10 Insane Stories From WWE Tryouts

Secret dream matches and the most insane feedback ever: featuring the Young Bucks and more...

WWE Eddie Kingston
WWE

So you want to be a WWE Superstar?

Well, tough t*tties. The process of getting there seems really quite difficult.

Ideally, these days, you must be a collegiate-level athlete ambiguous about how much you care - can't be a mark, can't disrespect the business - and if you don't get great within a short timeframe in a system that doesn't encourage you to make an organic connection with fans, there's a more than decent chance they'll bin you off.

Your poor ACL is at the mercy of what appears from the outside looking in to be an excessively intensive training regimen. If you can survive with that ligament intact, you'll appear on LVL UP (which you probably do not know exists) before debuting on NXT after a curriculum of shocked faces under some wacky persona or other.

You could wake up one day and discover that you are a person who thinks they are a bird, a mob boss, the dean of a university, a British late-night TV host or a yokel incel. Those aren't jokes; they are actually NXT characters.

Becoming a WWE Superstar TM is harder than it needs to be.

Opening the friggin' door is even harder...

10. One Of The Pro Wrestling's Biggest Ever Dream Matches Happened During A Tryout

Young Bucks Usos
wwe / new japan

After the Young Bucks voluntarily departed TNA following an ill-fated spell, during which their falling out angle went under nine minutes across two Xplosion matches, Matt and Nick Jackson signed with Ring Of Honor - but not before "trying out" for a second time with WWE in 2011.

Per Nick, they didn't expect an offer; it was a publicity stunt engineered to put their names on news sites. They didn't fancy WWE after their previous experiences working as extras (more on which imminently).

If you are unfortunate enough to be chronically addicted to Wrestling Twitter, the following two words will haunt you: Usos better.

That, or you'll read all about how the Usos actually spam more superkicks, if you analyse the statistics. This discourse is one of the worst battles in the WWE Vs. AEW culture war, since both teams aren't dissimilar at all - both really like thrust kicks and melodrama - and yet it persists with no correct answer.

And, depending on how Tony Khan is able to finesse the looming CM Punk situation, you'll never get to see the teams in action to determine which is better. You won't, but various WWE officials and roster members did when the Bucks wrestled the Usos in a match at said (unofficial) tryout. In 'Killing The Business', Matt put over the Usos huge for their selflessness, cardio and improvisational skills. William Regal put over the match, too.

But - inciting a ripple effect - Nick Jackson leaned on a guardrail after the match, only for an infuriated Booker T to wander into the scene, whose coat was under Nick's arm (unbeknownst to him). This furthered the narrative that the Bucks were disrespectful and aloof, which of course became their brand. No offer was forthcoming after that.

So, about those other times the Bucks learned what life in WWE is like...


9. The Young Bucks Learn A Lesson That One Day Changes The Course Of History

Young Bucks Brandon Cutler
AEW

Before the Performance Center was erected, and the system of recruiting and developing talent was conducted exclusively in-house, what often (but not always) happened was thus: if a wrestler plied their trade on the independent circuit, and made a WWE connection of some kind, they'd work an unofficial tryout match before a TV taping or do "extra" work at the taping itself.

If WWE deemed the talent promising, and they didn't show their arse under the lights, they'd extend a developmental offer their way. The talent, if successful, would then - depending on the timeline - shore up in Ohio or Florida. Or, if they were unlucky or had committed an atrocity in a previous life, Deep South Wrestling in Georgia.

This is how the Bucks first appeared in WWE's peripheral: they made a contact in Marty Jannetty, who then suggested that Shawn Michaels take a look at them. Shawn was nice to them and had heard raves over their work secondhand. The Bucks thought they were in - but Michaels, a Raw talent, wasn't at SmackDown. Before a wardrobe snafu ruined Matt Jackson's TV match with Chuck Palumbo - he was too busy adjusting his gear to sell - then developmental head honcho John Laurinaitis couldn't even be bothered to make small talk with the Bucks, wandering off before the word "Hi" had even left Matt's mouth.

Worse, Matt revealed in In the Bucks' autobiography 'Killing The Business' that the backstage WWE environment gave him anxiety - which had rather a lot to do with the fact that various unnamed top stars called he and Nick smaller than their two-year-old sons and homophobic slurs. WWE wasn't for the Young Bucks.

If the culture in WWE wasn't so toxic, perhaps there might not even be an All Elite Wrestling.


8. Lacey Evans Told Sammy Guevara How To Work

Sammy Guevara WWE
WWE

Sammy Guevara tried out for WWE in 2017.

He hadn't hit yet Pro Wrestling Guerrilla, so there was know way of knowing if he was fashionable enough for WWE, so they passed. That's the cynical/facetious take; perhaps WWE were wary of the attitude problems that Guevara was known for in the Texas scene.

