10 Last Minute Changes That Saved Wrestling Stables
Bad gimmicks and imperfect line-ups can kill a group off if things aren't course corrected.
Making mistakes is totally fine and being allowed to fail is what makes us stronger as people. How can you ever expect to learn if you don’t make a few errors along the way?
When it comes to the grand stages of the pro wrestling stage, however, you’re unfortunately exposed to the power of the limelight: from dizzying highs, to totally embarrassing lows… so if you’re lucky you’ll get all the kinks out of your new ideas before you put them in front of the public eye.
If not? Better act sharp.
Wrestling stables and teams are just as prone to bad gimmicks as individual stars and they also have the added unfortunate possibilities that come with working with multiple people. It might seem like a great idea you’ve got there, but in order for a gimmick to connect it needs to be assigned to the right people to sell it.
The groups in this list all hit speed bumps either before or after putting everything into gear and taking off from the start-line. Thankfully, the people in charge caught it early and managed to course-correct before things got very bad, very quickly...
10. The Brood
Christopher Daniels could never catch his WWE break. If the stories are to be believed, he was once considered to play the part of “The Higher Power” - the mysterious leader of the Corporate Ministry, essentially the boss of Undertaker and his goons, and responsible for all of their most devious acts. But instead, we got the “it was me, Austin, it was me all along” moment so… we can’t really complain.
Similarly, Daniels was also eyed up for another evil stable during his tenure working dark matches for the company. According to Gangrel in a conversation with Chris Van Vliet, his Brood stable was originally set to star Edge - who the company were sure was going to be a big success - and young hopeful Christopher Daniels. It was Edge who pushed for Christian’s inclusion, trying to find a space for his childhood friend.
It’s hard to say if 'The Fallen Angel’ would’ve been a good fit for The Brood but it’s certainly easy enough to picture. But the truth of the matter is, without Edge and Christian getting this moment to work together on WWE TV it’s possible that we wouldn’t have gotten everything that came after it.
And basically, anything that stops us from getting E&C’s 5 Second Pose gimmick…? Forget about it.
It’s a shame that Daniels never got his shot in WWE but the right decision was definitely made here.
9. The Shield
The WWE Universe was introduced to The Shield during CM Punk’s 2012 world title reign where they would routinely attack the Straightedge Superstar’s opponents. Months went by with CM Punk denying that he was affiliated with them. We as an audience could never quite tell if he was telling the truth or making barefaced lies, and the closest we got to confirmation was that Heyman had been paying the group off himself.
With this story in the rear-view mirror, The Shield could go on to bigger, better and more importantly their own things.
In CM Punk’s infamous tell-all appearance on the Art of Wrestling Podcast with Colt Cabana, he said that the plan was indeed to bring The Shield in as “his guys”. On-screen they certainly played that idea from a distance rather than spelling it out, which thankfully made the group more ambiguous and harder to predict because of it.
Punk additionally revealed the original line-up that was pitched to him for a new stable did contain Seth Rollins but he was to be joined by Daniel Bryan and The Big Show. Punk argued for a full set of younger stars which, thankfully, was granted. Established wrestlers, especially those with tenure like Big Show, should never be your first port of call for a group that’s going upset the status quo quite the way that The Shield did.
8. Harlem Heat
When it comes to the best talent that WCW produced then Booker T is in the conversation for one of the most important of all time. Not just as a single star, hitting his peak just as the company was bought out, but before then whilst teaming with his brother Stevie Ray as the adored Harlem Heat.
It’s a really good thing that they didn’t go with the original gimmick then.
In the fall of 1993, the brothers debuted at a house show alongside manager Colonel Robert Parker, whose character was that of a stereotypical Southern plantation owner. If you think you can already see where this is going then yes you are correct if you feel disgusted.
Apparently, Booker and Stevie - then known as Kane and Kole - were to have been two men that the Colonel “won” in a gambling game and, perhaps worst of all, they came to the ring wearing shackles around their wrists and ankles.
The phrase “what the f*** were you thinking” comes to mind, doesn’t it?
