10 Hyped Wrestling Rematches That Sucked

"Epic" wrestling rematches from WWE and beyond that got WAY too much hype.

Bray Wyatt Braun Strowman Extreme Rules Swamp
WWE.com

It's the hype that kills you.

Some wrestling rematches can be awesome. Look at those back-to-back belters between The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XXV and XXVI, for example. Or, for more repeat goodness, how about the big-boys-doing-big-power-moves magic Brock Lesnar and Goldberg pulled from... somewhere at 'Mania 33 after stinking up the joint 13 years earlier at XX?

Those are great examples of worthy reruns, but not every rematch works. Sometimes, wrestling tries a little too hard to cash in on what either definitely is or is perceived to be a hot issue, and the folks working the match just can't live up to the billing come bell time.

It's not challenging to see the logic in re-booking something, especially in the modern era; the people writing wrestling telly have a lot of programming to fill, and it makes sense that they'd try and get more bang for their buck from a certain feud before moving on.

The tricky thing is actually improving on the original. That hasn't been easy for wrestling over the years. Need some evidence? Try these follow-up wobblers on for size...

10. Braun Strowman Vs. Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt Braun Strowman Extreme Rules Swamp
WWE.com

Where: WWE Extreme Rules 2020

Why It Sucked: The 'Wyatt Swamp Fight' nearly killed any excitement for more cinematic matches last summer.

WWE weirdly sandwiched an unwanted challenge for The Miz and John Morrison in at Backlash before returning to Braun Strowman's feud with Bray Wyatt. Oddly, their fairly tame effort at MITB before that was almost superior to this bells-and-whistles approach at 'The Horror Show At Extreme Rules'.

The production made the 'Swamp Fight' feel like a '90s episode of Goosebumps, and Braun's over-the-top facial expressions turned it into WWE's very own live action Scooby Doo - all one needed was Strowman to start saying things like, "Zoinks!" and "Jeepers!" for maximum banter.

Nothing about the brawl was satisfying. It was a misstep in a year seemingly obsessed with cinematics, and it shouldn't have headlined the pay-per-view. The fact WWE hyped this up as the second coming of 'Boneyard' pretty much says it all.


9. Triple H Vs. Steve Austin

Survivor Series 2000 crane
WWE Network

Where: WWF Survivor Series 2000

Why It Sucked: If you've never had the pleasure, then go back to No Mercy 1999 (the US one) to watch Triple H and Steve Austin beat the sh*te out of one another in an excellent 'No Holds Barred' match. Then, to compare, flick forward to Survivor Series 2000 to see both guys go way too far.

Attempted homicide, basically.

Austin and Trips brawled around in standard fashion before the night's big set piece, and (again) there was almost something comedic about the mix of wide shots and Hunter's horrified face as 'Stone Cold' contemplated murder. That wasn't intentional, and it's why this was cringe city.

Fans mentally moved on from the 'whodunit' angle on the prior year's Survivors before the company. Rikishi's reveal as a hired gun and Triple H swooping in to out himself as the mastermind certainly muddied the waters. They'd set this right come No Way Out 2001's 'Three Stages Of Hell'.


8. Brock Lesnar Vs. Roman Reigns

Brock Lesnar Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Where: WWE WrestleMania 34

Why It Sucked: Babyfaces done wrong are awful.

That's definitely what Roman Reigns was back in 2018. In fact, scratch that, he'd leapt onto that train three-four years earlier before working Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 31. Fans booed him there, and they did so again in New Orleans for 'Mania 34. WWE didn't learn their lesson - they didn't want to.

The result was a tepid headliner that even a surprise finish couldn't save. Lesnar beat Vinnie Mac's designated superhero like he was filming the worst ending to a Marvel movie ever, and fans went home wondering what the point of all this was.

Roman was crestfallen inside the ring and few cared as they shuffled out of the huge Superdome stadium. This was not a rematch that needed to happen in the main event slot on the biggest card of the year. It just wasn't.


7. Steve Austin Vs. The Undertaker

The Undertaker Steve Austin 1999
WWE.com

Where: WWF Fully Loaded 1999

Why It Sucked: Steve Austin and The Undertaker have never had great chemistry.

Their original "epic" at SummerSlam 1998 was stymied by the fact both were babyfaces, but that masks the reality: 'Taker and Austin just failed to click. Their main event was average at best, and it was weird to watch two of the best ever struggle their way through a brawl in front of an MSG crowd that expected more.

The pair's rematch at Over The Edge '99 gets a sympathetic pass here; Austin and 'Taker were dealing with the shock of Owen Hart's fall by the time they rolled out for the headliner on that night, so it'd be unfair to criticise. Fully Loaded '99 though? Yeah, that's fair game.

Another wonky effort wasn't saved by the 'First Blood' stip or heavy Vince McMahon involvement. This was yet another stinker from two legends that really should've produced better. It's strange that some combos just don't work the way they should.


6. Roddy Piper Vs. Hollywood Hogan

Roddy Piper Hollywood Hogan
WWE.com

Where: WCW SuperBrawl VII

Why It Sucked: Pure match quality wasn't the priority when Roddy Piper and Hulk Hogan worked together at 'The War To Settle The Score' in 1985. Both were on top of the world as a new breed of WWF 'Superstar', and fans just couldn't wait to see them tear into one another. They could've played checkers in-ring that night and still came out shining.

12 years later, things were different.

Despite being older and slower, the iconic duo had nonetheless done their bit at Starrcade 1996. That match, whilst hardly a world beater, was worth doing. Another bout at SuperBrawl two months later, meanwhile, wasn't. WCW's own in-house follow-up was an unnecessary add-on that reeked from first bell to last.