Regardless, they never called him up, but you can still watch footage of Guevara in what is technically a WWE ring: the company uploaded it to YouTube.

Guevara is seen performing William Regal's favourite activity. No, not making Triple H a nice hot cuppa: instructing a developmental prospect to move forward with their left foot. This exercise was overseen by Lacey Evans, which seems weird until you remember that she was a marine and is probably well-qualified for this sort of thing. Still, it's a bit weird watching Lacey Evans, a not particularly great wrestler who'd only been at for a year in a role determining who is good enough to do it, like some grizzled solid hand agent. She berated Guevara for not announcing himself loudly enough and criticised his rolling technique.

The man can do a 630 senton!


7. RJ City Picks The Wrong Man To Antagonise

RJ City
AEW

RJ City is the delightful host of AEW's YouTube series Hey EW: supplementary company content that seeks to pop the interview subjects as much as the hardcore fans who consume its irreverent glimpses into the people behind the characters.

A gifted improv comic with a V-trigger-quick wit, City has also dabbled in the in-ring side of wrestling. He knows his way around a comedy match - in an outing against Daniel Garcia, he once covered his chest in fear of a chop before Garcia simply smacked him in the head - and found himself on WWE's radar over a decade ago. He attended his WWE tryout alongside Xaxier Woods, and later appeared on the Feel The Power podcast to talk about the experience.

In promo class, City was asked to show off his improv skills - to see if he could land a gig doing scripted promos, God WWE is so weird - and so City walked to what was effectively the judge's table. Perry Saturn was brought along to cast his eye over the prospects.

City walked over to him and asked to see his hands. Saturn, the man who annihilated Mike Bell for real, accepted the request. City said thanks - he just wanted to see "the rings of Saturn".

An intentionally naff joke, apparently, few people got it, and City created a rather awkward atmosphere.


6. Daniel Garcia Talks About The Warehouse Era

Daniel Garcia
AEW

Daniel Garcia is currently on the rise in All Elite Wrestling.

Locked into a long-term existential crisis arc, in which he is visibly regretting his chosen path as a sports entertainer - and getting over as a babyface in plain sight with his meme treasure trove of a Dance - he has main event-level potential. A prodigy of a technician and cool, very funny performer, he could headline pay-per-views in two years.

It almost went very differently for him.

He made sporadic appearances for WWE in 2021, in the dying days of its greedy 'Warehouse Era', as part of a tryout. According to Garcia's Talk Is Jericho appearance, Triple H shook his hand and welcomed him to the team - even though Garcia had actually not signed a deal and would not end up signing a deal. Twitter rumours suggest that Triple H and or William Regal actually wanted Garcia before the Warehouse policy was abandoned when Vince McMahon - possibly as punishment for losing the Wednesday Night War - demoted Triple H and reimagined NXT as a sex-pilled soap opera "worked" by green college athletes.

Garcia, in addition to possibly exposing that Triple H didn't know his ar*ehole from his elbow-uh, also laid bare the grim reality of the era. Purportedly, as he was leaving, Garcia was collared by then Senior Director of Talent Development Canyon Ceman, who told him that WWE would sign him "sooner" were another company to sniff around him.

"We're not that bothered to be honest, but we'll do it to spite AEW" was WWE's sales pitch, and they were transparent enough to say the quiet part loud!


5. WWE Writers Don't Think Much Of Eddie Kingston's Promo

Eddie Kingston WWE
WWE

'WWE Writers Don't Think Much Of Eddie Kingston's Promo' reads like an Onion headline; a self-contained joke mocking the absurdity of everyday mundane life.

Kingston told Renee Paquette on a 2021 episode of her Sessions podcast that, when he tried out for WWE in 2016, the writers observing promo class were horrified by his approach to interviews.

Kingston - one of the best promos ever, an agonised poet who can make it feel like a rivalry has consumed his very soul with a killer turn of phrase - attempted to put over the intensity of the training drills. He said he's been shot at and stabbed and would sooner do that. He also said - trying to convey how hard his life was, and how hard he turned out as a result - that where he comes from, people believe in 2Pac more than they believe in Santa Claus.

According to Eddie, he spotted two writers, whose confused looks signalled to him that he had no chance.

"Why isn't this fellow reading out his Wikipedia page?!"

Sadly for WWE, in what can only be explained as an administrative error, they actually loved his work in the tryout - but only made contact with Kingston hours after he had made his debut for All Elite Wrestling.


4. Thunder Rosa Takes Refereeing Classes?!

Thunder Rosa
AEW

Thunder Rosa's stock dipped massively last year.

