10 Least Convincing Intercontinental Champions In WWE History

Ryback was a dud, and he's not alone...

Traditionally, the Intercontinental Title is WWE's secondary belt. Established in 1979, the title was first held by Pat Patterson. A phony tournament was said to be held in Rio De Janeiro, but in reality didn't happen. This was done to try and give the belt - and thus Patterson - more credibility, rather than simply announcing that he had been awarded the new strap. Over the years, WWE management have had a love/hate relationship with the Intercontinental Title. When the company introduced the World Heavyweight Championship in 2002, the belt suddenly became less important to the promotion. In truth, the Intercontinental Title had been suffering a few years before that, and it would sadly be merged with the World Title at No Mercy that year. It wouldn't be long until the famous title would return. In 2003, WWE brought the belt back, and it's been a fixture ever since. The history of the Intercontinental Title has been crammed with worthy champions, not to mention Hall Of Fame-worthy stars. However, the belt has also had more than a fair share of title-holding duds. That's what this article explores, those performers who simply couldn't do the beloved championship justice. Latterly, WWE have installed Kevin Owens as the new Intercontinental Champion. There are hopes he can reinvigorate the failing title, which would make a change from the guys featured on this list.


10. Rocky Maivia

At first, it may seem startling to see the smiling face of Dwayne Johnson here. However, even though Johnson would go on to become 'The Rock', the start of his career was very auspicious indeed. Making his debut in late-1996, Rocky Maivia was out-dated as a character from the start. His happy-go-lucky babyface persona did not appeal to a fresh generation of WWF fans. Despite the fact that Maivia wasn't connecting with the audience, he was given the Intercontinental Title in February, 1997. In later years, The Rock would be entirely valid as champion, but that wasn't the case during his first run with the belt. Defeating Hunter Hearst Helmsley, Rocky would only hold the title for around 2 months. In April, he dropped it to Owen Hart on an episode of Raw Is War. Johnson's next run occurred in December, '97. By that point, he was an entirely different character altogether. Morphing into the heel persona of The Rock saved the man's career, because he was floundering as a babyface. Never was that any more evident than when he held the Intercontinental Title. A decade on from the classic Randy Savage vs. Ricky Steamboat bout at WrestleMania III in 1987, Rocky faced The Sultan in a dreary effort at 'Mania 13 in 1997.

9. Kerry Von Erich

In contrast to The Rock, Kerry Von Erich would have been better as Intercontinental Champion earlier in his career. By the time he was given a run with the title in 1990, he was a shadow of the performer he had been throughout the 1980's. In the then-WWF, Von Erich was known as the 'Texas Tornado', but he was unable to really establish himself in the company. Von Erich was never the original plan to defeat Mr. Perfect at SummerSlam and win the Intercontinental Title. That spot was set to go to Brutus 'The Barber' Beefcake, but a freak parasailing accident ruled him out of the match. The big Texan, Kerry was therefore his replacement, and the writing staff adhered to booking plans designed to take the title from Perfect. A shell of the great wrestler fans had watched construct epic bouts against the likes of Ric Flair, the Texas Tornado couldn't perform to his own lofty standards in the WWF. Arguably, he was never the same after getting his foot amputated in the mid-80's. Just a few months after winning the title, he dropped the belt back to Mr. Perfect. When champion, Von Erich rarely defended the title, and couldn't do himself justice.

8. Ryback

At WrestleMania 31, pro wrestling enthusiasts were delighted when Daniel Bryan captured the WWE Intercontinental Title. Fending off 6 other guys, including reigning champ Bad News Barrett, Bryan was a popular choice to win the Ladder Match. Shortly thereafter, the bearded grappler sadly had to vacate the title due to serious injury. He hasn't wrestled since. WWE had a major decision to make. Just who could follow in Bryan's footsteps as an adequate successor? At Elimination Chamber in May, Ryback was chosen as the next man to hold the famous belt. Naturally, a fair portion of the audience felt this was a poor decision. Ryback is not an in-ring performer on the level of Daniel Bryan, who had promised excellence with his reign before vacating. Eventually, Ryback would lose the Intercontinental Title to Kevin Owens. The former NXT Heavyweight Champion is a far more popular candidate, because he's considered a work horse inside the ring. As champ, Ryback was always swimming against the tide. Few fans wanted to see him handed the gold, and the fact he replaced Daniel Bryan made things even worse.

