10 Horrible WWE Matches That Prove Vince McMahon Lost It
Not even WWE's biggest stars were safe from Vince McMahon's booking HELL.
The cut off point for this list is SummerSlam 2022. Well, technically it's Money In The Bank 2022, because that was Vince McMahon's final PLE as the lead decision-maker in WWE. He'd return to wreak more havoc creatively after that, but the Triple H era launched at SummerSlam.
There's a three-year sample size too - nothing from before 2019 was considered to keep things closer to the end of Vince's run. That year really was the general nadir of Vince-led booking in the company. He'd run out of ideas, and it showed on TV and pay-per-view. Some of the matches McMahon chucked awkwardly onto supershows that year? Absolutely insane.
Keep in mind that he actually thought these things would get over and draw money. It's awkward to revisit.
Triple H has streamlined WWE PLEs as five match specials with a tight focus on lengthy in-ring action. It's working. There are some annoyed glances from those hoping for more, but...those people should scour what's on offer here and realise they've got it good in 2024! The alternative (stuffing PPVs with too many second-rate bouts) is very, very grim.
Here were some of the worst ones from Vince's final years in charge.
10. Braun Strowman vs. The Miz & John Morrison (Backlash 2020)
2020 was a unique year all-round, to be fair, but there were zero excuses for shoving this onto a big card. Braun Strowman was cast as a friendly monster who only got mad when he thought people were bullying him. It was the launching point for that dreadful Shane McMahon feud to come, but even Braun vs. Shane in a cage wasn't as bad as Vince's plan for Backlash the year prior.
Strowman defended his Universal Title vs. The Miz and John Morrison in a handicap effort that tried to go the comedy route. There might've been McMahon chuckling behind the scenes during the build when Miz and Morrison green-gunged Kayla Braxton or messed with Braun's rental car, but he was the only one laughing.
This was thoroughly crappy.
The actual match at Backlash wasn't much to shout about either. Everyone tried to play for laughs yet again, then Strowman brushed the two-on-one challenge aside like it was nothing. What a waste of everyone's time, man. This shouldn't have been on PPV.
9. Zelina Vega vs. Doudrop (Crown Jewel 2021)
You won't hear WWE's announcers talking about Zelina Vega winning the first ever Queen's Crown tournament on TV today. Nia Jax won Queen Of The Ring after the fact, and that's clearly more important to the company than this half-baked predecessor. It meant nothing almost as soon as it had finished.
Plus, fans in Saudi Arabia just didn't care about the final between Vega and Doudrop.
Oh yes, these were the Doudrop days. Piper Niven tried her best, but it was mission impossible to get the live crowd invested in her five minute scrap with Zelina. Afterwards, Vega turned into 'Queen Zelina' and put on a dodgy British accent. WWE lost interest in that almost as quickly as they'd lost interest in the entire tourney.
Names like Toni Storm, Liv Morgan and Shayna Baszler were in the brackets, so Vega vs. Doudrop was an odd choice for the final push anyway. Both gave it a shot, but this ultimately meant nothing and was nowhere near the historic moment WWE wanted it to be.
8. Bobby Lashley vs. Slapjack (Hell In A Cell 2020)
Retribution (or RETRIBUTION if you're feeling shouty) turned out to be one of the worst WWE ideas born during the pandemic. The renegade group held the company to ransom by claiming they didn't care about money or contracts, then...instantly calmed down as soon as they got money and contracts. It made the whole thing seem daft.
Slapjack was supposed to be a scrappy loose cannon, but he was more like Scrappy Doo than Brian Pillman. At Hell In A Cell 2020, he went up against Bobby Lashley for the United States Title. Were Retribution about to hold a secondary championship hostage?! No, no they weren't - Bob beat Slappy in less than four minutes.
It was basically a squash.
Vince McMahon was bad for counterproductive, puzzling booking towards the end of his run. Matches like this helped nobody! Lashley didn't need a win over Slapjack, and the supposedly-dangerous rebel was made to look totally redundant for no reason whatsoever.
7. Drew McIntyre vs. Madcap Moss (Elimination Chamber 2022)
Drew McIntyre's heel turn and feud with CM Punk has been a blessing for the Scot. He experienced peak popularity as a babyface at the worst time ever (the closed door days), but gamely soldiered on and did retain support from fans because his performances were just that great. Even so, WWE started giving him nothing to work with.
There's a Scottish slang phrase that sums it up: WWE gave Drew "hee haw" (sod all!).
In 2022, McIntyre got ready for a WrestleMania 38 battle vs. Happy Corbin that nobody wanted by wrestling Madcap Moss at Elimination Chamber in another match no-one fancied. The whole thing appeared to be a complete mismatch as soon as the bout's graphic flashed up on screen. The resultant nine-minute brawl was a worse joke than one of Madcap's gags.
The 'Falls Count Anywhere' add-on didn't change a thing. To their credit, Drew and Moss bumped around hoping to make something out of nothing, but they were living through the worst of McMahon monotony. Again, no wonder Trips bumped stuff like this off PLE cards.
6. Seth Rollins vs. Bray Wyatt (Hell In A Cell 2019)
It was only a matter of time before this pearler showed up.
Seth Rollins claims he screamed at Vince McMahon backstage for Hell In A Cell 2019. It was an embarrassment for him, Bray Wyatt, the once-proud Cell gimmick and WWE itself. For some reason, McMahon figured booking a non-finish inside HIAC was the way to go; and he also apparently thought nobody in attendance would mind.