The audience reaction was so negative, unsurprisingly, that the gimmick was never trotted out in front of cameras. Very soon afterwards the two got their far more appropriate and far more over gimmick as Harlem Heat and history tried its best to swipe this terrible mistake under the rug.
7. The Inner Circle
He may have used it as part of his heel schtick but there is nothing but truth in the fact that Chris Jericho signing with AEW was a massive get for the fledgling company.
Jericho's Inner Circle were a major part of AEW’s first couple of years competing in legendary gimmick matches such as the Blood n’ Guts cage match and two Stadium Stampedes. The arrangement of the men within that group however was originally vastly different.
It was Jericho himself that pitched for his future Jericho Appreciation Society stablemate Jake Hager to join him when the company originally suggested UK boxer and new signee Anthony Ogogo as the group’s muscle. On the flip-side, Jericho suggested that MJF join him as the young, mouthy up-start but AEW writers felt it better he was on his own and instead picked out Sammy Guevara.
Finally, the tag team originally considered for the group was the Lucha Brothers but, as Jericho stated on his own podcast, that felt too “superhero”. He wanted a pair of vicious killers, and Santana and Ortiz fit the mould perfectly.
Without the back and forth collaboration between Jericho and the booking team, the line-up of Inner Circle would’ve been vastly, vastly different and it’s fair to say that all of the best choices were made: for both the men inside and outside of the stable.
6. Evolution
Triple H’s on-screen presence throughout WWE for the last 30 years has been really rather consistent and, as such, you can kind of track the company by era depending on what he was doing: DX Trips, reign of terror Trips, corporate shill Trips, NXT Daddy Trips etc.
During the early 00s after the disbanding of DX, Triple H was leader of a stable by the name of Evolution. He represented the current state of the industry; with his council, leather handbag in the shape of a man Ric Flair, harkening back to wrestling’s past. Perhaps the most important piece of the puzzle though was who should represent the future. Randy Orton was a no-brainer but the muscle of the group, at one point, was a role considered for Mark Jindrak.
So close was this decision to being final that Jindrak shot promotional material for the stable but an assessment was made that he wasn’t quite ready for that level of pressure. Even Jindrak himself has admitted in recent years that he wasn’t the right fit, saying “attitude and s**t matters. Orton got with it… I didn’t.”
Evolution’s proudest accomplishment is breaking-out two of the industry’s biggest stars of that era in both Randy Orton and Jindrak’s eventual replacement Batista. More than that, the former Evolution nominee departing WWE to go work in Mexico proved to be the right move for the young Jindrak. In essence, everybody benefitted from this last minute switcheroo.
5. SAnitY
If you’ve never quite understood what appears to be random capitalisation in SAnitY’s name, let me help you out here. The capital Y was for Eric Young, the capital A was for Alexander Wolfe and the “nit” in the centre was for Nikki Cross. Oh, and the capital S was for Killian Dain.
Oh wait, what? No, sorry, “S” for Sawyer Fulton.
Sadly for Fulton, he’s reduced to little more than wrestling these days as his tenure with WWE amounted to very little. After debuting as part of SAnitY, he tore a pectoral muscle two months into their run and was ejected from the group. He was very quickly replaced by Dain, and was sadly out of the company about a year later.
Dain was the right man for the job and continued the group’s momentum that had been gained from their intriguing vignettes, shock reveal of Eric Young as the leader and their seriously underrated theme music. Dain provided that fullback position of the muscle to back up SAnitY’s anarchic behaviour in a way that Fulton couldn’t have mustered. He cut a much more imposing figure and added an even more intentional flavour to the already varied group.
To make matters worse for Fulton however, the original SAnitY concept was pitched to him way before the others got involved and was originally made up of himself, Solomon Crowe and Marcus Louis. It was put on hold and, when it finally did happen, pretty much opened the door for Fulton to be kicked out of the company. Ouch.
4. Blackpool Combat Club
One of the most entertaining things on wrestling television right now is Blackpool Combat Club and I am putting my foot down on that. A beautiful, unexpected synergy of violence between veterans Jon Moxley and Bryan Danielson, led by the man we all wish was our Dad: William Regal. Most recently the group has expanded their roster to include Wheeler Yuta through a series of bouts that has not just told a fantastic story for the faction but really grown Yuta’s star power and fan appreciation.