7. Billy Gunn

Billy Gunn always excelled as a tag-team wrestler in the 1990's. Alongside storyline brother Bart, Billy formed The Smoking Gunns. The duo would have a run lasting over 3 years in the WWF, before disbanding in late-1996. From there, Billy didn't do much of any real note before forming a tag-team with another disillusioned star, Road Dogg. The New Age Outlaws became a very effective tandem. During the height of his career, Gunn was an important member of D-Generation X. The coolest faction in the entire company, DX allowed Billy to show off more of his personality. By the year 2000, officials felt the Outlaws had run their natural course as a team, and decided to try splitting them as a unit. Billy had earlier won the King Of The Ring in 1999, but a failed solo run had led to him once again uniting with Road Dogg. At the turn of the millennium, he was repackaged as 'The One' Billy Gunn. In November, 2000, he beat Eddie Guerrero to win the Intercontinental Title. Whilst a well-known name on the roster, this new gimmick wasn't working for Billy. Fans didn't respond to his short reign as champ, and he was beaten by Chris Benoit at Armageddon less than one month after bagging the belt.

6. The Mountie

Speaking of short, unsatisfying Intercontinental Title reigns, The Mountie had one of the shortest. An established tag wrestler, Jacques Rougeau had been part of The 'Fabulous' Rougeau Brothers with his real-life brother, Raymond. After Ray retired in 1990, Jacques looked to launch a singles career in the WWF. A dramatic change of character would introduce fans to The Mountie. Inspired by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, the gimmick was largely started to instigate a feud against The Big Boss Man. After that series concluded, it was tough to see where Rougeau could go next. In early-1992, he shockingly defeated Bret Hart for the Intercontinental Title at a house show in Springfield, Massachusetts. The title switch was explained on television as a result of Hart being struck by illness, and thus not on top form. Mere days later, The Mountie was vanquished by Roddy Piper at the Royal Rumble Pay-Per-View. All in all, his title reign lasted 48 hours or so. Incredibly, this would be Piper's only title win the the WWF, and it was there to set up a match against Bret at WrestleMania VIII. Therefore, The Mountie was only a place holder as Intercontinental Champion, and not viewed as anything other than a transition by the company.

5. Curtis Axel

Giving WWE credit, they really tried with Curt Hennig's son, Joe. When Paul Heyman introduced the re-branded 'Curtis Axel' as his latest client in May, 2013, people wondered if the 'Midas Touch' of Heyman could get the best out of him. Clearly a talented in-ring wrestler, Axel didn't have much personality to speak of. Joe Hennig had toiled for years in the WWE system, and this looked set to be his big break. Things wouldn't pan out in the long run for Axel, he was just too bland. Even the hype-king himself, Heyman couldn't get fans invested in what Curtis was selling. Nonetheless, management really got behind him, programming him to face the likes of Triple H and John Cena on Monday Night Raw. Later, at Payback in June, Axel captured the Intercontinental Title. Defeating Wade Barrett and The Miz in a Triple Threat Match, Curtis Axel looked genuinely thrilled to bag the belt. His title run would last for 155 days, but was largely inconsequential to fans. When Big E Langston pinned him to win the strap in November, it seemed routine. WWE had long since given up on the idea of making Axel both a 'Paul Heyman Guy' and a huge star.

