10 Great Wrestlers And Their Terrible Impersonators

Some say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. To them I say ... "Gillberg."

Coming up with a successful gimmick is like trying to trap lightning in a bottle. Predicting what persona will get over and what will flop, what will be etched in wrestling iconography and what will linger like a bad smell, is incredibly difficult. When pushing a superstar, management may never be able to tell if they've got the next Hulk Hogan, or the next Curtis Axel on their hands. Sometimes it's just easier to dress one as the other. Gimmick infringement is one thing, but in the annals of wrestling history, there've been a number of cases when superstars have, for one reason or another, started impersonating other wrestlers under orders from Creative. Sometimes, management are trying to stick it to stars in other promotions, sometimes they're trying to give a younger superstar the rub that being associated with a more iconic star will give them, sometimes they've just run out of ideas. More often than not it's the last one, and the results aren't pretty. These are the acts that have tried their hardest to carry off the mannerisms of bigger, better stars, but have found the association more of an anchor around their legs than an elevation in status.

10. Goldust - Bluedust

Just drink that picture in. Really wallow in it. Let it change you on a fundamental level. Goldust himself is no stranger to the odd impersonation, except he's usually the one applying the costume, appearing as Vaderdust, Chynadust, Hunterdust (all terrible names for bands) during the late nineties. However, in early 1999, the cycle of parody became a closed loop when Goldust found himself the target of mimicry. The Blue Meanie, formerly a member of Al Snow's J.O.B. Squad, began to paint himself blue and adopt the sexual mannerisms of The Bizarre One. Weirdly, this wasn't Meanie's first time; he'd dressed as Bluedust during his time with ECW, when he and Stevie Richards would perform bizarre comedy skits. Needless to say, Bluedust was rubbish. After all, The Blue Meanie has built a pretty solid career on being fairly rubbish. Goldust and Bluedust had a fairly sloppy, paint-smeared match at St. Valentine's Day Massacre, before Bluie joined Goldie as an apprentice, and started calling him "mommy". Ugh. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xii0q6_goldust-vs-bluedust-st-valentine-s-day-massacre-2-14-99_sport Within months, both men would be gone from the WWF.

9. Sin Cara Azul - Sin Cara Negro

Poor Sin Cara, he never stood a chance. When the first thing you do on your first day in a wrestling promotion is botch your ring entrance, that's not a good start. If the next thing you do is get involved in a confusing feud with a doppelgänger before the audience even know who you are, it's a recipe for disaster. A few months after debuting, the Faceless One was suspended for 30 days due to his first violation of the WWE Wellness Policy (that was fast), but they didn't actually take the character of Sin Cara off TV for that long. Developmental wrestler Jorge Arias, aka Hunico, began wrestling on TV in the original Sin Cara's stead, turning the character heel in the process. The original Sin Cara, thereafter known as Sin Cara Azul, returned and vowed to defeat the imposter Sin Cara, thereafter known as Sin Cara Negro. Why was any of this happening? It was never made clear. The two men had an underwhelming match at Hell in a Cell, followed by a Mask vs Mask match on Smackdown, after which Negro was unmasked and exposed as Hunico. The whole angle felt like a somewhat-earnest attempt by WWE to impersonate a lucha libre style of booking. It was about stolen personalities, honour and betrayal, all ending with a Lucha de Apuestas ("gambling fight"), but fell flat because Sin Cara really wasn't over with the fans enough for the angle to feel big. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wyGxxRCsspo Ironically, Sin Cara Azul would later leave WWE, and the character of Sin Cara would once again be taken up by Hunico, the imposter.

