Both men pictured with Chris Melendez above badly wanted to help him succeed. Mr. Anderson and Bully Ray were reportedly impressed by the former military man's work ethic, and they agreed to do everything to make him TNA's next success story. They didn't bank on Dixie Carter failing to meet them halfway.

Melendez needed something more than the ex-soldier gimmick anyway.

Wrestling fans had watched companies like WWE and WCW try to make military service one of the most impressive things going for decades, and it felt old hat by the time Chris showed up in 2014. The fact he was wearing a prosthetic leg after losing one of his limbs in Iraq didn't charm the fanbase either, no matter how much TNA tried.

Melendez worked a total of 22 matches during a 2014-2016 core stint with the promotion. They'd bring him back for a one off at 2019's Salute To The Troops special, but that was little more than a token gesture designed to capitalise on his real-life military work. 


8. Rellik

Rellik TNA
TNA

Spell "Rellik" backwards. Yup, peak TNA creative.

Ex-WCW and WWE man Johnny Stamboli created a gimmick on the indys called REDRUM that referenced classic Jack Nicholson flick The Shining. TNA liked it, and brought him in to debut at Genesis 2007. REDRUM didn't last long - they'd changed his name to Rellik by the time Stamboli next showed up in his red mask.

Rellik teamed with Black Reign (Dustin Rhodes) for a while, but was gone by May 2008. It was a short and uninspiring run for the one-time FBI member. He obviously agreed, because Stamboli temporarily retired from wrestling in 2009. He'd return in 2010, but as REDRUM not Rellik. That was a TNA idea, after all.

The only way anybody would even know about Rellik in the modern era is if they happen to overhear someone ripping the p*ss out of him. He was very much one of those "LOL TNA" moments mentioned in the intro to this article. Being honest, it wasn't any wilder than other supernatural/dark characters.


7. Jesse Neal

Jesse Neal TNA
TNA

Heavily-inked rocker Jesse Neal was another former military man who originally leaned on that service to garner cheers from TNA's audience. Unsurprisingly, people stopped caring about that after a while. Harsh? Perhaps, but wrestling is a 'what have you done for me lately?!' kinda industry, and everyone knows it.

Adapting, Neal continued rocking up his look and formed a tag-team called Ink Inc with Shannon Moore. That was actually a solid spot for him, not least because the early 'USA vs. Everyone' stuff opposite Sheikh Abdul Bashir was xenophobic and played out. Aligning with Team 3D hadn't sold fans on Jesse either.

He had to earn his spot, so the team with Moore was a blessing.

Neal still struggled to show out as an organic worker just making his way though. If anything, he came across as a manufactured piece of business from TNA, and everything he did felt forced. The company cut their losses in 2011. That'd be it for Jesse's aspirations in the bigger promotions.


6. Anarquia

Mexican America TNA Hernandez Anarquia Sarita Rosita Zelina Vega
TNA

Eagle eyes will spot current WWE star Zelina Vega in that entrance snap from TNA group Mexican America above. She's on the bottom left holding hands with Sarita as Hernandez and Anarquia pose. If you remember Mexican America, cool, but it'd be more impressive if anybody recalled Anarquia at all.

He joined TNA as an ally for big Hernandez vs. Matt Morgan, then got announced as the faction's latest full-time member. Being honest, the presentation was all over the place. Here's why: Hernandez was a unit, and certainly didn't need someone to act as his bodyguard. Realising the error of their ways, TNA turned the pair into a tag instead.

Fair enough.

Say 'TNA's Mexican America members...GO!' to any fan and they'll either ask what the hell you're talking about or name Hernandez and maybe Rosita because she went on to WWE fame as Zelina. Hardly anybody is going to say: 'Oh yeah, that was Anarquia's stable between 2011-2012'.


5. Dakota Darsow

Dakota Darsow TNA
TNA

If you're a keen wrestling historian who spots surnames like a hawk (hawks, eagles - what's going on here?), then you'll notice that Dakota Darsow is long-time NWA/WCW and WWF stalwart Barry Darsow's son. WWE gave Dakota a developmental deal in 2009, but things didn't work out and they'd released him by 2009.

Naturally, he ended up in TNA a few years later.

Darsow played his part in the earliest knockings of the Gut Check concept by trying his hardest to earn a TNA contract during matches on TV. He'd lose out to Zema Ion (current WWE man Joaquin Wilde) at the first hurdle, but TNA wasn't quite finished exploring what Smash's boy could offer them.