After working one of the great women's matches in history opposite Dr. Britt Baker, and elevating AEW's women's division to a not inconsiderable extent before her iconic career highlight, she - through injury, a lack of professionalism or a combination of the two - declined as a performer. Her matches as AEW Women's champion were clunky and awkward, but hopefully, she can mount a comeback. The striking look, the intensity, the crowd connection: she's great in the ring on her day. In the ring.

"Your talent is there to see in black and white," WWE agreed. "We are officially interested in signing you. We're counting on you."

"Yeah we want you to be a referee."

What?!

Yes, per an appearance on the Sessions with Renee Paquette, Rosa, despondent with her lack of progress, asked if there were any refereeing gigs going and WWE somehow didn't say "You're better than most of our roster, get in the ring instead".

It's not all bad in this alternate timeline, the one in which Rosa accepts the gig. She still has an ACL ligament if she's not actually wrestling in NXT.


3. WWE PASSED On The Next Batista

Wardlow interview
AEW

WWE is the most inscrutable organisation, possibly of all time.

You can't like wrestling too much, otherwise they'll think you're a mark; at the same time, you can't disrespect the sanctity of the business, otherwise you'll get called a c*nt and be made to change in the hallway.

That's if you even make it that far: WWE is also inscrutable because it's very difficult to determine what they're actually looking for.

Consider Wardlow: he's tall, in great shape, is (respectfully) a super hunk, and is a strong pro wrestling actor who got over in AEW very gradually with his subtle use of camera-friendly body language. He's also perfected the simple, universally satisfying power-based style that every incarnation of WWE has loved then, now, forever.

You'd think he was a lock, but WWE passed after he tried out, which is insane in and of itself. He himself believes he aced it with flying colours, but WWE wasn't bothered. As an editorial comment, that might have something to do with the fact that Triple H was around that time besotted with chasing the osmosis high of workrate acclaim.

Wardlow also revealed to Chris Van Vliet that the ex-NFL wrestlers he tried out alongside openly expressed their apathy about wrestling.

Guess who from that group became a wrestling star!


2. The Briscoes Receive Rejection For The Dumbest Possible Reason

FTR Briscoes
AEW

Mark Briscoe's current AEW run is bittersweet, because while his secret smartest man in the room schtick is enormously entertaining, in a better timeline, he would have starred in a major promotion for years and years. The man's range is phenomenal; an hysterically funny and endearing man who is an exceptional brawler capable also of working lengthy epics, he's a modern great.

Of course, he only received this opportunity when WarnerMedia were talked into it following the tragic passing of his brother Jay. Jay too was a modern great; his promo game in particular was outstanding. Threatening, quotable, and funny, he could get a story over, sell a big match and make you piss yourself laughing in under two minutes when taking a quick break from his farming duties.

The Briscoes with a marketing machine behind them could and should have been major stars for years and years - but it never happened. That is because, per a recent Talk Is Jericho appearance, after a behind-closed-doors tryout in November 2009, and a second look in FCW, John Laurinaitis phoned Jay and said that the tag team wasn’t "cosmetically pleasing" enough for WWE. Meanwhile, at the November 29, 2009 SmackDown taping, David Hart Smith and Tyson Kidd won a handicap match over Erik Escobar - so it wasn't as if WWE needed depth in the tag team ranks or anything.

Not that it matters - the Briscoes ruled because they looked like they could eat you alive, and some wrestlers should look dangerous and uncouth - Jay was one of the most handsome wrestlers ever!


1. Athena Tells You That Nothing Has Changed

Athena AEW
AEW

In 2015, Stephanie McMahon had a great idea: the women should wrestle.

Why were you perving on them the whole time, guys? Shame on you.

Not remotely influenced by the success of Ronda Rousey or a social media backlash, Steph launched the 'Women's Revolution'. No longer would the women of WWE receive opportunities based on how they looked. A new era of competition and quality was upon us all.

Except this didn't exactly happen. Well, it did and it didn't. Actual parity exists between the men's and women's division to a far greater extent these days, and an argument can be made that the women are subjected to the same tedious clichéd booking as the men - that's a sort of equality! - but, as revealed by Athena, WWE is still institutionally a bit d*ckheaded.

Athena, whose awesome heel run in Ring Of Honor is far better than anything happening in AEW or WWE incidentally, disclosed to Chris Jericho on 'Talk is Jericho' that the tryout process was even more dismal than you'd expect. She was told she didn't have what was then the mandatory "Diva" look, and it was suggested to her that she should change her hair and attire. When that didn't work, but she secured another tryout a few months later, she was told, allegedly, to lose some weight - following which she felt guilty about eating anything other than strawberries.

But wait - didn't Athena try out before everything changed? And didn't she subsequently sign with WWE?

Correct, but whilst in WWE, per an interview with Chris Van Vliet, she was told to "dress sexy" and be more like Mandy Rose when Triple H was removed from developmental.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!