8. Mizdow - The Miz

Let me be very clear: Mizdow is not the terrible imposter in this case. That would be the Miz. During the latter stages of 2014, Damien Sandow was a lost soul. His Money In The Bank cash-in attempt had ended in disaster and he was consigned to the role of 'comedy act', dressing up as everyone from LeBron James to Davy Crockett to, god help us all, Magneto. However, salvation would come from the unlikeliest of places when Sandow was partnered with the Miz, and the two formed the team of Miz and Mizdow. Damien Mizdow's role was to ape the movements of Miz on the outside (and sometimes inside) of the ring, which was bizarrely, unfathomably funny. It was clowning at its best and, over time, the impersonator became infinitely more popular than the original. https://youtu.be/Eycw96fqSFM?t=105 Suddenly, Mizdow was the great wrestler and Miz was the terrible impersonator. The announcers even pointed out that Mizdow did The Miz's moves better than The Miz! The gimmick, which was utter garbage on paper, got Mizdow over in a huge way. Alas, that was not to last...

7. The Mega Powers - The Meta Powers

How To Assassinate A Wrestler's Momentum 101. WWE Creative thought that the reason why Mizdow got over was because he was a wrestler pretending to be another wrestler. Not because Sandow had been crapped on for months and his commitment to making a bad gimmick work was incredibly admirable to the fans. Nope, it seemed that the lesson they learned from the whole affair was "costumes iz de heehee lols", because not one month removed from having received a thunderous pop at Wrestlemania 31 for finally casting off the shadow of the Miz, Sandow was put back in costume as Macho Mandow, a Randy Savage clone. It didn't work for a number of reasons. First of all, Sandow's impersonation of Macho Man Randy Savage simply wasn't that strong; and second, he was chained to fellow perennial no-hoper, Curtis Axel, whose Axelmania schtick had slowly mutated into a full-blown doppelgänger of Hulk Hogan. The Meta Powers was born, and the whole thing stunk. Mandow and Axelmania only appeared on one PPV as a partnership; Payback 2015, where they were soundly beaten by The Ascension. Now that Hulk Hogan is a persona non grata with WWE, both gimmicks appear to have been scrapped and both men have scarcely been seen on WWE TV since.


6. Ric Flair - Little Naitch

WWE fans will recognise Charles Robinson as one of the most senior referees in the company, recently bamboozled by a rogue timekeeper at Summerslam 2015. But before that, Robinson was a referee in WCW, one with a slightly peculiar obsession with The Nature Boy, Ric Flair. In 1999, the dyed blonde ref allied himself with Flair's villainous Four Horsemen faction, helping them screw over their opponents. Robinson then made his wrestling debut at Slamboree 1999, fighting Randy Savage's girlfriend Gorgeous George with Savage's job on the line. Robinson came to the ring in a black Flair-like robe with "Little Nature Boy" written on the back, and would ape Ric's mannerisms, including his strut and his "WOOOO!" He was pinned in 10 minutes. The gimmick would end in near-tragedy for Robinson, however. The next week, Big and Little Naitch faced off against Randy Savage and Madusa, when a botched elbow drop from Savage would crack several of Robinson's vertebrae, collapse one of his lungs and put him on the shelf for months. https://youtu.be/zQz8KVJOBa4?t=354

5. Sting - nWo Sting

Most impersonations are short-lived affairs, designed with a single storyline in mind. Bizarrely, WCW's fake Sting lasted three years. In 1996, Jeff Farmer dressed as the Icon, Sting, to pull the wool over Lex Luger's eyes (not difficult - Luger is a dum dum), attacking him and making both him and the fans believe that Sting had allied with the new white-hot villains, the nWo. In the face of this appropriation of his likeness, the Stinger morphed into his most enduring incarnation, the Brandon Lee Crow-ripoff Sting with the white face paint. Of course, whenever Original Sting changed his appearance, Bogus Sting (aka nWo Sting) changed too, becoming a slightly shabbier version of the original. For the next few years, nWo Sting would just hang around, lose most of his matches, be forgotten about when real Sting was there, and generally be a bit rubbish. Bizarrely, nWo Sting did really well in NJPW. He started calling himself Extreme Sting, or EXterminator and his popularity actually eclipsed that of the actual Sting! It's a truly strange tale.