His final appearance came in 2012. Ironically, it was Ion who beat him yet again, albeit this time in less than 3 minutes. Dixie Carter lost interest in booking Dakota after that, and he hit the independents. Darsow's last match happened in 2018, so it's safe to assume he's given up on wrestling.


4. Mad Mikey

Mad Mikey Crash Holly TNA
TNA

Ready for back-to-back ex then future WWE star goodness in TNA? You got it.

Crash Holly was everywhere in 2000. He was king of the WWF's Hardcore Title division, and endeared himself to fans by evading the outlandish 24/7 rule in countless inventive skits. People really liked lil' Crash, but the character definitely had a shelf life. By 2003, he'd become one of Matt Hardy's followers before being let go that June.

TNA made their move to sign him in July, but they'd have to come up with a fresh character for Holly. That's why he became Mad Mikey, an irate little spitfire who got angry at pretty much everything around him. If you're noticing a trend here, it's 'cause Mikey had a fondness for playing the underdog - heel or babyface.

Mad Mikey didn't stick around for long. The character disappeared from TNA's weekly pay-per-views in October, then Mike Lockwood sadly passed away in November. He was only 32 years old when he died, which is awful. His death obviously overshadowed his brief TNA run and is why nobody brings it up.


3. Antonio Banks

Antonio Banks MVP TNA
TNA

Yep, that's MVP.

You likely don't remember that Banks worked 4 matches for TNA between 2003-2004 before going on to become one of WWE's hottest young stars in 2006. Being fair, you'd have to have been the kind of fan who tuned into programming like Xplosion to catch his debut. That came with a loss to Erik Watts on the 20 April '03 episode.

Banks didn't end up winning any of his 4 bouts. He jobbed in a tag before IMPACT that July, then got squashed by Monty Brown on the flagship proper a week or so later. Antonio wrapped up his short stay in TNA by losing another tag to America's Most Wanted in August. After that, he cut ties with TNA.

WWE was waiting, but they wanted to see what the renamed MVP could do in developmental first. TNA must've been kicking themselves when they saw what Porter went on to achieve. He could've been a linchpin homegrown success story for the promotion.


2. Judas Mesias

Judas Mesias TNA
TNA

Future Lucha Underground and MLW man Judas Mesias was part of TNA's occasionally awkward stable of heels who chased runaway monster Abyss. He was an improvement on Black Reign (by far the worst portion of Dustin Rhodes' epic career) and Rellik, but Judas was also just another character introduced by 'Sinister Minister' James Mitchell.

It's often forgotten that Mesias was supposed to be a kayfabe brother to Abyss. Y'know, like Kane to The Undertaker when he debuted in 1997. Thankfully, the cheap WWE knock offs stopped there and Judas didn't turn out to be a drink-driving necrophiliac with a character lore that confused fans.

Mesias lasted less than a year before being scrapped.

He'd only been brought in as a foe for Abyss, so it did make sense that the babyface wrecking machine won the feud then moved on. However, nothing about Judas in TNA lived particularly long in the memory. Can you name even one match or moment?


1. Murphy

Gunner Murphy Jaxson Ryker TNA
TNA

That's soon-to-be WWE social media fire-starter Jaxson Ryker on the left. He was known as Gunner in TNA, and formed a tag-team with fellow backstage security team member Murphy in 2010. Both would go on to become members in Hulk Hogan's Immortal stable, but they were nWo 'B' team members at best.

It didn't take long for Gunner to start pulling away from his partner.

Murphy stuck around in various lower-card spots until 2011. He wasn't technically taken off roster pages or released from his contract until October, but the ex-security guard hadn't wrestled since May. Without being cruel, he hadn't been missed on TV. TNA's fans were never into the security-turned-wrestler transition anyway.

That's why Murphy sits in the top spot on this list. He blended in with the furniture during his time in TNA, and that was true even when he was part of the biggest faction on TV. Going Immortal didn't do a thing for Murphy's chances of spinning out and taking a full time stab at TNA.

What other TNA wrestlers do you think people have forgotten? For some WWE, check out 10 Ruthless Aggression Era WWE Superstars You Totally Don't Remember and 10 Lockdown Era WWE Superstars You Totally Don't Remember! 


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.