10 Gimmicks Other Wrestlers HATED

Sometimes, even the WWE locker room wants certain wrestlers to totally FAIL.

The Undertaker Brodus Clay Fail WWE
WWE

Anyone who has ever stepped foot in even the indy-est of indy locker rooms will tell you that politics and cliques are rife in wrestling. Triple H might've successfully fostered a more positive environment behind the scenes in WWE, but there will still be boatloads of jealousy and people wanting to see others fail.

That's human nature, sadly.

The biz is a creative melting pot of ideas not everybody is going to like. There's no getting away from that, and it's fascinating. Some of your favourite wrestlers secretly (and sometimes not-so-secretly) wanted to see someone else's gimmick fall flat - either because they disliked the person doing it, thought it was in poor taste, or 'cause they thought a worker deserved better.

Names as heralded as The Undertaker, CM Punk, Bret Hart, Jake Roberts and Triple H himself all had something to say about characters others were playing. One even told another to go out on live TV and mess things up so WWE would be forced to change their plans.

Here are 10 gimmicks other wrestlers simply hated. Feel the love!

10. Jake Roberts Calls ‘Fake Razor & Diesel’ Stupid

Fake Razor Ramon Diesel
WWE

Jake Roberts has one hell of a death's door to living life to the fullest redemption story. God only knows how useful Jake could've been to the WWF's creative cause had he been on the straight and narrow back in the mid-90s. The 'Snake' has always had a genius-level mind for the biz - his psychology is often insanely brilliant.

He didn't need that to predict the 'Fake Razor' and 'Fake Diesel' idea would flop though.

Roberts was someone Vince McMahon leaned on for creativity in 1996, but he ignored Jake calling cosplay acts of Scott Hall and Kevin Nash stupid. That word is one the Hall Of Famer has used in multiple shoot interviews to describe what Rick Bognar and Glenn Jacobs were asked to do: Dress up as Razor and Diesel respectively.

Jake thought the whole thing was naff, and pointed out that it'd only make fans think of Hall and Nash then flip over to watch them work for WCW. It was counter-productive, and was never going to last long. In fact, it's a minor miracle that Jacobs went on to redeem himself as Kane.

Side note: Shawn Michaels was nice to Bognar and actually gave him some friendly advice backstage. Rick told this story during a chat with the Two Man Power Trip podcast. He wasn't expecting HBK to be so helpful about someone cosplaying his mate.


9. Godfather Can’t Stand RTC, Then…

Right To Censor
WWE.com

...ends up being stuck with them!

By his own admission during various interviews, The Godfather disliked what Right To Censor were doing. He actually didn't have a lot of time for Stevie Richards generally, and admits to making the poor dude's life a misery behind the curtain. Godfather wasn't a bully, but he could be pretty mean to folks he didn't like.

Imagine the man's horror when writers told him he'd be adding an extra 'o' to his name to become The Goodfather and joining RTC. Val Venis was in the same boat. He didn't really enjoy being part of the straitlaced, anti-everything group either. Score two members who wanted nothing to do with the gimmick then!

It feels like a pretty sick joke that Godfather ended up being part of a faction he didn't think had juice to begin with. That'd end up being his last proper full-time run with the company too, which probably makes things even worse. There was nothing good about RTC for The Goodfather.


8. Goldberg Loathes Gillberg

Gillberg WWE
WWE

Spare a thought for Duane Gill. The career jobber stumbled upon his big break by chance, and it only happened because the WWF fancied ripping the p*ss out of WCW monster Bill Goldberg. Thus, in late-1998, Duane became Gillberg. He sought laughs by riffing on Goldberg's mannerisms, entrance and moveset.

People giggled along, but Bill didn't find any of it funny.

Goldberg still doesn't enjoy reliving the Gillberg parody. He loathed the gimmick back then, and he loathes it now. Bill took it as a personal insult that someone would make money by poking fun at his very-serious, no-nonsense character over on the other channel. Keep in mind he was still finding his feet as a wrestler when Gillberg debuted.

It's easy to suggest that Bill lighten up, but put yourself in his shoes. WCW were pushing him to the moon, and here was some enhancement worker capitalising by making light of it. Funny from a fan's perspective. Not so much from Goldberg's. He wanted to crush Duane to dust.


7. Bret Hart Can’t Stand Unstoppable Goldberg

Goldberg Angry
WWE

Meanwhile, Bret Hart was 'Team Gillberg'.

The 'Hitman' would be team anything if it meant going against someone he simply can't stand. Watch any Bret shoot today and you'll probably find some sort of negative comment about Goldberg. Hell, Hart could be discussing the correct way to tie your shoelaces and he'd still find a way to take a pop at Bill.

Bret worked extensively with Goldberg in WCW, and that's when their problems started. An errant kick at Starrcade 1999 sent Hart into a tailspin of health issues and retirement, and he's never forgiven his counterpart. Since then, Bret has badmouthed Bill any chance he gets. That included sniping at his recent WWE runs from afar.

Amongst other things, Hart just can't comprehend why people in the stands or behind the scenes like Goldberg's work or character. It's paper-thin to him, and the whole unstoppable squash match monster gimmick is one this Canadian legend struggles to stomach.

Death. Taxes. Bret Hart hating on Goldberg.


6. Eric Bischoff Doesn’t Get Raven

Raven WCW
WWE.com

Is Eric Bischoff a wrestler? Well, he's wrestled against legends like Larry Zbyszko, Ric Flair and Steve Austin. He even pulled a five-star classic out of Jeremy Borash, for goodness sake! OK, not really for the last one, but bouts vs. the first trio were hardly awful. So, the Bisch qualifies for a spot on this list.

