10 Greatest Performers In WrestleMania History
Big game players at the showcase of the immortals.
For sports entertainers seeking immortality, there’s no better place to leave your mark than WrestleMania.
The flagship show is the centrepiece of WWE’s calendar year, and the company does everything in its power to drag casual and even non-fans into their orbit along with the hardcore viewers. The eyes of the world are on you - it’s the chance to shine.
But in ‘Mania’s 38-year storied history, who has been able to leave the greatest mark of all? Hundreds of wrestlers have entered the squared circle in the nearly four decades that WWE has run the event. Some had just the one match, some plied their trade in the undercard for a while, some had mixed success.
A select few, though, have been able to make WrestleMania their own. Stealing the show is the aim of any performer worth their salt, and a handful of them have managed this year upon year.
These are the wrestlers for whom the term “WrestleMania moment” was coined, who seized Vince McMahon’s proverbial brass ring at the most crucial time of all - and in doing so guaranteed their place in the annals of wrestling history.
10. Bret Hart
The Excellence of Execution’s WrestleMania record is a tale of two halves. Between ‘Manias II and VII, he was an ever-present, though rarely in matches of much import, taking part in Battle Royales and serviceable if unexceptional tag matches alongside Jim Neidhart.
Things changed in ‘92, though, with Hart in the ascendancy and locking horns with megastar and Intercontinental Champion 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper. The longtime friends had a terrific, cleverly crafted match, maybe the best of Piper’s career; only Savage vs Flair can come close on the card.
From there, Hart hit the main event. His IX loss to Yokozuna is tainted due to the Hulk Hogan factor, but Bret owns ‘Mania X, opening and closing the show. Special mention must go to the former match against brother Owen, one of the all-time great first matches.
He saved the best for his penultimate WrestleMania, though - the famous submissions match against Steve Austin which saw Hart turn heel and made Austin an icon as he refused to tap to the sharpshooter. Hart’s ‘Mania record is spotty - he returned 13 years later for an interminable bout with Vince McMahon - but his best matches are untouchable.
9. Randy Savage
Befitting for a wrestler of his calibre, Savage rarely had a WrestleMania match that wasn’t at least decent, and he had a tendency to steal the show, either subtly or definitively.
In the former category, there’s his match with George Steele at WrestleMania II; it doesn’t take a great deal to stand out on that duff card, but Savage and Steele work a fun and charming match around The Animal’s lust for Savage’s valet Miss Elizabeth. It’s of its time, but it’s enjoyable.
More notable, of course, is his WrestleMania III clash against Ricky Steamboat. The slick, technical clash for the IC belt was lightyears ahead of its time and remains inspirational for workhorse performers. Of similar stature is his ‘92 title fight against Ric Flair - it’s far more sports entertainment but the two men somewhere around their prime couldn’t help put on a cracker.
Elsewhere, Savage did the job for Hogan at V in the culmination of a great slow-build story, and carried Ultimate Warrior to his career best match at VII. He didn’t always get the spotlight he deserved - aside from the Hogan match, he headlined only IV as the conclusion of a drab tournament - but never failed to show out.
What’s impressive about Savage’s ‘Mania CV is the variety. From the aforementioned scientific bouts to pure comedy against Dusty Rhodes (and even a fairly bad commentary stint at ‘Mania IX), he showed off his impressive skill set in whatever position he was placed in.
8. Charlotte Flair
While a certain subset of wrestling fans will rankle at Charlotte’s persistent spot at the top of her division, the fact is she’s an immensely talented performer and one who has proved it on the grandest stage many times over.
She has repeatedly put on arguably the night’s best match, starting with her ‘Mania debut against Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks at 32. The culmination of the women’s evolution saw three of the four horsewomen determined to show what they could do, and achieving this in style; it’s a fast, slick, stiff match that sees Charlotte go over as the inaugural women’s champion.
The 33 four-way is less exciting, but her dream match against Asuka the following year is sensational. The two work brilliantly together, complimenting one another perfectly and putting on an unpredictable affair. Flair winning probably was the wrong choice, but the match is still great.