4. Undertaker €“ Fake Undertaker

Brian Lee didn't have much luck in the WWF. He's mostly remembered as 'Chainz', one part of the stable Disciples of the Apocalypse, a biker gang who feuded with Puerto Rican gang Los Boricuas in the Wrestling Observer's Worst Feud of the Year in 1997. The feud was called Gang Warz. It was rubbish. However, this wasn't Lee's first foray into the WWF. He actually made his debut a few years earlier, in 1994. The good news is, this run led to him headlining Summerslam that year. The bad is, it was as the Fake Undertaker. The Undertaker had disappeared from WWF TV for the better part of 7 months in 1994, taking time off after the Royal Rumble to allow Mark Calloway's back to heal. In his absence however, Ted DiBiase, the Million Dollar Man and the person who had first (kayfabe) brought The Undertaker into the WWF, announced that he had found a new Undertaker, one he controlled with money rather than his usual urn. It was an odd storyline, which culminated in The Undertaker returning for a match with the imposter at Summerslam. Even though the spectacle of the Deadman's resurrection was cool (if utterly campy), the match itself was a glacially-paced dud and all fans were happy to see the back of Lee's greenhorn 'Taker. Speaking of the Brothers of Destruction...

3. Kane - Fake Kane

What is it with WWE and ripping off Taker and Kane? In 2006, for a very stupid month in May/June, Kane was being tormented by voices, reminding him of May 19. This was the date that Kane's family kayfabe died in a kayfabe fire. It was also the release date of See No Evil, a new slasher flick starring Kane, but that had nothing to do with anything, shut up. Turns out the voices belonged to an imposter Kane, played by Drew Hankinson (aka Festus or Luke Gallows in later years). Fake Kane dressed in Kane's old clothes and mask, and would attack him during matches. The two had a match at Vengeance, which rivalled the Undertaker/Undertaker match in terms of crowd apathy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cuIjFcLbG4A Despite the imposter Kane getting the victory, the angle was deemed a flop by management and immediately scrapped. The next night on Raw, Original Kane simply threw Fake Kane out of the arena, and that was that. But before he became Kane, Glenn Jacobs was involved in a little mimicking of his own ...


2. Diesel & Razor - Fake Diesel & Fake Razor

Well, this was a bad idea. Razor Ramon (Scott Hall) and Diesel (Kevin Nash) were two of the WWF's hottest properties in 1996, and when they left for more lucrative contracts at WCW, their absence left a huge hole in the company. What stung even more than their absence was the fact that Hall and Nash were acting like their old WWF characters on WCW TV. Not only did WWF sue (successfully) in order to get them to stop, but they also put into action one of the dumbest ideas they'd ever had. Because they owned the rights to the names, WWF advertised that "Diesel" and "Razor Ramon" would be making an appearance on Monday Night Raw, despite both men also being advertised for WCW Nitro. Confused, fans tuned in to see this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kgEMnxe31uQ Apparently Razor and Diesel were like Doctor Who and had regenerated into shabbier versions of themselves. The gimmicks unbelievably lasted until the Royal Rumble 1997, despite being as welcome as "a fart in church", as JR put it. Rick Bognar, who played Razor, left the company when his 1-year contract expired but Glenn Jacobs found slightly better fortune, going on to become The Big Red Machine, Kane.

1. Goldberg - Gillberg

The granddaddy of the useless impersonators, Gillberg was WWF's attempt at biting satire. During the Monday Night Wars, Goldberg had become an unstoppable money-making machine, ploughing through opponents and generating a tornado of crowd support. His undefeated streak slowly but surely became a ratings-pulling juggernaut in the industry and the WWF desperately needed to make some sort of counter attack. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PcxIjPhpDqY That's ... Oh dear. Fun fact, Gillberg is still in the record books as the longest-reigning Light Heavyweight Champion in WWF history. It's a bad world we live in.

Content Producer
Content Producer

Adam is a sports writer, comedian and actor, currently living in London.