It didn't help that Piper had looked like an idiot for accepting a non-title match at Starrcade... which he won. When the title was on the line at SuperBrawl, he lost. Worse, the title's importance was barely made clear to fans on TV beforehand.


5. The Rock Vs. John Cena

john cena the rock
WWE.com

Where: WWE WrestleMania 29

Why It Sucked: 'Twice In A Lifetime'.

That joke will haunt WWE forever, and rightly so. Between WrestleMania XXVII and XXVIII, the promotion made a massive deal out of John Cena vs. The Rock happening only once. Anyone who slept on this wouldn't get another chance to see such a huge main event. Oh no, wait, they would.

XXVIII's match was special because it was Rocky's first singles showing since losing to Goldberg at Backlash 2003. 'Mania 29's match didn't have that unique atmosphere going in - it was also rather obvious that Cena was going to get his win back in 2013. 50/50 booking at its worst, then.

The Cena vs. Rock feud had also been built on resentment from both sides. Come 29's conclusion, an injured Dwayne (that injury didn't help his workrate on the night) was lifting Johnny boy's arm, dropping his head and sort of acknowledging that Cena was the better man. Something about it didn't feel right at all.

This was a massive disappointment.


4. The Undertaker Vs. Yokozuna

The Undertaker Yokozuna
WWE.com

Where: WWF Survivor Series 1994

Why It Sucked: The WWF tried to load up on gimmicks and hysteria for the 1994 Survivor Series by booking a major return, celebrity guest referee and second go-around for the 'Casket' gimmick. The Undertaker returned, future internet meme Chuck Norris was the ref and Yokozuna was surely going for a big snooze in that box.

This was arguably worse than its predecessor at the Royal Rumble though.

Again, Survivors lacked freshness. Fans had already watched Yoko's eyes bulge out of his skull whenever he went near the coffin, and they knew they were going to see some slow brawling before 'Taker put his foe down for good. Plus, Norris was more of a distraction than a worthwhile extra.

There aren't many casket bouts worth watching, but this is defo one to skip. If anything, The Undertaker's OTT "passing" at the Rumble makes that the bigger spectacle. The sequel should've happened on house shows, if anything.


3. Hulk Hogan Vs. The Undertaker

The Undertaker Hulk Hogan Judgement Day 2002
WWE.com

Where: WWE Judgment Day 2002

Why It Sucked: Hulk Hogan's best matches in 2002 came against The Rock, Kurt Angle and Brock Lesnar. Others, vs. Hulk Hogan and The Undertaker dropped into mediocre territory, and that's kinda' sad considering they were framed around Hulk's first WWF Title reign since the early-90s.

'Taker and Hogan had wrestled before at Survivor Series 1991, but any fans hoping that a much-changed 'Deadman' would be able to improve on that match with his aging counterpart would end up disappointed. Their Judgment Day 2002 repeat was an outright disaster and proof positive that Hulk needed someone to carry him.

The Undertaker, surprisingly, wasn't up to the task. Judgment Day's main event came across as a lame WCW World Title showing from late-1999, and that is not a compliment in the slightest. Hogan failing to jump for 'Taker's chokeslam summed up the pain.

Maybe these guys just didn't have chemistry either? Nah, they just had a crap match.


2. Seth Rollins Vs. The ‘Fiend’

Seth Rollins Bray Wyatt Fiend
WWE.com

Where: WWE Crown Jewel 2019

Why It Sucked: Bold promises were made following the infamously rotten conclusion to Hell In A Cell 2019. WWE kinda' put a hand up, admitted the non-finish to Seth Rollins vs. The 'Fiend' sucked hard and promised to make up for things at Crown Jewel the next month by tacking on an almost-laughable 'Match Cannot Be Stopped For Any Reason' stipulation.

Bray Wyatt and Seth must've been rolling their eyes.

They'd been booked into a corner at HIAC, and they were always going to feel the grind in Saudi Arabia. Fans hardly considered Crown Jewel a top pay-per-view for a start, and Wyatt's all-too-familiar red lighting made the brawl more cinematic than anything else - it was hard to see at times, although maybe not as hard as it had been inside the cage.

Perhaps the only saving grace here was that Bray's alter ego won and didn't have to suffer the indignity of another visual defeat (which HIAC had been). Still, the match wasn't good, and the feud seemed like a nightmare fans would never wake up from.


1. Hollywood Hogan Vs. Warrior

Hogan Warrior
WWE.com

Where: WCW Halloween Havoc 1998

Why It Sucked: You had to know this would take top spot.

Regardless of how much wrestling has changed over the past 30 years, there's still something so timeless about Hulk Hogan vs. The Ultimate Warrior at WrestleMania VI. It's peak WWF pomp, and the main event is rightly considered one of the most flashy mega-matches of all time.

By 1998, the rebranded Hollywood Hogan wanted his win back. He was riding high as the leader of the ultra-cool nWo faction, and he also believed re-airing the 'Mania battle on WCW pay-per-view would reap huge rewards for everyone. Reality bit hard at Halloween Havoc when Eric Bischoff tried Warrior on for size.

Warrior vs. Hogan II is viewed as the blueprint for terrible wrestling rematches. The build was confusing and convoluted, the actual action sucked and Hulk f*cked up a fireball spot mid-match. Literally nothing clicked for these guys.

What other mega-hyped wrestling rematches do you think totally sucked? For more like this, check out 10 Things That Happened AFTER Wrestling Matches That WWE Won’t Tell You and 10 Records That Could Be Broken At WWE Royal Rumble 2021!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.