The following year, she made history as part of the first women’s headline match. It’s an uncommonly selfless performance from Flair here, who knows she’s absolutely not the focus of the clash but is integral in bringing the clash together.
And at 36, there’s a true show-stealing match for Rhea Ripley’s NXT title. Again there’s a strong argument that Flair shouldn’t have won, but the chemistry in this first time encounter is palpable, and in an empty performance centre, they put on something pretty special.
7. Hulk Hogan
Hogan’s WrestleMania record is tainted by the fact that a lot of his major matches really aren’t very good. The triptych of WrestleManias VII-IX saw Terry stink the place out in ill-advised matches with Iraqi sympathiser Sergeant Slaughter, Sid Justice (and the tardy Papa Shango), and Yokozuna, who Hogan squashed in 30 seconds to make Bret Hart look bad.
All the same, in many ways WrestleMania is the house that Hogan built, and that can’t be forgotten. He headlines the first three, teaming with Mr T in the first (in a match that’s actually really good), and bodyslamming Andre The Giant in the third; the match is no great shakes, but that slam could be THE iconic image of professional wrestling.
Hogan also enjoyed a remarkable second act, returning at WrestleManias X8 and XIX to take on The Rock and Vince McMahon. The former might just feature the most important crowd in WrestleMania history - they conduct the match, turning Rock heel for the evening. And the latter is lowkey Vince’s greatest in-ring encounter.
If Hogan is more important to WrestleMania as an idea than an active wrestler, well, that’s Hulk Hogan for you. He’s not always putting on the best matches, but odds are we wouldn’t still be watching this product without him.
6. Edge
Edge is the Billy Wilder of WrestleMania: a classic in every genre. His 12 matches on the grandest stage cater to fans of all types of sports entertainment. He can close a show in huge matches against Roman Reigns and Daniel Bryan, or in the still-underrated clash with The Undertaker which arguably sealed his status as an all-time great singles guy.
He has helped to propel some of the 21st century’s finest gimmick matches, taking wild risks in ladder matches, most notably the inaugural Money In The Bank at 21 and the second ever TLC match at X-7 (the best match at probably the best WrestleMania - some accolade).
He has at least one legitimate show-stealer, the wildly entertaining hardcore brawl with Mick Foley, which sees the ascendant star put in a shift involving barbed wire and a flaming table spot. There’s even some standard quality wrestling in there, like his perfectly decent title defence against Alberto Del Rio (which for a while appeared to be his last ever match).
The well-meaning but dull last man standing bout with Randy Orton in 2020 blots his copybook a little (is it the least rewatchable of all time?), but he’s scheduled for a dream match with AJ Styles this year which, by all rights, should send him up the pecking order.
5. Roman Reigns
On one hand, Roman Reigns’ utter dominance of the WrestleMania main event scene doesn’t speak too well to the company’s ability to build new stars other than him. This April’s show will see him headline his sixth in eight years, and in a match we’ve seen before, at that.
On the other hand, it’s hard to say he doesn’t merit his spot. It’s taken a while, but the Roman Reigns project has finally worked. The guy feels like a proper megastar, perfectly at home in the spotlight.
At their best, his matches have been terrific. Last year’s triple threat was an absolute blast, with Reigns picking up a huge win over two all-timers in Edge and Bryan. Better still is his first main event against Brock Lesnar; while that match is best remembered for its explosive ending (on which more later), it must be said that the one on one element of it was hard-hitting excellence, with Reigns taking to the position of The Guy terrifically.
Even when his matches have been less great - vs Triple H or The Undertaker, his achievements continue to stack up. With every year he looks more comfortable at the top of the table.
4. Steve Austin
No one did more with less than Stone Cold Steve Austin in WWE. His active duty in the company lasted all of eight years, but in that time he won everything there was to win, helped changed the game forever, and made a truckload of cash.