Yeah, why not throw hard-earned dollars up against the wall to go see an inconclusive ending to a gimmick bout specifically created to avoid such a thing?! It's a real head-scratcher why fans in Sacramento were so annoyed. Honestly, this was insanity from the then-boss. He needed an editor to tell him no.
Vince once masterfully laced his pay-per-views with cliffhanger endings or satisfying babyface wins. This was neither. It was a shocking example of arrogance, and showed a complete disregard for paying customers who might...y'know...want to see an actual winner. That really isn't much to ask for on PPV when the Cell is involved.
5. Shane McMahon vs. Roman Reigns (Super ShowDown 2019)
Anyone buzzed for the thought of Shane McMahon in AEW should remember how in-your-face trash Shane-O's latter day WWE career could be. His ego must've been running wilder than Hulkamania in the 80s, because McMahon ended up calling himself the "Best In The World". He won World Cups and even beat Roman Reigns.
It's in the record books.
Vince willingly put his son over WWE's poster boy at Super ShowDown 2019. There is context, being fair: Drew McIntyre got involved, and Shane was mid-push (for whatever reason). Fair enough, but there was no call for McMahon controlling an excruciating heat section midway through. The match was slow, dull and just didn't need to happen.
This is the kind of booking that pushed Roman into creating his brilliant 'Tribal Chief' character the next year. Even he was sick of WWE forcing everything he was involved in. The fact a sweaty Shane beat him on PPV this late in the game says everything about Vince's creative.
4. Alexa Bliss vs. Randy Orton (Fastlane 2021)
So, mind you, does this spook show surprise.
Bray Wyatt was a creative genius to some, but WWE mishandled his 'Fiend' character terribly at times. A dark alliance with the corrupted version of Alexa Bliss had promise, but there was just one problem: Vince McMahon was manning the controls, and he wanted to "make movies". So, fans were greeted with Fastlane 2021.
There, Alexa met Randy Orton in an admittedly-eye catching (when it was announced) intergender match. Bliss and Orton weren't about to trade holds or do much wrestling at all though. Nah, they were going to take everyone on a whistle stop tour through some basic stunts, pranks and a lot of Alexa laughing.
Things peaked when a crispy version of Bray's 'Fiend' showed up to get involved and gift Bliss the win. Latter day WCW would've been proud of the nonsense on display here. Some might defend WWE for daring to be different. This didn't work though.
3. Kurt Angle vs. Baron Corbin (WrestleMania 35)
If anyone tries to defend this, then there will be fisticuffs! In all seriousness, it was an insult to the great Kurt Angle that he jobbed to Baron Corbin in a six-minute snoozer at WrestleMania 35. This was Kurt's final match, so you'd think Vince McMahon would go all out to honour the Olympian with something special.
'No chance in hell, pal. Ha ha!'.
'Mania 35 was one of the busiest cards in living memory. It was an exhausting one-night show that featured 16 matches (including the Kickoff), and that might've made it harder for Angle to stand out. You see that? That's an attempted excuse. Fisticuffs. Right, enough of that.
WWE don't get a pass for treating Kurt with such contempt. His retirement was far too low key for such an epic career, and it came across loud and clear that Vince didn't give a crap. He wanted Angle on the show, but put him in the most afterthought spot imaginable.
What a missed opportunity.
2. Damian Priest vs. The Miz (WrestleMania Backlash 2021)
Scotty Too Hotty playing a zombie was literally the only highlight from this mess.
Triple H booked Damian Priest as an impressive leader before things went south for Judgment Day. Priest even rode momentum all the way to a MITB cash-in and World Heavyweight Title reign. Meanwhile, a few years earlier, Vince was putting him in "Zombie Lumberjack Matches" vs. The Miz on PLE. Booker. Of. The. Year.
Again, there's a touch of sadness to all of this. There was a time when McMahon's creativity knew no bounds; he could make even the silliest stuff work on occasion, but scripting fake zombies to act as lumberjacks was rubbish. Sure, it was a movie tie-in that raked in the cash, but that came at the cost of making full-time workers look stupid.
Miz was even devoured by the undead, then returned on TV a few weeks later with barely a scratch. It was mortifying to think that WWE hyped this up as must-see. Who knows how Damian and Miz managed to keep a straight face throughout?
1. Vince McMahon vs. Pat McAfee (WrestleMania 38)
Vince McMahon as a heavy non-wrestling presence on television in early 2022 was hard to justify. Vince McMahon working matches in-ring at WrestleMania? Certainly not. Coming out to address the fans or make matches was one thing, but getting in there on the biggest weekender of the year was another.
Yikes.
McMahon worked Pat McAfee in a thrown-together match during 'Mania 38's second night. McAfee had already beaten Austin Theory, which was enough of a sideshow for the event, but then the loudmouth announcer goaded Vince into an impromptu bout too. Fans popped at first, then the bell rang.
Nobody was expecting Bryan Danielson or AJ Styles out there, but McMahon couldn't even be a decent version of himself. Putting this on the lineup at WrestleMania, unadvertised add-on or not, was a ridiculous decision from someone who was pathetically out of touch.
What other PPV/PLE matches during the final years of Vince McMahon's era proved he was losing it? For more WWE, check out 10 Unlikely Wrestling Faction Members That Totally Worked and 10 Things You Didn't Know About The WWE Title!