He wasn’t the only name considered for the BCC’s apprentice role however, and Daniel Garcia was certainly one wrestler who came up in the discussion.
We can’t be sure how serious the talk got but it was apparently quelled when Jericho spoke up and requested Garcia for his own new outfit, the Jericho Appreciation Society.
It’s possible that Garcia in Blackpool Combat Club could’ve worked but Yuta’s sympathetic and scrappy nature are what made that story so great and it’s tough to picture Garcia achieving quite the same effect. Which is fine because so far Garcia has been able to spread his own wings in JAS with its “I’m a sports entertainer” gimmick.
This last minute change may be a fresh one but our immediate reaction is that it’s paying off dividends for everyone involved.
3. NWO
Objectively one of the most important moments in wrestling history is the reveal of “the third man”. Hulk Hogan, returning to WCW, casting off the red and yellow and his long-time babyface superhero character to join Hall and Nash and form the New World Order shook the industry in ways that are still felt today.
Whilst the nWo was set to have three members however, it wasn’t always the case that Hogan was going to step into that role. How does a name like Sting grab you? Eric Bischoff even confirmed that Sting had agreed to the idea before the plans changed when Bischoff met with the Hulkster.
Speaking on his podcast 83 Weeks, Bischoff said “Once Sting agreed to be the third man, it was literally within days that I ended up getting a phone call from Hogan and flew out to California.” That is to say, it was around this time that a clearer picture came into focus for the WCW booker.
Whilst Sting as one of the founding members of the nWo may have been cool to see, it’s hard to know if it would’ve worked and most importantly Hogan turning heel on Randy Savage to announce his position of “the third man” was a way bigger shock for the WCW audience.
Moreover, the group’s ongoing feud with 'The Icon' gave Sting something to do for a very long time so in truth it positively affected both men’s careers.
2. Team PCB
In the summer of 2015, WWE decided to celebrate the mutterings of a women’s revolution and the successes of many of NXT’s female talents by… bringing several of them up to the main roster at once and putting them into randomly assigned teams like they’d all just passed around Harry Potter’s sorting hat backstage.
In truth, the less remembered about this era perhaps the better. One team however stands out because of the controversy that, quite thankfully, WWE nipped in the bud before it got even worse.
Paige, Charlotte and Becky were collectively known as Team PCB which sounds like a name that was picked in about six seconds which is likely the case. Just days beforehand they had debuted on Monday Night Raw as the “Submission Sorority”, much to the delight of the online wrestling audience who immediately realised the name didn’t just sound pornographic… it literally was the name of an adult video series.
Seriously, all that money and all those employees and nobody thought to Google this one?
The scrambling for a name change was WWE trying to put the fire out before it spread and sure, whilst many jokes were made, they were lucky not to get in genuine trouble with any sponsors or networks by accidentally name dropping a porn series on their supposedly PG TV show.
1. The New Day
When you think of The New Day you think of bright splashes of enthusiasm, Xavier Woods’ trombone playing and the power of positivity. This is a stark difference from the three men’s first appearance together.
After suffering several losses as a tag team, Big E and Kofi Kingston were approached by Xavier Woods who claimed they won’t get ahead by “kissing babies and shaking hands”. It implied that the group was to take a militant edge, similar to the Nation of Domination from the 1990s.
Vignettes began to air that at the time seemed very confusing and to this day still feel totally at odds with the finished product: Woods, in a tie and braces, speaking like a preacher man and riling up a gospel crowd who drape him in a sparkling robe and drag him away from the microphone. We were all left baffled and assumed that the gimmick was dead on arrival.
Suffice to say that when the New Day hit the ring as a unit for the first time their momentum began for real and it only grew and grew. Whatever it was that WWE was trying to impose on them, the men behind the idea superseded it and instead played the energetic and excitable characters that we know and love.
Today The New Day are recognised as one of the most successful stables in wrestling history.