4. Albert

2001 featured a lot of title changes in the World Wrestling Federation. A glut of performers in the mid card pack hadn't been helped by the acquisition of more from the likes of WCW and ECW. Suddenly, TV time was more of a precious commodity than before, making one Intercontinental Title decision even more baffling. In June, Albert beat Kane to become champion. Diamond Dallas Page interfered, hitting Kane with a dodgy-looking Diamond Cutter. One quick 'Albert Bomb' later, and Albert was Intercontinental Champion. Fans weren't enthused by what they were seeing. Up until that point, Albert had been little more than a tag-team attraction, and it was obvious that he was only being pushed due to his huge size. Kane had just defeated Triple H in a 'Chain Match' at Judgment Day, so it was confusing to see his title run be cut short so suddenly. Fast forward just 27 days, and Albert was staring at the lights for a new champion. On one edition of Raw in July, Lance Storm won the Intercontinental Title. Of course, Storm was part of the incoming WCW 'Invasion', which is why he was given the title. Thankfully, he was also a great wrestler, and a far more fitting choice as champ than Albert, who struggled to get over with fans.

3. Dean Douglas

It's unlikely that there are any official promotional pictures of Dean Douglas as WWF Intercontinental Champion. At In Your House 4 in October, 1995, Shawn Michaels was set to drop the belt to Douglas live on Pay-Per-View. Reportedly, that didn't sit well with HBK, who wanted to avoid the job if he could. Earlier, Michaels had also apparently been attacked by Marines in a night club incident. Therefore, the match didn't happen as scheduled. Instead, Michaels vacated the Intercontinental Title and it was awarded to Douglas. Before the man playing the teacher gimmick could sneer too much, he was jobbing to Razor Ramon. As quickly as he was been awarded it, Dean Douglas had lost the Intercontinental gold. In total, Douglas held the belt for much less than an hour. There have been long standing rumours that 'The Kliq' were in Vince McMahon's ear, convincing him to abort plans to make Douglas anything other than a brief champion. If true, it would have been interesting to see what the clearly-talented Dean could have done with the strap. As it was, he was hampered by a cartoon-like gimmick that didn't resonate with fans.

2. Bob Holly

Imagine a scenario today where the WWE Intercontinental Title changed hands on an episode of Main Event. That's pretty much what happened in 1995, only the title switch took place on the long-defunct Action Zone program. Cast as 'Multi Sport Superstar', Bob Holly was said to be a race car driver outside of the WWF. This fell in the era when Vince McMahon was obsessed with making his stars have jobs aside from wrestling. The character wasn't really over, although fans were fine with Holly existing on the lower mid card. In April, 1995, Bob shocked everyone by pinning Jeff Jarrett to win the Intercontinental Title. On the same broadcast, the title was vacated, because Jarrett's foot was revealed to have been on the ropes. A rematch took place, and Holly fell to the former champion. Jeff Jarrett left the show with his title in tact. It was a wholly unnecessary scenario, especially considering it meant the Intercontinental Title was briefly vacated. As 'Hardcore' Holly, Bob would go on to become a much more over part of the product. As 'Spark Plug' Bob Holly, he was not, and he was a poor choice for the Intercontinental Title mix.

1. Ezekiel Jackson

It's likely that many WWE fans have already forgotten about Ezekiel Jackson. In 2011 however, the company were dead set on making him a featured star on television. Introduced as Brian Kendrick's bodyguard in 2008, Jackson was clearly a very impressive physical specimen. Upon seeing him wrestle, it was clear that he didn't have enough about him to motor up the card. That didn't stop WWE management from trying, and that's why they decided to put the Intercontinental Title on the man. At the one-off Capitol Punishment Pay-Per-View in June, 2011, Jackson defeated Wade Barrett to win the belt. Admittedly, fans popped for the title switch, but that excitement would soon wear off quickly. Swiftly, WWE realised Ezekiel was ill-prepared to be champ. Just months later, he lost to Cody Rhodes on an episode of Smackdown in August. Collectively, fans breathed a sigh of relief. During his reign, Jackson had done nothing to suggest he deserved the role as Intercontinental Champion. When people talk about all the champs in the title's lengthy history, Ezekiel Jackson will surely be considered one of the least convincing, certainly from an in-ring standpoint. What other WWE Intercontinental Champions failed to convince you? What do you make of the choices listed here? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!

In this post: 
Curtis Axel
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.