Accordingly, he didn’t work too many ‘Manias, but the matches he did have were pretty great. To get the bad stuff out of the way, his inaugural match against Savio Vega is forgettable, and his penultimate against Scott Hall comprised two men edging past their prime and not too enthused about their position on the card (though Hall’s selling of the Stunner is a must-see).
Then there’s the rest of it. His coronation against Shawn Michaels at XIV is a wild, overbooked delight. His trilogy against The Rock is era-defining, with the first setting the pair apart as the industry’s best, the second the culmination of an amazing event, and the third a fitting swansong for Austin.
And of course, the aforementioned Bret Hart match at XIII. It could be the best WrestleMania match of all time; as far as structure and storytelling goes, it’s basically unbeatable. It turned Austin into the face of the company, a position he’d occupy until his retirement. It’s the stuff legacies are built on.
3. Seth Rollins
Is it too early to give such plaudits to Seth Rollins? Well, possibly. The guy is only eight matches deep into his WrestleMania career, and admittedly looks a little directionless a few weeks from this year’s show.
But what he lacks in quantity, he makes up for in quality and incredible consistency. All of these matches are at the very least effective. The Shield squashing the New Age Outlaws and Kane was perfect for WrestleMania XXX, and his match with Triple H was a solid torch-passing moment.
The good stuff, though, is incredible. He put on an ROH-influenced mini-classic with Cesaro and one of the all-time great IC bouts against Miz and Finn Balor. His sprint against Brock Lesnar opened WrestleMania 35 with a bang, and his clash against Kevin Owens was a highlight of the spooky pandemic show.
Best of all is his showing at WrestleMania 31. If his early match with Randy Orton wasn’t enough - and with THAT RKO, it could well have been - he wound up literally stealing the show, cashing in his briefcase to inject himself into the main event, taking home the big prize in a genuine wrestling surprise. He has plenty of time to add to his legacy, too, though who knows what he’ll be doing this year.
2. The Undertaker
On the basis of The Streak alone, it’s certainly tempting to put The Undertaker at #1, and there’s certainly an argument that he deserves it. For a spell, no matter where his match wound up on the card, his was the main event, and we were blessed with some true gems along the way.
We can’t overlook the lousy stuff, and there’s a fair bit of it. From the workmanlike - Diesel, Jake Roberts - to the garbage - Boss Man, Sid - and not forgetting the true horror of the Giant Gonzalez match, which ended in a chloroform-assisted DQ, the early days of ‘Taker’s streak were nothing to write home about.
Once it clicked, though, it was glorious. From 23 (Batista) through 29 (CM Punk), there’s a strong case to be made that he had the best match of the night every time. Two matches against Shawn Michaels rank among the best ever, WrestleMania or otherwise. The emotion and high drama of the HHH Hell In A Cell. Each year boasted something different, but incredible.
And while the streak ended on a shonky note vs Brock Lesnar, ‘Taker got to sign off WrestleMania in the superb cinematic boneyard match with AJ Styles. The lows are pretty low, but the highs are stratosphetic.
1. Shawn Michaels
Basically, you don’t get the nickname “Mr WrestleMania” without being pretty great at WrestleMania. HBK wrestled 17 bouts at the show of shows; none of them are outright bad, some of them are incredible, and some go far beyond that.
Michaels can claim the first WrestleMania ladder match in the iconic, influential X bout with Razor Ramon. He boasts the first and only ‘Mania 60 minute Iron Man match, in which he headlined XII with Bret Hart; it’s a divisive one, but undeniably impressive, not to mention bold in its construction.
He ushered in the Attitude Era putting Stone Cold over in 1996. He retired Ric Flair in 2008. His headliner against John Cena is among the most underrated main events in the PPV’s history. His match with Chris Jericho is arguably the best part of XIX, in contention for the best ‘Mania.
He tore it up with Kurt Angle in a true barnburner that the pair called mostly on the fly. Oh, and then there are those two showstoppers against The Undertaker, one which should have headlined XXV, one which did headline XXVI. And then he retired a legend and definitely didn’t do another show in Saudi Arabia...