10 Legitimate Fighters Who Competed In WWE

When worlds collide.

Big Show vs. Floyd Mayweather - WrestleMania 24
WWE.com

After weeks (and by weeks we mean years) of speculation, Ronda Rousey finally made her WWE bow last week by interrupting Asuka's Royal Rumble celebrations and pointing awkwardly at the WrestleMania sign.

There have been more impressive wrestling debuts over the years, but few have generated as much mainstream interest as this one. A UFC box office draw for more than five years, the 30-year-old might just be the biggest acquisition Vince McMahon has made since Brock Lesnar in 2012.

In a way, whatever Rousey ends up doing in the ring (and, as of the latest reports, it looks like being an inter-gender tag team match against Trips and Steph) is unimportant. Her main function is to drum up some media interest in the Show of Shows, which takes place on 8 April.

But, as a matter of personal pride, you imagine she will want to follow in the footsteps of guys like Kurt Angle and Brock Lesnar - and not, say, Akebono. That is to say that, while the list of legitimate fighters to have performed in WWE is long, not all of them have been success stories...

10. Akebono

Big Show Akebono Sumo Match WrestleMania 21
WWE.com

Crossovers between the worlds of professional wrestling and sumo wrestling is rare, partly because few exponents of the former are actually large enough to make it anything more than a formality, and partly because exponents of the latter would probably have great difficulty performing a springboard dive to the outside of the ring.

Big Show, however, is one of those rare WWE employees who - at a purported 500lbs (this was probably greatly exaggerated, but there's no denying that he's a pretty substantial guy) - was well capable of standing toe to toe with a legitimate sumo supremo. Namely Akebono, who he fought at WrestleMania 21.

More than a decade later, it's still not entirely clear why Vince McMahon and co were so keen on this idea. It's not like Akebono - who had also competed in kick-boxing and MMA - was a household name or anything; in fact, he had much less of a profile than Show himself.

The feud also lacked any kind of story beyond the fact that both men, being very large, had a yearning to have a big, manly cuddle in the middle of the ring. Needless to say, the resulting spectacle was a pretty poor for those watching in the audience (though, mercifully, it only lasted about a minute).


9. Daniel Puder

daniel puder
© Patrick Fallon/ZUMA Press/Corbis

Anyone who has enrolled at wrestling school knows that the first rule of wrestling school is that you don't talk about wrestling school. The second rule is that results are predetermined, and you probably shouldn't under any circumstances try and beat up your opponent for real.

Tough Enough rookie Daniel Puder skipped the inaugural lesson, however, which is why on an November 2004 episode of SmackDown he put Kurt Angle in a Kimura lock, a submission hold he had picked up from his time as a mixed martial artist. To be fair, Angle did arrogantly challenge the newcomers to a real fight, on the basis he expected to win easily.

Fortunately for Angle - who, so we're led to believe, was just a few seconds away from tapping out to a wrestler nobody had ever heard of - the referee had the presence of mind to count a quick pinfall whilst his assailant's shoulders were (sort of) parallel with the mat.

This would turn out to be the highlight of Puder's tenure with WWE. After presumably getting a stern talking to backstage, he was punished in front of the cameras with a series of stiff chops from veterans Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit and Hardcore Holly at the Royal Rumble a couple of months later.


8. Butterbean

Butterbean Knocks Out Bart Gunn
WWE.com

Winning the first (and, it's probably fair to assume, only) WWE Brawl For All looked, on paper, like the kind of achievement that could perhaps have helped elevate Bart Gunn to heights he had only ever dreamed about.

But company officials - who apparently planned to use the tournament as a springboard for Steve Williams - had very different ideas.

Instead of giving the winner a push for the main event, they rewarded him with a WrestleMania XV shootfight against Butterbean, a legitimate heavyweight boxer who - well, who was called Butterbean. Suffice it to say, this didn't end well for Gunn, who was knocked out after about 30 seconds.

Thankfully for all involved, WWE's sudden urge to put on real fighting instead of the make-believe stuff in which they traditionally trade turned out to be little more than a passing fad. Butterbean, impressive though he was, hasn't been invited back since.


7. Dan Severn

Dan Severn Suplex
WWE.com

It was a toss-up between Dan Severn and fellow MMA fighter-cum-professional wrestler Steve Blackman for this spot, but the former - as one of the founding fathers of UFC during its formative early '90s era - has to get the nod.

After training as a professional wrestler under Al Snow, Severn rocked up in Vince McMahon's WWE in 1997, joining the company during what was a relative boom period for shootfighting.

Mostly, this was because of 1998's infamous Brawl For All tournament, in which - at the behest of Vince Russo - wrestlers trained in pretend-fighting got the rare opportunity to beat each other up for real (which went about as well as could be expected).

Unfortunately, both - Severn and the aforementioned Blackman - ended up pulling out after the first round, despite winning their respective matches. The rest of his career in the ring was similarly disappointing, and he eventually packed it in 1999 after WWE asked him to get "666" tattooed on his forehead. Probably a good call.


6. Bobby Lashley

bobby lashley test
WWE.com

Because he was practically anointed Brock Lesnar's successor by company heads, and because nobody will ever really match the accomplishments of Brock Lesnar in the squared circle, Bobby Lashley's first stint in WWE is regarded by most as something of a failure.

But parallel claims cannot be made of his tenure in Impact Wrestling - from where he recently departed after four world title reigns - nor the time he has spent competing in MMA, a sport in which he currently holds a record of 15 wins from 17 fights.