He'd leave Raven off one looking at WCW's best characters.

This is something co-host Conrad Thompson occasionally teases Eric for on their '83 Weeks' podcast. Bischoff has never quite understood the appeal of Raven's mopey, grunge-inspired gimmick. It's always been milquetoast creative to him, and he refuses to budge on that opinion. Fair enough.

Thompson and other listeners who fondly recall Raven's Flock have asked Eric why he didn't push Raven into a more prominent spot. Clearly, the then-WCW boss just didn't see any money in it. The Kurt Cobain stylings of Raven passed him by completely, and he doesn't regret a thing about that either.


5. Triple H Hates The Forced ‘King’ Gimmick

Triple H King Of The Ring
WWE.com

Check the look of pure disdain written all over Hunter's face above.

He won the WWF's King Of The Ring tournament in 1997 after a year of sheer misery post-'Curtain Call', but Triple H definitely didn't want to wear that cartoony crown with the big logo plonked on top of it. According to Bruce Prichard on various pods, Trips would go out of his way to wreck the royal props on the road.

'The Game' (who wasn't quite at that lofty level just yet) lost every crown handed to him, and the same went for the garish robe he was asked to wear. Eventually, he'd settle on the robe, but the crown? That had to go. If he was going to be 'King', then he wanted it to be in his image. In other words, not a walking cartoon.

Christ, the guy must've got PTSD when he was shaking GUNTHER's hand over in Saudi Arabia and handing him the crown in 2024. Same when he passed Nia Jax her crown on the same show. All those flashbacks to '96 could've had him running a mile!


4. Scott Hall Worries About Goldust

Goldust 1996
WWE.com

"Worries about" might be putting things gently. Scott Hall didn't have a lot of time for the WWF's bold new Goldust character in late-1995/early-1996. Privately, the then-Razor Ramon was already pulling away from the company after plateauing financially on the roster, but Dustin Rhodes' fresh gimmick might've tipped him over the edge.

Hall would later refute any claims of homophobia. According to him, it was more that Vince McMahon was pushing the envelope with a sexually-suggestive character during an era when that wasn't the norm. Plus, Scott told others backstage that his kid and young friends watched WWF programming. He didn't think they should be watching someone gyrate and touch himself like Goldust was.

Rightly or wrongly, Hall felt how he felt. He didn't have heat with Dustin, but intensely disliked what he was bringing to the table during their Intercontinental Title feud as Goldust. Roddy Piper would end up subbing in for Razor, then Scott left for WCW by the summer of '96.


3. CM Punk Resents The Miz

The Miz WWE champion
WWE

Here's a fun one that bled into modern-day WWE.

They've squashed any lingering beef now, but there was a time when CM Punk and The Miz didn't have a ton of time for one another. Arn Anderson has openly discussed this on his podcast before. According to 'Double A', most of Punk's distaste for Miz stemmed from bitterness that Mizanin was headlining WrestleMania cards before him.

Punk wasn't the only one. The Miz had faced significant heat from members of the locker room since debuting, and that only intensified the closer he got to money matches against the likes of John Cena on shows such as 'Mania. Anderson noticed that CM was chief amongst the antagonists though.

A lot of that frustration would bubble over and become the catalyst for Punk's "pipebomb promo" later in 2011. Before that, he was grumbling to anyone who'd listen that The Miz was headlining the biggest pay-per-view on the planet. 

Interesting, but not the last Punk involvement here.


2. Punk Also Dislikes What John Cena Represents

John Cena WWE
WWE.com

Back to that "pipebomb" for a sec.

During it, Punk said he didn't personally dislike John Cena, but he did hate "this idea that you're the best". Later, ex-WWE writer and actor Freddie Prinze Jr told fans tuning into his podcast that it was fairly common knowledge backstage how Punk felt - everyone knew he didn't dislike Cena as a guy, but did dislike "everything he represented".

In other words, Cena was WWE's poster boy and was always going to be a firm favourite go-to for Vince McMahon. Everyone else was a second priority to 'Big Match John', and it'd be that way until JC decided to step away from wrestling full-time. That was staring Punk in the face. He didn't like it.

Triple H told Prinze Jr that Punk only hated what Cena was doing because he knew he'd hoover up the acclaim in a similar spot. Most believed it was outright jealousy and nothing more. Whatever the case, it seems true that Punk wasn't fond of Cena's holier-than-thou babyface gimmick.


1. The Undertaker Wants ‘Funkasaurus’ To Fail

Brodus Clay
WWE

Brodus Clay's nerves must've been shredded when none other than The Undertaker approached him backstage and told him to make sure the debuting 'Funkasaurus' character flopped in 2012. 'Taker didn't think it was a good idea at all, and badly wanted to see the intimidating Brodus go back to being a menacing heel monster.

Clay decided to throw his all into the dancing bit instead of listening.

Perhaps that's unfair. He probably did listen, but can't be criticised for doing what WWE told him to do. The Undertaker was a powerful player behind the scenes, but this wasn't his company. Brodus had to please people other than 'The Deadman', so he had a lot to weigh up. He certainly didn't want a frosty look at Gorilla from Vince McMahon.

'Taker thought the 'Funkasaurus' was silly and a poor fit for someone like Clay. Who knows how differently things could've turned out for Brodus had he taken the advice and tanked? Being honest, it likely wouldn't have worked out well for him either way. Talk about a rock and a hard place.

What other gimmicks did fellow wrestlers hate on? For more WWE, check out 10 WWE PPV Matches That Prove Vince McMahon Lost It and 10 WWE Feuds That Started Over The DUMBEST Things! 


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.