It's the latter, you figure, that currently makes him such an attractive proposition for Vince McMahon, who reportedly has his heart set on pairing Lashley up with the man he was supposed to replace a decade ago, their paths having yet to cross either in the Octagon or the squared circle.

This should be a big money-spinner for WWE, and rightly so. It's rare that the company has managed to get two legitimate heavyweights to step into the ring at the same time, and though it may not be a five-star wrestling spectacle, it will be interesting to see how they shape up next to one another.


5. Evander Holyfield

Holyfield Hardy Snme2007 051616  4c176f0098cd85d494dba33584a702ca
WWE

It's kind of generous to say that Evander Holyfield "competed" in WWE. He basically just rocked up for one episode of Saturday Night's Main Event, where he spent a couple of minutes throwing unconvincing punches at Matt Hardy.

This formed part of MVP's ongoing United States Championship feud with the latter, which consisted - for some reason - of things like a basketball game, a chest match and hotdog-eating competition; essentially everything other than, you know, an actual wrestling match.

Holyfield was supposed to fighting the corner of the champ, but he eventually took exception to being bossed around, and threw a right hand in his direction once he was done with Hardy, thus ending the contest after about three, extremely tedious minutes.

Given how well WWE used fellow boxers Mike Tyson and Floyd Mayweather at WrestleManias XIV and XXIV, this one probably has to go down as something of a disappointment.


4. Ken Shamrock

The Rock Ken Shamrock 1998 Survivor Series
WWE.com

Like Severn, Ken Shamrock played a key role in helping to establish the UFC name during the early 1990s, and like Severn, he was eventually lured into signing for the WWE at the end of the decade under the promise of a fatter pay-cheque.

But the World's Most Dangerous Man, as he became known, had much more staying power than most of Vince McMahon's MMA experiments. He became a solid upper mid-card fixture for almost three years before departing in 1999 to resume his career in the Octagon.

This wasn't a fluke, either. Having competed in the squared circle before making the move into MMA, he really was a pretty accomplished worker, sharing great matches with The Rock at King of the Ring 1998 and Owen Hart - in a brilliantly bizarre "Lion's Den match" - a couple of months later at SummerSlam.

What ultimately prevented him from reaching the main event was perhaps his lack of ability on the mic. He had joined WWE at a time when it was deep in the throes of the Monday Night Wars, and the company had (correctly) decided that it was character and storyline that would help them overturn Nitro's ratings lead.


3. Floyd Mayweather

Floyd Mayweather Big Show
WWE.com

Seriously, who knew Floyd Mayweather was so protective of Rey Mysterio? It was seeing a returning Big Show manhandle WWE's resident underdog at No Way Out 2008 that prompted the boxer to jump over the fan barricade and land a couple of right hooks.

The result was an interdisciplinary match at WrestleMania XXIV, pitting a welterweight who came in at no more than 170lbs against the so-called World's Largest Athlete, a man so big that he's twice broken the WWE ring simply by landing on it really hard.

Totally mismatched though this was, it was actually a pretty entertaining spectacle. Show played his role to a tee, repeatedly resisting what must have been an almost uncontrollable urge to throw a punch of his own, despite his opponent's seemingly stiff approach in the ring.

The only problem was that the match's outcome could be predicted by people in another galaxy. Mayweather was (and still is) undefeated in the world of boxing; there was absolutely no way he was going to agree to lose a play-fight in the aid of sports entertainment, however much money they threw at him.


2. Brock Lesnar

Braun Strowman Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Paul Heyman's favourite (and, very possibly, only) client could probably beat just about anyone in the world in a no holds barred fight to the death. If you're skeptical about that claim, go back and watch the crushing right hand he landed on Braun Strowman at last week's Royal Rumble.

What sets Brock Lesnar apart from nearly everyone else on this list is that he's actually competed in two different types of legitimate fighting: amateur wrestling - where he held the NCAA Heavyweight Title during his college days - and, latterly, mixed martial arts.

It was in UFC where the sporting world really stood up and paid attention. Despite getting into the sport relatively late in the day, the Beast Incarnate beat industry legend Randy Couture in 2008 to win the promotion's biggest prize, which he carried for almost two years.

As for his success in the squared circle, if you've followed WWE at all over the last five years then you'll know that there is seldom a moment when Lesnar is not at the very heart of the Monday Night Raw main event. And, in case you haven't figured it out yet, this trend is set to continue until at least his date with Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 34.


1. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle 2004
WWE.com

Kurt Angle perhaps holds the mantle of being both the best legitimate fighter ever to walk through the doors of WWE's Stamford headquarters - minority sport or not, Olympic gold medals don't come easily to anyone - and the most successful at making the transition to the squared circle.

What's remarkable about this is that, in 1996, the current Raw general manager was a veritable pro-wrestling sceptic. He initially rejected Vince McMahon's advances, believing that pretend-fighting would be a waste of the talent he had spent the best part of two decades cultivating.

Ironically, part of the reason he flourished in the ring was because he started his WWE career as a blank slate. Comparisons to the likes of Bret Hart were inevitably made by others, but he wasn't trying to imitate anyone. His shtick, like all of the greats, was almost entirely original.

Any gaps in his understanding in the business were also plugged by his insatiable appetite for thrilling - and, at times, horrifying - the crowd. There are wrestlers who have led careers twice as long who haven't taken half the amount of risks Kurt Angle has.


Contributor